CLSW wrote:

* Removed soft-sliderslide, and soft-sliderslide2.wav cuz they were useless on Taiko and CtB both.

Okay, now it seems ready, Enjoy your apple!

• [Kantan]

1. 00:12:320 (7,8) - consider removing finish for these two notes ? A bit overemphasized imo.
2. 00:23:891 (21,22) - swap these notes to k d ? This could fit both the vocal and the snare at 00:23:891 -
3. 00:29:462 (29,31) - swap these notes to d k ? Similar to ^
4. 00:44:034 (50,51) - swap these notes to d k ? The vocal at 00:44:462 (51) - is higher-pitched than 00:44:034 (50) -
5. 00:57:748 (70) - maybe d here to show the drop in vocal pitch ?
6. 01:25:605 - How about adding k here and change 01:26:034 (110) - to d ? The patterns in this part are just too sparse that they does not fit the music well.

• [Futsuu]

1. 00:11:034 (11,12) - maybe k d here to maintain a better pattern consistency as 00:07:605 (2,3) - ?
2. 00:12:320 (14,15,16) - Similar to Kantan, d k D would be better here.
3. 00:15:320 (19,20,21) - It seems that k d k could follow the snares nicely.
4. 00:16:391 (22,23) - try changing 00:16:391 (22) - to k and move 00:16:605 (23) - to 00:16:819 - and change to d ? This could follow the vocal in a way better.
5. 00:21:320 (35) - consider deleting this to make it consistent to 00:24:748 - ?
6. 00:23:891 (42) - k could follow both the vocal and the snare there.
7. 00:42:962 (92) - maybe k here to fit the high-pitched vocal ?
8. 00:44:462 (96) - maybe k here for snare consistency ?
9. 01:26:462 (187,188) - Again, k d could follow the snare at 01:26:462 (187) - , thus resulting in a better flow imo.

• [Muzukashii]

1. 00:08:462 (8) - k could fit both the vocal and the snare there.
2. 00:11:891 (24) - ^
3. 00:15:534 (39,41) - swap these notes to d k ? This could accompany the increase in vocal pitch there.
4. 00:16:819 (43,44) - d k could follow the snare at 00:17:034 (44) -
5. 00:23:891 (71) - same as Futsuu
6. 00:36:534 (118,119) - same as 00:16:819 (43,44) -
7. 00:39:962 (133,134,135,136) - consider removing the finishes here ? A bit overemphasized imo. Also, d k k d could follow the vocal pitch better.
8. 00:48:320 (165) - K ? The vocal pitch there is higher than 00:48:748 (166,167) -
9. 00:49:177 (167) - D would be better since it has the same vocal pitch as 00:48:748 (166) -
10. 00:52:177 (178) - ^
11. 00:55:605 (191) - ^
12. 01:02:462 (216) - ^
13. 01:08:891 (241) - same as 00:48:320 (165) -
14. 01:09:748 (243) - same as 00:49:177 (167) -
15. 01:18:212 (275) - This note appears to be a little bit awkward. Consider deleting it to follow 01:16:498 - ?
16. 01:29:891 (318) - same as 00:49:177 (167) -
17. 01:33:320 (332,333) - K D would be nice since the vocal pitch at 01:33:320 (332) - is higher than that at 01:33:748 (333) -
18. 01:36:748 (346) - same as 00:49:177 (167) -

• [Oni]

1. 00:10:820 (21,22) - maybe d k for the sake of snare consistency ?
2. 00:19:391 (64,65,66,67) - It seems the d kkk could result in a better flow of notes since the vocal pitch at 00:19:391 (64) - is lower than that at 00:18:962 (63) -
3. 00:26:998 (101) - k could follow the background clapping sound nicely.
4. 00:28:177 (108) - k could fit both the high-pitched vocal as well as the snare there.
5. 00:39:962 (168,169,170,171) - same as Muzukashii
6. 00:46:712 (201) - consider deleting this note ? There is no obvious sound to be followed.
7. 00:48:320 (212,214) - swap these notes to K D ? Same as Muzukashii.
8. 00:52:177 (228) - same as Muzukashii
9. 00:55:177 (242,244) - same as 00:48:320 (212,214) -
10. 01:02:034 (280,282) - ^
11. 01:05:891 (298,299) - K D could match the vocal pitch nicely.
12. 01:09:320 (315) - same as Muzukashii
13. 01:14:248 (343) - d could represent the drop in vocal pitch there.
14. 01:29:462 (433,435) - same as 00:48:320 (212,214) -
15. 01:36:320 (467,469) - ^

