beatmap discussions


permalink

permalink

permalink

owo

permalink

enlo, I do have some questions for the 2nd kiai chord thing...
01:35:332 (95332|3,95332|1,95332|0,95494|0,95494|2,95494|1,95656|2,95656|3,95656|0,95818|3,95818|1,95818|2,95980|1,95980|3,95980|0,96142|1,96142|2,96304|3,96304|0) - and 01:45:710 (105710|3,105710|2,105710|0,105872|2,105872|1,106034|3,106034|1,106034|0,106196|2,106196|1,106359|3,106359|2,106359|0,106521|1,106521|0,106683|3,106683|2) - have similar/the same vocal expression but the 1st one aim on chord feeling while the 2nd one aim only for the generic jump thingy... dunno if im right or not but maybe u need also to emphasize the 2nd part to chords also to be consistent? seems the 2nd one feels underwhelming

permalink

permalink

permalink

permalink

permalink

ill definitely watch this (hope I wont forgor)

permalink

overall clean

permalink

MODS:

 

Aishiteru(HARD ig)

00:08:098

00:08:098 - 00:13:098 - I do kind of think the emphasis on these hats are kinda unnecessary as it would look inconsistent with 00:05:806 - 00:09:140 - ... suggest to reduce

00:49:973

00:49:973 (49973|3,49973|2,50112|1,50112|0,50251|3,50251|2,50390|1,50390|0,50529|2,50529|3,50668|1) - not sure with this JT here since its kind of has huge gap with normal diff, why not reduce it to JS?
something like this will do

01:16:848

01:16:848 (76848|3) - kind of nitpick, move to col2? its sandwiched with 01:15:598 (75598|3,77056|3) - 2 LNs

NORMAL

00:25:806

00:25:806 - 00:29:348 - 00:32:473 - 00:39:140 - 00:41:015 - why not add notes here? to fill the gap in top diff

EASY

00:04:140

00:04:140 (4140|3) - this seems out of place since theres no LN in most intro parts, why not make this consistent to other parts 00:02:473 (2473|2,2681|1,2890|3,3098|0) - as im pretty sure theres some auditable sound 00:04:348 -

00:36:431

00:36:431 - add note?

01:17:473

01:17:473 - to 01:22:577 - EZ vs NM diff: normal represents vocal LNs with notes on piano sound while easy with only 2/1 and 1/1 LN which is kind of have huge gap... so why not fill it with some note in vocal in it?

so that somehow it will get near the gap for NM diff.

GENERAL THINGY

general

GENERAL: (GOOD)

AUDIO AND TIMING:


  • *offset( good too )

HS(GOOD)

BG:(GOOD)

  • 1080p

HP/OD(GOOD)

TAGS:

  • remove tv size as its already in title

META SOURCE:

permalink

overall chart seems tobe improve compare to what ive seen in my first glance maybe thanks to @ly_tou's mods... gl with the set

permalink

MODS:

 

00:27:542

00:27:542 - why this suddenly 1-note in here while the other parts emphasize them as doubles? would suggest todo the same.

00:54:592

00:54:592 - 00:55:392 - you could emphasize this cybol by adding 1-note. while 00:56:192 - is optional since the dense rolls starts there

01:04:892

01:04:892 - add 1-note like what u did 01:05:292 - or remove note 01:05:292 -

01:06:592

01:06:592 (66592|1,66642|0,66692|1,66742|0) - kind of heavy in left-hand due to shields, can do this or rearrange ur ownn based on ur prefered

01:35:367

01:35:367 (95367|3) - the LN lenght for this is inconsistent with the rest 01:35:292 (95292|0,95304|1,95317|2,95342|5,95354|4) - , this should be end in 01:35:417 -

03:00:804

03:00:804 (180804|1,180831|0) - maybe move this somewhere as this is the only part that has dense LNs compare to other parts like 02:59:036 (179036|1,179116|1) - maybe like or u can come up ur own

03:51:426

03:51:426 - add 1-LN in here, same length as 03:51:492 (231492|4) - on col4 so it wont feel empty

same case with 04:48:426 - 04:49:026 - 04:49:626 -

Generaal Thingy:

 

general

GENERAL(OK)

  • Artist: 九立つ気
  • Kyutatsuki
  • Title: FINΛL PHΛSE
  • Romanised: Final Phase
  • Source: BOSSFGHT(not added)
    note: not sure for the souce I provide but its mentioned as album for this song

Audio & Timing(OK)

