I specifically said that I'm not talking about the average. An average would make it so that people would try actively to not get low ranking players into their clan. The "weighted sum" (or whatever it is I'm talking about) would make it so that low ranking players wouldn't have a significant effect on the rank of the clan if higher ranked players are already members, but they wouldn't pull the rank down. Thus, there's no reason not to have them in your clan.
forum
[added] Clans - A detailed suggestion.
posted
Total Posts
525
This is a feature request. Feature requests can be voted up by supporters.
Current Priority: +11,795
maybe we can just say it "group" consist of around 15 peoples max. with no rank system. i think that's more reasonable for a rhythm game type.
plus that's more simple and easier for the dev to implemented it.
plus that's more simple and easier for the dev to implemented it.
As for groups/clans/whatever we call them. Ranking should be average pp or total pp imo. Having ranks on clans would make osu even more fun 
the ranks should be for every game mode ofc!
the ranks should be for every game mode ofc!that's just my opinion though, everybody have different opinion but at the end everything are decided by the dev. Just hoping they've a quite good plan on this.
I understand that ranking ain't everything, but It adds a nice overview of what clans would be good in future tournaments for an example!
Clan ranks should be calculated by using weighted sum of all its members' pp. As for Shivarion's statement, without ranks clans are boring imo. Also, the min. number of members might be 16, since 16v16 multiplayer is available now.
If there are clan battles, we need 2 ranks, Weighted Sum Clan pp Rank and Clan Battle Rank.
Then again, let's leave it to the devs' decision.
If there are clan battles, we need 2 ranks, Weighted Sum Clan pp Rank and Clan Battle Rank.
Then again, let's leave it to the devs' decision.
thats a good idea. although the rank discrimination a lot of players will face to get into a clan will be annoying.RichJoker wrote:
Clan ranks should be calculated by using weighted sum of all its members' pp. As for Shivarion's statement, without ranks clans are boring imo. Also, the min. number of members might be 16, since 16v16 multiplayer is available now.
If there are clan battles, we need 2 ranks, Weighted Sum Clan pp Rank and Clan Battle Rank.
Then again, let's leave it to the devs' decision.
I think weighted sum is better than average pp. With average pp calculation, every clan will literally dump its low pp members. At least the rank discrimination of the weighted sum rank will be less than average pp rank.Riince wrote:
thats a good idea. although the rank discrimination a lot of players will face to get into a clan will be annoying.RichJoker wrote:
Clan ranks should be calculated by using weighted sum of all its members' pp. As for Shivarion's statement, without ranks clans are boring imo. Also, the min. number of members might be 16, since 16v16 multiplayer is available now.
If there are clan battles, we need 2 ranks, Weighted Sum Clan pp Rank and Clan Battle Rank.
Then again, let's leave it to the devs' decision.
You should win in clan wars to get clan PP obviously. And the amount of PP given will be determined by the rank difference.
For example if some clan which rank is #250 wins some other #100, the first one will be given *i have no idea how much* PP. But if #100 wins #250 , the winner will receive much less .. . Something like that. Such system will prevent farming for top clans and greatly reward others for beating top clans
*I'm done here*
For example if some clan which rank is #250 wins some other #100, the first one will be given *i have no idea how much* PP. But if #100 wins #250 , the winner will receive much less .. . Something like that. Such system will prevent farming for top clans and greatly reward others for beating top clans
*I'm done here*
if clan wars will be possible though you'll definitely want to stack as many heavy hitters as possible if you want to be a top clan.RichJoker wrote:
I think weighted sum is better than average pp. With average pp calculation, every clan will literally dump its low pp members. At least the rank discrimination of the weighted sum rank will be less than average pp rank.
