CrestRising wrote:

[General:]

• 
  For Easy and Normal, at 01:21:674 to 01:32:288 I don't get why there are a lot of overlaps. There's nothing rhythmically or visually that leads to this. Its worse in Normal than Easy since I couldn't even get it the second time playing it. I just found it odd. If you are going to keep this however, you might as well keep the pattern going in the second half of the verse. Here, lemme explain all to you. First, those are stacks, not overlaps (overlaps here means slider that placed on top on another slider or on another hitcircle). Second, 01:21:674 to 01:32:288 is literally the middle of the song, where on most songs there will be breaks. But here, there were no breaks on the song (the vocal's still flowing) so the only way to let people enjoy the mapping while also resting is by two ways available, by slowing down the slider speed, or by making some stacks. I chose the second way, and I'm not placing them randomly, I followed the music pattern.
  
  Also, I don't understand all the reason for timing points at around 02:48:013 It just switches the volume around from 60 and 10. Its not like the music gets any louder or quieter.Tried to make a variation of spinnerspin sound that followed music pattern "closely" lol actually this is just a random messing-up but I think I'll keep it up for now 'cause I liked it <3
  
  If you can, I think a spinner near the end of the map (not the song) may fit nicely. Spinner on the end of the map will breaks storyboard

[Normal:]

• 
  00:15:959 (2) This looks odd. Cutting slider technique. Mostly popular on nowadays maps (; or atleast my nowadays maps
  02:42:388 (3,3) If you delete these two circles, it will give a kind of good "waiting" period between 2 and 4? Its hard to explain, just try it out. Just a thought. Wow, a very nice idea actually, and follows the song in a different way nicely. But... I think I'll keep mine.
  Just one last thing, in places like 00:55:245 (1,2,3,4,5,6) it might be better if you combined 4 and 5 into one slider. Talking about this pattern, this isn't replicated in the last chorus but its in the first two. Just thought I'd point that out. I'll try to do what did you mean here.

[Hard:]

• 
  Just in general, I think 1 beat overlaps/stacks like 00:35:959 (2,3,4) are odd and it seems like too much of a delay, since a lot of stacks have objects that are 1/2 or 1/4 beats apart. Just a thought. Well... imo it's fine
  00:14:531 (6) I think it would sound better if you took the repeat off of this slider. Nice idea! Thanks!
  02:42:388 (5,5) You could delete these two and then add a circle a 1/2 beat before (red tick just before) both of the 6's. It would sound better. I think mine was better o.o
  03:00:959 (1,2,3,4,5,6) Just out of the blue, its ironic that the place where the pattern doesn't happen in Normal happens only here in Hard. If you want to have a little variety [from Normal], you could change 1,2,4, and 5 into circles instead. lol I'll change the one on Normal instead.
  03:06:674 (1,2,3) It would look a lot cleaner if this was all just stacked neatly.

Amazing map, amazing storyboard. Good luck with mapping.

gdeath wrote:

Hello!

[Easy]
01:00:959 (1,2,3) - This pattern runs in opposite direction with rhythm. I would reverse the slider at 01:00:959 (1) and remove the slider at 01:02:031 (2). Uhh.. not really. And I just don't want to add a reverse here.

[Normal]
I dont wanna be picky. I'm fine with all of them.

[Hard]
02:46:674 (1) - how about having the spinner with clap end at 02:48:817 and adding a circle at 02:49:531 with finish? Hmm... If there's any post-spinner notes after this, it'll be hard for players with widespread spinning style to hit the notes (and to get spinnerbonuses)
If you take this suggestion, other diffs could have this pattern as well.

Good job.
Deserve a star.

