Kloyd wrote:

M.4.M

Normal
00:06:164 (1) - Spacing issue
00:17:592 (1) -
00:21:878 (1) -
00:25:211 - need beats here (I recommend adding stack circle)
00:25:688 (1) - spacing issue
00:29:974 (1) -
00:54:259 (1) -
01:07:592 (1) -
you might realize that keeping distance is crucial on Easy/Normal diffs. Try to find more by yourself since I fell I only point spacing.

01:05:926 (4,5) - try to move just a bit to avoid slight-overlap
01:10:449 - adding a slider can be better to keep flow
01:25:449 (6) - adding notes?
01:31:402 -
01:56:164 -
01:59:973 (6) - a suggestion here http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/734345
03:00:926 - a suggestion here (stack notes) http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/734352

Hard

00:40:449 (1) - stack completely with white (2)
00:43:069 (1,2) - not good flow. use Ctrl+H for first one
00:59:021 (1,2) - make this same?
01:02:592 - need notes here
02:09:497 (2,3,4,5,6) - hmm suggestion. Use Polygon-Circle-Function on 'Compose' Tab
02:56:640 (3,4,5,6) -

I love cs5 lol

Good one. Hope your map ranked

Hard wrote:

A wild Chiva appears. OKAY
LET'S do it !


(M4M and all)

Chivas Mod of DESTRUCTION

Well. I won't destroy anything. I just thought that sounds kinda good... Yeah... Well...

...

I'll just start


[ Normal ]

SPOILER

00:07:116 - the spacing is different than before. consider changing this, otherwise it's confusing.
00:16:878 - maybe add a slider here? I guess it would fit, otherwise there's awkward silence...
00:21:402 - something's missing here, too. Since you're following the drum and suddenly you just... ignore the base.
00:29:497 - ^
00:57:592 - those sliders seem unreasonable for me and don't fit with the beat. They look pretty, though.
01:10:211 - maybe change into a slider that goes till 01:10:449
01:10:688 - New Combo
01:25:449 - Something's wrong with the spacing here
01:30:449 - add circle here or sth. else
01:47:592 - spacing seems a bit wrong
03:09:497 - idk somehow it doesn't sound right...
03:18:069 - delete NC ... I guess

Woah I already finished? I bet it will be a fun map if you change some little things


[ Hard ]

SPOILER

00:21:402 - awkward silence again
00:29:021 - another awkward silence. maybe add a clap circle i think it would sound nice
00:40:926 - this is confusing me. I don't know if you should change it. Maybe I just pointed it out because I don't like stacks
00:50:688 - this kinda destroy my flow, consider changing it. Except you want to troll the player. If that's the case it is wonderful and fun
00:52:116 - maybe add something here
01:02:830 - here too it needs something...
01:03:307 (1) - make that slider round. Curves are good and beautiful
01:24:735 - new combo here
01:24:973 - delete nc
01:25:687 (3) - again. Try to make a curve
01:51:402 (3,4,5) - doesn't seem to fit here
02:09:497 (2,3,4,5,6) - this pattern is a bit awkward... Maybe use something else. (Polygon maybe?)
02:19:497 (1) - change the position, so that it won't overlap
02:32:592 - add something here
03:05:688 - same like 00:40:926
03:08:307 - ^

I like your map. Take a star.

dkun wrote:

I saw this on #modreqs. I love 2PM!

[Normal]
00:05:211 (3) - Try grid4/nogrid out and make this slider symmetrical via the Y-axis. I can tell it was your intention, just wasn't executed properly.
00:07:116 (5) - ^
01:03:783 (1,2) - I can't tell if this is an attempted blanket, but refer to what I say below about blankets.
01:10:926 (3) - Could totally be constructed better by using grid4. Try using three slider points!
01:13:307 (2) - ^
01:25:449 (6) - Why is this so close to 5? I would move this a bit farther away.
02:25:688 (2) - Stack this with 7 of the previous combo.
02:46:640 (1,2,3,4,1) - You should stick to symmetry on the Y-axis like the rest of the map if you're going to have combos like these.
03:12:354 (1,2,3,4,5) - ^

[Hard]
00:07:354 (5) - I feel this note is unnecessary if you're following the lyrics.
00:19:259 (5,1) - Is there a reason why spacing here is inconsistent compared to everything else so far?
00:25:688 (1,2) - The blanket could use some work. (Here's an image. Use the approach circle of the slider to help you.)
00:27:354 (1,2) - ^
00:42:592 (8,1) - Should move (1) to avoid the overlap. Doesn't take that much, right?
00:44:497 (3,4) - Same blanket comment as above.
00:59:021 (3,4) - You could move 4 a few more grids away so it doesn't overlap with 3.
01:27:116 (6,1) - I think you get what I'm trying to say about avoiding overlaps, right?
01:46:878 (1,2) - Nice part with the hitsounds here.
02:30:926 (6) - NC, maybe?
02:59:497 (7,1) - I'd switch NC between these two notes.

Call me back (if you want :p) when you get a few more mods.

