Hello there. A lot has been going on it seems, so this post may be a quite long. As I'm going to be reading from backwards, my reads may change mid-post.
Ace Timing wrote:
I think that for this game to move forward it is imperative that someone be lynched (just my personal opinion). I personally want to wait for rEdo to say something, so until then I'll just withhold my vote until then.
Yes.
We can't No-Lynch D1. We need more information and some flips to narrow down our choices and pinpoint scum.
Static Noise Bird wrote:
We can't be sure whether Slaini's newbieness is sincere or just a scum cover-up before, uh, before we're sure about it.
This is my real problem. His newbie play can't guarantee he's just hiding scum. That's why I mentioned some posts before that we (or at least, what I'm going to do) is wait for D2 for some reactions. That lynch seems like we just have no idea who's scum and we rather lynch a newbie to eliminate the possibility.
rEdo wrote:
My thoughts so far:
- If sLaiNi would be today's lynch and he would flip scum, very most likely his scumpartner would be Zexion. I haven't seen any exchange of words at all until just recently, when the Hika wagon got more attention. That's weird. This is even weirder, I mean the way sLaiNi's trying to discredit someone for voting Zexion. I'm really close to thinking this is a sLaiNi & Zexion scumteam, but I really need information to work with. That information being sLaiNi's alignment.
- Ace Timing is a fucking pile of WIFOM all around.
- Sakura/Nyquill and Drezi seem the towniest.
- Jess is eating dinner whole game.
If there's anything you want to ask me, please go ahead immediately.
Sakura already said that theory and so far if your reason to suspect me being scum is a lack of comunication, then you're really lost. If you're accusing me for that then why not partner me with Ace or Jess? AFAIK I haven't had direct discussions with both of them so they may be well my scumparterns? (as I assume you're using that point because we try to "distance each other") Discrediting a vote towards someone its hardly proof that those two players have conections, or do we have to suspect you being someone's partner because Slaini's vote to Hika (now you) was really shady and someone (doesn't matter who now) pointed it was scummy?
100% Agree
I hardly think Sakura was the towniest. Her overall paranoia and her ignoring some posts made me really weary of her attitude. I still don't know what to say about Nyquill.
Dinner must be pretty big. Jess non-participation will only lead to trouble reading her later on.
rEdo wrote:
sLaiNi wrote:
I have to say that Jess' didn't contribute a lot. Still, I don't think we should vote her just now.
So I will vote Hika for known reasons. But as we aren't in a hurry it might be a good idea to wait for her replacement, wouldn't it?
So you said it'd be better to wait for a replacement, yet you voted her, okay.
Like honestly, I don't really see a case against Hika except for being lurky as fuck and voting people for shiggles, but isn't that the same thing sLaiNi's been doing?
I completly agree on this one, which is why I said posts ago that if I had to take a guess Slaini should be scum, but I can't really bring myself to lynch him just because jumping onto the wagon... newbie reasons.
rEdo wrote:
@everyone: Please tell me why a Hika/rEdo lynch is better than a sLaiNi lynch. Do you get any information from this except for actually checking Hika''s alignment? I don't think she talked with anyone, I believe there's just no links that you connect with her.
Hika's attitude was extremely secretive. I really don't care if you are talking and scumhunting right now because you are someone different, but if Hika was just reaction testing without posting her results the entire game that meant:
1. She wasn't actually doing anything
2. She didn't have time to post her findings before leaving the game.
Number 2 is extremely unlikely because if I would be leaving a game I would at least post my results of the plan I was talking about posts ago before leaving. So, its very likely she was just buying time and
pretend to be scumhunting with her "masterplan". And let's not forget the "yeah you just acted how I thought" and then no conclusions about that.
rEdo wrote:
Oh, an interesting observation:
p/4282338/
p/4300240/
Note how both sLaiNi and Zexion are on the same wagon when somebody's close to getting hammered.
"My scumreads are both of the same wagon so they must surely be scum! How about we propose a Sakura+Drezi scumteam now?" You're just making excuses to make us think you've solved the game by coincidences. Navizel was scummy as hell until that point (before his "claim") so all active players had a good reason to bring him up to L-1 so he would finally talk.
...and he's still being scummy IMO.
Static Noise Bird wrote:
Alright, good. Now I'm even more convinced about how bad the Hika/rEdo wagon is/was.
Vote: Slaini
L-1, if you derphammer you're getting a guaranteed full-day scum-read and instant vote from me tomorrow "Kappa".
"This is me jumping in the bandwagon because rEdo wrote nice walls, don't mind me".
Ace Timing wrote:
wat? The proposed Scum team was you and Zexion. As Zexion has not responded recently, I am certainly not the most suspicious one here.
Slaini has obviously given up at this point. Are we waiting for Zexion to make a return to hammer the nail into the coffin?
Kek no. I still think Hika/rEdo should eat rope. rEdo bringing up an old theory makes me think he's just being oportunist of Sakura's earlier posts.
------------------
@rEdo: Before you claim "yeah Slaini/Zexion confirmed beacuse Zexion's deflecting votes or asdf", take a look at Hika's posting. You can't tell me there's nothing wrong there. Now that I meantion it, I remember saying the same to SNB...
Also I want to hear Nyquill's stance on this.
, but yeah, I should not have put that "you're" there.