Darcsol wrote:

2nnt wrote:

Update

Sorry about the bad quality again, but this is the best I can do with 20 mb limit.

But well, my excuse is the length of the song

Even with the file size reduced, it's still exceeds the total file limit. I appreciate you for trying.

1. 01:18:299 ~ 01:19:237 and two other parts between kiai: why do you stop kiai here? I don't see a reason for it

1. 00:30:487 (1,3) - I would make "beat blanket" here instead of it: http://puu.sh/erdn
2. 00:39:862 (1) - unsymmetrical a little, but it's ok
3. 00:54:393 — note?
4. 02:48:299 (5) - forgot to put finish on the end?
5. 03:23:924 (1) - unsymmetrical a liiiittle again
6. 03:46:893 — add note between sliders?
7. 04:36:112 (2) - remove finish?

1. 00:37:987 (1) - 1 grid left to keep the same distance between notes
2. 00:56:268 (5) - finish?
3. 01:02:830 — I would put a note here
4. 01:35:643 ~ 01:37:987 — hmm... ok, ok
5. 03:26:971 — start break right after the note, not here
6. 04:41:737 (1) - forgot finish

1. 00:42:440 (2) - stack it using zero spacing (disable grid first)
2. 00:52:283 — note?
3. 01:04:002 (1) - remove nc?
4. 01:08:221 (2) - did you want to stack it or not? I don't get it
5. 01:29:315 (7) - the same about stack
6. 01:30:252 (9) - and again
7. 01:45:838 — note?
8. 01:48:416 (12) - stack again
9. 01:49:354 — place one note here and move next 1/4 later
10. 02:22:283 — note!
11. 02:34:002 (1) - remove nc?
12. 02:53:924 (3) - stack it, oh
13. 02:59:315 (8) - ^
14. 03:00:487 (1) - ^
15. 03:24:862 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - make note-only stream instead?
16. 03:33:299 — why did you drag break's end? It makes no sense here
17. 03:56:502 (1) - remove nc?
18. 04:20:643 (4) - stack it
19. 04:22:518 (9) - ^
20. 04:23:221 (2) - I think it's close to scorebar

TicClick wrote:

General

1. 01:18:299 ~ 01:19:237 and two other parts between kiai: why do you stop kiai here? I don't see a reason for it It's for style. I like to break the choruses to parts if possible.

Normal

1. 00:37:987 (1) - 1 grid left to keep the same distance between notes Fixed.
2. 00:56:268 (5) - finish? Added.
3. 01:02:830 — I would put a note here I think it's fine without it.
4. 01:35:643 ~ 01:37:987 — hmm... ok, ok ...
5. 03:26:971 — start break right after the note, not here Added.
6. 04:41:737 (1) - forgot finish Fixed.

Hard

1. 00:42:440 (2) - stack it using zero spacing (disable grid first) Fixed.
2. 00:52:283 — note? I think it's fine.
3. 01:04:002 (1) - remove nc? It's a personal style of mine. I always add a combo before kiai time.
4. 01:08:221 (2) - did you want to stack it or not? I don't get it :\ Meh, it won't be stacked.
5. 01:29:315 (7) - the same about stack
6. 01:30:252 (9) - and again The two above will stay the same.
7. 01:45:838 — note? Added.
8. 01:48:416 (12) - stack again I think it's fine.
9. 01:49:354 — place one note here and move next 1/4 later Added.
10. 02:22:283 — note! Again I think it's fine.
11. 02:34:002 (1) - remove nc? Again, for style.
12. 02:53:924 (3) - stack it, oh
13. 02:59:315 (8) - ^
14. 03:00:487 (1) - ^ I think all of them are fine.
15. 03:24:862 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10) - make note-only stream instead? I think it's fine.
16. 03:33:299 — why did you drag break's end? It makes no sense here Fixed. There's little significance to it anyway.
17. 03:56:502 (1) - remove nc? Again, style.
18. 04:20:643 (4) - stack it I think it's fine.
19. 04:22:518 (9) - ^ Slightly fixed.
20. 04:23:221 (2) - I think it's close to scorebar I agree. Fixed.

Now is the sad thing: bitrate of your mp3 is 320 kbps. If you aim for rank, lower it down to 192 kbps at least (no less than 128), then fix the offset (usual it's something near +30ms; check on test mode), re-set the preview time and do full submit. Thanks lovhin456 for your services.
Good luck with map!