19:54 inverness: it's my first bubble y know
19:55 -Bakari-: So.. he's going to bubble it?
19:55 inverness: dunno really, but he said "will definitely bubble this soon"
19:56 inverness: the problem is, i don't know when the "soon" is >.<
19:59 *-Bakari- is editing Owl City - Gold [Hard]
20:00 -Bakari-: 01:50:781- how about circle here? I think it fits here quite good.
20:00 inverness: wait wrong map
20:01 inverness: o3o actually,
20:01 inverness: if I'm going to add note over there
20:02 inverness: owait
20:02 -Bakari-: 03:02:745 (5,2)- ULTRA NAZI - stack them if you want. Just to make it looks better in editor :D/
20:03 inverness: o.o wait
20:03 inverness: nice idea!
20:04 -Bakari-: 03:15:245 (1,2,3,4,5)- ULTRA NAZI [2] - move it 2 grids down to avoid overlap with HP-bar >.</
20:04 inverness: lol the second one sorry, no, it'll break my placements o3o
20:05 -Bakari-: 03:32:388 (1,2,3,4)- ULTRA NAZI [3] - where's your awesome sliders? I'm sure you can make some blankets 
20:05 -Bakari-: here!
20:05 inverness: ^ lol this one
20:06 inverness: ok i'll try o3o
20:07 -Bakari-: 00:45:067- and probably circle here for vocals. Or try to re-arrange rhythm a bit to end slider at 00:45:067? :3/
20:08 -Bakari-: Ganteng diff is ganteng. ♥
20:08 inverness: LOL
20:12 inverness: lol for the blanket on those windmill sliders
20:12 inverness: IT'S HARD TO MAKE ONE
20:12 inverness: T_T
20:12 inverness: but I made through it and now it's nice <3
20:13 -Bakari-: yay
20:13 -Bakari-: Normal
20:13 -Bakari-: try AR5 it will be AMAZING during kiai!
20:14 inverness: o.o
20:14 -Bakari-: 00:28:459 (4,1)- this kind of overlaps is a bit confusing for beginners
20:15 -Bakari-: 01:20:602 (4,1)- 01:22:567 (2,3)- 01:22:745 (3,1)- 01:24:531 (2,3)- it;ll be really hard for Normal players with 
20:15 -Bakari-: hidden :<
20:15 -Bakari-: They will have to guess how long to wait till next click :V
20:15 inverness: overlap fixed
20:16 -Bakari-: There's some overlaps like that one, so fix them all!
20:16 -Bakari-: 02:10:245 (2)- I'd start it at 02:10:602- because of vocals!
20:17 inverness: some are quite undisturbing
20:17 inverness: for the stacked circles, i guess no D: it's okay imo
20:17 -Bakari-: It's up to you, of course :)
20:18 inverness: o3o I will primarily map to music rhythm, if the rhythm's hard, then I'll map on the vocals.
20:18 inverness: if the rhythm's still recognisable, I'll map to rhythm instead :)
20:18 -Bakari-: 00:55:959 (2)- EASY DIFF - probably a bit confusing flow. Beginners will move it from the end. >.<
20:19 -Bakari-: I love your style.
20:19 -Bakari-: 01:04:531 (3,4)- same as above! Remember, people will probably play osu! for their first time! So, it's better to 
20:19 -Bakari-: make it as easy as possible 
20:19 inverness: eh, lemme make the image explanation
20:20 -Bakari-: 01:43:817 (1,2)- well.. can be read as stacked slider. (same, start from the end.) 
20:20 inverness: http://puu.sh/1Fvmx good
20:20 -Bakari-: 02:40:959 (1)- whistle/finish on slider head o3o/
20:21 inverness: http://puu.sh/1FvmT bad D:
20:21 -Bakari-: Yea, I understand it!
20:21 -Bakari-: But still, they're beginners! So be gentle!
20:21 -Bakari-: Anyway, I have nothing else to say! :) Good map!
20:22 inverness: o3o about whistle/finish on other diffs I don't add them so...
20:22 inverness: \:D/ ok!
20:22 -Bakari-: Oh, ok. Anyway, you can add them on every diff! :D
20:22 *-Bakari- runs
20:23 -Bakari-: That's it. NOW CALL GRUMD IF YOU WANT o3o/
20:23 -Bakari-: And here's an awesome track for you.
20:23 *-Bakari- is listening to BT - All That Makes Us Human Continues
20:24 -Bakari-: I HAVE TO GO NOW
20:24 -Bakari-: See you tomorrow! \>3</
20:24 inverness: no wait
20:24 inverness: just post the savelog and i'll kudos that

BCI wrote:

hi
some m4m .__.

[Easy]
00:35:245 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2) - i feel that combopattern so inconsistent owo for me it may be more good and awesome to add NC on 00:38:102 (3) (you do this in 01:43:817 (1,2,1,2) lolol lol fixed~
00:55:245 (1,2) - move last point on (1) one grid down and (2) (slider) one grid right to do more nice overlap OK!
01:10:602 (2,3) - this pattern in Easy... >< i like this, but please think about it (i don't mention other patterns which is the same) >.< i know but I love it ,_,
01:20:245 (5,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - (so many lolol) this kind of stacks is kinda hard for an easy espesially it's so many >.< pls think about it too This part is intended for "break" to allow people rest on the stacks.
01:23:817 (3) - add NC here (moar awesomness + new words on SB) OK!
01:35:245 (3) - ^ OK!
01:38:102 (1,2) - same as 00:55:245 (1,2) but move (2) one grid left kay
01:50:959 (4) - you can do this slider in another form >.< like http://puu.sh/1FVpf also it will be good to do slider's end soft + finish for consistency with other diffs o3o changed into something else but thanks for pointing out!
02:10:602 (2) - one grid down and right? OK!
02:48:013 - why this timing sections here, makes no effect owo o3o just check it out by playing it and you'll find out why (;
03:02:388 (1) - remove NC for consistency with others NC in this place (01:58:102 (1,2,3,4,5,6) ; 00:49:531 (1,2,3,4,5,6) ) ok (:
03:10:245 (3,4) - y'know what to do i think (same as 00:55:245 (1,2) - ) Fixed!

