just pass by and I think I can help with the rerank.
mod info:
Black: Suggestions.
Bule: Emphasis suggestions.
Red: Unrankable stuffs. Must be fixed.
Personal opinions: (I am sorry if you find it hard to read it bcz of my bad English)
I think the map introduced to a new concept of mapping style. In this case, we cannot judge the map's quality with the common point of view. So I don't expect to hear words related to #osumapping2015. It hurts the mapper, as well as the modders, and it just shows one's disrespect to the mapper and rudeness.
Streams are fine bcz of the song itself. Though 5-minute stream party may be tiring but it is fine after all bcz the map is overall challenging. And that's why I find no overmapping in the map.
Since the map breaks no ranking criteria and it is unranked due to individual opinions (maybe the different understandings of QUALITY), I just don't agree with the disapproval. But on the other hand, I hope that people can get together to understand each other better through the unranking process (but not a drama). And the map deserves an approval after all.
We don't always need so-called high-quality maps but maps for playing. Products serve for use, but not for appreciation, and so do beatmaps.
Please give the map a try. Thank you.
Good luck
如果这图rerank不了我的L还怎么办啊QuQ
_______________________________________
mod info:
Black: Suggestions.
Bule: Emphasis suggestions.
Red: Unrankable stuffs. Must be fixed.
[HIGAN TORRENT]
- 02:59:191 (1,2) - You can make a better blanket here ((1)'s tail and (2)'s path), just like how you do 03:04:740 (1,2) -
- 04:03:006 (1,2,3,4,5) - I've tried mapping such a pattern for some times but I don't think it looks good (and the pattern won't let the part be more joyful to play bcz a player don't need to move his/her cursor to hit 1,2,3,4)
- 04:25:116 (16,1) - it will be frustrating for the player to break here lol
- 05:00:925 (2,3,4,5,1) - 总感觉有点玩过头了
_______________________________________
Agree.
[quote="captin1"]
unfortunate that this is the reality of the QAT now, that they believe they can make subjective unranks for "map quality" without any attempt at improving the map because they believe their definition of "quality" is more important than the BATs involved in ranking the map
I personally don't have much of an opinion on the map one way or the other, but the simple fact that this was unqualified on such a weak concept just disappoints me
unfortunate that this is the reality of the QAT now, that they believe they can make subjective unranks for "map quality" without any attempt at improving the map because they believe their definition of "quality" is more important than the BATs involved in ranking the map
I personally don't have much of an opinion on the map one way or the other, but the simple fact that this was unqualified on such a weak concept just disappoints me
Personal opinions: (I am sorry if you find it hard to read it bcz of my bad English)
I think the map introduced to a new concept of mapping style. In this case, we cannot judge the map's quality with the common point of view. So I don't expect to hear words related to #osumapping2015. It hurts the mapper, as well as the modders, and it just shows one's disrespect to the mapper and rudeness.
Streams are fine bcz of the song itself. Though 5-minute stream party may be tiring but it is fine after all bcz the map is overall challenging. And that's why I find no overmapping in the map.
Since the map breaks no ranking criteria and it is unranked due to individual opinions (maybe the different understandings of QUALITY), I just don't agree with the disapproval. But on the other hand, I hope that people can get together to understand each other better through the unranking process (but not a drama). And the map deserves an approval after all.
We don't always need so-called high-quality maps but maps for playing. Products serve for use, but not for appreciation, and so do beatmaps.
Please give the map a try. Thank you.
Good luck