  • offset: I dont feel with the delay of notes(ig)

HS(OK)

  • 1-HS min for RC

BG

  • dimension of 2000 x 1067 the length part seems low for the 1080p side

OD/HP (OK)

  • HP/OD = 8.2/7.8 seems fair

TAGS

  • ln dance edm etherflux: bossfight etherflux electronic experimental artcore new zealand sv boss

suggest to remove ":" in etherflux part since I dont kinda think its necessary to add it

META SOURCE:

  • given in map desc. page
permalink

check aimod (ctrl+shift+a) as theres seems to have unsnapped kiai's

permalink

maomao <3

permalink

PART 2:

 

NM

00:14:946

00:14:946 - kinda smol probs, col1 looks soo empty here ( 4th 1/1 miss ) that its kinda unbalance, suggest to move atleast 1 note in there.. its either 00:15:795 (15795|1) - or 00:16:644 (16644|1) - or even 00:16:078 (16078|2) -
same for 00:16:078 - for col4

00:35:607

00:35:607 (35607|5,36173|4) - make this somehow alternate of 00:33:342 (33342|2,33908|1) - by using ctrl + g like what u did in first part 00:24:286 (24286|2,24852|1,26550|4,27116|5) -

00:48:059

00:48:059 (48059|2,48059|1) - HD diff uses only 1-note while this one is double and kinda in low kick one. instead of that, why not double this 00:47:210 - and 1-note on 00:48:059 - for the vocal expression since it matches 00:47:493 (47493|0,47493|2,47776|3,47776|6,48342|5,48342|4) -

01:39:003
01:51:456

01:51:456 - same explanation as 2272370#4666962

02:19:757
02:28:814

02:28:814 (148814|3,148956|4,149097|5) - smol suggestion: make this somehow same as 1st part but kinda blocks the LN 02:29:097 (149097|1,149380|2) - .. can rearrange to:

for the good flow

EZ

00:12:399

00:12:399 - 00:12:965 - 00:13:531 - 00:14:097 - I dunno if my understanding for RC is right but u can somehow can add note for the change of rhythm since the bpm is very low anyway and also for filling the gap for NM diff. Tho this is pretty much optional since this one is fine ig. tho if accepted, can apply 00:21:173 - section

tho this is very optional so feel free to reject

00:55:135

nothing much to see here

permalink

Part 1:

 

IN

00:13:956

00:13:956 - missing note here for hat.

00:24:993

00:24:993 - has hithat same as 00:25:559 - tho has less one

00:27:540

00:27:540 - 00:27:824 - pretty much optional but theres hats there to add there.
same for 00:36:597 - 00:36:880 -

00:50:324

00:50:324 - optional too to add a note here, a kick

01:19:899

01:19:899 - 01:22:163 - theres hat in here

02:16:361

02:16:361 - 02:25:418 - pretty sure this one similar to 02:14:097 - . so add note?

 

HD

00:22:446

00:22:446 - can add note like u did 00:13:390 - since its somehow similar part

00:25:701

00:25:701 (25701|4) - smol suggestion for this to express the vocal like what the IN did... cut this till 00:26:267 - and add another LN at same position till 00:26:691 - so the shield can still keep. heres the sample:
.

if applied, do also to the alternate ones 00:34:757 (34757|2) - and the 2nd part

00:40:559

00:40:559 (40559|6,40701|0) - somehow the kicks are louder here, can emphasize to doubles

00:48:201

00:48:201 - add note for hat?

01:09:569

01:09:569 (69569|2) - theres no instru or vocal to represent this note. even the IN and EX doesnt have note too, suggest to remove

01:43:956
01:51:597

01:51:597 - hat, same as 1st kiai I mention

 

note: will continue each diff everyday

PS:

permalink

permalink

permalink

nano :KeqingHeart_Milkman:

permalink

I dont have any cent in overall chart the svs are pretty much handle-able(playable) but I have a very concern in only one section... and its in 03:16:098 - to 03:30:160 -

the veeery long a** anchor at col1 feels very uncomfy to me (very much my skill issue and I want to point this) as I have to press an estimate of 15sec-ish long train tracks of notes in my left-hand as thats the only part of losing my accuracy(if u see my plays during qualify rankings). losing acc at SVs are a thing but in this, this is too much.