Nardoxyribonucleic wrote:

Hi, here comes a taiko mod as requested in my queue. Hi

[General]

Delete the timing point at 01:02:034 - which is redundant for all diffs. Fixed

• [Kantan]

1. 00:12:320 (7,8) - consider removing finish for these two notes ? A bit overemphasized imo. Delete finish at (8)
2. 00:23:891 (21,22) - swap these notes to k d ? This could fit both the vocal and the snare at 00:23:891 - Fixed
3. 00:29:462 (29,31) - swap these notes to d k ? Similar to ^ Fixed
4. 00:44:034 (50,51) - swap these notes to d k ? The vocal at 00:44:462 (51) - is higher-pitched than 00:44:034 (50) - Fixed
5. 00:57:748 (70) - maybe d here to show the drop in vocal pitch ? Fixed
6. 01:25:605 - How about adding k here and change 01:26:034 (110) - to d ? The patterns in this part are just too sparse that they does not fit the music well. Fixed

• [Futsuu]

1. 00:11:034 (11,12) - maybe k d here to maintain a better pattern consistency as 00:07:605 (2,3) - ? Fixed
2. 00:12:320 (14,15,16) - Similar to Kantan, d k D would be better here. change to D k D
3. 00:15:320 (19,20,21) - It seems that k d k could follow the snares nicely. Fixed
4. 00:16:391 (22,23) - try changing 00:16:391 (22) - to k and move 00:16:605 (23) - to 00:16:819 - and change to d ? This could follow the vocal in a way better. Fixed
5. 00:21:320 (35) - consider deleting this to make it consistent to 00:24:748 - ? Fixed
6. 00:23:891 (42) - k could follow both the vocal and the snare there. Fixed
7. 00:42:962 (92) - maybe k here to fit the high-pitched vocal ? Fixed
8. 00:44:462 (96) - maybe k here for snare consistency ? Fixed
9. 01:26:462 (187,188) - Again, k d could follow the snare at 01:26:462 (187) - , thus resulting in a better flow imo. Fixed

• [Muzukashii]

1. 00:08:462 (8) - k could fit both the vocal and the snare there. Fixed
2. 00:11:891 (24) - ^ Fixed
3. 00:15:534 (39,41) - swap these notes to d k ? This could accompany the increase in vocal pitch there. Fixed
4. 00:16:819 (43,44) - d k could follow the snare at 00:17:034 (44) - Fixed
5. 00:23:891 (71) - same as Futsuu Fixed
6. 00:36:534 (118,119) - same as 00:16:819 (43,44) - Fixed
7. 00:39:962 (133,134,135,136) - consider removing the finishes here ? A bit overemphasized imo. Also, d k k d could follow the vocal pitch better. Fixed
8. 00:48:320 (165) - K ? The vocal pitch there is higher than 00:48:748 (166,167) - Fixed
9. 00:49:177 (167) - D would be better since it has the same vocal pitch as 00:48:748 (166) - Fixed
10. 00:52:177 (178) - ^ Fixed
11. 00:55:605 (191) - ^ Fixed
12. 01:02:462 (216) - ^ Fixed
13. 01:08:891 (241) - same as 00:48:320 (165) - Fixed
14. 01:09:748 (243) - same as 00:49:177 (167) - Fixed
15. 01:18:212 (275) - This note appears to be a little bit awkward. Consider deleting it to follow 01:16:498 - ? Fixed
16. 01:29:891 (318) - same as 00:49:177 (167) - Fixed
17. 01:33:320 (332,333) - K D would be nice since the vocal pitch at 01:33:320 (332) - is higher than that at 01:33:748 (333) - Umm...Not change
18. 01:36:748 (346) - same as 00:49:177 (167) - Fixed

• [Oni]