[Normal]
00:42:388 (3) - do it with the new slider system pls Fixed o3o
01:23:817 (1,2) - same stacks.. i read this as 1/2 so pls think about it too >.< Nah, the song won't tell you to hit it on 1/2 (;
01:43:817 (1,3) - do it with the new slider system pls k!

[Hard]
03:35:245 (3) - NC? OK!

so proo SB. my star here owo

Frostmourne wrote:

I will mod this next year (maybe 1 or 2 January) , don't have too much time currently orz..

General
Fine !

Easy
00:28:102 (2) - whistle at the first point here to correspond with 00:25:245 (2) - Fixed.
02:19:174 (2,3) - a bit hard for Easy diff ? Not really I guess..

Normal
HP+1 is not too hard for this diff I would say OK!
00:27:745 (3) - add whistle on the first part too , I think it sounds good so Nope, consisting sound pattern

Hard
fine

have my special 2 stars for amazing SB+neat map+you are gold Yay thanks! Good luck on your Gold, Frost!

I can't really find many points to mod because I don't want to mod by my own subjective opinions so those are only points needed to be fixed imo

Static Noise Bird wrote:

Modreq by GamerX4Life on my queue~ Wow thanks GamerX4life!

[General]
Pro SB.

[Easy]
00:15:245 (1) - It's not too bad, but wouldn't hurt to try making it completely symmetrical Fixed with simpler points instead.
00:26:674 (1) - ^ k
01:11:317 (3) - Stack it properly with the previous one >__> For these manual stacks, I'll explain these later
01:13:102 (2) - When you have fixed the one at 00:26:674 (1), just copypaste it here I don't think it'll matched with the blanket I intended.
01:16:317 (2,3) - Staaaaaacks
01:21:674 (1) - Move this somewhere and stack the next one with previous one's end
01:23:817 (1) - Stack it properly with the previous one
01:26:674 (1) - ^
01:28:102 (4) - ^
01:29:531 (1) - ^
01:30:959 (4) - ^
etc.
01:35:245 (1) - Actually here you can see that the end is longer than start, so try to fix this kind of sliders. Perfect is better than good. Fixed.
02:19:174 (2,3) - Not going to mention any of these stacks from now on

[Normal]
00:25:602 (4) - Copypaste and flip the slider from 00:26:674 (1) here, it's way better
01:20:602 (4,1,2,1,2,3,4,1,2,3,1,2,3) - This almost-stacking thing is ridiculous in my opinion, why not just move them away/stack them properly
02:56:317 (2) - Move the white points bit more away from red point, suggestion below OK.

[Hard]
The stacks.
00:36:674 (4) - v I don't know what are you trying to show here, but I'll try to follow you.

Good luck, could be great to see this ranked without those weird stack things. Also loving the SB, must say again.

ykcarrot wrote:

Hi, requested by HelloSCV \:D/ yay thanks SCV!


[General]
Timing points in the spinner 02:46:674 (1)
02:48:370 - It's unnecessary. You have already 10% green line before. Fixed.
02:48:727 - ^ Done.


[SB]
About ending.
Seems code is technically fine, but there is black line at right side and bottom. You'd better change the images(oldfilm-eff0, oldfilm-eff1, spotlight-eff and white) from small size to 640*480 and fix the codes. 0.0 there's no problem on mine though ._. but if someone else confirm this, I'll change it


[Hard]
Fine!


[Normal]
01:14:174 (3) - I suppose it should be straight like 01:12:745 (1) Hmm... But this is intended and I think I'm fine with the current one.
02:39:531 - Drag end of break time to here Done.
02:49:709 - Remove break time Done.


[Easy]
01:23:817 (1) - Turn off grid snap and stack perfectly. Done.
02:21:674 (2) - Move right by 1 grid OK!
02:59:531 (3) - Too curved Fixed!


Manual stacking works fine. I don't see any problem.
I know this map is gold! Fix those stuffs and call me back.