1. delete “2PM - Hot (Kazey).osb”in songs file

1. 00:19:497 (3,4) - make a better blanket like this 00:27:593 (3,4) -
2. 00:26:641 (2,3) - ^
3. 00:38:069 (3,4) - ^
4. 00:38:545 (4,5,2,4) - put them into the same shape will be very good
5. 01:05:449 (3) - 01:05:926 (4) - 01:07:592 (6) - 01:09:735 (2) - U should not be disturbed by lyric,map objects in white tick would be very good.
6. 01:45:688 (2,3) - make blanket here？
7. 02:07:592 (5) - clap on tail
8. 02:08:545 (1) - remove clap
9. 02:09:021 (2) - remove clap on arrow and add one on tail （I think U just need to put clap on first white short tick and third white tick in this diff. that is available by new players.
10. 02:32:830 (1) - suggest volume low down to 5%. finish sounds noisy here,I prefer delete it.

1. 00:08:069 (6) - move to (256,152)
2. 01:21:164 (1,2) - better blanket
3. 02:07:830 (3,4,5) - ^
4. 01:24:973 (1) - why nc here?
5. 01:52:830 (2,3) - make a blanket here?
6. 02:09:973 (3) - plz keep the same rhythm like 02:05:688 (3) - and add clap in this section
7. 02:34:735 (1) - same suggestion as normal
8. just some suggestion~ u should add some flow in this diff,and it will make objects beautiful and enjoyable.

Sweet Vanilla wrote:

hi, M4M from my queue~
sorry for late~
i'm a noob mapper ;w;
[General]

1. delete “2PM - Hot (Kazey).osb”in songs file

[Normal]

1. 00:19:497 (3,4) - make a better blanket like this 00:27:593 (3,4) -
2. 00:26:641 (2,3) - ^
3. 00:38:069 (3,4) - ^
4. 00:38:545 (4,5,2,4) - put them into the same shape will be very good
5. 01:05:449 (3) - 01:05:926 (4) - 01:07:592 (6) - 01:09:735 (2) - U should not be disturbed by lyric,map objects in white tick would be very good.
6. 01:45:688 (2,3) - make blanket here？
7. 02:07:592 (5) - clap on tail
8. 02:08:545 (1) - remove clap
9. 02:09:021 (2) - remove clap on arrow and add one on tail （I think U just need to put clap on first white short tick and third white tick in this diff. that is available by new players.
10. 02:32:830 (1) - suggest volume low down to 5%. finish sounds noisy here,I prefer delete it.

[Hard]

1. 00:08:069 (6) - move to (256,152)
2. 01:21:164 (1,2) - better blanket
3. 02:07:830 (3,4,5) - ^
4. 01:24:973 (1) - why nc here?
5. 01:52:830 (2,3) - make a blanket here?
6. 02:09:973 (3) - plz keep the same rhythm like 02:05:688 (3) - and add clap in this section
7. 02:34:735 (1) - same suggestion as normal
8. just some suggestion~ u should add some flow in this diff,and it will make objects beautiful and enjoyable.

that's all,good luck~ and nice song

1. 00:31:403 (4) - Feels a bit too... weird to play, honestly, and the jump later is kinda hard. This, imo, feels much better to play!
2. 00:59:973 (1) - Pattern would look / play better if you placed (1) at x160 y160.
3. 01:09:497 (2,3) - Pattern would look / play better if you placed (2) at 320;176 and (3) at 432;176.
4. 01:15:211 (2) - This pattern is asymmetrical, moving (2) to 96;160 would solve this issue.
5. 01:16:640 (5) - This plays kinda weird, why not moving the second sliderpoint to 400;96?
6. 01:55:211 (5,6) - This really.. doesn't look fine. If you'd like to fix it, move the second sliderpoint to 152;192.
7. 02:13:544 (2) - Why not just copy and reverse 02:10:926 (5) - to make it symmetrical?
8. 03:12:830 (2) - This should be in 256;76 to stack perfectly with the sliderend.
9. 03:18:069 (6) - Place this at 152;240? It really looks much better >:
   
   Solid map, both spacing and rhythm (although a bit generic, but gotta blame that on the song) are fine. No big problems aside from placement in general here.

1. 00:18:783 (4,5) - I'd say try to avoid this stuff in general, it looks ugly and usually doesn't play well. There's not really how to fix it in this map, but it will stay as an advice for your next maps.
2. 00:34:973 (5,6,7) - I don't really like this jump, it just... doesn't flow well. I'd say ctrl+g (6,7) and fix spacing accordingly.
3. 00:41:640 (4) - Move this 1 grid up, it's stacked wrongly.
4. 00:44:735 (4) - Uh... fix this?
5. 01:31:640 (3,4) - I would avoid this as well, it kinda confuses me and flows weirdly.
6. 01:43:307 (6) - Jump is a bit too harsh for the map. I'd place this note at 256;176.
7. 01:56:640 (1) - This jump is also too harsh, but I have no idea on how to fix it >:
8. 02:22:116 (1) - Same as 01:31:640. Also, I think this may be unrankable..
9. 02:25:926 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - You sure these are okay for a Hard diff? It's CS5, after all.
10. 03:01:164 (4) - Ctrl+G on this flows a bit better.
11. 03:12:830 (5,6) - Jump is a biiit too harsh.
12. 03:13:307 (6,7) - This one, same as ^
13. 03:19:497 (1) - Shouldn't this spinner start at the same time as Normal diff? Will be consistent, at least.
    
