Hi~! Mod through in-game chat request :3
I can't mod higher than Insane, so I'll stop now
Good luck VINXIS
General
*It would be really nice if you add soft slider slide, because the sound of those slider slide is kinda disturbing to the sound of the hitsound like whistle and clap
*The gap between Basic and Medium is too small I think. Basic have 1.85 stars while Medium just have 2.15 stars, but suddenly there's one star gap between Medium and Handsome's Advanced
*You didn't add any source for the song? :3
*There isn't any storyboard in this mapset, so you should turn off your Widescreen Support
*Your bg dimension is 1228 x 768 which is unrankable. You should crop it to 1024 x 768 instead to make it safe
Others are pretty fine I guess~!
*The gap between Basic and Medium is too small I think. Basic have 1.85 stars while Medium just have 2.15 stars, but suddenly there's one star gap between Medium and Handsome's Advanced
*You didn't add any source for the song? :3
*There isn't any storyboard in this mapset, so you should turn off your Widescreen Support
*Your bg dimension is 1228 x 768 which is unrankable. You should crop it to 1024 x 768 instead to make it safe
Others are pretty fine I guess~!
Basic
Whoa. AR 4.3? It's Basic diff. that refers to the easiest diff. in this mapset. Some beginner players might get surprised by that fast approach rate. It would be really nice if you decrease it. For this diff, I think AR 2 will suits more :3
Same goes for OD. It would be great if you change it to 2 instead of 2.9
00:18:580 (2,1) You could improve this blanket. Just move the center point of this slider -> 00:17:980 (2) 4 grids downwards
00:28:180 (2,1) Here too. You should improve this blanket to make a pattern that entertain the players. Move the center point of this slider -> 00:27:580 (2) 4 grids upwards
00:31:255 (1) This spinner is too suddenly after the note at 00:31:180 (3). This is the easiest diff in this mapset, and in my opinion, it isn't allowed to put an object at blue tick and make 1/4 rhytm like that. It would be safer if you move this spinner to 00:31:330 (red tick), but keep to make it ended at 00:32:380
00:45:880 (1,2) Fix this blanket please~! Move the center point of this slider -> 00:45:580 (1) 2 grid upwards
01:08:380 (1) Try to put this slider to x:132 y:252 so that the head of this slider will get stacked with this note -> 01:06:880 (3). After that, all you need to do to prevent the DS problem is : Move this note -> 01:08:980 (2) to x:96 y:100
00:56:380 (1) I think, using finish at the end of this spinner is too loud. Just use whistle and clap instead
01:08:380 (1) It would be really nice if you put this slider at x:132 y:252 instead, so it'll form stack with 01:06:880 (2). After that, move this note -> 01:09:280 (2) to x:168 y:120 to prevent the DS problem
01:13:180 (1) Using finish at this note is too loud since there's no bass sound from the main music. It would make this note sound weird and didn't fit the main music well. I suggests you to remove finish then, use whistle and clap at this note instead
01:13:255 (1) Like I said before, you should not put this spinner at the blue tick at an easiest diff. Anyway, this song has 200 bpm (fast bpm) which is it'll surprise some beginner players when this spinner appears so suddenly right after they click that note. I suggests you to start the spinner at 01:13:330 (red tick) instead so those beginner players will have some time before they started to spin. Anyway, it would make the spinner fits well with the rhytm of the main music
Same goes for OD. It would be great if you change it to 2 instead of 2.9
00:18:580 (2,1) You could improve this blanket. Just move the center point of this slider -> 00:17:980 (2) 4 grids downwards
00:28:180 (2,1) Here too. You should improve this blanket to make a pattern that entertain the players. Move the center point of this slider -> 00:27:580 (2) 4 grids upwards
00:31:255 (1) This spinner is too suddenly after the note at 00:31:180 (3). This is the easiest diff in this mapset, and in my opinion, it isn't allowed to put an object at blue tick and make 1/4 rhytm like that. It would be safer if you move this spinner to 00:31:330 (red tick), but keep to make it ended at 00:32:380
00:45:880 (1,2) Fix this blanket please~! Move the center point of this slider -> 00:45:580 (1) 2 grid upwards
01:08:380 (1) Try to put this slider to x:132 y:252 so that the head of this slider will get stacked with this note -> 01:06:880 (3). After that, all you need to do to prevent the DS problem is : Move this note -> 01:08:980 (2) to x:96 y:100
00:56:380 (1) I think, using finish at the end of this spinner is too loud. Just use whistle and clap instead
01:08:380 (1) It would be really nice if you put this slider at x:132 y:252 instead, so it'll form stack with 01:06:880 (2). After that, move this note -> 01:09:280 (2) to x:168 y:120 to prevent the DS problem
01:13:180 (1) Using finish at this note is too loud since there's no bass sound from the main music. It would make this note sound weird and didn't fit the main music well. I suggests you to remove finish then, use whistle and clap at this note instead
01:13:255 (1) Like I said before, you should not put this spinner at the blue tick at an easiest diff. Anyway, this song has 200 bpm (fast bpm) which is it'll surprise some beginner players when this spinner appears so suddenly right after they click that note. I suggests you to start the spinner at 01:13:330 (red tick) instead so those beginner players will have some time before they started to spin. Anyway, it would make the spinner fits well with the rhytm of the main music
Medium
Ummmm..... Why are you using 1/2 Beat Snap Divisor in this diff?
