forum

Katsura Hinagiku starring Itou Shizuka - Haru ULALA LOVE yo

posted
Total Posts
48
show more
Topic Starter
Momochikun
Thx.. fixed some~
UnitedWeSin
Hey Mochi^^
Here's a mod for you.

[General]

  1. Seems fine.
[Insane]

  1. 00:34:664 (5,1) - This bothers me in play. The flow is a bit too harsh with this jump here. Try stacking the 5 on the head of the 00:34:150 (3) instead.
  2. 00:45:807 (1) - Just a suggestion. For a nicer flow, try stacking this on the head of the 00:45:121 (3) and then placing the 00:45:807 (1,2,3) in a triangle. Here's what I mean:
  3. 01:03:292 (3,1) - The music makes me really want to hit two notes here and then play the spinner. Try moving the spinner 1/4 later and adding another circle.
  4. 01:10:321 (4,5,1) - Most it more upwards, around (168, 56). It will make a nicer flow from the previous slider and fix the blanket. If you do so, make sure 01:11:007 (2,3,4) are following in the curve.
  5. 01:24:207 (1,2,3) - Try to make the spacing more consistent. It will look nicer.
[Hard]

  1. 00:15:978 (2,3,4,5,6) - This is too difficult for a hard imo. Try to make it more simple and use a repeating slider at 00:16:321 instead. Maybe like this:
  2. 00:20:950 (1,2,3) - This is confusing because we start the repeating slider before the music calls for it. I suggest that you replace the 1 with a single circle, and then move the 3 to 00:21:807 and remove two repeats from it. That will be easier to read and follow the music nicer.
  3. 00:22:492 (1) - Make the finish a normal finish instead here? Seems more fitting and consistent with the Insane diff.
  4. 00:25:921 (3) - Maybe rotate it by 12 degrees to make a nice blanket with the 1 here.
  5. 00:33:464 (1) - Normal finish on the head maybe?
  6. 00:49:407 - Really suggest that you add a note here and get rid of this confusing stacking with the 00:48:892 (3,4) since there is an active piano part in the music that the player can hear.
  7. 01:09:121 (1,2,3,4,1) - The blankets look pretty sloppy here. Try to clean it up a bit. Move the 01:09:635 (2,3) downwards a bit so the 3 can sit in a blanket with the 01:10:492 (1) and the 2 can sit in between the sliders perfectly.
[Normal]

  1. 00:00:721 (2) - This slider doesn't feel so great imo. Since this is normal, try to make use of some 1/2 sliders. Here are a few rhythms you could try:
    Image

    Or if you want to get right of that 1/2 stack right at the beginning of the map, then try:
  2. 00:05:692 (4) - Just a suggestion here, if you delete this note and rearrange the 00:06:035 (1), you can make the rhythm after it 00:06:035 (1,2,1) feel nicer with how the vocals are. That's because you put a pause in front of and behind the 00:08:092 (2).
  3. 00:22:492 (1) - Same as hard, maybe make the finish a normal finish.
  4. 00:25:921 (2) - I think it would be better to use a rhythm that follows more closely to the vocals here. Try removing the repeat from the 2 and adding another 1/2 slider. Then move the 4 1/2 earlier. This way you can add the clap in that you are missing also.
  5. 00:31:064 (4,5) - It's so bland and straight. =w= Add some curves and curve the 5 more upwards so it doesn't overlap with the 00:29:007 (2). Here's just an example, try it out:
  6. 00:33:464 to 00:41:350 - You've used onbeat normal hits here. It sounds very strange... Try to remove the normal hits from beats 1 and 3 and place them only on beats 2 and 4. It will sound much nicer with the music.
  7. 00:33:464 (1) - Same as hard, try a normal finish.
  8. 00:34:492 - Try to add a note here with a clap. It's a bit strange that we have this pause here after the music starts to pick up.
  9. 00:36:207 (1,3) - The normal hits on the head are kind of loud since these are onbeats, can you replace them with soft whistles?
  10. 01:06:378 (1,2,1) - You've add the normal hits on the onbeats here. Please change to the offbeats.
  11. 01:06:378 (1,1) - Placement looks not so great imo. Try flipping the 01:07:750 (1) over and making it blanket the first slider. You could try giving the wave more of a curve, it would be more interesting imo. Here's what I mean:
  12. 01:10:492 (1,2) - Similar point, the normal hit should be on the 2 there. Remove the one from the end of the 1 and add it to the 2.
  13. 01:15:292 (2) - Normal hit on the head is nice here.
  14. 01:17:350 (1,2,3,4) - Same as 01:06:378 (1,2,1). The normal hits are placed incorrectly here.
  15. 01:28:321 (1) - To make it more interesting here, try pointing the slider more to the right. Also if you add some anchors, you can make a slider that fits the playful music here a bit better. her's just an example:
Anyways. The Insane is pretty nice. I don't like your spread. The hard is really jumpy for a set without an Easy diff, and the Normal diff is too difficult for beginners to play imo. You chose a very large spacing for the easiest diff. You could try placing the objects in a lower spacing. I recommend trying to map an Easy diff and adding more 1/2 rhythms in the Normal. If you really don't want to do that, then you'll have to make the Normal a bit easier.
Good luck!^^
Topic Starter
Momochikun