    Map is fine, kinda oldschool-style, I like it. Some jumps are really over-the-top for a Hard difficulty, though. Nice map.

Blue Dragon wrote:

[Normal]

1. 00:31:403 (4) - Feels a bit too... weird to play, honestly, and the jump later is kinda hard. This, imo, feels much better to play!
2. 00:59:973 (1) - Pattern would look / play better if you placed (1) at x160 y160.
3. 01:09:497 (2,3) - Pattern would look / play better if you placed (2) at 320;176 and (3) at 432;176.
4. 01:15:211 (2) - This pattern is asymmetrical, moving (2) to 96;160 would solve this issue.
5. 01:16:640 (5) - This plays kinda weird, why not moving the second sliderpoint to 400;96?
6. 01:55:211 (5,6) - This really.. doesn't look fine. If you'd like to fix it, move the second sliderpoint to 152;192.
7. 02:13:544 (2) - Why not just copy and reverse 02:10:926 (5) - to make it symmetrical?
8. 03:12:830 (2) - This should be in 256;76 to stack perfectly with the sliderend.
9. 03:18:069 (6) - Place this at 152;240? It really looks much better >:
   
   Solid map, both spacing and rhythm (although a bit generic, but gotta blame that on the song) are fine. No big problems aside from placement in general here.

[Hard]

1. 00:18:783 (4,5) - I'd say try to avoid this stuff in general, it looks ugly and usually doesn't play well. There's not really how to fix it in this map, but it will stay as an advice for your next maps.
2. 00:34:973 (5,6,7) - I don't really like this jump, it just... doesn't flow well. I'd say ctrl+g (6,7) and fix spacing accordingly.
3. 00:41:640 (4) - Move this 1 grid up, it's stacked wrongly.
4. 00:44:735 (4) - Uh... fix this?
5. 01:31:640 (3,4) - I would avoid this as well, it kinda confuses me and flows weirdly.
6. 01:43:307 (6) - Jump is a bit too harsh for the map. I'd place this note at 256;176.
7. 01:56:640 (1) - This jump is also too harsh, but I have no idea on how to fix it >:
8. 02:22:116 (1) - Same as 01:31:640. Also, I think this may be unrankable..
9. 02:25:926 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - You sure these are okay for a Hard diff? It's CS5, after all.
10. 03:01:164 (4) - Ctrl+G on this flows a bit better.
11. 03:12:830 (5,6) - Jump is a biiit too harsh.
12. 03:13:307 (6,7) - This one, same as ^
13. 03:19:497 (1) - Shouldn't this spinner start at the same time as Normal diff? Will be consistent, at least.
    
    Map is fine, kinda oldschool-style, I like it. Some jumps are really over-the-top for a Hard difficulty, though. Nice map.

1. add tag 'HANDS UP' please. this is album title.

1. 00:17:592 (1) - add finish slider head.
2. 00:19:497 (3) - add clap slider end.
3. 00:35:688 (5) - add clap slider end.
4. 00:50:926 (4) - ^
5. 00:55:688 (1) - add finish slider head.
6. 01:30:926 (2) - remove finish slider end. loud imo.
7. 01:31:878 (1) - ^
8. 01:31:878 (2) - remove finish.
9. 01:45:688 (2) - add clap slider head and end.
10. 01:46:759 - why 5% volume? not fit imo. remove better. 01:47:473 - also, this greenline delete please.
11. 01:51:402 (5) - add clap slider head and remove clap slider end.
12. 02:03:783 (6) - add finish slider end.
13. 02:31:402 (2,4) - remove finish.
14. 03:17:116 (5,6) - remove finish slider end.
    

1. 00:00:450 (1,2) - add whistle slider end.
2. 00:24:973 (5) - remove finish slider end better.
3. 01:03:426 (2) - remove this note better. not fit rhythm.
4. 01:13:307 (5,6) - overlaps bit bad. i suggest this.
   SPOILER

   
5. 01:27:592 (1) - not stack better. try this.
   SPOILER

   

P o M u T a wrote:

hi!


[General]

1. add tag 'HANDS UP' please. this is album title.

[Normal]

1. 00:17:592 (1) - add finish slider head.
2. 00:19:497 (3) - add clap slider end.
3. 00:35:688 (5) - add clap slider end.
4. 00:50:926 (4) - ^
5. 00:55:688 (1) - add finish slider head.
6. 01:30:926 (2) - remove finish slider end. loud imo.
7. 01:31:878 (1) - ^
8. 01:31:878 (2) - remove finish.
9. 01:45:688 (2) - add clap slider head and end.
10. 01:46:759 - why 5% volume? not fit imo. remove better. 01:47:473 - also, this greenline delete please.
11. 01:51:402 (5) - add clap slider head and remove clap slider end.
12. 02:03:783 (6) - add finish slider end.
13. 02:31:402 (2,4) - remove finish.
14. 03:17:116 (5,6) - remove finish slider end.