Well, you're right. I just show some kind of balanceRiince wrote:
if clan wars will be possible though you'll definitely want to stack as many heavy hitters as possible if you want to be a top clan.RichJoker wrote:
I think weighted sum is better than average pp. With average pp calculation, every clan will literally dump its low pp members. At least the rank discrimination of the weighted sum rank will be less than average pp rank.
can ppy put this in the game already
I want to see more people in multiplayer already
and this give people a reason to get better at osu!
defeating other clans thats why i dont see any good challenges
in multiplayer every room i see is like easy-normal and when i find an
insane room no one plays well... except like those one or two high ranking people
I want to see more people in multiplayer already
and this give people a reason to get better at osu!
defeating other clans thats why i dont see any good challenges
in multiplayer every room i see is like easy-normal and when i find an
insane room no one plays well... except like those one or two high ranking people
He said it will be added this year.[ HDthunder ] wrote:
can ppy put this in the game already
having clan is good
Why do people keep pouring stars to this request?! Don't you guys think it has enough stars?
This is gonna happen either way, it's just a matter of time.
This is gonna happen either way, it's just a matter of time.
Upd: +2 from meGigo wrote:
Why do people keep pouring stars to this request?! Don't you guys think it has enough stars?
This is gonna happen either way, it's just a matter of time.
im gonna waste my starts now so we have 7K muhahaha
7000 exactly, WOW
its never enoughGigo wrote:
Why do people keep pouring stars to this request?! Don't you guys think it has enough stars?
This is gonna happen either way, it's just a matter of time.
When/where?Fureimuu wrote:
He said it will be added this year.[ HDthunder ] wrote:
can ppy put this in the game already
I heard something in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VAjH4DA ... ZsaBHj_b7ARiince wrote:
When/where?
The exact time is: 30:25 for people who don't want to watch the whole thing. You should watch it though it's actually pretty interesting to watch and listen to him explain everything related to the historysheela901 wrote:
I heard something in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VAjH4DA ... ZsaBHj_b7ARiince wrote:
When/where?
I'd prefer having a half-assed team system for now than nothing at all!
I'd rather wait for a team system that actually works fully instead of a buggy one that isn't finishedYukiteru Amano wrote:
I'd prefer having a half-assed team system for now than nothing at all!
I wonder if it's possibleYazawa wrote:
a team system that actually works fully
peppy said infinite possibilities so i say yesFureimuu wrote:
I wonder if it's possibleYazawa wrote:
a team system that actually works fully
timestamp is somewhere around 30:40sheela901 wrote:
I heard something in https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VAjH4DA ... ZsaBHj_b7ARiince wrote:
When/where?
whoops been said already lol
also support!
Wait if ppy Said it will be Added this year should this topic be marked like [Added]?
It would be misleading if it was tagged as "Added" but it wasn't Added in-game yet.marcostudios wrote:
Wait if ppy Said it will be Added this year should this topic be marked like [Added]?
if he didn't add this feature in the game with this many stars there would be warYarai wrote:
It would be misleading if it was tagged as "Added" but it wasn't Added in-game yet.marcostudios wrote:
Wait if ppy Said it will be Added this year should this topic be marked like [Added]?
with this edition to the game i think a tutorial for the osu! interface considering that
more people would play because they'd be encourage to play with friends and face other clans.
He's already said it will be added by the end of this year
A request will be marked if the team thinks that the purpose is met.
Just focus your discussions on how to enhance an idea
Just focus your discussions on how to enhance an idea
give us some programs on the website to make our own clan tagsOinari-sama wrote:
A request will be marked if the team thinks that the purpose is met.
Just focus your discussions on how to enhance an idea
special profile pics for our clans. and we need super cool matching uniforms
cause we need to play ball.
If teams had their own private forum then it would be 10/10[ HDthunder ] wrote:
give us some programs on the website to make our own clan tagsOinari-sama wrote:
A request will be marked if the team thinks that the purpose is met.
Just focus your discussions on how to enhance an idea
special profile pics for our clans. and we need super cool matching uniforms
cause we need to play ball.
I would hope that a separate chat for each group can be formed in bancho
I heard something like this was going to happen in peppy's presentationlaishiou wrote:
I would hope that a separate chat for each group can be formed in bancho
Me too.Yarai wrote:
I heard something like this was going to happen in peppy's presentationlaishiou wrote:
I would hope that a separate chat for each group can be formed in bancho
Still waiting for it^^
I prefer separated rank system rather than cumulative (which mean the same rank system like player already have) so the clan will have 4 different rank based on 4 mode.
and also it would be nice if there's minimum require level to create a clan. Just to prevent clan spamming.
and also it would be nice if there's minimum require level to create a clan. Just to prevent clan spamming.
i check this thread everyday to see if
peppy would post a date.
