1. Dunskin's Taiko Oni (4.83 stars, 1204 notes)
2. Easy (0.97 stars, 178 notes)
3. Hard (4.86 stars, 439 notes)
4. Roddie's Normal (4.02 stars, 319 notes)

misja056 wrote:

[general]

SPOILER

[attachment=0:bd7f2]ladygagataiko-1024x768.jpg[/attachment:bd7f2]

Please credit this. Thank you

[Easy]

00:16:429 (1) - Delete new combo
00:18:261 (1) - Delete new combo
00:18:719 (2) - New combo
00:19:635 (1) - Delete new combo
00:38:872 (1) - ^
00:43:452 (1) - ^
00:46:200 (1) - ^
00:49:864 (1) - ^
00:52:612 (1) - ^
00:53:986 (2) - New combo
00:54:444 (1) - Delete new combo
00:56:734 (1,2,3) - Anti-jumps not allowed in an easy. Fix those!
01:04:063 (2,3,4) - ^
01:06:353 (1) - Delete new combo
01:27:421 (3) - Unstack this from 01:26:505 (1) -
01:45:284 (1) - Delete new combo
01:48:948 (1) - ^
01:55:360 (1) - ^
01:59:482 (1) - ^
02:01:315 (1) - New combo
02:02:689 (2) - Delete new combo
02:22:841 (1) - New combo
02:23:299 (2) - Delete new combo
02:37:956 (4) - New combo
02:39:788 (1) - Delete new combo
02:59:482 (4) - New combo
03:01:315 (1) - Delete new combo
03:03:605 (3) - New combo
03:05:437 (1) - Delete new combo
03:06:811 (2) - New combo
03:14:597 (2) - New combo
03:18:261 (5) - New combo
03:19:177 (1) - Delete new combo
03:29:711 (2) - New combo
03:32:918 (1) - Overlaps 03:31:086 (1) -
03:59:482 (2) - New combo
04:02:231 (3) - New combo
04:04:063 (1) - Finish.

All fixed

[Hard]

Some new combo's made no sense at all.
You improved really a lot from the first time I "modded" your map ^^

00:40:246 (4) - Delete this note, put this here 00:40:131 (4) -
00:40:360 (5) - Put here an extra note (fits better with voice)
00:43:910 (4) - Delete this note, put this here 00:43:795 (4) -
00:44:024 (5) - Put here an extra note (fits better with voice)
00:47:574 (4) - Ah you know it.
00:51:696 (7) - Delete this note and let the spinner begin there and end it at the original point.
01:15:742 (1) - Delete new combo
01:22:841 (1) - ^
01:48:948 (1,2,3,1) - Same pattern same rules
01:57:650 (5) - Delete this note and let the spinner begin there and end it at the original point.
02:28:795 (1) - Delete New combo
02:32:231 (2) - If you're holding on to a pattern than you should follow it (new combo here)
02:35:208 (1) - Delete new combo
03:12:765 (1) - ^
03:16:658 (1) - ^ Fixed
03:20:093 (1) - ^
03:38:643 (1) - ^
03:49:177 (2) - If you're holding on to a pattern than you should follow it (new combo here)
03:53:070 (1) - Delete new combo

Behonkiss wrote:

Easy:
00:20:093 - Maybe add a hitcircle here to go with the "aaa"? Allright
03:01:773 (2) - A slider this short on Easy seems a little weird. delete this slider add spinner

Hard:
01:55:131 (3) - This being a slider feels off. Maybe change it to 2 hitcircles half a beat apart?no
02:28:795 (1) - Same here. Try ending the slider half a beat earlier. no

Good job overall.

Behonkiss wrote:

Roddie's Normal:
Slider speed feels a little fast for a Normal. What? That is not true really... I find this slider velocity to be well suited.
01:49:406 (2) - Consider putting this on the same horizontal plane as the previous hitcircle. It'll look neater. Very well.
03:30:628 (4) - Consider making this a new combo, and getting rid of the new combo on the slider right after it. Nah.

CDFA wrote:

If you're still looking for guest diffs, you can go ahead and take this map. I'd be happy to re-map any parts or re-work it to fit your map or something. Feel free to take the background too. I low-key prefer it over the current one :> no thanks

Hard:
01:26:276 (1) - Overlapping the HP bar! ;~; Fixed
02:13:681 (5) - Add clap Fixed
02:41:162 - Add note here with clap no
02:41:620 - Add note with finish ^
03:22:841 (3) - Add clap on end of slider Fixed
03:30:628 (4) - Add clap Fixed
04:03:719 (5) - Add whistle on end of slider Fixed

Easy:
00:49:864 (2) - Add clap on end of slider Fixed
01:04:063 (2) - Add clap Fixed
01:05:895 (1) - ^ Fixed
01:21:009 (1) - It's symmetrical, but could there be any way that the two sliderticks could be right on top of eachother? :> Fixed
01:59:482 (2) - Add clap on end of slider Fixed
02:08:643 (1) - Remove clap Fixed
02:09:101 (2) - Add clap Fixed
02:30:628 (2) - Add clap on repeat Fixed
02:30:628 (2) - Remove clap from end Fixed
02:34:292 (1) - Add clap on end Fixed
02:41:162 - Add note here with clap Fixed
02:41:620 - Add note with finish nah
03:51:238 (1) - Add clap on end of slider ^