[hard]

1. 00:00:450 (1,2) - add whistle slider end.
2. 00:24:973 (5) - remove finish slider end better.
3. 01:03:426 (2) - remove this note better. not fit rhythm.
4. 01:13:307 (5,6) - overlaps bit bad. i suggest this.
   SPOILER

   
5. 01:27:592 (1) - not stack better. try this.
   SPOILER

   

good luck

Sonnyc wrote:

Hi there~ Randomly appeared to be one of the few more mods.

Normal:

-- Imo, it didn't felt natural that OD is higher than AR. Just my opinion.

00:19:497 (3) - Missing clap
00:22:830 (3) - ^
00:27:592 (3) - Missing clap at the end.
00:29:497 (5,1) - Add clap at (5), and start NC from there.
Well hope you could do some work on hitsounds to make more organized. Currently feels quite random.
01:19:497 (3,4) - Distance error.
01:47:116 (3) - This is nearly in-audible. I doubt if this is rankable.
02:17:354 (1) - Imo, making the space 0.8 would be better in reading.
02:32:830 (1) - Finish didn't sound well here.
02:47:116 (2,4) - Remove Claps? Felt a bit spammed.
03:00:926 (4) - Reduce 1/2, and add 1/1 slider at 03:02:354? The current rhythm didn't felt nice.

Hard:

-- CS3 in Normal, and 5 in Hard feels unbalanced to me.

00:05:211 (3) - Increase 1/4 fits the song better.
01:52:830 (2) - The jump didn't fit imo.
02:51:878 (6) - 1 grid right.

Winek wrote:

Hello! From my modding queue. Sorry, i'm not a good modder, though i'll try my best. Yeah, I'm French Toast and French Fries, French all over. Vive le Québec \o/

[General]
You should maybe review your hitsound, it sound bummer
So much straight slider... Curves and forms.

[Normal]
01:12:830 (1,2) - Maybe remove the clap at the end of slider (1) and put on the both head of these slider?
01:28:069 (4,5) - Remove clap on 5 and put it to 4 instead.
02:24:259 (9,1) - Swap NC?
02:42:354 - Drum hitsound doesn't really feel.

[Hard]
00:30:926 (1) - Move at 212|280
00:49:021 (3,5) - Stack well?

Sorry for the short mod! Bonne chance!

Right, all fixed, thank you!

1. nice song choice! :3
2. I'd like to see more combocolours.
   I know your colours match the background, but personally I just prefer more colours. xD
   example

   
   but that's up to you ofc. c:

1. 00:01:878 (4,5) - move and rotate 5 a bit to match better with 4
   screen

   
   (I made this rather sloppy, you can do better. xD)
2. 00:05:211 (3,4,5) - doesn't fit that well imo, maybe change to something like this:
   screen

   
   or
   
   and let break start at 00:07:592, maybe? (like in the screens)
   otherwise it feels kinda weird, cause the last object before the break is right on the long white tick.
   also, if you don't want to change that part up, you might want to ctrl+g 5, imrpoves the movement
3. 00:17:592 (1,2) and some more parts - match them better (increase the curve for example)
   comparison

   
   it just looks more interesting to me, sorry. orz
   and the movement from 00:19:497 (3,4) is not that nice. ;n;
   (the moevement from 2 to 3 isn't that nice either, but the slidershapes match waaay better, so it looks fine ~)
   include 4 into the pattern from before?
   screen

   
4. 00:24:973 (6) - replace with short slider til long white tick maybe?
   otherwise there is this red/white tick change (which might be a bit too hard to read for the easiest diff)
   alternatively, place a circle at 00:25:449, that's work as well.
5. 00:37:116 (2,3,4,5) - I don't know why, but the sliders look kinda weird to me.
   it's just their shape that looks distorted. xD look at the shape! -
   examlple (left side = "normal" slider)

   
6. 00:40:449 (1,2) - if you match them, do it correctly?
   like this-comparison

   
7. 00:59:497 - there is an object missing (there is a beat there, I'd expect an object)
8. 01:30:926 (2) - add reverse maybe? to avoid that red/white tick thing
9. 01:41:402 - why do you use 0.75 multiplier here? you remove it at 01:41:878 again and it's actually of no use..
   so remove completely?
   it's different with the other SV change, tho.. personally, I'd really don't like them n Easy/Normals.
   espeicially not, if Normal is the easiest difficulty.. it's just too hard to read. (imo)
   I'm sure you can think of something nice for that part - 02:42:354 - 02:48:902 - that's easier to read and looks nice!
   (also, please change the sampleset, it doesn't fit .. or at least it sounds unpleasinf to my ears, dunno if that's for everyone like that.. ><)
10. 01:55:211 (5,6) - readabilty of them is so-so.. buuut Idk. it's kinda your style.. but meh. >:
    keep it, but keep in mind that it's breaking the flowmovement and is not easy to read
11. 02:22:354 (5,6,7,8,1) - think of a nice pattern? a square or pentagon for example
12. 02:26:164 (4) - pay attention to having the red anchor in the middle of the slider (and on the red tick)
    looks better I think.. but if you want to have more variety you could place the red anchor on the blue tick, too.
    same goes for 02:28:069 (6)!