Not trying to rush it or anything
but that'd make me so excited
i can finally start collecting my 4 man squad
and rule the osu! universe.
peppy would post a date.
Not trying to rush it or anything
but that'd make me so excited
i can finally start collecting my 4 man squad
and rule the osu! universe.
Where did it say 4 man squad :O[ HDthunder ] wrote:
i check this thread everyday to see if
peppy would post a date.
Not trying to rush it or anything
but that'd make me so excited
i can finally start collecting my 4 man squad
and rule the osu! universe.
I was hoping for a 1-8 team
100 Man Squad Bro!
Yes, something like this would actually be really interesting... Hope we can get a date if possible^^
Although i hope that there are some restricions to this feature so that there won't just be spamming new clans everywhere...
And if possible keep it so that theres no ingame benefit (individual rank wise)
I can see that something like a ranking system for clans to be intruiging but something like exclusive something for a specific clan might be too much, unless it is something private actually meant for that clan specifically not a open thing hogged by a big clan
Osu is still a public game where everyone can play to get high ranked without any exceptions, even supporters are equal in terms of literally just playing the game (well there are some benefits that don't affect gameplay)
Although i hope that there are some restricions to this feature so that there won't just be spamming new clans everywhere...
And if possible keep it so that theres no ingame benefit (individual rank wise)
I can see that something like a ranking system for clans to be intruiging but something like exclusive something for a specific clan might be too much, unless it is something private actually meant for that clan specifically not a open thing hogged by a big clan
Osu is still a public game where everyone can play to get high ranked without any exceptions, even supporters are equal in terms of literally just playing the game (well there are some benefits that don't affect gameplay)
that's like what i saidDothThouHoist wrote:
Although i hope that there are some restricions to this feature so that there won't just be spamming new clans everywhere...
Shivarion wrote:
and also it would be nice if there's minimum require level to create a clan. Just to prevent clan spamming.
Oh yeah, lol... Sorry about that...Shivarion wrote:
that's like what i saidDothThouHoist wrote:
Although i hope that there are some restricions to this feature so that there won't just be spamming new clans everywhere...Shivarion wrote:
and also it would be nice if there's minimum require level to create a clan. Just to prevent clan spamming.
Wat
The guilt... It starts to corrupt me, what did i do to recieve this? Oh yeah... Copyright... Wat...
my squad will be like seirin basketball team
except it'll look like we have 4 but really have 5
we have our special technique/member
except it'll look like we have 4 but really have 5
we have our special technique/member
Is he a hedgehog?[ HDthunder ] wrote:
my squad will be like seirin basketball team
except it'll look like we have 4 but really have 5
we have our special technique/member
Please be a hedgehog....
i need to find a guy named kurokoIVo one wrote:
Is he a hedgehog?[ HDthunder ] wrote:
my squad will be like seirin basketball team
except it'll look like we have 4 but really have 5
we have our special technique/member
Please be a hedgehog....
on osu! lol XD
clans would make the game much better Just saw the idea of the Multiplayer Team vs. Team, and it somehow convinced me (of course, the topic itself sounds very interesting).
For now, I'll sit down and see how things turn out.
For now, I'll sit down and see how things turn out.
++ Support.
What would be great would be to limit the members of a clan based on their nationality to avoid there are clans as "rrtyui x GGBY x Andrea x Sherry" if you know what i mean
And if possible, a ranking based on the maps played on the MONTH and not on lifetime players.
Or do clan battles with random maps based on the average level of the players.
So many possibilities, it would be great to have this before 2015 ...
What would be great would be to limit the members of a clan based on their nationality to avoid there are clans as "rrtyui x GGBY x Andrea x Sherry" if you know what i mean
And if possible, a ranking based on the maps played on the MONTH and not on lifetime players.
Or do clan battles with random maps based on the average level of the players.
So many possibilities, it would be great to have this before 2015 ...
wow so many stars and it never will come true xD
ppy already said that he is going to do it..XinCrin wrote:
wow so many stars and it never will come true xD
Awesome, I've been wanting this feature to be added for a long time now!
