Nah, make that about 60% on the second part.LadySuburu wrote:
At this point I'm about 95% sure Two is town, and 75% sure one of the people attacking him is mafia.
Triple post: Attacking is defined loosely and may not be the right word. I'd include bmin11, Rolled, and Mash in the list of people.LadySuburu wrote:
At this point I'm about 95% sure Two is town, and 75% sure one of the people attacking him is mafia.
that really doesn't make sense, mainly what I read is them asking for an explanation so they weren't blindly following Two which is more than reasonable. "trust me cause I say so" isn't exactly the most convincing argument everLadySuburu wrote:
Triple post: Attacking is defined loosely and may not be the right word. I'd include bmin11, Rolled, and Mash in the list of people.LadySuburu wrote:
At this point I'm about 95% sure Two is town, and 75% sure one of the people attacking him is mafia.
FUN FACT: Assuming 4 mafia, there's a 55% chance at least 1 of 3 randomly selected players are mafia.LadySuburu wrote:
60% chance one of bmin11, Rolled, and Mash is mafia
Like I said, maybe attacking isn't the right word.Chris wrote:
that really doesn't make sense, mainly what I read is them asking for an explanation so they weren't blindly following Two which is more than reasonable. "trust me cause I say so" isn't exactly the most convincing argument ever
I fail to see how they are doing anything but pointing out that Two has explained nothing in this supposed master plan
also how can you even claim Mashley is doing anything when it's Two asking him to use his hider ability on him, which could potentially end in his death
It's up to Mashley in the end but personally I don't see why not when you explain it like that. If he dies and you don't, you're getting lynched D2 anyways.Two wrote:
It's simple, just have mashley formally agree to hide behind me tonight. If he's telling the truth then I won't die. If I die without taking him with me, he's mafia. If neither of us die, I'm town. Because of that, if he rejects this he's mafia.
Also, if you are opposed to such a pro-town idea, you are mafia as well. See how fun this is?
it doesn't necessarily mean that both of us are town, just means that I'm town since he supposedly didn't die from hiding behind meLybydose wrote:
Ok so here are the possibilities if Mashley agrees to hide behind Two:
Neither dies: This means either both are town OR both are mafia. Likely the former.
In most games, Hiding takes priority over everything except Copying (this includes bussing and blocking). Furthermore, strongman can't directly target a Hider since it trumps even that.Wojjan wrote:
Still though this strategy isn't airtight. He's not counting a busdriver or a roleblocker or a strongman to take them both down regardless of Two's apparent nightkill immunity(?) Heck if Lilac and pieguy got fancy there might be an interceptor around.
Hiding takes priority over busdriving. Hiders cannot be roleblocked, but bus drivers can.Wojjan wrote:
mod: confirm please.
also votecount?Votecount:
Also how come if Mashley hides behind two, two won't die?Two wrote:
It's simple, just have mashley formally agree to hide behind me tonight. If he's telling the truth then I won't die. If I die without
17 hours ago.Gabi wrote:
Posting here before i go to sleep.
That said, i'm going to unvote. Will continue when i wake up tomorrow
Usually I wouldn't either, except the only thing that's happened so far is Two and Mashley's N1 plan.LadySuburu wrote:
I don't really like the Lynch all Lurkers policy style play, but I've got nothing better right now and I've started to get a little annoyed by lurkers over the past few games.
Maybe confirmed was too strong of a word, but come D2 he should be.Salvage wrote:
How's Two confirmed town now? Wasn't his plan to make him so? .. Oh god Two how i envy you and your persuasion powers , people already trusting him already on d1, cool.
omg whyyyyyWojjan wrote:
I'm gonna have Two shout at you a lot until you do.
KRZY wrote:
anyone willing to roleclaim? make this interesting please
I don't see much difference between these quotes. They were both asking for a role claim if we go to the basis. Ofcourse, Two shows better intention by saying "just one person please", but you can't entirely say KRZY's would be anti-town move as you guys were pressuring the fuck out of us as if we were students who could not finish their homework. Or do you guys seriously need more posts saying "Ya I agree" with a wall of texts? Or do you think you can force a good idea by wagging the person's neck like you guys did? (and calling that as a pro-town actions as well). I think you guys are overreacting against lurkers for D1 while there are nothing but few to talk about.Two wrote:
Anyone want to claim aux anyway? Just one person please.
are you even reading the thread? Two is not actually confirmed town right now, but will either be confirmed mafia or town after the first night. Since it would be utterly stupid for a mafia to do such a gambit that would confirm him as mafia like that, chances are very high that he is town.Salvage wrote:
How's Two confirmed town now? Wasn't his plan to make him so? .. Oh god Two how i envy you and your persuasion powers , people already trusting him already on d1, cool.
Lybydose wrote:
are you even reading the thread? Two is not actually confirmed town right now, but will either be confirmed mafia or town after the first night. Since it would be utterly stupid for a mafia to do such a gambit that would confirm him as mafia like that, chances are very high that he is town.Salvage wrote:
How's Two confirmed town now? Wasn't his plan to make him so? .. Oh god Two how i envy you and your persuasion powers , people already trusting him already on d1, cool.
Well no because they could technically both be mafia. Unless the mod pops in to say "yo sup Two is town" you don't take that for granted.Lybydose wrote:
So basically anyone attacking or questioning Two right now is not acting in the town's best interests.
I don't want to. If Two is protown right now, and KRZY is showing signs of him being anti-town my vote will have to go for him.Wojjan wrote:
hi gabi do a trick
come on boy do a trick
What exactly do you expect me to do except for voting?Chris wrote:
unvote, Vote Gabi
posts again and still doesn't even bother to do anything but vote, wow
more than thisGabi wrote:
What exactly do you expect me to do except for voting?
hipost your thoughts/opinions on stuff, every post you've made has just been to vote or unvote, have you even read the thread?
Vote : Raging Bull
THEN
Posting here before i go to sleep.
That said, i'm going to unvote. Will continue when i wake up tomorrow
THEN
I don't want to. If Two is protown right now, and KRZY is showing signs of him being anti-town my vote will have to go for him.
Vote : KRZY
Oh come on bandwagon harder.Gabi wrote:
I don't want to. If Two is protown right now, and KRZY is showing signs of him being anti-town my vote will have to go for him.
Vote : KRZY
Town doesn't win by being passive.Gabi wrote:
Ah well, i have to admit this is my first mafia game, i didn't think people would be so agressive on the first day. But at the moment i dont really have anything to add and my vote stays where it is. Allthough i would like to see KRZY defend himself.
mafia logic: "oh shit they're bandwagoning one of our members quick bandwagon someone else they'll never know"Salvage wrote:
why's that i'd like to hear smart two.
it also works the other way, "oh look a bandwagon is forming let's hop on it"Lybydose wrote:
mafia logic: "oh shit they're bandwagoning one of our members quick bandwagon someone else they'll never know"
Completely unrelated to the game:Rantai wrote:
*useless post*
Also: Users browsing this forum: Rantai and 22 guests
Oh come on guys. I might as well point everyone who doesn't post as lurkers