Please change AR to 5 instead of 5.5
Whoa. The SV gap from Basic to Medium is too big! The difference is 0.4! If the Basic diff. has 0.70 SV, then, the SV of this diff. should be 0.90 ~ 1.00. Please change it to prevent an unexpected moment afterwards like popped bubble *cough* or even get disqualified at the seventh day :p
00:03:580 (1) This spinner is too short for high bpm music. I tried to spin at it and I didn't even get 1000 somehow . Consider to make it longer. You could make this spinner longer by starting it at 00:02:980 and ended it at 00:05:001. The music has already started at 00:02:980 so I thought it would be fine to start that spinner over there :3
00:07:180 (1) It would be nice if this slider has the same curvy shape like these sliders -> 00:09:580 (1) and 00:11:980 (1)
00:33:580 (1) You could try to emphasize the histsound of this part, just change the sampleset to drum-hit normal -> http://puu.sh/cXNkf/dc9567b172.jpg then add whistle. In my opinion, it suits more with the music
00:34:030 (2) Do that ^ for this note too, but you didn't need to add whistle here
00:34:480 (3) Do that ^ for this note as well, but this time, you also should add whistle
Please change AR to 5 instead of 5.5
Whoa. The SV gap from Basic to Medium is too big! The difference is 0.4! If the Basic diff. has 0.70 SV, then, the SV of this diff. should be 0.90 ~ 1.00. Please change it to prevent an unexpected moment afterwards like popped bubble *cough* or even get disqualified at the seventh day :p
00:03:580 (1) This spinner is too short for high bpm music. I tried to spin at it and I didn't even get 1000 somehow . Consider to make it longer. You could make this spinner longer by starting it at 00:02:980 and ended it at 00:05:001. The music has already started at 00:02:980 so I thought it would be fine to start that spinner over there :3
00:07:180 (1) It would be nice if this slider has the same curvy shape like these sliders -> 00:09:580 (1) and 00:11:980 (1)
00:33:580 (1) You could try to emphasize the histsound of this part, just change the sampleset to drum-hit normal -> http://puu.sh/cXNkf/dc9567b172.jpg then add whistle. In my opinion, it suits more with the music
00:34:030 (2) Do that ^ for this note too, but you didn't need to add whistle here
00:34:480 (3) Do that ^ for this note as well, but this time, you also should add whistle
Handsome's Advanced
00:32:380 (1) Whoa. Nice slider <3
00:33:580 (1) Same as Medium diff. You could try to emphasize the histsound of this part, just change the sampleset to drum-hit normal -> http://puu.sh/cXNkf/dc9567b172.jpg then add whistle. In my opinion, it suits more with the music
00:34:030 (2) Do that ^ for this note too, but you didn't need to add whistle here
00:34:480 (3) Do that ^ for the head of this slider as well, but this time, you also should add whistle
00:40:780 (1,2,3,4) Whoa. Very nice blanket <3
00:55:630 (1) I think, you should add whistle at the head, the reverse part, and the tail of this slider since the music strongly suggests it
00:33:580 (1) Same as Medium diff. You could try to emphasize the histsound of this part, just change the sampleset to drum-hit normal -> http://puu.sh/cXNkf/dc9567b172.jpg then add whistle. In my opinion, it suits more with the music
00:34:030 (2) Do that ^ for this note too, but you didn't need to add whistle here
00:34:480 (3) Do that ^ for the head of this slider as well, but this time, you also should add whistle
00:40:780 (1,2,3,4) Whoa. Very nice blanket <3
00:55:630 (1) I think, you should add whistle at the head, the reverse part, and the tail of this slider since the music strongly suggests it
Walao's Hyper
There are some missing claps in this diff :
00:15:880 (1) This slider's tail
00:16:330 (2) This slider's tail
00:16:630 (4) This note
00:17:980 (3) This slider's head
00:18:430 (4) This note
00:18:880 (7) This slider's head
00:20:680 (6) This note
00:21:130 (8) This note
00:22:780 (2) This note
00:23:230 (5) This slider's head
00:23:680 (6) This slider's head
00:24:280 (1) This slider's tail
00:24:730 (4) This note
00:25:630 (8) This slider's head
00:26:680 (1) This slider's tail
00:27:130 (2) This slider's tail
00:27:580 (5) This slider's head
00:28:480 (9) This slider's head
00:32:380 (5) This slider's head
etc
00:33:580 (1) Add whistle (D:C1) at this slider's head to support the music
01:00:730 (8) Why not stack this note perfectly with the tail of this slider -> 01:00:280 (6) ?
Nothing wrong about the flow. That's nice
00:15:880 (1) This slider's tail
00:16:330 (2) This slider's tail
00:16:630 (4) This note
00:17:980 (3) This slider's head
00:18:430 (4) This note
00:18:880 (7) This slider's head
00:20:680 (6) This note
00:21:130 (8) This note
00:22:780 (2) This note
00:23:230 (5) This slider's head
00:23:680 (6) This slider's head
00:24:280 (1) This slider's tail
00:24:730 (4) This note
00:25:630 (8) This slider's head
00:26:680 (1) This slider's tail
00:27:130 (2) This slider's tail
00:27:580 (5) This slider's head
00:28:480 (9) This slider's head
00:32:380 (5) This slider's head
etc
00:33:580 (1) Add whistle (D:C1) at this slider's head to support the music
01:00:730 (8) Why not stack this note perfectly with the tail of this slider -> 01:00:280 (6) ?
Nothing wrong about the flow. That's nice
I can't mod higher than Insane, so I'll stop now
Good luck VINXIS