UnitedWeSin wrote:

Hey Mochi^^
Here's a mod for you.

[General]

  1. Seems fine.
[Insane]

  1. 00:34:664 (5,1) - This bothers me in play. The flow is a bit too harsh with this jump here. Try stacking the 5 on the head of the 00:34:150 (3) instead. fixed
  2. 00:45:807 (1) - Just a suggestion. For a nicer flow, try stacking this on the head of the 00:45:121 (3) and then placing the 00:45:807 (1,2,3) in a triangle. Here's what I mean: i like the flow i have, no change for now
  3. 01:03:292 (3,1) - The music makes me really want to hit two notes here and then play the spinner. Try moving the spinner 1/4 later and adding another circle. k ~ added
  4. 01:10:321 (4,5,1) - Most it more upwards, around (168, 56). It will make a nicer flow from the previous slider and fix the blanket. If you do so, make sure 01:11:007 (2,3,4) are following in the curve. fixed the blanket
  5. 01:24:207 (1,2,3) - Try to make the spacing more consistent. It will look nicer.omg.. fixed~
[Hard]

  1. 00:15:978 (2,3,4,5,6) - This is too difficult for a hard imo. Try to make it more simple and use a repeating slider at 00:16:321 instead. Maybe like this: fixed on my own
  2. 00:20:950 (1,2,3) - This is confusing because we start the repeating slider before the music calls for it. I suggest that you replace the 1 with a single circle, and then move the 3 to 00:21:807 and remove two repeats from it. That will be easier to read and follow the music nicer.okay.. i got hard time fix this xD
  3. 00:22:492 (1) - Make the finish a normal finish instead here? Seems more fitting and consistent with the Insane diff. i'll check this later
  4. 00:25:921 (3) - Maybe rotate it by 12 degrees to make a nice blanket with the 1 here. fixed the blanket
  5. 00:33:464 (1) - Normal finish on the head maybe? make it consistent with insane
  6. 00:49:407 - Really suggest that you add a note here and get rid of this confusing stacking with the 00:48:892 (3,4) since there is an active piano part in the music that the player can hear. i make it as same as insane, i just followed the drum sound at the whole mapset
  7. 01:09:121 (1,2,3,4,1) - The blankets look pretty sloppy here. Try to clean it up a bit. Move the 01:09:635 (2,3) downwards a bit so the 3 can sit in a blanket with the 01:10:492 (1) and the 2 can sit in between the sliders perfectly.looks nice.. fixed
[Normal]

  1. 00:00:721 (2) - This slider doesn't feel so great imo. Since this is normal, try to make use of some 1/2 sliders. Here are a few rhythms you could try:
    Image