I have no clue how but I get very excited at the thought of an excellently designed, functioning clanwar-system.Since almost entirely everything about osu! is brilliant, i think that if anyone can figure it out, ppy+osu team can.JohnTrololo wrote:
(...) do clan battles (...)
osu!mania player here and I would love to see this implemented.
I can only imagine how awesome mania clans would be.
This would help tie the community together so well xD
I can only imagine how awesome mania clans would be.
This would help tie the community together so well xD
i want a date...
that not the estimation
of this year an actual number plz
that not the estimation
of this year an actual number plz
Best idea here :v
Winter-Fox_old
8,000+ Stars now
Guilds would be a great idea, i feel like guilds make any game fun because it creates communities within communities and makes the group smaller because of easy to identify clicks. Attack on titan tribute game had no need for guilds but implemented it anyway and the community flourished because of it.
Topic Starter
What in the actual fuck... I leave the forums for 3 months and it gains 6k star priority....
I'm blown away...
I'm blown away...
This has to be the highest ever star priority. Hopefully Clans/guilds/teams becomes a thing sometime soon .
.- H i N a - wrote:
I want this
Well , me too but don't hope too much
, the Request has been made 4years ago 
this thread should just be locked tbh.
it's long known that peppy is working on a clan system, so people are just wasting time/stars on this thread
it's long known that peppy is working on a clan system, so people are just wasting time/stars on this thread
It's ironic because you're wasting your time by saying others are wasting their time; hell I'm wasting my time writing this.
Well , maybe it's long know but i didn't knew that, i've just read the details of the suggestion , not all the posts aftersilmarilen wrote:
this thread should just be locked tbh.
it's long known that peppy is working on a clan system, so people are just wasting time/stars on this thread
This sounds interesting. I suppose there are gonna be like Multiplayer clan matches as well or clan rankings.
Ten thousand stars. GO
Under two months left on the year.
Peppy promised this would be implemented by the end of the year. So, this is either coming soon, or we can discard what he said in France a few months back.
Peppy promised this would be implemented by the end of the year. So, this is either coming soon, or we can discard what he said in France a few months back.
i hope you guys aren't supporting this more, it'll already be done, so...
someone should disable stars, it's a waste of 'em
someone should disable stars, it's a waste of 'em
yeahCanadianPaws wrote:
i hope you guys aren't supporting this more, it'll already be done, so...
someone should disable stars, it's a waste of 'em
This will be coming on 2015 according to peppy (I asked him in game). He said he's already made some progress on it. I believe this will come out at the same time or after the new website is done.
I'm just saying, we might have to wait another 6 months or so.
I'm just saying, we might have to wait another 6 months or so.
yes, that's why i think someone should disable the function of stars >.<
Will it get over 9000?!?!
Wooohooooooo close to over 9000!
CAVEGAMINGWORLD at 35 registered members back this idea.
Please please please get this going
I NOW SHALL GIVE ALL MY VOTES HERE PLUS GET OUR TEAM TO DO THE SAME
Please please please get this going
I NOW SHALL GIVE ALL MY VOTES HERE PLUS GET OUR TEAM TO DO THE SAME
yeah..
support this feature
support this feature
This is a good idea. But I dislike the idea of it being just for "Tag-Team". Why not normal "Team Vs.". I dislike tag-team and this idea would be really good if tag-team wasn't it's limit. Other than that I like the ideas of simple clans, and then there could be a #clan chat, which would be really cool.
Very useful considering how this has got an insanely huge amount of priority already.AxE Rayden wrote:
CAVEGAMINGWORLD at 35 registered members back this idea.
Please please please get this going
I NOW SHALL GIVE ALL MY VOTES HERE PLUS GET OUR TEAM TO DO THE SAME
Why not lock this thread already, users are just wasting their stars and the feature has pretty much already been confirmed for some time now.
what good will locking the thread do? it's not going to stop users throwing stars at this request :p
you can throw stars at locked requests?
i haven't test that personally, but i don't think so. let's test it
edit: works for me
edit: works for me