1. 00:10:820 (21,22) - maybe d k for the sake of snare consistency ? Fixed
2. 00:19:391 (64,65,66,67) - It seems the d kkk could result in a better flow of notes since the vocal pitch at 00:19:391 (64) - is lower than that at 00:18:962 (63) - Fixed
3. 00:26:998 (101) - k could follow the background clapping sound nicely. Fixed
4. 00:28:177 (108) - k could fit both the high-pitched vocal as well as the snare there. Fixed
5. 00:39:962 (168,169,170,171) - same as Muzukashii Fixed
6. 00:46:712 (201) - consider deleting this note ? There is no obvious sound to be followed. Um...Not change
7. 00:48:320 (212,214) - swap these notes to K D ? Same as Muzukashii. Fixed
8. 00:52:177 (228) - same as Muzukashii Fixed
9. 00:55:177 (242,244) - same as 00:48:320 (212,214) - Fixed
10. 01:02:034 (280,282) - ^ Fixed
11. 01:05:891 (298,299) - K D could match the vocal pitch nicely. Fixed
12. 01:09:320 (315) - same as Muzukashii Fixed
13. 01:14:248 (343) - d could represent the drop in vocal pitch there. Fixed
14. 01:29:462 (433,435) - same as 00:48:320 (212,214) - Fixed
15. 01:36:320 (467,469) - ^ Fixed

That's all and good luck~

- Love1yV1ruS - wrote:

From my modding queue

oni

00:18:748 (62,63) - ctrl + g Fixed
and.... nothing else gj =。=

muzu

01:41:034 (362) - how about put it here 01:40:819 Fixed
and... nothing again...

futsuu

01:13:177 (159) - put it here 01:13:391 Um...I thing not
01:40:605 (217) - 01:40:819 ^

kantan

nothing. gj

eat my star and good luck

mrdumpling64 wrote:

Hi from mod queue

Legend:
d = small don
k = small kat
D = don with finish
K = kat with finish

Kantan

00:49:177 (58) - I don't think finisher fits this note. not change for same all diff
00:56:034 (68) - ^ ^
01:02:891 (78) - ^ ^
01:05:034 (81) - k might fit this better? Fixed

Futsuu

00:08:462 (4,5) - dk might fit the beat better? Fixed
00:09:320 (6,7,8) - ddk Fixed
01:07:177 (144,145) - dk? Um...not change

not much to point out, good diff.

Muzukashi

00:17:891 (47) - k? Fixed and change some note
00:25:177 (75) - ^ Umm...No
01:01:177 (211,212) - dd ^

Oni

nothing really to point out, good diff.

Good mapset overall, starred

1. 01:41:462(133,134) could be changed to k
2. Seems fine

1. 00:10:605 can be removed
2. 00:17:462 ^

1. 00:10:605 d , personally I don't suggest putting triplets other than ddd or kkk in a muzukashii, it is very rare. This applies to all notes in this diff
2. 01:21:748 d
3. 01:25:177 d
4. 01:28:605 d

1. 00:16:712 remove , vocal ends at the previous note
2. This diff is also fine

mliencheng wrote:

mod from mod queue request

[General]

I don't suggest changing much the key volume , but 40% is really quite low

Since this is a taiko map , it's okay for the drum sound to be slightly high , it also helps the rhythm of gameplay

Anyways, I think 01:22:605 this time section could possibly be removed Ok change some green line 40% to 60% but 01:22:605 not remove

[ Kantan]

1. 01:41:462(133,134) could be changed to k Umm...No
2. Seems fine

[ Futsuu]

1. 00:10:605 can be removed Umm...No but remove 00:11:034 (11) and change some pattern
2. 00:17:462 ^ Umm...No but remove this 00:17:891 (26)

[ Muzukashii]

1. 00:10:605 d , personally I don't suggest putting triplets other than ddd or kkk in a muzukashii, it is very rare. This applies to all notes in this diff Ohh! ok change
2. 01:21:748 d Change
3. 01:25:177 d Not change
4. 01:28:605 d Change

[ Oni]

1. 00:16:712 remove , vocal ends at the previous note Umm...not change
2. This diff is also fine

Nice mapset

1. 00:48:320 - unsnapped green line

1. HP 4 , 2 is too low so that i can pass when i only play 3/10 of whole song
2. 00:13:605 (9) - this note is not really necessary because you already had big note to emphasize this part on 00:12:320 (7,10) -
3. 00:33:748 (35,36) - ^

