Did a hell of a bunch of testplaying to check though Marathon again and to also fine-tune the timing.
Taiko
*Isn't kiai supposed to only start/end on the downbeats of measures? Regardless, many kiai sections start/end at weird spots like blue ticks, so I highly suggest fixing those.
*Almost 3000 combo? Holy...
Marathon
*Just noticed that you have more than three slider speeds (didn't think about it when I suggested that you use a slower speed at 03:20:009). You'll need to either change 03:20:009's 0.75x speed (which I still think is too fast here and suggest trying 0.5x again) or remove the 2x from 02:40:603 (1).
*I wasn't going to complain about there being too much kiai, but using multiple fountains like at 06:48:774 and 06:49:681 is a bit excessive, especially since you didn't add them at 06:58:451 and 06:59:359. I suggest removing these two fountains.
*But, I wouldn't mind if you added one at 07:03:290 since I expected it here.
*Background sizes look kinda strange since many are too wide. The black bars at the top and bottom don't look that great, but it's up to you whether you wanna try messing with the SB to scale them, finding new images, or something like that.
*00:50:192 (3,1,2) - The slider speed changes around here are confusing enough with a 1/4th repeating slider that goes directly into more 1/4th notes. I think this would flow much better if you removed one repeat.
*02:12:073 (1) - I keep expecting this to be 1/3 earlier due to the really close distance spacing. How about vertically flipping it (and rotating it like 30 degrees with ctrl-shift-r) like this? http://puu.sh/rhv
*04:51:625 (1,2) - The 1/8th sliders here and at 04:53:032 (1,2) sound pretty bad imo. If you really have to use them, then perhaps try 1/6th snapping or something like that?
*06:22:161 (8) - perhaps add a note here?
Timing
6,910: +10 should work better
78,875: I'm not the best at streams, so this was a challenge to test, but I think it's fine.
107,430: Try +20 (feels really early)
112,604: Early, so +10.
163,304: Sounds fine.
250,804: Butterfly starts before this, and the beginning sounds a little bit fast, so try starting this at 238,145 instead (and resnap since the offset is changed a little bit)
04:46:004: The bpm is still fine here, but Misao is a bit earlier than the music. It's a bit hard to match the offset to her without making it really sound off with the music, so I'm not going to add a new offset.
300,034: Fine.
350,700: Felt a tiny bit off, but I think it's fine.
429,924: -5 felt a bit better. The timing gets early one second, then late the next, but an earlier offset felt like a better average for this section.
08:45:214: I hated to do it, but the last few measure felt even more off than the rest of the section. 525,214 should be close enough.
Remember to be very very careful when resnapping (do each section individually) as to not screw up the 1/4th and 1/3rd sections.
Unfortunately, MATs cannot bubble approval maps, so I really can't do anything else with this map. But good luck!
Taiko
*Isn't kiai supposed to only start/end on the downbeats of measures? Regardless, many kiai sections start/end at weird spots like blue ticks, so I highly suggest fixing those.
*Almost 3000 combo? Holy...
Marathon
*Just noticed that you have more than three slider speeds (didn't think about it when I suggested that you use a slower speed at 03:20:009). You'll need to either change 03:20:009's 0.75x speed (which I still think is too fast here and suggest trying 0.5x again) or remove the 2x from 02:40:603 (1).
*I wasn't going to complain about there being too much kiai, but using multiple fountains like at 06:48:774 and 06:49:681 is a bit excessive, especially since you didn't add them at 06:58:451 and 06:59:359. I suggest removing these two fountains.
*But, I wouldn't mind if you added one at 07:03:290 since I expected it here.
*Background sizes look kinda strange since many are too wide. The black bars at the top and bottom don't look that great, but it's up to you whether you wanna try messing with the SB to scale them, finding new images, or something like that.
*00:50:192 (3,1,2) - The slider speed changes around here are confusing enough with a 1/4th repeating slider that goes directly into more 1/4th notes. I think this would flow much better if you removed one repeat.
*02:12:073 (1) - I keep expecting this to be 1/3 earlier due to the really close distance spacing. How about vertically flipping it (and rotating it like 30 degrees with ctrl-shift-r) like this? http://puu.sh/rhv
*04:51:625 (1,2) - The 1/8th sliders here and at 04:53:032 (1,2) sound pretty bad imo. If you really have to use them, then perhaps try 1/6th snapping or something like that?
*06:22:161 (8) - perhaps add a note here?
Timing
6,910: +10 should work better
78,875: I'm not the best at streams, so this was a challenge to test, but I think it's fine.
107,430: Try +20 (feels really early)
112,604: Early, so +10.
163,304: Sounds fine.
250,804: Butterfly starts before this, and the beginning sounds a little bit fast, so try starting this at 238,145 instead (and resnap since the offset is changed a little bit)
04:46:004: The bpm is still fine here, but Misao is a bit earlier than the music. It's a bit hard to match the offset to her without making it really sound off with the music, so I'm not going to add a new offset.
300,034: Fine.
350,700: Felt a tiny bit off, but I think it's fine.
429,924: -5 felt a bit better. The timing gets early one second, then late the next, but an earlier offset felt like a better average for this section.
08:45:214: I hated to do it, but the last few measure felt even more off than the rest of the section. 525,214 should be close enough.
Remember to be very very careful when resnapping (do each section individually) as to not screw up the 1/4th and 1/3rd sections.
Unfortunately, MATs cannot bubble approval maps, so I really can't do anything else with this map. But good luck!