1. 00:05:211 (3) - move to 316|216? -> triangle with 1+2
   you'd have to place the following objects differently then, tho (cause overlap ><)
2. 00:07:116 (4) - rotate a bit to get better movement from 3-4-5
3. 00:08:069 (6) - might want to remove this, same reason as in Normal
4. decrease volume for Normal sampleset parts, maybe? It's so loud.. @@
5. 00:53:783 (4) - include in the pattern of 1+2+3? the jump would be fine, imo, and it looks better too!
6. 01:08:545 (2,3) - think of a different shape? it looks so unstructured to me. qq

Squirrel wrote:

hey there!
mod from queue ~

[General]

1. nice song choice! :3
2. I'd like to see more combocolours.
   I know your colours match the background, but personally I just prefer more colours. xD
   example

   
   but that's up to you ofc. c:

[Normal]
your mapping style is kinda oldschool. I'm not saying that's a bad thing, I just noticed. And it kinda fits the song, too.

1. 00:01:878 (4,5) - move and rotate 5 a bit to match better with 4
   screen

   
   (I made this rather sloppy, you can do better. xD)
2. 00:05:211 (3,4,5) - doesn't fit that well imo, maybe change to something like this:
   screen

   
   or
   
   and let break start at 00:07:592, maybe? (like in the screens)
   otherwise it feels kinda weird, cause the last object before the break is right on the long white tick.
   also, if you don't want to change that part up, you might want to ctrl+g 5, imrpoves the movement
3. 00:17:592 (1,2) and some more parts - match them better (increase the curve for example)
   comparison

   
   it just looks more interesting to me, sorry. orz
   and the movement from 00:19:497 (3,4) is not that nice. ;n;
   (the moevement from 2 to 3 isn't that nice either, but the slidershapes match waaay better, so it looks fine ~)
   include 4 into the pattern from before?
   screen

   
4. 00:24:973 (6) - replace with short slider til long white tick maybe?
   otherwise there is this red/white tick change (which might be a bit too hard to read for the easiest diff)
   alternatively, place a circle at 00:25:449, that's work as well.
5. 00:37:116 (2,3,4,5) - I don't know why, but the sliders look kinda weird to me.
   it's just their shape that looks distorted. xD look at the shape! -
   examlple (left side = "normal" slider)

   
6. 00:40:449 (1,2) - if you match them, do it correctly?
   like this-comparison

   
7. 00:59:497 - there is an object missing (there is a beat there, I'd expect an object)
8. 01:30:926 (2) - add reverse maybe? to avoid that red/white tick thing
9. 01:41:402 - why do you use 0.75 multiplier here? you remove it at 01:41:878 again and it's actually of no use..
   so remove completely?
   it's different with the other SV change, tho.. personally, I'd really don't like them n Easy/Normals.
   espeicially not, if Normal is the easiest difficulty.. it's just too hard to read. (imo)
   I'm sure you can think of something nice for that part - 02:42:354 - 02:48:902 - that's easier to read and looks nice!
   (also, please change the sampleset, it doesn't fit .. or at least it sounds unpleasinf to my ears, dunno if that's for everyone like that.. ><)
10. 01:55:211 (5,6) - readabilty of them is so-so.. buuut Idk. it's kinda your style.. but meh. >:
    keep it, but keep in mind that it's breaking the flowmovement and is not easy to read
11. 02:22:354 (5,6,7,8,1) - think of a nice pattern? a square or pentagon for example
12. 02:26:164 (4) - pay attention to having the red anchor in the middle of the slider (and on the red tick)
    looks better I think.. but if you want to have more variety you could place the red anchor on the blue tick, too.
    same goes for 02:28:069 (6)!

soo, overall I am missing a bit of structure. like repetitive patterns and such.
I'm sure you can think of some, try to!

[Hard]
hehe, really oldschool mapping technique! :3 it's kinda interesting to look at. (I've never seen CS5 before lol)
and basically I'd say the same things as in Normal. - there are some flowmovement issues.
you could use a few more patterns.. well. yeah.
the SV change fit's better here! .. uhm, some minor things:

1. 00:05:211 (3) - move to 316|216? -> triangle with 1+2
   you'd have to place the following objects differently then, tho (cause overlap ><)
2. 00:07:116 (4) - rotate a bit to get better movement from 3-4-5
3. 00:08:069 (6) - might want to remove this, same reason as in Normal
4. decrease volume for Normal sampleset parts, maybe? It's so loud.. @@
5. 00:53:783 (4) - include in the pattern of 1+2+3? the jump would be fine, imo, and it looks better too!
6. 01:08:545 (2,3) - think of a different shape? it looks so unstructured to me. qq

yup. that's it.
osu definitely needs more k-pop, please rank this! *^*

good luck! *squee*

OscaR CUBE wrote:

Hii,, i'm a new beatmapper..
sorry if my mod don't help you so much.. anyways, thank you to post your mod bro!

