xxdeathx wrote:
I bubbled CloudSplash16's Black Bullet loli duo song p/3839269#p3839269 - just be careful about the artist:
There's an ongoing discussion in ranking criteria forums about about whether the artist should include Enju and Tina's names since they are just characters from Black Bullet, but this is what KSHR told Cloudsplash to go with for now, and the rest of the map looks good.
I don't think the situation should hinder the map's bubble though, so I gave it.
I should probably clarify this.
As some of you know already, there is the forum where the exact same thing has been discussed in the Ranking Criteria sub forum.
If you've never read it, please read
it first.
As you can read, I'm all for this suggestion that only voice actors' names should be added to unicode/romanized artist fields.
The following are reasons why I agree with this.
1. They are real singers who sing the song, also characters are fictional.
2. To prevent BSS error. For more detail, please refer to
Sonnyc's post.
3. It looks weird.However I told CloudSplash to keep the current artist because even I don't know if this can be a valid reason for the disqualification. Well I guess no one probably cares such a thing though. In conclusion, I think it'd be safe to keep the current one until the rule about this is stated into the Ranking Criteria.
I would appreciate it if you could post your opinion in the forum which I linked above.