Garven wrote:

Modding because it's supercell <3

[SB]
3.png and 3-1.png: I guess you're not H-boy anymore, hehe. it might be -w-

[All difficulties]
01:26:150 (1) - Maybe have this as the soft soundset so you don't get that strong snare pop at the end? k

[Easy]
00:11:786 (2,3) - I don't recommend having stacks under sliders for easy difficulties. It's hard to discern the rhythm. yep
00:44:332 (3,1) - I dunno about using this rhythm for a stack after having so many other stacks at a different rhythm. Might be better doing multiple rhythms with stacks in a Normal rather than an Easy.

[Normal]
01:14:150 (4) - That little bump intentional? Looks kind of weird.

「Hard]
00:30:150 - with the rhythms you have set up here, I was expecting a note here. yea
00:39:059 - Maybe add a note here? nah
01:01:968 (4) - I had a hard time seeing this note. The thin approach circle combined with the dark purple color made it a little difficult to see it. Maybe change it to the light purple combo color? √

[PoLKmix]
00:13:059 (1) - Surprised at no finish on this √
00:55:059 - Aaah, I keep wanting a note here, haha. nah~

Good stuff!

justnobody wrote:

hi T*12.
here's my mod.

[Easy]
should be fine.

[Normal]
00:18:877 (1) - make it not stacked by 00:18:513 (4). maybe it's the fault of my picky eye.√

[Hard]
00:15:059 (1,2,3) - make them place more neatly?
01:01:968 (4) - this trap is totally insane.

[PoLKmix]
00:23:423 (x) - add a note? nah
00:28:695 (5,6) - looks strange...

just a bunch of lazy suggestions and a star.

heatwave95 wrote:

[General]
Some of your patterns make people dizzy D:
better fixed you patterns ~

[Easy]
00:11:786 (2,3) - for easy don't put circle under the slider , people hard to see nah...
00:36:332 (1,2) - ^
00:37:786 (3,4) - ^

[Normal]
00:22:150 (1) - 2 grid down ? k
00:55:604 (N) - put circles ?


[Hard]
00:45:059 (2) - spacing D: ? nah~

[PolKmix]

00:14:513 (1) - Remove new combo nah..
00:28:695 (5,6) - Here don't make it near , try make it jump sure fun :3

[Overall]
Maybe need some mods ~

starred ~ *

CXu wrote:

Sorry for late mod~~

[Easy]
00:18:877 (1) - 00:26:877 (4) I don't like the low volume of the hitsounds here, but meh idk >.<
00:59:241 (5) - I think this slider should start at 00:59:604

[Normal]
I find this difficulty easier to follow than [Easy] since it's mostly a constant 1/1... Anyways, nothing wrong with this diff >.<

[Hard]
00:30:150 - Add note? yep~
00:56:695 - I was expecting a speedup to 1.25x here >.< em...it would be like to be a big project...no change=w=
01:02:695 (1,2) - This is weird

[PoLKmix]
This is fine too

Nice, Star~~

Odaril wrote:

Please reply to this mod sayin what you didn't fix (and what you did) and why.
Also, if you have any question, feel free to ask me in-game

General
Maybe add "H-Boy" to the tags, since it is your previous name ? sure
I have an offset of 1,431. Remember to resnap the kiai sections. sure

Easy
00:05:786 (1) - I don't think you should silence beats like that - it made that slider rather confusing to play. k
01:20:332 (4) - Same. Also, wouldn't it be better to make a crescendo with the ticks ?
01:26:150 (1) - On the same range of ideas, a decrescendo here would be nice.

Normal
You didn't use in the beginning the same sound samples as in the other diffs you made.
00:42:521 (2,3) - A crescendo here would sound really nice.
01:19:976 (4,1,1) - Make a crescendo until the second beat of (1) ?

Hard
00:17:604 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Crescendo ?
01:20:877 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2) - ... crescendo ? ;_;

PoLKmix
Well. Is fine...


I know I'm annoying with the crescendos but hitsounds are very important in a map, and you missed possibly awesome hitsounds.
I enjoyed playing the Hard a lot.

James2250 wrote:

-The hitsounds sound pretty quiet compared to the song in most places if you want to turn some of them up slightly
-2 seconds seems slightly longer than is needed for the audio lead-in in my opinion change to 1s
-The HP bar seems lower down than it is meant to be, or is that just me?
-Why have Hard with a lower SV than Normal? its my awkwardness .., but i dont want to change it.

Easy: raise volume by 10%
You could avoid some small overlaps like 00:52:703 (4,5) and 01:12:703 (1,2) to look slightly neater in general k

Normal: raise the kiai time'svolume by 10%
00:16:703 (2,2) - same overlap comment k
00:42:522 (2,3) - ^ ^

Hard:
00:34:521 (5) - try and avoid the hidden repeat here by the previous hitburst k
00:43:249 (4,1) - minor things like this you could clean up more ^
01:21:976 (5,1) - same repeat comment nah

PoLKmix:
-The OD is much lower than Hard on this difficulty if you can try and fix that OD+1
00:14:158 (1) - remove new combo? k
00:28:703 (5,6) - odd spacing change a design by lks...
00:34:885 (1,2) - overlaps like these could look alot nicer ^
00:39:976 (4,6) - ^ ^
01:10:340 (7,1) - spacing k

Some parts could look more organized while playing but not bad overall
Deserves a star~

KuraiPettan wrote:

Easy
- Approach rate +1 k
00:43:611 (2) - I think this clap is unnecessary and it sounds weird :/ ^
00:51:612 (2) - Add clap ? ^
00:59:249 (5) - Add whistle onto the beginning and onto the end ^ feel good
01:26:158 (1) - Start it 3/4 earlier, It will fit the song more. ^

Normal
01:24:885 (2) - I think you should use the proper spacing here, (2) is too far from (1). It's fine like this but I will prefer with the appropriate spacing. k
01:25:885 - Add a spinner here as in "Easy" and "PoLKmix" ? nah

Hard
01:25:885 - Add a spinner here as in "Easy" "PoLKmix" ? nah

That's all I can find, It's a nice map with a nice flow. Hope It will be ranked soon.
*star*

Colin Hou wrote:

[General]:

1. missing skin elements: default-comma.png, default-dot.png, default-percent.png, default-x.png 已经忘了当时用的啥字体了-A-找个类似的...
2. 3.jpg, 3-1.jpg 有明显瑕疵...
3. 结尾的spinner有/没有统一一下

这个无法统一了。。

星星很久前就交掉了 orz

Gonzvlo wrote:

Hi,

Sometimes the jumps/anti-jumps felt a bit weird but I didn't have much trouble with most of them while playing. Although, there are some spacing issues that you should fix.

[General]

1. Skin: The files "Spinner-osu", "Spinner-spin" and "Spinner-clear" are missing, make sure to add them and full submit. (If you don't want make custom ones, use the file included in the template skin)

[PoLKmix]

1. 00:27:268 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - This pattern uses 3 different spacing values, that's definitely not a good idea. Try something a bit more consistent, like this.
2. 00:37:813 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - Same here, (4) and (1) are way too close. Let me suggest something like this

That's all, let me know when you're ready!