Pereira006 wrote:

Hello~~

Imo-> my opinion

[General]

Only Easy diff is Inconsistency in Kiai Times at 02:40:704 and another diff's is 02:41:620 pleasse make conscienty kiai times Changed


[Easy]

00:19:635 (2,3) - Remove the whistle at (2) and add at (3) to make conscienty hitsound Fixed
00:38:872 (4) - I can see my owm is bad symentric try the end point need 2 grid right and the red point need 1 dowm to better symentric? IMO No
00:49:864 (2) - again bad symentric arc look this http://puu.sh/yyNu better arc if you wanna No
00:56:734 (1) - I guess you forget add clap Fixed
01:13:681 (1) - too much points why no try same slider at 01:17:345 (1)? IMO No
01:57:650 (1) - I can see my owm is bad symentric and too much points try http://puu.sh/yzth this sliders ? IMO No
02:13:681 (3,1) - Inconsistency spacing if you fix this spacing carefully spacing at 02:15:055 (2,3) Fixed
03:32:918 (1) - the end slider is unspanned http://puu.sh/yyGY Fixed
03:10:933 (1) - i can see my owm bad symentric wut ?
03:23:757 (3) - need add whistle only end slider is fit more IMOFixed

some bad slider symentric,but good gameplay and stuff cool

Leorda wrote:

Hiiii

[General]
* Inconsistent in tags andkiai. You might want to make it consistent Done


[Easy]
00:30:169 (1) - Too soon from spinner for easier diff. It can be hard to reach for beginners
01:53:528 (1) - No large spacing please....
03:03:605 (1) - Same issue as 00:30:169 (1)

All fixed

[Hard]
01:13:223 (2) - This slider is touch the HP Bar
02:15:055 (2) - The tail slider is touch the HP Bar

All fixed

Good luck~

DJPop wrote:

~Easy~
00:18:719 (1) - use only 1 white dot
00:27:879 (1) - add finish
00:36:124 (2) - add finish at the end
00:46:200 (3) - make a pure U slider (don't use red dot) sorry :S
01:21:009 (1) - add finish at start
01:42:994 (1) - ^
01:53:986 (2) - use only 1 white dot
01:55:818 (4) - ^
03:01:315 (1) - move to 56:184
02:56:276 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - move them right to the center of screen
03:31:086 (1) - use only 1 white dot
04:00:399 (1) - remove new combo
04:02:231 (1) - ^

~Hard~
00:29:711 (1) - add finish at start
02:56:276 (1) - ^ (normal one)

~Taiko~
- Unsnapped notes

Lizzehb wrote:

[Easy]
00:15:055 (1,2,1) and 00:30:628 (1,2,3) - These are the exact same note patterns but spaced differently. Umm, change? Because differen slider shapes.
03:28:337 (1) - This HAS to have some kind of hitsound, I can't hear it if it does, so turn it up a little more. (Unrankable btw) %30^^


Also, can you make an insane? Technically you only mapped 1 and 1/2 of a difficulty....no

Xgor wrote:

Xgor's bubble checking time!

[Easy]
00:30:628 (1) - Add new combo here. Unless you have a really good reason for using no new combo after a spinner you should always have a new combo after a spinner.

Better fix that before it gets ranked x.x everything else seems to check out fine though.

Saturos-fangirl wrote:

[Easy]
boring but decent

[Roddie]
nice etnas

[Taiko]
funky but good

[Hard]
no offense but 1. this is definitely Insane 2. the whistles sound random
00:54:902 (3) - line this up horizontally with 1 NO !
01:43:223 (1) - too soon after a spinner I think its good for me
03:29:482 (1) - ^ ^


Contact me back when you are ready to be rebubbled

NotShinta wrote:

For whatever reason, you informed me that you wouldn't like a bubble from SFG, so here you go. This is not a return to modding maps, but I consider these special circumstances with help and the amount of people involved etc. <3

Hard:
- Concerning 'Hard' difficulty title: within the spread, calling this 'Insane' would imply a higher difficulty jump than what's there. I also consider the notes after spinner to be appropriate to the difficulty.
-- However, I agree that some of the whistles can seem a bit random. Hope to speak to Niva, but they do work perfectly in the chorus.
-- I'd stack differently placed notes on slider ends... well, differently, but nobody else seems to have a problem with playability.

Roddie's Normal:
04:05:895 (3) - Maybe raise volume to about 25% here? Still has that ending effect, without the awkward almost-silenceness.

Easy:
-- Lots of inter-combo symmetry errors that could be fixed to stop relentless ugliness. Give a shout if you want them fixed (recommended).
00:48:490 - I'd personally add a note here, to fill an awkward gap.
01:50:322 (1) - Try shortening this to 01:52:154 (Scale by -> ~0.66, if you prefer) and adding notes on the 1/1s following. Goes on a bit too long and awkwardly in my opinion as/is.
-- Good difficulty otherwise!

I'd still like to talk to Niva first, but if you can get another few reliable, supported opinions about the whistles, I'd happily bubble this while I'm here.