forum

Wakeshima Kanon - killy killy JOKER (TV Size)

posted
Total Posts
78
show more
toara_fict
Gratz~ :3
Satellite
congratz :3
Mao
Cool, congratz! :3
Kenezz
Gratz o3o
Topic Starter
smallboat
Thanks everyone ~ ! www

ZZHBOY wrote:

爽终于i有I难度rankedgd热妈的信船业随手ranked
下次不給你做I
kirigherkins
Thank you for finally convincing me to watch this.
Best decision.
dkun

ykcarrot wrote:

Here are mistakes you BATs did. Qualified maps only.


Case 1. The suffix was changed by the mapper

SID - V.I.P (TV Size) Has now been put into ranked at the time of this post.
Correct title : V.I.P -アニメ Ver.-
Proof : http://vgmdb.net/album/35508

SAKURA*TRICK - Won(*3*)Chu KissMe! (TV Size) taken out of qualified.
Correct title : Won(*3*)Chu KissMe! [TVサイズ]
Proof : http://vgmdb.net/album/43764


Case 2. TV sized song was not released through the album
In this case, every suffix should be removed. Because the mapper can't prove "song name (TV Size)" is correct.
If you think the credits of the video is a reputable source, watch the video. There is no suffix at all.

Fuchigami Mai - Watashi no Housekibako (TV Size) taken out of qualified based on what's been given.
Related albums : http://vgmdb.net/album/41016 http://vgmdb.net/album/42072
Video : http://youtu.be/HhHPXZX1KGg?t=55s

Wakeshima Kanon - killy killy JOKER (TV Size)
Related album : http://vgmdb.net/album/44570
Video : http://youtu.be/rzY7qyXEBSI?t=48s

Petit Rabbit's - Daydream cafe (TV Size)
Related album : http://vgmdb.net/album/44890
Video : http://youtu.be/wtjSP5rlk5k?t=59s


Seems you BATs don't want to change the rule, so you are demanding maps have title error.
Then unrank them all up to your conviction. And watch the mappers' reaction.
Most of them will change the title because they really hope their own map being ranked and have no power against the BATs.
Or have no will to change the rule.

They were many maps have error since the rule was legislated. Because the song title in the rule includes extension(suffix).
Some people raised objections to the rule since the day, they were ignored exhaustively.
You BATs still saying let's discuss in RC, but I can just imagine how my opinion will be ignored.
Another really trivial issue, but please remove (TV Size) from the title, as it's not listed in any official sources. Please let me know if you have any credible sources or if you've removed the title.

I'll be more than happy to put this map back into qualified.
Suimya
well I found another source with the tv size title o.o



I think it's fair enough, to keep it as it is.
dkun
The actual title is what is in the brackets. What you linked is just verifying that it's actually a TV size, not that the title includes TV size.
Suimya

dkun wrote:

The actual title is what is in the brackets. What you linked is just verifying that it's actually a TV size, not that the title includes TV size.
But that's from the official site, and that's the soundtrack for this series.

So I guess it can be titled like this at least "killy killy JOKER TV size"

And the soundtrack will be out soon o3o/
hopperhtkn
Any BATs looks like Mental patient or too stupid.
You guys should think again why we have used (TV size) for TV size maps.

The rule we really need is "All Anime size maps should put (TV size) the end"

I'm sry violent language but I'm so irritate about that thing.

Best Regards.
Sellenite

dkun wrote:

The actual title is what is in the brackets. What you linked is just verifying that it's actually a TV size, not that the title includes TV size.
Anyone who supports title without TV size. I consider he/she is stupid enough,try to find the source please
try not self-talk among your BATs’ community,try to more consider general mappers please
so many funny unrank stuffs now
good game.
captin1
I think this is a much larger scale change than what you may be making it by calling it trivial. this is something that will affect hundreds of current pending maps if this is established as the rule.

I believe the title should be kept as is, as this is the official shortened cut for the TV broadcast, while an official metadata source of this particular cut simply does not exist yet. the (TV Size) suffix is one that is extremely well established and understood. Any casual player will look at a mapset with this suffix and understand that it is the shortened cut for the anime. and isn't that the most important thing?

If anything, I don't think this is just a slight change, and should be brought to discussion in the team and in the general community before a full consensus and standard is reached and established
mintong89
http://www.amazon.co.jp/%E3%80%8Cselect ... =pd_cp_m_1

I guess this is already can be a source. dkun, I know you want to follow the rules, but next time can you please check properly before unrank something? Unrank isn't a good thing, it'll completely hurt the mapper, and don't trust that ykcarrot's quote rigidly.
keeeeeeko
Topic Starter
smallboat
Thanks everyone source offer (on title) , I hope it rerank soon ! :)
BeatofIke
Re-rank this map already!
Unranking this map was pointless! :x
ZZHBOY

dkun wrote:

The actual title is what is in the brackets. What you linked is just verifying that it's actually a TV size, not that the title includes TV size.
我比较帅所以我没被unrank 唔
dkun

mintong89 wrote:

http://www.amazon.co.jp/%E3%80%8Cselector-infected-WIXOSS%E3%80%8DBOX-WIXOSS%E3%82%B9%E3%82%BF%E3%83%BC%E3%82%BF%E3%83%BC%E3%83%87%E3%83%83%E3%82%AD%E4%BB%98-Blu-ray/dp/B00K68K1K0/ref=pd_cp_m_1

I guess this is already can be a source. dkun, I know you want to follow the rules, but next time can you please check properly before unrank something? Unrank isn't a good thing, it'll completely hurt the mapper, and don't trust that ykcarrot's quote rigidly.
t/146542 - maybe you should read up some more

Ranking this as-is after discussion with smallboat. Please treat this as the same from the previous set of BAT's.
Zero__wind
大家好 我来给激霸音效投1分儿了
Topic Starter
smallboat

Zero__wind wrote:

大家好 我来给激霸音效投1分儿了
诶诶 01老兄 饒了我吧 :o
Secretpipe
Gz
Lari
gratz ~
Satellite
yay
Mafumafu
恭喜船业!啥时候能带我啊Twt
ZZHBOY
他妈的
Please sign in to reply.

New reply