Crystal
Crystal wrote:
Hi Cloud~ mod from queue
sorry for late w[Insane]
- 00:06:477 (1,2) - Consider changing these to a slider, the rhythm here isn't so clear, and too many circles will lead to a confusion on reading. I prefer circles here.
- 00:20:585 (1,2,3) - Stacking like this will make the stream harder, which doesn't fit the map's difficulty imo. ;; (Same goes on 01:20:908 (1,2,3) - ) I like these though. I think they match the song well.
- 00:59:017 (3) - 256|140 might be better. I don't think so.
- 01:44:259 (8) - The direction of the slider might make the flow harder to play. I suggest putting the head at 368|232 and the end at 388|268. ok
[Hard]
- 00:14:260 (4,5) - I thought it is 1/2 at first play. Since the location makes it hard to change, I suggest adding a NC. I don't think it needs NC. It's quite readable as 1/1 at AR8.
- Fine.
Good luck!
appleeaterx
appleeaterx wrote:
Hello CloudSplash16! from my queue
dunno if you already fixed somethings from the other mod o_o:idea: General
* Add audio lead-in time in every diff? I thought it's already enough, but I'll add a bit more...Hard
* 00:11:504 (3,4) - CTRL+G for rhythm only? The string sound at 00:11:666 - should have more emphasis than 00:11:504 (3) - imo No, I prefer the current rhythm.
* 00:34:531 (2,3) - No 1.3x spacing here like the rest of the combo? Nope
* 00:54:801 (1,2,3,4) - Same as Insane Needs stack for the emphasis, I guess I'll add a NC.
* 00:57:396 (1) - Same as Insane, I'd add a finish here like Meyrink :3 ok
* 01:15:881 (4,1) - Use 1.2/1.3 spacing here? Everytime you have a gap in the KIAI you use 1.2/1.3 so why not It doesn't matter. Current placement plays nice.
* 01:18:151 - I do recommend mapping this hi-hat sound out here. Having a gap at a red tick where there's no actual sound in the song itself like 01:15:881 (4,1) - is fine, but not here, or else parts like 01:23:340 (3) - shouldn't be mapped either. No, current rhythm is good.
* 01:26:421 (4) - I'd split this one into 2 circles to make the finish clickable. I see that you're trying to follow the guitar here, but the cymbal sound in the song is more important in my eyes. I think this slider end flow does a fine job of emphasizing the finish. Click =/= emphasis.
* 01:43:611 (2) - Point the slider end to somewhere else, so that it flows much better to (3)? There is no problem with the flow.Insane
* 00:25:774 (8,9,1) - I'd actually make the distance between (9,1) larger than (8,9). To me, clap-to-finish should get more emphasis than bass-to-clap. It doesn't matter.
* 00:30:963 (5,6,1) - ^ ^
* 00:37:125 (2) - Hmm.. I don't recommend doing this here. With a repeat slider like this, you miss the vocals + clap on 00:37:287 (3) - . Try a circle + slider here instead? I'd be nice if the vocal+clap was actually clickable here. No, it's not necessary to have clicks on them. The repeat emphasizes the clap well, and in the way I want it.
* 00:57:396 (1) - Meyrink has a finish here, and I think you should add it too, there's a cymbal in the song ;w; ok
* 00:57:882 (2,3) - I'd CTRL+G these for rhythm only. Considering that there's no real hold-note in the song at 00:57:882 (2) - , there shouldn't be a slider there imo. I prefer the current rhythm because the slider end goes nicely with the hihat, and increase emphasis on the bass and clap after.
* 00:59:990 (1,2,3,4) - This confused me a lot. (1,2) are one stack, and (3,4) as well - but there's a small break at (3,4). This can be easily misread and I recommend you to space it out for readability. It's perfectly readable at AR9.
* 01:10:205 (5) - Add whistle on the slider end for the bass sound? No.
Nice mapset, needs a bit more patches in the Hearts diff but I think it'll be fine after a few more mods!
If you want you can call me back if you want the Easy diff modded as well.
I hope you can rank this soon, good luck o3o/
EDIT: you can have a star as well
CelsiusLK
Thanks guys.CelsiusLK wrote:
Hi, modding here
[General][Hard]
- Meyringk's Normal have check on widescreen support while the others doesn't fixed
[Insane]
- 00:02:260 (5) - NC this ? the beat here sound so strong here and the rhythm here is quite different from the previous so I guess it okay to NC here Not necessary.
- 00:04:855 (5) - Similiar to above ^
- 00:17:828 (7) - Whistle at tail? No, it doesn't match my hitsound pattern. It's a weaker beat.
- 00:18:801 (2) - Whistle at head? No.
- 00:19:125 (3) - ^ No.
- 00:25:612 (7) - Ctrl+H this? it can make the flow to the next note a bit better , and I find it quite awkward having to flow to the same direction as 00:25:287 (6) - since I feel like the music on these two notes do not really feel the same imo I like the current flow.
- 00:33:882 (8) - How about delete this note , I feel like you first follow the instrument really nice but why you follow the vocal here it okay to follow the vocal if you can suppose to put this on a new combo pattern but it just feels weird to change the thing to follow in a middle of combo eventhough the note is at the end of the combo like this one imo Circle stacked on slider end helps make strong emphasis on the next note.
- 00:58:044 - Why not map this beat? Current rhythm follows bass and snare drum sounds.
- 01:01:774 (2,3) - How about convert to 1/1 slider because the way the vocal sing this part is somhow a bit suit for slider imo No.
Great HardHere a star from me
- 00:04:855 (1,4,5) - Stack this? so it feels a bit consistent with the next notes I can't do it because it will break spacing or break my other stack.
- 00:05:179 (2) - Whistle at head? No.
- 00:18:477 (1) - Whitstle at tail? ok
- 00:19:774 (1,2,3,4,5) - How about place these like this ? imo the current one flow a bit weird at 00:20:098 (3,4) - having to move to (4) which line up with (2) then go straight to (5) which a bit line up straight to (4) , it kinda feels weird for me to apply that flow at the part where the music doesn't really has anything that feels like it need to change to sudden straight downward jumps Moved a bit.
- 00:28:206 (8) - Ctrl+G? for better flow and spacing imo No.
- 00:36:314 (8) - Whistle? No.
Nice Insane ,I really enjoy it
Good luck
Momovely's diff removed on his request. :<
@Momovely, let me know if you change your mind.