Meh, it won't be stacked.

TicClick wrote:

Even when you turn grid snapping off?

spboxer3 wrote:

[general]

• 
  Settings
  

1. Inconsistency PreviewTime in Backfire's Taiko
2. Inconsistency red line in Backfire's Taiko
3. suggest use same kiai time

All fixed.

[Normal]

• 
  
  Overlaps
  (Some overlaps of notes/sliders in this diff don't look good. Here is a list of beats that overlap eachothou could space them farther apart.)
  

1. 00:43:642 (1,2,3) -

mapping

1. 00:41:767 (7) - NC at this way. because (9) combo It's too much for Normal~
2. 01:53:017 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - Umm... where's clap hitsound? add clap for this part?[IMO]
3. 02:10:829 (6,7,1) - spacing issue~ because...↓
4. 02:11:063 (7) - unsanp slider (end)
5. 03:47:392 (3) - unsanp slider (end)

All fixed.

[Hard]

• 
  Settings
  

1. suggest AR use 8

I think it's fine.

mapping

1. 02:27:704 (4,5,6,1) - spacing issue~ This is on purpose.
2. 04:13:876 (6,8) - could you stack them? It's pretty then now ~
3. 04:20:204 (3,4) - ^

The first suggestion I'll fix but not the second one.

[Backfire's Taiko]

• 
  Settings
  

1. Draining Time:4:37 I remember over 4:30 It's unrankable ;_;

mapping

1. 00:06:112 (1) - spinner end at 00:07:752 - ? 1/4 rhythm It's not fit at this way include It's spinner in Taiko

All fixed by Backfire.

red is unrankable issue. bule is need to discuss. Black is just suggest.

that's all
good luck

WVSagi wrote:

Normal

[Normal]
01:33:329 (6) - add whistle?
01:55:360 (4) - add clap (front).
01:57:235 (2) - add clap.
01:57:704 (3) - add clap (reverse arrow).
02:00:282 (1) - add whistle (front), and add finish (end).
02:30:517 (1) - add finish at the end.
02:33:329 (1) - add clap (end), and remove the whistle at the end of the slider, it's weird.
02:37:548 (7) - remove finish?
03:12:704 (2) - add whistle (front).
03:13:642 (3) - add whistle (front + repeater 2).
03:15:517 (1) - add whistle (front)
03:16:454 (2) - add whistle (front)
03:17:392 (3) - same like 03:13:642 (3).
03:51:610 (4) - remove the whistle.
03:53:017 (1) - add finish (spinner end). Most of them fixed/added.

------------

Hard

[Hard]
01:00:517 (1) - add finish (spinner end).
01:34:267 (1) - same ^
03:04:267 (1) - same again ^ I think all of it is unnecessary.

Jacob wrote:

• Background image must be 800 x 600. Resize it using an image editor. The maximum size for a background image is 1024 x 768. The majority of maps have backgrounds in this size and it looks better.
• Kiai times in Backfire's Taiko are unsnapped.
• Unsnapped timing sections at:
01:04:237
01:18:299
01:19:237
01:34:237
02:34:237
02:48:299
02:49:237
03:04:237
03:56:737
04:10:799
04:11:737
04:26:737 That doesn't matter much. Oh well, fixed.

Asakichi wrote:

[Hard]
There are many over 10 combo
I think half combo interval is best.

for example,
00:17:392 (6) - NC
00:21:142 (5) - NC
00:24:892 (5) - NC
00:28:642 (6) - NC
I think it's fine, mostly because of personal preference. Technically the maximum combos you can have is 16 (I think). There are a few maps that went over the limit.

Ch1ka wrote:

[General]
Nothing found, except BG. There is so many beautiful pictures with Alice and Marisa, why didn't you choose a better one? My diff's BG is only a placeholder, unless if change my mind. I'm open for any suggestions, but I'm a picky person.

[Normal]
00:52:313 - Add a note? A-Aah~ Added.
01:18:798 (1) - Remove NC It's my mapping style; I tend to include a NC right before a kiai time.

[Hard]
01:04:032 (1) - Remove NC
01:16:454 (3) - Stack with 01:15:048? Fixed.
01:18:798 (1) - Remove NC
02:34:032 (1) - ^
02:49:032 (1) - ^
03:56:532 (1) - ^
04:11:532 (1) - ^ Again all of this is just my personal mapping style. If enough people opposes them, I might remove it.