1. hp4
2. 00:08:462 (4,5) - try to reverse these note, this kind of pattern is harder for newplayer because he/she can't switch kat and don perfectly
3. 00:09:748 (8) - move to 00:09:962 - and remove 00:10:177 (9) - to make more break
4. 00:17:034 (26) - remove, the reason is same as above
5. 00:20:034 (34) - ^
6. 00:27:105 (51) - ^
7. 00:33:748 (67,69) - ^
8. 00:41:248 (89) - ^
9. 00:35:462 (72,73,74,75,76,77,78,79,80) - reduce some notes, it is too hard
10. 00:57:748 (122,123,124,125,126,127,128,129,130,131,132,133) - ^ try this
11. 01:11:462 (157,158,159,160,161,162,163,164,165,166) - ^
12. 01:38:892 (218,219,220,221,222,223,224,225,226,227,228,229,230,231) - ^

1. 00:07:177 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - this continuous pattern on muzu is too hard, try to make more break like this
2. 00:11:034 (17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24) - ^
3. 00:13:605 (27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38) - ^
4. 00:19:391 (50,51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59) - ^
5. try to make 1/4 pattern less frequent

1. 00:56:891 (247,248,249,250,251,252,253,254,255,256,257,258) - this pattern is a bit messy, try this would be more clear
2. 00:59:998 (267,268) - move to 01:00:105 - sounds better imo

qoot8123 wrote:

sorry for late www

[General]

1. 00:48:320 - unsnapped green line Ohh Ok Fixed

[ Kantan]

1. HP 4 , 2 is too low so that i can pass when i only play 3/10 of whole song Umm...for Newbie i will keep
2. 00:13:605 (9) - this note is not really necessary because you already had big note to emphasize this part on 00:12:320 (7,10) - Ok remove
3. 00:33:748 (35,36) - ^ Ok remove (35)

[ Futsuu]

1. hp4 same Kantan
2. 00:08:462 (4,5) - try to reverse these note, this kind of pattern is harder for newplayer because he/she can't switch kat and don perfectly Fixed
3. 00:09:748 (8) - move to 00:09:962 - and remove 00:10:177 (9) - to make more break Fixed
4. 00:17:034 (26) - remove, the reason is same as above Fixed
5. 00:20:034 (34) - ^ Fixed
6. 00:27:105 (51) - ^ Fixed
7. 00:33:748 (67,69) - ^ Fixed
8. 00:41:248 (89) - ^ Fixed
9. 00:35:462 (72,73,74,75,76,77,78,79,80) - reduce some notes, it is too hard Ok Fixed
10. 00:57:748 (122,123,124,125,126,127,128,129,130,131,132,133) - ^ try this Fixed
11. 01:11:462 (157,158,159,160,161,162,163,164,165,166) - ^ Fixed
12. 01:38:892 (218,219,220,221,222,223,224,225,226,227,228,229,230,231) - ^ Fixed

[ Muzukashii]

1. 00:07:177 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - this continuous pattern on muzu is too hard, try to make more break like Fixedthis
2. 00:11:034 (17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24) - ^ Fixed
3. 00:13:605 (27,28,29,30,31,32,33,34,35,36,37,38) - ^ Fixed
4. 00:19:391 (50,51,52,53,54,55,56,57,58,59) - ^ Fixed
5. try to make 1/4 pattern less frequent ok

[ Oni]

1. 00:56:891 (247,248,249,250,251,252,253,254,255,256,257,258) - this pattern is a bit messy, try this would be more clear Ok Fixed
2. 00:59:998 (267,268) - move to 01:00:105 - sounds better imo Fixed

the overall is okay, but this difficulty on everydiff is harder, especially muzu, it contain too many continuous 1/2+1/4 pattern,you can use 1/4 on muzu, but remenber don't make the 1/2+1/4 continuous pattern too long , also oni is a bit hard too, but it is fine to me Thanks I will memorize

game rock wrote:

Hi, From Game's Queue

d
k
D (Big d)
K (Big k)


[Kantan]

00:20:891 - Change to k? for the patterns. I think that low sound , not change
00:37:177 - Change to d, and here 00:37:605 - Change to k, is better for the combination. Fixed

[Futsuu]

00:42:962 - Change to d? for the pettern and the combination kd dk. Fixed
00:44:891 - Change to d. Fixed

