M4M from #modreqs
[General]
Time Signature:
Note: Cannot adjust to non-x/4 times in editor, have to edit the beatmap file manually. Also note that 3/4 time does not equal 6/8 time.
01:28:856: 6/8 time
01:41:779: 4/4 time
02:57:471: 6/8 time
03:10:394: 4/4 time
If this seems too complicated, remember to set the Beat snap divisor to 1/3 (depending on difficulty) during those sections, then back to what you were normally using when the timing change is over.
Colors:
Highly recommend removing the grey color group, replacing with any color not white/grey would be fine.
Difficulty:
AR 8 seems too unforgiving for Hard. Lower to at least 7.
[Easy]
00:41:779 (2,3,4)- Reorganize these three so 4's slider doesn't overlap 2 (Aesthetic - difficulty), example:
01:43:625 (4)- Perhaps change this slider out for a spinner to end the section?
02:10:394 (2,3,4)- Same as what I suggested for 00:41:779 (2,3,4)-.
03:12:241 (2)- Same as what I suggested for 01:43:625 (4)-.
[Normal]
03:12:241 (1)- Replace with spinner, same duration.
[Hard]
00:17:894 (4)- Remove event -- overmapping.
00:19:741 (4)- Overmapping
03:40:856 (3,4,5,6)- Feels like overmapping -- virtually empty music-wise, the stream feels forced.
03:52:510 (3,4,5)- ^^^^
04:14:202 (4)- Overmapping
04:16:048 (4)- Overmapping
04:19:741 (4)- Overmapping
04:21:587 (4)- Overmapping
04:23:433 (4)- Overmapping
00:21:471 (3)- Intentional jump? If not, reposition sliders (3) and (4) accordingly.
00:42:933 to 00:44:317- Are these supposed to be new combos for each note? Seems unnecessary -- combine them into one group.
00:57:702 to 00:59:087- ^^^^
02:11:548 to 02:12:933- ^^^^
02:26:317 to 02:27:702- ^^^^
04:09:702 to 04:10:625- ^^^^
04:17:087 to 04:18:471- ^^^^
04:24:471 to 04:25:856- ^^^^
[Summary]
You definitely put in a lot of work, and I like your attention to detail on everything from the hitsounds to the sliders. Good song selection too, very nice!
For the most part, the Easy/Normal difficulties had very little issues that I noticed. Definitely better than I had expected being a modless map at this point. The Hard seems like you're going out of your way to make it more difficult than it needs to be -- it's not Insane, but it feels like you're trying for a Hard-Insane mix. Let it breathe!
Overall, a map with tons of promise that is currently in an 8/10 state -- you're almost there! Good luck!
[General]
Time Signature:
Note: Cannot adjust to non-x/4 times in editor, have to edit the beatmap file manually. Also note that 3/4 time does not equal 6/8 time.
01:28:856: 6/8 time
01:41:779: 4/4 time
02:57:471: 6/8 time
03:10:394: 4/4 time
If this seems too complicated, remember to set the Beat snap divisor to 1/3 (depending on difficulty) during those sections, then back to what you were normally using when the timing change is over.
Colors:
Highly recommend removing the grey color group, replacing with any color not white/grey would be fine.
Difficulty:
AR 8 seems too unforgiving for Hard. Lower to at least 7.
[Easy]
00:41:779 (2,3,4)- Reorganize these three so 4's slider doesn't overlap 2 (Aesthetic - difficulty), example:
01:43:625 (4)- Perhaps change this slider out for a spinner to end the section?
02:10:394 (2,3,4)- Same as what I suggested for 00:41:779 (2,3,4)-.
03:12:241 (2)- Same as what I suggested for 01:43:625 (4)-.
[Normal]
03:12:241 (1)- Replace with spinner, same duration.
[Hard]
00:17:894 (4)- Remove event -- overmapping.
00:19:741 (4)- Overmapping
03:40:856 (3,4,5,6)- Feels like overmapping -- virtually empty music-wise, the stream feels forced.
03:52:510 (3,4,5)- ^^^^
04:14:202 (4)- Overmapping
04:16:048 (4)- Overmapping
04:19:741 (4)- Overmapping
04:21:587 (4)- Overmapping
04:23:433 (4)- Overmapping
00:21:471 (3)- Intentional jump? If not, reposition sliders (3) and (4) accordingly.
00:42:933 to 00:44:317- Are these supposed to be new combos for each note? Seems unnecessary -- combine them into one group.
00:57:702 to 00:59:087- ^^^^
02:11:548 to 02:12:933- ^^^^
02:26:317 to 02:27:702- ^^^^
04:09:702 to 04:10:625- ^^^^
04:17:087 to 04:18:471- ^^^^
04:24:471 to 04:25:856- ^^^^
[Summary]
You definitely put in a lot of work, and I like your attention to detail on everything from the hitsounds to the sliders. Good song selection too, very nice!
For the most part, the Easy/Normal difficulties had very little issues that I noticed. Definitely better than I had expected being a modless map at this point. The Hard seems like you're going out of your way to make it more difficult than it needs to be -- it's not Insane, but it feels like you're trying for a Hard-Insane mix. Let it breathe!
Overall, a map with tons of promise that is currently in an 8/10 state -- you're almost there! Good luck!