SPOILER

NORMAL
- 00:29:497 (1,3) - Remove the clap sound.. yep
- 00:29:974 (2,4) - Add clap sound.. (?) hm, why not!
- 00:37:116 (2) - Remove the calp sound?? ^
- 00:48:069 (1) - same ^ ^
- 01:18:545 - add kiai here ? hm, already fix
- 02:19:497 - same ^ ^
- 03:05:211 - same ^ ^
- 02:19:497 (1,4) - Change it like this ?? http://puu.sh/6Pvg0.jpg Right
- 02:34:735 - end the spinner here ? nop
- 03:20:449 - same ^nop

SPOILER

HARD
- 00:15:449 (1) - Remove this object? Indeed, sounds better! thx!
- 00:29:497 (2) - add clap sound here, and the reverse arrow.. nop
- 03:20:449 - end the spinner here?? nop

I think that's all... Thank you!
Sorry for my bad english... Aah, it's ok dude, I understand

yf_bmp wrote:

[General]
Your hitsound addition sounds chaos. I think you should remap hitsounds (especially hitclap). 2|4 clap is okay for this music
I think your map looks chaos, too. For better feelings, you may put the notes according to the law. (Such as shape, flow, and other method)

Yeah I know, i'll work on it, I had trouble finding the right rhythm that sticks with this music.

[Normal]
00:24:259 (5,1) - Please don't do such overlap in this 3-star normal, and it looks a little ugly indeed, fixed
00:28:545 (4,1) - too close ^
00:40:926 (2,4) - not overlap ^
00:51:878 (5) - NC
00:59:497 (6) - NC here,00:59:973 (1) - remove NC ^
02:52:354 (5) - NC ^
03:09:497 (6) - ^ ^

[Hard]
00:05:211 (3,1,2) - Do not do such overlap. it looks not fine now Fixed
00:19:259 (5,1) - ^ ^
00:30:211 (3,1) - ^ ^
01:06:640 (2) - ^ ^
01:09:973 (4,1) - ^ ^
etc. I won't write down every such issues since there are too many.

00:25:688 (1,2) - blanket better
00:27:354 (3,4) - ^
etc. I won't write down every such issues since there are too many.

00:26:878 (2,3) - too close ^
00:57:592 (1,2) - ^ ^
01:08:545 (2,3) - ^ ^
02:09:497 (2,3) - ^ ^

02:56:640 (3,4,5,6) - make a square here Fixed!

OK. That is all. I'm not satisfied with this map now. But I think you can make it better! Go ahead!
If you feel content with this mod, please tell your friends about our Modding Queue!
Good Luck!

P o M u T a wrote:

no kds
[Hard]
01:03:307 (1) - add finish slider head.
01:18:545 (1) - ^
02:19:497 (1) - ^
02:49:973 (1) - ^

[Normal]
02:19:497 (1) - remove clap slider head. instead finish.
02:49:021 (1) - remove clap here. really loud imo.

Kazey wrote:

P o M u T a wrote:

no kds
[Hard]
01:03:307 (1) - add finish slider head.
01:18:545 (1) - ^
02:19:497 (1) - ^
02:49:973 (1) - ^

[Normal]
02:19:497 (1) - remove clap slider head. instead finish.
02:49:021 (1) - remove clap here. really loud imo.

Hey! Don't worry, I'll mod your map dude, you're in my modding queue =3(I'm just busy atm)
By the way, thank you for this mod!

Raiku wrote:

Just another Raiku post!

[Hard]

As a general rule of thumb, I feel all your new combos should start on the downbeat. Really?

00:28:783 (2,3,1) - There are a few instances such as this pattern here where I felt the slider end and the following notes could level out and form a line with the intent of improving the flow a little more (http://puu.sh/6ZsFJ.jpg). Notice how I moved the slider after to the right a little to form a flow out of the combo. Sure, right, fixed!

00:34:735 (4) - I feel this should be a new combo up to the last slider since it is a new vocal section. ^

00:45:449 (4,6) - Avoid this overlap. This can be overcome by implementing what I suggest here: (00:44:497 (3,4,5) - http://puu.sh/6ZsOx.jpg) and here (00:46:402 (6,7) - http://puu.sh/6ZsQH.jpg). Note: I moved 4 and 5 down 1 space on grid level 2, and moved 6 and 7 up 2 spaces. ^

01:24:735 (5,6,7) - I made this triple more linear, how do you feel about this (http://puu.sh/6ZsWG.jpg). 1 grid up ftw!

02:32:354 (4,2) - I avoided this overlap by moving 2 to the right a touch and adjusted the next combos line accordingly (http://puu.sh/6Zt3m.jpg). Fixed!

