1. Use consistent combo colours in all diffs?
2. Open letterbox in Taiko Oni to make consistent?
3. Add Kiai in Tenshi's Hard like other diffs?

Leorda wrote:

[Insan3]
00:45:521 (3,4) - Remove whistle and add clap? I like to have it similar to the part at 00:56:188 (3,4) so while it doesn't sound bad it would be inconsistent. I'll keep it as is

So you shouldn't play this Map if you:
- did'nt play the Game (Shame on you! Get out and buy it - seriously)

1. I suggest removing kiai from all diffs (except Tenshi's which doesn't have it). I don't think it's necessary, you have a lovely SB and some strobes already; what's the point of adding more flashing?
2. Dark blue combo colour blends in too well with black parts of the SB like 00:00:410 - maybe increase the lum to about 85-100 or choose a lighter colour you like.
3. Not a big issue but the BG has awful black borders at the top and bottom, it'd be great if you could find a BG without this because the current one doesn't look great.
4. Add black fade out to the end of the SB, it's odd having to see the BG right at the end of the map.

1. Why 80% volume at the start and at 00:53:744 you should keep this consistent with Normal and change it to 40% (and 60% if you follow my suggestion) in these places.

1. 00:11:077 to 00:21:521 - volume 60%?
2. 00:53:744 to 01:04:188 - volume 60%

1. For me this diff didn't follow the pace of the song. Sure, it's hardish and has lots of jumps but I don't think it suits the song.

Shulin wrote:

[Tenshi's Hard]

00:14:299 (3) - Delete? Rhythm sounds better without it imo. Sounds better the way it is to me.
00:14:632 (5,6) - Sorry but these small sliders are awful at this SV, don't play well at all imho. I think they would be better replaced as circles. re-worked this part.
00:15:632 (8) - ^ but not this one. It's fine to me.
00:15:966 (9) - Remove whistle from the slider body. how did that even get there?
00:16:632 (2,3) - Spacing? It's spaced like 1/3 when it's 1/6. Compare the spacing with 00:13:077 (1,2) - I like this spacing, it's easy enough to read IMO. And I don't want them sliders touching each other.
00:17:632 (4) - Same thing about this small slider. I remember this not being the way it is. I wonder if DarkDunskin changed this without my permisson?
00:19:632 (3) - ^ no.
01:04:299 (4) - Delete? Sounds better to me. nope
01:23:632 (2) - Delete and replace with note at 01:23:744 - instead? Follows the rhythm of the song better at this part. hm. nope.

Shulin wrote:

[Insan3]

1. For me this diff didn't follow the pace of the song. Sure, it's hardish and has lots of jumps but I don't think it suits the song.

then you are the first one to think that way. but whatever...can't please everyone

00:05:077 (1,2,3) - Why's the jump so big? It doesn't really fit; just compare it to how you mapped the same music 00:15:744 (2) - 00:31:744 (4,5,6) - etc) jump seems fine as it picks up the volume change
00:05:521 (3) - Add whistle? sure, since you are the 3rd one to want a whistle right here
00:08:410 (1,2) - Keep the same rhythm as 00:09:744 (3,4,5) - or maybe end 00:08:410 (1) - sooner at 00:08:855 - and add some notes after. Right now it just sounds odd, there's no drum beat in the song at 00:08:966 but you have one and then there's the gap that makes no sense when you compare it to 00:05:744 (1,2,3,4) - I changed it to something I think turned out pretty well as it is easy and repeatitive (jk it is better now)
00:32:188 (6) - Add whistle here? errrrr ok
00:41:299 (2,3) - ^ nope
01:07:521 (2,3,4) - Huge jump for no reason? It comes out of nowhere and there's nothing in the music that seems justify the biggest jump in the map. again volume and fits rather well in terms of flow
01:13:077 (5) - New combo? Helps readability of 01:13:521 (7) - imo well it used to be a NC here...but ppl keep constantly bitching about my "readability NCs"....you are awesom for acknowledging something like that

Tenshi-nyan wrote:

00:16:632 (2,3) - Spacing? It's spaced like 1/3 when it's 1/6. Compare the spacing with 00:13:077 (1,2) - I like this spacing, it's easy enough to read IMO. And I don't want them sliders touching each other.

Tenshi-nyan wrote:

01:23:632 (2) - Delete and replace with note at 01:23:744 - instead? Follows the rhythm of the song better at this part. hm. nope.

Shulin wrote:

I'm here ~
Unexpected, but a nice surprise

[Normal]

This now has some unsnapped slider ends that weren't there before here are the locations:
Not only unsnapped sliderend, it seem the whole map got a bit off so I full resnapped everything.

00:36:827 (3) - done
00:40:827 (3) - done
01:00:160 (5) - done
01:19:494 (3) - done
01:23:494 (3) - done

If you can fix these that'd be great.

[Insane]

01:24:188 (1) - If you could change this new combo to the middle blue colour it's easier to read. Fixed for p3n

wmfchris wrote:

[General]
- Considering you're not applying any SB to taiko diff, and the .osb is making scrolling sound corresponding to the SB, just merge .osb into .osu. (and then delete osb and full submit =P)

Sorry I can not change that. If I put the Storyboard into .osu instead of .osb the Storyboardsounds gets twice as loud because the .osb will automatically recreate itself or something like that. That's a Bug and has not been fixed so far. Talk with Lybydose about that if you don't believe it, he has the same Problem on this Map: http://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/40339/start=30

- So Pereira006 doesn't really mapped the GD to be ranked? In this case I'm not really sure whether he should be tagged (e.g. http://osu.ppy.sh/s/21754 where Doomsday made a diff) Okay, untagged pereira006

[Taiko]
00:47:744 - Like what you've done before it's preferred to use a kdk / dkd stuff to fit the flute in the music. Consider dkkdk?
Sorry I don't like dkkdk Combos at all :/

[Hard]
I'll suggest a HP-1 since this is just a hard. (as HP in insane is the same) done
00:06:632 (3) - Just a spacing that you can easily fix. down 1 grid lv4 fixed
00:13:744 (2,3,4,5,6) - sounds a bit akward comparing with the quiet music background (don't have better solution but orz) okay
00:19:632 (3,4,5) - ^ sure

[Normal]
01:00:188 (5) - clap at the beginning like you've done before? done

looks ready, so when they're fixed just call me.