Takane6 wrote:

Weleh... baru aja masuk bulan baru... muncul drama ginian...
Its getting hotter here :3

please dont talk about attitude at each other... both of you hve a good point :3 I agree

maybe im not pro at this... but in my opinion... :
+first, Actually sakura have to re-bub it... because sakura pop it... if sakura dont... it means sakura just do a pop and run action???

+next, about hitsound... there is million hitsound that may not fit to the music but it can be fit if the hitsound are used in a proper place...
lets take a look at this map >>> Rex - Heart of Witch
the HS lookslike very awkward... (never find more awkward than this, sorry nowsmart xD) the music is full of piano... but the hitsound used is... wew.... and its very loud too... but it was used in a proper place... so its no problem (because its ranked)
the point is... it still okay for the HS.. the HS is fit to the music too...
if sakura said find a better hitsound...why not give the better one when pop it instead of ask someone?... as i said before... is this pop and run action?? too bad... i didnt see a charisma of a BN here... no offense... I agree x2

Takane6 wrote:

+next, about hitsound... there is million hitsound that may not fit to the music but it can be fit if the hitsound are used in a proper place...
lets take a look at this map >>> Rex - Heart of Witch
the HS lookslike very awkward...

nowsmart wrote:

I'm sorry, I'm still newbie about hitsound and this is my 1st map TT

[Shana Lesus] wrote:

what's happening here? o.o

[Shana Lesus] wrote:

what's happening here? o.o

SPY wrote:

Since we've stopped, I highly recommend
you not to start it again.

Takane6 wrote:

Start what? Its true... Right? Blame me if i did it wrong...
If you said you hve stopped... then What will happen into this map in the future?

Starry- wrote:

This is pointless, just stop. If you all wish to continue please carry our your concerns via PM with each other. Watching this thread just is painful and is no help to the mapper in improving their map - which should be the purpose of each post here after this map has just been popped.

Lets forget this all now, and help the mapper. Otherwise I'll probably just call someone to clean up these posts. It's ridiculous.

To the mapper: there are various points of concern which you might need to address before calling [ S a k u r a ] to rebubble your map.

Hitsounds:

I understand what Sakura means by them feeling a bit noisy. The main purpose (for most mappers) in creating hitsounds is to make them have a nice matching feel with the music - which currently it does not. The current clap sound, for example, feels too noisy or too prolonged. Since most of your mapping comes from layering drums mostly, it's best to get a more fitting 'snare' sound. The current finish sound doesn't match the music much at all.
I believe this is what caused concerns.

Furthermore, the hitsound placements aren't that consistent between each difficulty.
Sometimes, in 4K NM, for example, there will be finish, when in HD it is clap.
Sometimes, in 4K NM, for example, there will be whistle, when in HD there is no hitsound.
I recommend to do the following:

1. Open 4K NM difficulty in the editor
2. File -> Open Difficulty -> For Reference (the top bar, maybe in fullscreen you can't see these options well.)
3. Choose 4K HD
4. View -> Show Sample Name (the top bar, in fullscreen you can't see these options well.)

Then you can see a sidebyside comparison of hitsounds, and you can make them identical to each other.
If you need help with this, you can ask someone, or me if I'm free in IRC. It's really helpful to use.

Overall quality

Looking at the 4K NM diff alone, I can tell it has a few balance issues. That's why I said before, it's probably best to get this map a few more mods before asking Sakura for a rebubble. I'm sure people will have a few things to suggest.

Thank you Zan - for being productive with metadata within the last few posts.

What to do now

1. Fix hitsound consistency like I suggested in the hitsound section of this post.
2. Find a few more mods around via PM, #modreqs or within the modding queue forums.
3. Once you have around 2+ more mods in each diff, feel free to call Sakura back again.

Don't aim for bare minimum. Mapping isn't about creating 'your first ranked map!', but rather making an enjoyable and quality mapset for the player. Being lazy doesn't settle. So it's recommended, if you can, to get a few more mods.

If you have any issues, feel free to contact me via PM.

Zan - wrote:

[Metadata]

• 
  Tags:

1. [_M_o_m_o_]

2. delete anime, because it will be in anime genre if get ranked
3. remove mirai kuriyama akihito kanbara, because it's not their CV who sing this song (not a character song) but im not really sure about this too xp

Zan - wrote:

yes no need to kudosu \:D/

Verniy_Chan wrote:

Hi Meiko Senpai >.<)/
Mod from Moe Hunter Mania Queue

General : ( √ )
Mapset : ( √ )
Metadata : ( √ ) maybe you need more TAG
Timing : ( √ ) BPM 84.95 :3
Audio : ( √ ) Hitsound hmm~
Background : ( √ )

4K = |1|2|3|4|

4K NM

01:14:790 i hear stream sound here optional 1: add new LN here or optional 2: LN here 01:14:084 (74084|2) - end here 01:15:144 added option 2
seem it look perfect

4K HD

00:23:584 (23584|1,23937|2) Ctrl + G for balance hand ok
00:25:350 (25350|1) move to 1? follow pattern like 00:28:175 ok
00:25:703 (25703|2) if you aggre suggest like above, move 2 ok
00:31:588 (31588|0,31706|0) are you sure make patter like this? if you want 00:31:706 (31706|0) move to 4 moved
00:34:061 (34061|3) move to 2 and 00:34:178 (34178|1) move to 3 no
00:44:302 (44302|2) can you explain here? same sounds
00:52:777 (52777|3) ^ ^
00:59:605 add note? why?
01:14:790 - 01:15:144 i think hear another stream sound here I don't hear that D:
That all

