chomelisgod wrote:

You promised me that I'll be happy and grateful after this. Dont lie to me ._.
Hard:
02:01:520 - That circle overlaps too much with the two sliders front and behind. I would move slider 1 to the right and slider 3 to the left, positioning the circle towards the centre. Fixed that

Kyversible insane:
01:39:128 - Objects end isnt snapped, but i guess its not noticeable. It's intentional

apoplexy:
03:10:592 - It looks so confusing, so i would straighten out or organise this triplet of circles to look neater. it's just the way hanzer maps lol
03:15:878 - I would prefer a straight or organised line of circles.
03:16:735 - ^

Overall, awesome song, awesome mapping, can really see the effort put into it. The osu system isnt too happy with the amount of kiai time your using so careful with that. GL with ranked.

Musty wrote:

This is concerning the hardest difficulty. It's mostly suggestions:
00:53:735 (4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - it doesn't feel obvious while playing for me but i think it's alright? Yeah, suggested by nold and I quite liked it.
01:20:306 (3,4,1) - 01:21:163 (3,4,1) - 01:27:163 (3,4,1) - this is not fun to play because the music actually seems to be have a fast paced rhythm which is stable here, so it feels like you have to go faster because the map is like that and it's not really fun to play to be honest but everyone else liked it ;__; i prefer to keep it for now
02:28:163 (4) - put the note a bit slightly lower because it feels like its as close as the previous one fixed for Ends since i don't think it's a big deal
03:15:449 (1,1,1,1,2,1,2,1,1,1,1,1,2,1,2,1) - This is uber creative but i don't like that kind of stuff which is pretty surprising while playing sightread. just hanzer being hanzer B) jokes aside he liked it so no change,,,


everything else on the difficulty is absolutely perfect i love this one so much

Static Noise Bird wrote:

Just a few things here before it's ready to go.

[general_]
The ending spinner could start at the same point in all diffs (kyversible-insane and normal are inconsistent with the other three).
The widescreen support should probably be unticked in the diffs that don't have SB. it's actually intentional to left them all ticked
Slightly concerned about the hard/insane gap, but we'll see how it goes. only qats gets concerned by diff spread :^)

[easy_]
03:02:592 (3,4) - The DS. The. Rotate (4,5) by 25-40 degrees, snap to an appropriate distance and we're good. The.

[hard_]
00:44:592 (3) - NC.
01:24:020 (5) - ^ done both

[insane_]
inverness [✓]

[apofluxus_]
(✓?_?)✓

Poke (preferably via THElegram) when you've updated this and let's get the party started.
e

Desperate-kun wrote:

After internal discussion, we decided to disqualify this mapset over the following concerns.

[apoplexy_]

All of the issues below apply to the first part of the collab, mapped by inverness.

Some of the rhythms need improvement in terms of circle-slider composition, as they don't reflect the song's rhythm well. For example, 00:51:449 (1,2,3,4) - would make more sense like this: http://puu.sh/hrEG1/491fbcdb6c.jpg as the two beats emphasized by the song here, 00:51:878 and 00:52:163 -, would both be clickable then. It will make the pattern play more intuitively.
Other examples:
00:53:163 (1,2,3,4) -
00:58:306 (1,2,3,4) -
01:05:163 (1,2,3,4) -

i don't really see your point between bad song reflection (or whatever you call it) with the patterns themselves. judging from your suggestion, is it because the sliders didn't start on white ticks or something? also for the emphasis beats you stated, if those are really emphasis, you missed 00:51:735 - which basically sounds the same like the emphasis beats as you stated. therefore, it's not really an emphasis, at least for me. my patterns worked out well, considering everyone didn't really see them as much of an issue.

01:20:306 (3,4,1) - While these kind of 1/4 jumps are generally a nice and challenging gimmick, some of them happen to not play very smoothly due to weird transitions, which makes them unpleasant to play. Examples would be:
01:28:020 (3,4,1) -
01:21:163 (3,4,1) -

these are not 1/4 lol
please enlighten me on what you said by "weird transition" and "unpleasant gameplay" because again, nobody (including me) had any problems whatsoever with it

[Normal]

Be careful with short multiple-repeat sliders. As they are very short, players of this level are not able to read when the slider will end. Therefore, the patterns involving them need to have simple, easily readable placement, that doesn't involve going back over the slidertrack, stacking or anything similar. Examples:
01:21:735 (5,1) -
02:43:735 (6,1) -

Additionally, there are some tiny spacing errors in this difficulty, sometimes caused by stacking, that make objects touch each other slightly although they are not supposed to, which should be fixed to avoid confusion and to make the map more polished. Examples:
00:53:163 (1,2) -
01:30:878 (4,5) -

Sorry that it took so long. We wish you the best of luck with your mapset!