Alright let's see what I can find.
General:
Why is this still in WIP? i'm guessing that now the diffs are done, you should move it to pending.
re-size the 2 BG's to 1024x768 so that there's no black on the BG
Easy:
00:02:313 (3,1) - are you sure that beginners can reach this in time?
00:09:908 (4) - make this a NC because the instrumental changes like the v-shape slider.
00:17:821 (4) - i think beginners might let go because the hitburst gets in the way. I suggest that you move (4) here so that it'd be easier for beginners.
00:19:746 (2,3) - same as 00:12:612
00:21:029 (1) - the hitburst is still covering this note by the time (3) is hit. suggest that you move this note somewhere else so that it'd be fully visible for beginners.
00:42:205 (4) - ^
00:56:965 (1,2) - remove the claps because they sound weird and replace the clap at the end of (1) for a finish as it matches with the vocals IMO
01:02:099 (1) - add a finish at the end? same reason as above.
01:07:233 (1,2) - same as 00:02:313 and for (1) and add finishes at the ends? ^
01:10:441 (3) - same as 00;21:029
01:12:366 (1) - same as 01:02:099
01:20:067 - i feel that something's missing here. add a 1/1 slider to follow the instrumental because beginners might think that (1) is following this part instead of the next part.
01:22:634 - ^
01:25:200 (4,1) - for (4), same as 00:21:029 and for (1), beginners won't know when this slider will end, ik it's following the drums but this seems too hard for them. suggest that you do something easier for them
Easy^2:
00:03:453 - add a circle here to follow the instrumental or replace (1) for a 1/2 slider to make it easier.
00:06:111 (1) - ^
00:09:149 (1) - ^
00:17:500 (5,6) - i feel that going around in circles looks boring. I suggest that you move it here. IMO this looks fun as the pattern changes from a diamond to a triangle.
00:19:104 (3) - I think you forgot to add a finish at the beginning?
00:23:436 (4,1) - uhh i'm guessing that this is a spacing error as the current DS between these notes is at 0.64 and the default DS is at 0.8, and add a whistle or a finish at the beginning of (1) to match the vocals.
00:25:682 (4,5) - remove the claps because it sounds weird and it ruins the consistency.
00:28:569 (5,6) - ^
00:34:505 (1) - add a finish at the beginning to march the vocals?
00:35:147 (2) - same as 00:25:682 but at the end.
00:38:837 (5) - same as 00:25:682
00:39:479 (7) - ^
00:42:848 (5) - to keep the consistency, add a clap at the end
00:44:773 (1) - i think replacing this for a finish here sounds better as your using the whistles at this part. also if you do this, add whistles at every 2nd and 4th downbeat.
00:49:906 (1) - same as 00:34:505 but reduce the volume of the finish. 50% should be fine.
00:56:965 (1,2,3,4) - this is why i mentioned why the claps shouldnt be at the easy diff. this 1 sounds a lot better while the easy diff sounds weird.
01:02:741 (3) - same as 00:34:505
01:07:874 (2) - ^
01:13:009 (3) - ^
01:17:500 - add a 1/1 slider because players might think that (1) is following this instead of the next part.
01:18:142 (1) - ^
Kirino's Easy^3:
I think this diff needs to use the BG on Easy^4 since he/she is doing a guest diff
00:05:731 (1) - replace this for a circle at 00:06:111 because it feels weird if this slider is here.
00:11:807 - is there a reason why a break is here? remove it because the Hp bar doesnt decrease that much.
00:13:971 (1) - I think that this loop can look nicer.
00:15:254 (3) - this 1 looks fine so make (1) like this slider
00:17:821 (4) - replace this for a 1/1 slider to follow the long pause.
00:23:115 (1) - remove the finish at the end because i think that sounds weird.
00:30:976 (1,2,3,4) - add whistles at the 2nd and 4th downbeat like the previous combo to keep that pattern going. the whistles sound nice but idk why you stopped.
00:34:024 (1) - I suggest that you face it the other way like this so that it'd look less confusing.
00:49:906 (1,3) - the finishes at the beginning looks fine but at the end it sounds weird. Suggest that you remove the finishes at the end.
00:52:473 (1,2,3) - IMO it looks like these sliders look different. correct me if i'm wrong if they're the same.
00:57:607 (1) - add a finish at the beginning to match the vocals?
01:02:741 (2) - ^
01:04:666 (3) - I find it odd that this is a wave slider while the other sliders in this combo are curved sliders. so make this a curved slider so that it'd flow properly.
01:12:366 (1) - same as 00:57:607 but at the end.
01:24:238 (5) - ^
Easy^4:
Switch BGs with Kirino's diff. like i said about the GD.
00:03:453 - add a circle here to follow the instrumental? i feel that something's missing here.
00:06:491 - ^
00:39:318 (7) - ooh i think that you can do better than this. IMO this looks ugly.