Funky song dude, love the map and good luck! Thank you for this mod bro!

1. Disable the "Lettebox during breaks" because not used in most map.

1. 00:03:307 (5) - Hmm...not bad, but try out the form like this? Appearance and flow is also good.
   
   image

   
2. 00:21:402 (5,1) - Swap the new combo.
3. 00:22:354 (2,3) - Change to the slider instead of the two circles. Slider are fitting to the song than the circle.
4. 00:24:259 (5,6) - try this rhythm?
   
   image

   
5. 01:49:021 (1) - Move to x:236 y:28 for blanket.
6. 02:12:354 (7,1) - Swap the new combo.
7. 02:25:688 (3) - Move to x:256 y:88 in order to put on a straight line.
8. 02:26:640 (5) - new combo here.

1. 00:02:830 (4) - Appearance is bad, so move to x:328.
2. 00:58:783 (4) - Spacing is narrow.
3. 00:59:736 (6) - new combo here

1. 00:17:592 (1,2,3,4) - The slider curve 3 is the only sexy curved slider there, owo but you might of been using the old editor way of making blankets but just pointing this out
2. 00:23:307 (4) - You should make it face to the other side, it looks very crammed if you make it face left where the next notes will show up, maybe something like this : http://puu.sh/70mMC.jpg and yeah leave the position of the note the same
3. 00:29:497 (1) - You see this doesn't align correctly in the y-axis you need to make it to 192 like notes 3 and 5 00:30:450 (3,4,5) - (Your trying to make a symmetrical pattern here right?)
4. 00:48:069 (1) - I don't see any reason to make this straight, maybe you can curve it up?
5. 01:04:735 (2,3) - Maybe next time you don't do things like this again orz, its fine but makes your map really unclean D: having the next note touching the previous note in someway
6. 01:14:735 (1,2,3,4,5) - Make this pattern symmetrical to like how you did 00:29:497 (1,2,3,4,5) - right now its very unsymmetrical and I assume your trying to do the same thing here as there?
7. 01:47:116 (3,4,5,6) - A Great place to do stacking if you wanted to!
8. 02:00:926 (1,2,3) - More alignment issues, make sure 1 aligns with 3!
9. 02:19:021 (3) - Move this down more, to prevent overlapping with 02:20:449 (2) - please. Right now, it's really close to that it doesn't look nice like said before!
10. 02:25:688 (3) - I don't know if this is intentional but its not correctly centered to the grid, might want to fix it to make it look a little more clean I guess orz
11. 02:31:402 (2,3,4) - This pattern looks boring when you repeat it again and again, how about you try this? http://puu.sh/70v4B.jpg it would work loads better.
12. 02:56:164 (3,4,5) - If your going do symmetry like this, you might as well maybe sure they are centered to the grid , move this whole thing more to the left for that to happen.
13. 02:58:545 (1) - Fix the spacing of this note if you change the above.

1. The claps are noisy here D: but I think your at this point its better to mod the issues with hitsounds rather than redo them LOL
2. 00:07:116 (4,5,6,7,8) - Rhythm can be simplified D:, best bet would be to reverse 4 and use a triplet like this : http://puu.sh/70vqr.jpg It's a weird way to start the song, when people are just getting sense of the rhythm
3. 00:21:640 (6) - I don't recommend using such long slider for a hard , it doesn't mix well with the triplets and weird blue tick rhythms you use, probably decrease to red tick and add a circle to the white tick?
4. 00:22:592 (8,9,10) - If you want to do rhythms like this you must add a circle at 00:24:378 - to match with that.
5. 00:36:164 (1) - Ermm, kinda random slider placement >.> , maybe try this? well you need to move the next note too, here's how the whole thing looks like : http://puu.sh/70vK2.jpg that's seems good to me!
6. 00:36:640 (2) - Oh and you might want to add the new combo here instead and remove at 00:36:164 (1) -
7. 00:58:188 (2) - I don't think the note here fits well, it sounds noisy and doesn't even fit anything even with the clap sound off and the clap sound just awful there.
8. 01:00:449 (7) - Why face up? make it face more down( so it doesn't touch the hp bar D:) like this : http://puu.sh/70vWZ.jpg
9. 01:20:092 - Add a note here to keep the triplets flowing well throughout the kiai (you added them sparingly across the kiai anyway)
10. 01:30:569 - ^
11. 01:55:569 - ^
12. 02:06:045 - ^ same you have to add triplets for this kiai too if you did for the first
13. 02:09:378 - ^
14. 02:56:759 - ^
15. 01:54:735 (2) - Not an issue but might want to align with 01:54:259 (5) - in the y-axis

Gamu wrote:

Hello

M4M Request from you

[General]

1. Disable the "Lettebox during breaks" because not used in most map. Right, fixed!

[Normal]

1. 00:03:307 (5) - Hmm...not bad, but try out the form like this? Appearance and flow is also good.
   
   image

   
   Sure!
2. 00:21:402 (5,1) - Swap the new combo. Ok!
3. 00:22:354 (2,3) - Change to the slider instead of the two circles. Slider are fitting to the song than the circle. ^
4. 00:24:259 (5,6) - try this rhythm? ^
   
   image

   
5. 01:49:021 (1) - Move to x:236 y:28 for blanket. nazi! oh wait?!
6. 02:12:354 (7,1) - Swap the new combo. ^
7. 02:25:688 (3) - Move to x:256 y:88 in order to put on a straight line. ^
8. 02:26:640 (5) - new combo here.