I hope my mod can help you to rebubble this map
Nice Map and Good Luck for RANK -nya~ (づ｡◕‿‿◕｡)づ

Adinata28 wrote:

Hi Meiko, sorry for my late mod T^T)
Mod from Moe Hunter Mania Queue

Key :
|1|2|3|4|5|6|7|

General

Seems Fine~

7K NM

00:04:867 (4867|2) - Delete ? i think no need to double-note here. ok
00:05:573 (5573|6) - Move to 6 ? hand balance. Is really necessary? I think no problem
00:05:926 - Delete 1 note ? no need to double note ok
00:20:405 - Delete. ^ patron chaged
00:22:524 - Add note. no, here I'm not following the clap
00:23:584 (23584|6) - its awkward to me if you put Whistle here. agree
00:29:234 (29234|1) - same here. ^
00:26:762 (26762|5) - Maybe, move to 5 ? ok
00:35:944 (35944|5,35944|2) - why not do Reverse of 00:35:238 (35238|0,35238|2) - ? => http://puu.sh/gvOhB/8169c1bf27.png idk (?
00:36:297 - Add a note ? no
00:37:003 - Add a note necessary?
00:40:888 (40888|0) - Move to 2 ? Hand Balance. ok
01:14:790 (74790|1) - Move to 1 and then 01:14:790 (74790|5) - Move to 7 why :c
Nice~ thanks :3

Good Luck, Meiko ^.^)/

Frim4503 wrote:

col:1,2,3,4,5,6,7

7K NM

00:36:650 - add note. make double, same sound as 00:33:825 (33825|5,33825|2) - ok~
00:37:357 - add note
00:45:832 (45832|6) - move to 4 ^

4K HD

00:53:248 (53248|2) - make double. same sound as 00:50:423 (50423|1,50423|2) - ok :3
00:57:486 - ^ same ok

other dif seem fine to me

please reply before
expired 24/3/2015

shionelove wrote:

Thanks for fun story,and good luck for rank!

Z3nx wrote:

Replied to the offline pm you sent

hahahahah no kds ( really )

Opinions are never welcome when not asked for, so click if you wanna

Hi personal onion on le hitsounds here :

Hitsounding is something that's really amazing if you can execute it well

- Le deep quote from some Einstein thing ( not really )

jkjk

The hitsound here is not bad, however, what is kinda uhhhh how do I say it, uhh, kinda distracting and unnatural is the heavy bass on whistle/normal, N:C3, would be great if it's toned down a lil bit

2ndly, some hitsounds overlap too much and creates something that is outstanding, eg. 01:01:371 (61371|1,61371|6,61371|0) - which kinda feels weird ( you know what i mean )

Some hitsounds have a massive gap at the tail, would be preferred if they are cut for file size


Hitsounding can become something that would make players crank up their effects volume just to feel the satisfaction of it, it can be used to deter players, try to balance it out and make sure it's pleasant to the ears ~

( Coincidentally, https://osu.ppy.sh/s/118494 Lifetheory's Daisy has some really amazing additive hitsounding that makes me real excited, the hitsounds here makes the whole beatmap a notch better | Even using defaults like this https://osu.ppy.sh/s/149528 makes the whole experience better )
( Before you start flaming me on how that is std and how this is mania, remember that we are listening to the same audio, enjoy the hitsounding, enjoy the music, enjoy the combination, and most importantly enjoy playing the beatmap as a whole ~ )

shi shiny teeth!

[Shana Lesus] wrote:

Hello Meiko
BN check

[General]

BG :
Audio :
Timing :
Spread :
Metadata :

Source : 境界の彼方 and add in tags kyoukai no kanata

Pattern Review:
(notice that columns are following like 1 2 3 4 for 4K diffs and 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 7K diffs)

[7K NM]

00:03:101 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3052413 or https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3052433
00:04:514 (4514|3) - delete


[4K NM]

01:08:257 (68257|3) - delete
01:08:434 - http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3052471

[4K HD]

00:13:872 - add note to 4
00:13:931 (13931|3) - delete
00:14:225 (14225|2) - delete
00:22:877 - https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3052490
00:42:536 (42536|1) - delete
00:46:715 - add note to 3
01:11:141 (71141|2) - delete
01:11:259 (71259|1) - move to 3

[Momo's 7K HD]

00:21:818 (21818|4) - delete

[Shana Lesus] wrote:

BG :
Audio :
Timing :
Spread :
Metadata :

other problems have been corrected with Meiko through irc

All diffs checked, with patterns and hitsounds all right
Qualified

YunoFanatic wrote:

very nice!

juankristal wrote:

Argentina tiene mappers, si señor

Felicidades ;D

Takane6 wrote:

yosh! gratz >w<)b

Kyousuke- wrote:

grazzz =w=b

-[ AmiShici ]- wrote:

Omedeto Senpai >,<)/

Verniy_Chan wrote:

wah..
finally~ qualified
Gratz >w<)