[Muzukashii]

01:22:177 - Change to k, is better the rhythm. Fixed
01:29:034 - ^ Fixed

[Oni]

00:34:177 - Change to d? is better. I think that high sound , not change
01:03:212 - Change to d for the combination kd dk. I want to keep , I think kk dk it's will be good for player
01:06:641 - ^ ^
01:10:069 - ^ ^
01:30:641 - ^ ^
01:34:069 - ^ ^
01:37:498 - ^ ^

Nice Beatmap and I hope my mod has helped you

Coro wrote:

asked to taiko mod this, but I can't find anything wrong~
go for rank~

Grimbow wrote:

Hi! From mod queue!

d - Small don
D - Big don
k - Small kat
K - Big kat

Black means something that I think needs changed
Orange is just a suggestion

[Futsuu]

01:23:892 (173,174) - Ctrl+g these notes, then the k will land on the clap sound in the song Ok Fixed
01:25:178 (175,176,177,178,179,180,181) - Why don't you make this pattern a mirror of the last? EG: Change 01:25:606 (176) - to a k, Change 01:26:035 (177,178) - these two to d's (and If you took my previous mod then change 01:26:891 (179) - to a k) A bit of a weird suggestion but I think it would fit nicely in your beatmap! Ok Fixed

[Oni]

00:16:391 (48,49,50,51,52) - Ctrl+g this pattern, I think it flows better with the music as dkdkk since you can hear the two notes in the song at 00:16:712 - and they are the same pitch Umm..I think dkdkk it's has a little hard change that ko kkdkk


Good, fun map! There were a few more thing I could have written but those would be nazi mods and I think the map is fine the way it is! Have a star and good luck with rank! (∩｀-´)⊃━.*･｡ﾟ

Genocide wrote:

o_o
delete the second red line
call me if you want my mod

Kunieda wrote:

heyy from burrito booth :3

[Kantan]
01:20:034 (100,101) - ctrl+g (?) Fixed and change 01:21:748 (102,103,104) - to ddK

[Futsuu]
00:14:034 (17) - remove finish Fixed
00:41:891 - add d Fixed (Add note k)
00:42:320 (83) - k not change
01:05:891 (134) - D not change
01:29:891 (184) - K not change
01:36:748 (200) - ^ not change

[Muzukashii]
01:23:677 (266) - k not change
01:27:105 (279) - ^ Fixed

[Oni]
01:01:712 (276) - d I think it's will hard a little , not change
01:04:605 to 01:05:462 - not change
01:17:677 - add d some break not add
01:21:105 - ^ some break not add
01:26:248 - ^ some break not add

very nice map, good luck

bananannian wrote:

Hi! From my forum NM/M4M taiko queue.
I am pretty thorough, so don't feel bad if I point out a lot of issues. A lot of times they are just my opinions, so feel free to object to them. :3
After looking through my mod, would you mind taking the time to check out my taiko set? <3

Btw, I don't know how to make bpm/offset/scroll speed changes, so don't ask me those pls. XD

d = don
k = katsu
D = big don
K = big katsu


[General]
I would say that Oni should be more difficult (since it's Oni), but it's still fine as it is as it matches the difficulty curve.

Very polished beatmap, this mod might be short, I hope it's still helpful!

[Kantan]
00:12:320 (7,9) - change to d, I feel like there isn't enough suspension in the music to warrant a D Fixed (00:14:034 (9) - remove finish)
00:25:177 (22,23) - change to kd, match vocals Fixed
00:44:891 (50) - change to k, vocals should be k here since 00:45:748 (51), being the same pitch, is also k Umm...not change
01:40:605 (130,132) - change to d and k, match vocals pitch Fixed

[Futsuu]
00:26:462 - I would prefer this to be mapped as this: not change

Your version match the beat, mine the vocals. Your choice!
01:07:177 (136,137) - change to d k, match vocals pitch Fixed
01:15:105 (156) - change to k, voice is pretty high here, although there is a slight decrease in pitch I would still prefer k over d Fixed
01:42:533 (214) - change to k, ^ Fixed