    Or if you want to get right of that 1/2 stack right at the beginning of the map, then try:
    i just changed into spinner -w-
  2. 00:05:692 (4) - Just a suggestion here, if you delete this note and rearrange the 00:06:035 (1), you can make the rhythm after it 00:06:035 (1,2,1) feel nicer with how the vocals are. That's because you put a pause in front of and behind the 00:08:092 (2). i'll consider this
  3. 00:22:492 (1) - Same as hard, maybe make the finish a normal finish. k
  4. 00:25:921 (2) - I think it would be better to use a rhythm that follows more closely to the vocals here. Try removing the repeat from the 2 and adding another 1/2 slider. Then move the 4 1/2 earlier. This way you can add the clap in that you are missing also. imo missing clap before finish is fine
  5. 00:31:064 (4,5) - It's so bland and straight. =w= Add some curves and curve the 5 more upwards so it doesn't overlap with the 00:29:007 (2). Here's just an example, try it out: orz.. okay~
  6. 00:33:464 to 00:41:350 - You've used onbeat normal hits here. It sounds very strange... Try to remove the normal hits from beats 1 and 3 and place them only on beats 2 and 4. It will sound much nicer with the music. try to change rhytm
  7. 00:33:464 (1) - Same as hard, try a normal finish. fixed
  8. 00:34:492 - Try to add a note here with a clap. It's a bit strange that we have this pause here after the music starts to pick up. i think it still better to add after slider
  9. 00:36:207 (1,3) - The normal hits on the head are kind of loud since these are onbeats, can you replace them with soft whistles?
  10. 01:06:378 (1,2,1) - You've add the normal hits on the onbeats here. Please change to the offbeats.
  11. 01:06:378 (1,1) - Placement looks not so great imo. Try flipping the 01:07:750 (1) over and making it blanket the first slider. You could try giving the wave more of a curve, it would be more interesting imo. Here's what I mean: k
  12. 01:10:492 (1,2) - Similar point, the normal hit should be on the 2 there. Remove the one from the end of the 1 and add it to the 2. normal on thhe 2 looks nice, but the rest feel weird IMO
  13. 01:15:292 (2) - Normal hit on the head is nice here. added
  14. 01:17:350 (1,2,3,4) - Same as 01:06:378 (1,2,1). The normal hits are placed incorrectly here. changed
  15. 01:28:321 (1) - To make it more interesting here, try pointing the slider more to the right. Also if you add some anchors, you can make a slider that fits the playful music here a bit better. her's just an example: added anchors xD
Anyways. The Insane is pretty nice. I don't like your spread. The hard is really jumpy for a set without an Easy diff, and the Normal diff is too difficult for beginners to play imo. You chose a very large spacing for the easiest diff. You could try placing the objects in a lower spacing. I recommend trying to map an Easy diff and adding more 1/2 rhythms in the Normal. If you really don't want to do that, then you'll have to make the Normal a bit easier.
Good luck!^^
Almost fixed..
Thanks a lot for mod ~ :)
pife1
Hi:
In Normal:
01:13:235 and 01:13:921 : In my opinión here should have some notes because the Singer contine singing, also I feel this part a bit empty

In Hard:
00:33:121 (5) - Excuse me, but Why didn't you use the claps like 00:21:807 (3)
01:15:978 and 01:16:150 (6,7) - This part is some confusing because of the precise momento there is a sound of piano and tend precipitate to 01:16:150 (6,7)

In Insane
00:43:921 (4,5) - could remove them
00:54:721 (4,5,6) and 00:55:064 (7,8,9) - Could replace these circles with short slider like the hard
01:15:978 and 01:16:150 (6,7) - same problem of piano like hard

That's all

when I grow up I want to make maps like you
Topic Starter
Momochikun
Minor change.. thanks
Teara
Nice.

Only found a few issues. Call me back once you fixed it.