^

[Hard]

1. 00:02:830 (4) - Appearance is bad, so move to x:328. Fixed!
2. 00:58:783 (4) - Spacing is narrow. ^
3. 00:59:736 (6) - new combo here ^

sorry for very short mod..
Hitsound is not good orz, but i can help it for you :3
In other words, I able to add hitsound for you! If you need help, please call me

Tari wrote:

Let's see.

[Normal]

1. 00:17:592 (1,2,3,4) - The slider curve 3 is the only sexy curved slider there, owo but you might of been using the old editor way of making blankets but just pointing this out Ok, fixed!
2. 00:23:307 (4) - You should make it face to the other side, it looks very crammed if you make it face left where the next notes will show up, maybe something like this : http://puu.sh/70mMC.jpg and yeah leave the position of the note the same ^
3. 00:29:497 (1) - You see this doesn't align correctly in the y-axis you need to make it to 192 like notes 3 and 5 00:30:450 (3,4,5) - (Your trying to make a symmetrical pattern here right?) Changed pattern.
4. 00:48:069 (1) - I don't see any reason to make this straight, maybe you can curve it up? Why not
5. 01:04:735 (2,3) - Maybe next time you don't do things like this again orz, its fine but makes your map really unclean D: having the next note touching the previous note in someway Yeah, k
6. 01:14:735 (1,2,3,4,5) - Make this pattern symmetrical to like how you did 00:29:497 (1,2,3,4,5) - right now its very unsymmetrical and I assume your trying to do the same thing here as there? ^
7. 01:47:116 (3,4,5,6) - A Great place to do stacking if you wanted to! Stacked!
8. 02:00:926 (1,2,3) - More alignment issues, make sure 1 aligns with 3! Already
9. 02:19:021 (3) - Move this down more, to prevent overlapping with 02:20:449 (2) - please. Right now, it's really close to that it doesn't look nice like said before! Ok, fixed!
10. 02:25:688 (3) - I don't know if this is intentional but its not correctly centered to the grid, might want to fix it to make it look a little more clean I guess orz nazi stuff fixed!
11. 02:31:402 (2,3,4) - This pattern looks boring when you repeat it again and again, how about you try this? http://puu.sh/70v4B.jpg it would work loads better. ^
12. 02:56:164 (3,4,5) - If your going do symmetry like this, you might as well maybe sure they are centered to the grid , move this whole thing more to the left for that to happen. ^
13. 02:58:545 (1) - Fix the spacing of this note if you change the above. ^

[Hard]

1. The claps are noisy here D: but I think your at this point its better to mod the issues with hitsounds rather than redo them LOL XD
2. 00:07:116 (4,5,6,7,8) - Rhythm can be simplified D:, best bet would be to reverse 4 and use a triplet like this : http://puu.sh/70vqr.jpg It's a weird way to start the song, when people are just getting sense of the rhythm Yeah, understood, but I pref this actual pattern bro
3. 00:21:640 (6) - I don't recommend using such long slider for a hard , it doesn't mix well with the triplets and weird blue tick rhythms you use, probably decrease to red tick and add a circle to the white tick? ^
4. 00:22:592 (8,9,10) - If you want to do rhythms like this you must add a circle at 00:24:378 - to match with that. Fixed!
5. 00:36:164 (1) - Ermm, kinda random slider placement >.> , maybe try this? well you need to move the next note too, here's how the whole thing looks like : http://puu.sh/70vK2.jpg that's seems good to me! ^
6. 00:36:640 (2) - Oh and you might want to add the new combo here instead and remove at 00:36:164 (1) - ^
7. 00:58:188 (2) - I don't think the note here fits well, it sounds noisy and doesn't even fit anything even with the clap sound off and the clap sound just awful there. Deleted!
8. 01:00:449 (7) - Why face up? make it face more down( so it doesn't touch the hp bar D:) like this : http://puu.sh/70vWZ.jpg Pattern changed!
9. 01:20:092 - Add a note here to keep the triplets flowing well throughout the kiai (you added them sparingly across the kiai anyway) Right,
10. 01:30:569 - ^ ^
11. 01:55:569 - ^ ^
12. 02:06:045 - ^ same you have to add triplets for this kiai too if you did for the first ^
13. 02:09:378 - ^ ^
14. 02:56:759 - ^ ^
15. 01:54:735 (2) - Not an issue but might want to align with 01:54:259 (5) - in the y-axis ^

Alarido wrote:

Congratz For the Ranking!!!!

Edit: a possible, subjective, little, missing thing here at Normal diff, noticed at ~25s while playing.