00:58:088 (4) - remove this note because it's not following anything. if you say the piano, the end of (3) and the beginning of (5) is following the piano
00:59:372 (8) - ^
This is the best I can do. GL
General:
Why is this still in WIP? i'm guessing that now the diffs are done, you should move it to pending.
re-size the 2 BG's to 1024x768 so that there's no black on the BG
Easy:
00:02:313 (3,1) - are you sure that beginners can reach this in time?
00:09:908 (4) - make this a NC because the instrumental changes like the v-shape slider.
00:17:821 (4) - i think beginners might let go because the hitburst gets in the way. I suggest that you move (4) here so that it'd be easier for beginners.
00:19:746 (2,3) - same as 00:12:612
00:21:029 (1) - the hitburst is still covering this note by the time (3) is hit. suggest that you move this note somewhere else so that it'd be fully visible for beginners.
00:42:205 (4) - ^
00:56:965 (1,2) - remove the claps because they sound weird and replace the clap at the end of (1) for a finish as it matches with the vocals IMO
01:02:099 (1) - add a finish at the end? same reason as above.
01:07:233 (1,2) - same as 00:02:313 and for (1) and add finishes at the ends? ^
01:10:441 (3) - same as 00;21:029
01:12:366 (1) - same as 01:02:099
01:20:067 - i feel that something's missing here. add a 1/1 slider to follow the instrumental because beginners might think that (1) is following this part instead of the next part.
01:22:634 - ^
01:25:200 (4,1) - for (4), same as 00:21:029 and for (1), beginners won't know when this slider will end, ik it's following the drums but this seems too hard for them. suggest that you do something easier for them
Easy^2:
00:03:453 - add a circle here to follow the instrumental or replace (1) for a 1/2 slider to make it easier.
00:06:111 (1) - ^
00:09:149 (1) - ^
00:17:500 (5,6) - i feel that going around in circles looks boring. I suggest that you move it here. IMO this looks fun as the pattern changes from a diamond to a triangle.
00:19:104 (3) - I think you forgot to add a finish at the beginning?
00:23:436 (4,1) - uhh i'm guessing that this is a spacing error as the current DS between these notes is at 0.64 and the default DS is at 0.8, and add a whistle or a finish at the beginning of (1) to match the vocals.
00:25:682 (4,5) - remove the claps because it sounds weird and it ruins the consistency.
00:28:569 (5,6) - ^
00:34:505 (1) - add a finish at the beginning to march the vocals?
00:35:147 (2) - same as 00:25:682 but at the end.
00:38:837 (5) - same as 00:25:682
00:39:479 (7) - ^
00:42:848 (5) - to keep the consistency, add a clap at the end
00:44:773 (1) - i think replacing this for a finish here sounds better as your using the whistles at this part. also if you do this, add whistles at every 2nd and 4th downbeat.
00:49:906 (1) - same as 00:34:505 but reduce the volume of the finish. 50% should be fine.
00:56:965 (1,2,3,4) - this is why i mentioned why the claps shouldnt be at the easy diff. this 1 sounds a lot better while the easy diff sounds weird.
01:02:741 (3) - same as 00:34:505
01:07:874 (2) - ^
01:13:009 (3) - ^
01:17:500 - add a 1/1 slider because players might think that (1) is following this instead of the next part.
01:18:142 (1) - ^
Kirino's Easy^3:
I think this diff needs to use the BG on Easy^4 since he/she is doing a guest diff
00:05:731 (1) - replace this for a circle at 00:06:111 because it feels weird if this slider is here.
00:11:807 - is there a reason why a break is here? remove it because the Hp bar doesnt decrease that much.
00:13:971 (1) - I think that this loop can look nicer.
00:15:254 (3) - this 1 looks fine so make (1) like this slider
00:17:821 (4) - replace this for a 1/1 slider to follow the long pause.
00:23:115 (1) - remove the finish at the end because i think that sounds weird.
00:30:976 (1,2,3,4) - add whistles at the 2nd and 4th downbeat like the previous combo to keep that pattern going. the whistles sound nice but idk why you stopped.
00:34:024 (1) - I suggest that you face it the other way like this so that it'd look less confusing.
00:49:906 (1,3) - the finishes at the beginning looks fine but at the end it sounds weird. Suggest that you remove the finishes at the end.
00:52:473 (1,2,3) - IMO it looks like these sliders look different. correct me if i'm wrong if they're the same.
00:57:607 (1) - add a finish at the beginning to match the vocals?
01:02:741 (2) - ^
01:04:666 (3) - I find it odd that this is a wave slider while the other sliders in this combo are curved sliders. so make this a curved slider so that it'd flow properly.
01:12:366 (1) - same as 00:57:607 but at the end.
01:24:238 (5) - ^
Easy^4:
Switch BGs with Kirino's diff. like i said about the GD.
00:03:453 - add a circle here to follow the instrumental? i feel that something's missing here.
00:06:491 - ^
00:39:318 (7) - ooh i think that you can do better than this. IMO this looks ugly.
00:58:088 (4) - remove this note because it's not following anything. if you say the piano, the end of (3) and the beginning of (5) is following the piano
00:59:372 (8) - ^
This is the best I can do. GL