[Normal]
01:13:578 (4,5) - Try making this a longer slider. At the moment its very tricky to play, and this would flow better IMO. (Normal sampleset on start and end ofc)



[Mochi]
AR 9 is no good. It's to fast and the bpm doesnt justify it. Please lower it to 8.
Topic Starter
Momochikun
Fixed all ~ thanks
Boncho
Normal
_____________________________________________
00:23:178 - add a note because I think it sounds better

Hard
_____________________________________________
Everythings ok here

Insane
_____________________________________________
00:20:007 - add a note on (2)
new combo begins 00:11:350 (1) instead of 00:11:435 (2)


Very nice map
This was everything because I cant find more.... ''orz
Topic Starter
Momochikun

Bonch0 wrote:

Normal
_____________________________________________
00:23:178 - add a note because I think it sounds better i want to make it easier

Hard
_____________________________________________
Everythings ok here

Insane
_____________________________________________
00:20:007 - add a note on (2) it doesn't fit IMO
new combo begins 00:11:350 (1) instead of 00:11:435 (2) downbeat.. my NC is right


Very nice map
This was everything because I cant find more.... ''orz
Sorry no change..
Thanks for mod :)
Teara
ulala! Sorry for being very late.

Strangely enough the title has TV EDIT in it and not TV SIZE.



Good luck!
Topic Starter
Momochikun
Thank you ~ <3

Edit : to any Bats that willing to check this.. can you make the title and artist appeared at 00:11:521 ? any color is fine ~ :roll:
NoHitter
Made a few minor changes in [Mochi]
SPOILER
18:55 Momochikun: hi.. i got 16+ SP bubbled anime map.. can i ask you to check it ?
18:56 NoHitter: got two maps to check xD
18:56 NoHitter: already
18:56 Momochikun: xD
18:57 Momochikun: you want to bubble that map ?
18:59 NoHitter: hopefully
19:30 Momochikun: can i ask a early request for recheck.. ? you can do it wherever you have time >.<
19:36 *NoHitter is editing [http://osu.ppy.sh/b/277615 Katsura Hinagiku starring Itou Shizuka - Haru ULALA LOVE yo Koi!!! (TV EDIT) [Mochi]]
19:37 NoHitter: is it really TV EDIT in all caps?
19:37 Momochikun: yes..
19:37 Momochikun: look at the link that teara give on the thread if you have doubt ~
19:38 NoHitter: mochi looks fine. just a few nazi things
19:39 NoHitter: reverse this slider for better flow? 00:12:550 (4) -
19:40 Momochikun: why ? i think it's fine..
19:41 NoHitter: well just that the sliders following the same direction flows less xD
19:41 NoHitter: anyway, if you don't want to change, let's move on
19:41 NoHitter: 00:33:464 (1,2,3) - can you make the blankets here better?
19:41 NoHitter: http://puu.sh/4iMNY.jpg
19:41 NoHitter: right now (2) is slightly off the middle
19:42 NoHitter: and (3) doesn't follow (1)'s shape properly
19:42 Momochikun: i'll try to fix it like the picture
19:44 NoHitter: 00:41:350 (1,2,3,1,2,1,2,3,4) - just a comment on the combo here. why not make the combo match with the lyrics? http://puu.sh/4iMSi.jpg
19:45 Momochikun: fixed..
19:46 NoHitter: 01:16:835 (3) - move down by 1 grid so that the stream will be curved properly [nazi]
19:47 Momochikun: ok fixed..
19:48 NoHitter: Hard is fine
19:48 NoHitter: let's cross fingers and hope there's no unrankable stuff in Normal
19:48 NoHitter: xD
19:48 Momochikun: lol
19:48 Momochikun: i'll update it then
19:50 NoHitter: btw curious... this is hayate the combat butler right???
19:50 Momochikun: updated ~
19:50 Momochikun: yes it is..

Ranked!
Topic Starter
Momochikun
Thanks for checking ~ <3
Oyatsu
Baka!!! WHy you always make me crazyy~? :o
Freya
o3o congratz
jonathanlfj
never got around to modding this ><
Congratulations~
BeatofIke
Congratulations Mochi! :)
Natsu
gratz
hoLysoup
lol this artist title..
you might as well just put Itou Shizuka
congrats~
Frostmourne
H-I-N-A Hinagiku!
Topic Starter
Momochikun
Thankyou guys ~
and jona if you don't mind you can mod my other pending maps :p /runs
Please sign in to reply.

New reply