Agkaemon wrote:

{Overall}
Check offset. Not sure about it. BPM is correct though. I'm not good at timing. Hopefully other modders can check it.

[Normal]
HS size +1 (bigger)? I think it's fine.
00:37:548 (5) - nc
00:38:017 (1) - remove nc
00:38:485 (2) - nc I think it's fine.

[Hard]
01:36:775 - this empty space is empty, not even part of the break. D: Problem? Either way, it does no harm other than delaying the break to hit that specific beat.
02:34:032 (1) - Remove new combo? Like I said to the other modder, It's a mapping style of mine. I tend to include a NC right before a kiai time.
02:38:251 - Insert beat? I think it's fine.
03:05:673 - Timing section, 5% soft? I think it's fine. I might do additional sound adjustments later on.
03:11:767 - Timing section if previous applied, back to previous settings.
03:24:892 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13) - Shape these like an U sides left right and bottom. Ask me via PM if you don't understand what I mean. I understand what you meant, but I will have to reject it. My mapping style is against something like that. I might make adjustments later on.
01:04:032 (1) - Remove nc? Once again, personal preference.
01:04:735 (2,5) - Make more clap patterns with these 2nd and 4th beats of a measure with a clap where you don't do whistles? Forgot to add them. Fixed.
02:32:392 - Timing section 5% soft?... then recover previous vol. Again I think it's fine.

Ch1ka wrote:

Sure. For example:

1

2

3

Saten wrote:

Did you finish polishing Hard? It's still WIP it says The Hard diff is now playable but currently it needs hitsounds.

[Normal]
00:30:069 (1) - Finish on end
00:34:288 (1) - whistle on end
00:44:600 (6) - ^ All added.
01:18:819 (1) - why New Combo? should really be avoided unless it's longer than a 1/1 beat I think it's fine.
01:45:069 (1,1) - You can remove that one as well. But since the next object is 1/1 away from the previous object, this looks okay It will stay.
01:53:038 (1) - finish on start Added.
02:22:803 (1) - 1 grid right I have made a different adjustment instead.
02:34:756 (2) - clap
02:48:350 (5) - clap on end Both added.
03:26:788 (1) - this NC is kinda unnecessary I think it's fine.

giO- wrote:

Hello, from #modreqs for Mod for Mod with Renard - Smoke Tower http://osu.ppy.sh/s/38149


General

Resized BG to 1024x768

BG

Added.


Normal

00:10:850 (5) - stack this better
00:19:756 - add clap
00:24:444 - ^
00:25:381 (4) - ^
01:11:319 (6) - ^
01:59:131 (4) - ^
02:00:069 - ^
02:24:444 (1) - ^ All added/fixed.

Hard

00:22:686 (10) - i would delete this The slider is replaced by a circle.
00:29:834 (10) - this one finish on blue tick, remove 1 repeat http://puu.sh/14QED I think it's fine.
01:23:741 (3) - stack this better
01:25:616 (7) - ^ Both fixed.
01:34:053 (11) - replace with 1 beat I think it's fine.
02:01:944 (3) - stack better
02:06:631 (6) - ^
02:37:803 (9) - ^
02:52:569 - clap
04:16:944 (4) - ^ All added.
04:41:670 (6) - delete? I think it's fine.

Good luck!

EveOfTheNight wrote:

Hi~ Saw your request on #modreqs
Normal
Add Whistle Noise To All Of The Following:
00:48:819
00:56:319
01:11:319
01:17:413
02:09:444
02:13:194
02:18:350
02:37:569
03:03:819
04:00:069
04:00:303
04:09:444
04:09:678 This is the only hitsound I'll add.
04:22:803 - for this one also put a "finish" sound

Darcsol wrote:

EveOfTheNight wrote:

Hi~ Saw your request on #modreqs
Normal
Add Whistle Noise To All Of The Following:
00:48:819
00:56:319
01:11:319
01:17:413
02:09:444
02:13:194
02:18:350
02:37:569
03:03:819
04:00:069
04:00:303
04:09:444
04:09:678 This is the only hitsound I'll add.
04:22:803 - for this one also put a "finish" sound

Most of your suggestions are merely personal preference, as the hitsounds you suggested barely had any significance.