[Muzukashii]
00:12:320 (19,20,21,22) - change to D D K K, match vocals pitch better Keep
00:20:891 (49,50) - change to d k, onbeat should be d since there isn't any significant high-pitched sounds to warrant a k not change
00:27:748 (74,75) - change to d k, ^ not change
00:41:462 (122) - change to d, ^ not change
01:13:819 (233) - I would change this run from this not change

to this

Again, your version match the beat, mine the vocals. Your choice!
01:29:034 (288) - change to k, match background synth not change
01:41:248 (327) - see 01:13:819 not change

[Oni]
00:45:748 (193,194,195,196) - change to kkdd, match vocals' pitch not change
00:47:248 (204) - change to k, previously you mapped vocals as k, this should be k as well not change
01:09:962 (315,316,317,318) - although keeping up with previous pattern, I couldn't find a rhythm in the music that matches these 4 notes here. Consider recomposing. Umm...not change
01:22:284 - add k, follow background synth (F - Ab - C) not add
01:25:712 (410) - change to k, match background synth (F - Ab - C) not change
01:29:141 (430) - ^ not change


There you go! Very nice set, and very nice song! Hope you find this mod helpful, and good luck beatmapping!

qoot8123 wrote:

The usage of pattern is pretty nice, but the spread doesn't fit the current standard, so i point out some things which needs to be changed

[ Kantan]

General

:idea: You map continuous 2/1 pattern here, it is not acceptable now, you should try to make some 4/1 break on calm part or a place which could have 4/1 break, do not use 2/1+1/1 pattern form opening to end,this is the only problem on kantan. Delete a lot TwT

[ Futsuu]

General

:idea: 1/2 pattern is acceptable now, but remember to make some 2/1 break (a little 4/1), there is lack of break Some Delete

[ Muzukashii]

General

:idea: also needs some 1/2 break, for example : 00:19:391 (42,43,44,45,46,47,48) - this part could be revised Delete and find hard pattern and change them

Oni is fine, kantan to muzu may need a bit overhaul to make some break , i don't want to point out which notes could be removed, it might break your good structure, so i hope you can fixed them by your own

No KD

qoot8123 wrote:

after adding more break on muzu and futsuu, the difficulty issue is improved a lot . i think i could let this set a go

Bubbled!

: p/3536843/

good luck o/

Love wrote:

I'm not going to pop this, but to avoid a higher chance of a disqualify, your Muzukashii->Oni spread needs a bit of a tune up. Sure the patterns in the Oni are pretty easy, but compared to the Muzu it's actually too dense. You could fix this a bit more by using more of the vocals at first, then using the rhythm in the song. An example of this is from 00:07:177 - 00:08:891 - this would be used (leaving the last part blank and starting on the 1/2 after that instead of the 1/1 after the start of another stanza): http://puu.sh/gffFa/84e2ae6de3.png

Please don't KD, I'll provide a full mod if necessary but it'll probably be pretty long.

Maino Zaki- wrote:

เมื่อไหร่จะ rank ล่ะเนี่ย รอจนเบื่อแล้วอ่า

rew0825 wrote:

Maino Zaki- wrote:

เมื่อไหร่จะ rank ล่ะเนี่ย รอจนเบื่อแล้วอ่า

นั่งรอเเบทมาตูดเเฉะละ = =

qoot8123 wrote:

Oni:

00:46:605 - the break should on 00:46:391 - instead of 00:46:605 - Ok fixed




I will rebubbled it after fix that

qoot8123 wrote:

Rebubbled!

xtrem3x wrote:

Mod request via ... by me XD

________________________________________________________________________

General:

Don: d
Kat: k
Big don: D
Big kat: K

________________________________________________________________________

Kantan:

01:22:605 (87) - this point is correct XD (futsuu/muzu/oni)

GOOD
________________________________________________________________________

Futsuu:

00:13:177 (11,12) - change to K

01:22:605 - same as muzu/oni

________________________________________________________________________

Muzukashii:

00:12:748 - k (high vocal but in simple note, with K is rare)
00:13:605 - change to K (high vocal and sound)
00:13:819 - delete

01:22:605 - same as oni

________________________________________________________________________

Oni:

01:22:498 - Move to 01:22:284- (a triple and later...)
01:22:605 - change to K (emphasis in finish plate XD)

________________________________________________________________________

7 months later this taiko mapset is better .-. ... take my star (owo)/