Rule Breaker is a poorly considered suggestion and suggesting it implies that you don't care about standards; nor do you seem to respect the foundations of this game. I think that all guidelines should be strict and should be followed in a similar fashion to rules. That way, there is less room for mappers to do ridiculous things. Rules should be breakable under very rare circumstances, or when the rules aren't clear enough. VBR MP3s are an example of this, because the current rules imply that they should never peak at above 192KB/s. This is false. They are allowed to peak above this, but the rule for audio quality implies otherwise.
What I detest (I really do) is when mappers try to get around the rules and guidelines or to attempt to justify something because the rules and guidelines give them wiggle room. NatsumeRin's horrible sliders are the latest example of this. If nothing else, I think that there should be stricter guidelines in place and that mappers should be encouraged to stick to the guidelines, unless they have an extremely compelling reason to do otherwise.
Maps have became more and more ridiculous and they are allowed solely because they don't break the current rules (or worse, the rule breaking is considered as negligible). I think that it's time for standards to be tightened, because for all of the experienced people who are used to the senseless characteristics of many maps, there are perhaps a hundred times as many newer players who would be confused by messy patterns and sliders. This is not what we want for a game that's now very popular.