CelsiusLK wrote:

recheck, no kds

[General]

1. I'm pretty unsure, is "KANON NAKAGAWA" need to be capitalize ?

[Kawaii]

1. 00:08:111 (4) - NC here for different snap ? it think its not needed
2. 00:11:511 (4) - Ctrl+G would make here 00:11:111 (3,4) - a bit better imo i like the current flow
3. 00:14:211 (3) - Delete whistle ? sound a bit not right for me i think its fine
4. 00:21:311 - Increase volume a bit here around 20% sound a bit better for me here ok
5. 00:20:911 (3,1) - Try this rhythm ?
   SPOILER

   
   sound bettter imo , it kinda feel a bit awkward for me here since you intend to use slider end on downbeat here 00:21:511 - nah its fine imo
6. 00:42:711 - Hitsound volume 30% ? 20% is fine
7. 00:45:511 - the hitsound volume is a bit low here , try increase a bit to around 35-40% would be good , just to be safe here 20% is fine
8. 00:46:311 - ^ ^
9. 00:51:911 (1,4) - I recommend end these on 1/2 because it make the rhythm here play a bit better for me the 1/4 sound pretty a bit not need to be map that much imo since the way you use 1/4 spacing at slider end doesn't feel right to me somehow but it's up to you here i think it fits
10. 00:55:111 (1,1,4) - ^ ^
11. 01:14:311 - Hitsound volume 40% sound nice here it's fine imo
    copy-paste hitsound mods to other diffs

[Hard]

1. 00:08:211 (5) - Delete this ? since the beat is 1/6 here , 1/4 not sound like 1/6 that much imo yea
2. 01:00:511 (3) - 1/2 normal slider sound a bit better here imo i think it's fine
3. 01:20:211 (6) - Same as 00:08:211 (5) - ok

[Normal]

1. 01:06:711 (5) - Add clap at head and use whistle at tail instead ? yeah fixed
2. 01:03:111 (4) - Whistle at head ? i think it will be too much

[Easy]

2. 00:07:111 (3,1) - Sound a bit weird here , try this ? mapping 00:07:711 -
   SPOILER

   
   you have to do something with the slidertick sound here too if you fix

Call me back
for recheck

NolanM wrote:

Kawaii =^_^=

I think 8.5 approach rate is better im not sure... hm..
00:14:211 (3) is too far from 00:13:911 (2) I think. This jump is too hard comparing it with the rest of the song. ok
00:32:511 (4,1,2,3,4) - This group has big jumps, but 00:32:711 (1,2) are too close together. Maybe you can move 00:32:911 (2) to x:176 y:246. Isee that you're trying to stack it with the slider before, but when played, it doesn't feel like it flows that much. did something here
00:33:911 (5) - Maybe you can stack this on top of 00:33:311 (4) . that anti jump seems a bit harsh for me
01:28:911 (1) - If you want to, stack on top of 01:27:911 (2) ? i think its fine
01:31:802 - Move this a little bit further away from 01:31:511 (1), because I have the urgency to tap it a little earlier the way it is. sure

Hard :O

00:40:311 (4) - I think this is too hard to read for hard players, because it's also similar to something you used in Insane too :3 Maybe you can just move it to the side a little, so it's not stacked on top of 00:40:311 (4) . ok
Is it allowed for 7.5 AR? If so, I think it's better with 7.5 AR :3 raised it a little
00:46:311 (2) - Fix DS more i dont see whats wrong

Normal :3

01:10:711 (5,6) - You can make this a stack would be confusing imo
01:14:311 (1) - Why does normal have a spinner when hard/insane does not? same as easy

Easy

01:14:311 (1) - Same thing, why does normal and easy have a spinner here and other difficulties do not? because I think it fits for a short spinner
01:31:511 (3) - I think other mods will say that this is not easy enough for easy, but I think it's fine. Plus, what can you replace it with?? i changed to something easier

Sorry, this mod wasn't that detailed. When you mod my map, feel free only to make it as descriptive as this mod was, if you want :3
Good luck! This song is hawt :3 And I <3 dat background

1. how is this diff name even relevant to the song
2. 01:12:511 (1) - i feel this nc isn't too necessary
3. 00:21:311 - i think we've discussed about this before? what did u end up unsilencing that for the other map? do the same here

1. 00:07:911 (4,5,6) - dude u even used 1/6 on ur insane diff.
   01:20:111 (5,6) - ^
2. 00:30:911 (4,1) - why does this look so off
3. 00:35:911 - the head could use some hitsounds?
   00:39:111 (1) - ^
   

1. 00:35:711 (3,4) - a double circle like this is good for emphasizing stuff that sound alike, but here its a vocal then instrument. so u could switch to slider instead
2. 00:51:911 (1,2) - here u can try 1/2 repeats instead i think it would be fitting towards the instruments that stand out here
   00:58:311 (1,2) - ^

1. 00:34:311 (1,2) - ew /me runs
2. 01:06:311 (2) - this part just feels a bit weird >> u could try this
   
   SPOILER

   

Kibbleru wrote:

general

kawaii

1. how is this diff name even relevant to the song reported
2. 01:12:511 (1) - i feel this nc isn't too necessary ya
3. 00:21:311 - i think we've discussed about this before? what did u end up unsilencing that for the other map? do the same here haven't touched this diff since that discussion. fixed from previous mod anyway

hard

1. 00:07:911 (4,5,6) - dude u even used 1/6 on ur insane diff. already fixed from previous mods
   01:20:111 (5,6) - ^ ^
2. 00:30:911 (4,1) - why does this look so off what
3. 00:35:911 - the head could use some hitsounds? rip hitsound copier
   00:39:111 (1) - ^ ^

normal

1. 00:35:711 (3,4) - a double circle like this is good for emphasizing stuff that sound alike, but here its a vocal then instrument. so u could switch to slider instead i think it's fine
2. 00:51:911 (1,2) - here u can try 1/2 repeats instead i think it would be fitting towards the instruments that stand out here nah i'd rather have them like this
   00:58:311 (1,2) - ^

easy

1. 00:34:311 (1,2) - ew /me runs reported
2. 01:06:311 (2) - this part just feels a bit weird >> u could try this changed to something else
   
   SPOILER

   

1. use 60% volume here 01:17:311 - ? so the hitsound volume will somehow consistent with hard and insane
2. 01:06:711 - Why no whistle here too ? , just like hard and insane

1. 00:21:311 - aw yea , you should delete this green timing point since you don't want to use low volume for this tick now in insane <_<

Sekai-nyan wrote:

Call me after you get Celsius' bubble =3=/

CelsiusLK wrote:

easy and normal

1. use 60% volume here 01:17:311 - ? so the hitsound volume will somehow consistent with hard and insane
2. 01:06:711 - Why no whistle here too ? , just like hard and insane

hard

1. 00:21:311 - aw yea , you should delete this green timing point since you don't want to use low volume for this tick now in insane <_<

oh you nerfed easy ? there is no 1/2 slider here now 00:15:111 - , 00:18:311 -

Call me back <_<

Kibbleru wrote:

IM RANKING THIS NO NINJA PLS

Setz wrote:

SAMMA BOIIIIIIIIII

No Dap wrote:

rip

Lust wrote:

Howdy No Dap, I spoke to you in game over this:

I will have to disqualify this mapset due to the very quiet hitsounds around 00:45:511 - in the hard and insane difficulties. Players need to have the feedback, especially considering one of the quiet hitsounds is located on a clickable object. +10 - 15% should do the trick.

The BNG will handle this mapet from now on. Should be a quick requalification. Good luck!