as I observe in this part there seem to be a 4 section of same sound (around 03:16:098 - to 03:19:730 - | 03:19:848 - to 03:23:480 - |03:23:598 - to 03:27:230 - | 03:27:348 - to 03:30:160 - ). Like can u somehow divide those into 2 (03:16:098 - to 03:23:480 - to left hand and 03:23:598 - to 03:30:160 - to right hand stack/anchor) so that it can have at least a variation and also can spare players left hand.

permalink

when I see hoyo-mix, I hype

permalink

balls

permalink

hyep

permalink

Randome mod throw(top diff only)

 

00:00:660

00:00:660 (660|3) - better to extend this to 00:00:967 - as it doesnt represent anything to make a grace(also look cringy)

00:01:890

00:01:890 (1890|0) - same case ^

00:03:890

00:03:890 (3890|1) - better move to col1 coz it sandwitches with the LNs (looks uncomfy to play)

00:17:506

00:17:506 - 00:17:583 - these 2 worth adding double than 00:17:429 - tho I only suggest to double 00:17:583 - and remove 1 00:17:429 -

00:17:736

00:17:736 - can add 1 note

00:23:890

00:23:890 - this much better

00:33:736
00:38:967

00:38:967 (38967|3,39121|3,39275|3,39736|3) - I dont even kno what to feel bout this, can u atleast move 1 or 2 of these 00:38:967 (38967|3,39121|3,39736|3) - note somewhere?

00:39:890

00:39:890 (39890|0) - col3 for more comfy

00:43:121
00:43:890
00:47:583

00:47:583 (47583|0,47736|2,47890|1,48044|3,48198|0,48352|2,48506|1,48660|0) - can u somehow balance these LNs? too biased to left

00:58:967

00:58:967 - whats the reason for triple? sound kick only

01:30:044

01:30:044 (90044|0,90121|1,90198|0,90352|1,90429|0) - nice OH trill but looks disgusting, just rearrange whatever u like

general

add note:00:08:044 - to 00:16:660 - : 01:14:506 - to 01:23:121 - --> I somehow feel conflict with these parts as I dunno what to suggest... 00:08:352 (8352|0,8352|1,8967|3,8967|2,9583|3,9583|2) - these 1/2 LNs feels like it doesnt fit to be that long when comparing 00:08:044 (8044|2,8044|3) - coz this start 1/2 represent guitar while the others are just cybols. Ask opinions for this one

 

FREE MOD

permalink

NOTE:

The current one feels fine imo since I tend to make solo guitar abit special one. But considering the diff spike thingy, I might buff the kiais to get closer to the gap for solo guitar and heres my ideal solution:

  • 1st Kiai - 1/1 JS(jumpstreams)[current] --> 1/2 JS[buffed ver.] to make more dense

  • 2nd Kiai - 1/2 JS[current] --> HS(handstreams)[buffed ver.]

  • 3rd Kiai - HS[current] --> Chordstreams[buffed ver.] ** I notice that there are some kicks in blue lines and just bg rolls in white lines like 03:19:922 - 03:20:094 - so I can somehow make doubles in some blue line and single note in white line.

Gonna ask for more opinions for this as I get mods soon.

permalink

permalink

permalink

source: https://vndb.org/v7660#main (note: dont click if ur under 18)

tags ig:

japanese j rock pop jpop j-pop jrock j-rock ヴィーナスブラッド-アビス- venus blood abyss visual novel vn video game vg eroge ゆき chronicle ~cat side~ fa featured artist mpg mg quest mappers' guild 伊吹ユキヒロ ibuki yukihiro dualtail opening OP theme song ~cat side~ joof12

permalink

permalink

another self update: reducing overextend LN releases ( mostly 1 1/4 long LNs ) in some exaggerated parts but... there are some parts that leave as it is and these are the list:

permalink

self update for this diff:

buffin these section 00:06:126 - 00:16:496 - |00:18:348 - 00:25:941 - | 00:47:978 - 00:50:570 - | 00:50:756 - 01:01:682 - | 01:26:496 - 01:29:089 - since the former one is very identical to HD diff

permalink

2212131#4469382

same case here for 00:04:089 (4089|1,4274|2,4459|3,4645|0,4830|1,5015|3) -

Avoid using more than 5 consecutive 1/2 notes.
tho I dunno if I see this case in some rank map but will still debate if this is okay or make an aternate pattern

permalink

00:17:608 (17608|0,17700|1,17793|3,17885|2,17978|0) -
00:23:533 (23533|0,23626|1,23719|3,23811|2,23904|0) -
00:34:645 (34645|3,34645|2,34737|1,34830|2,34922|3,35015|0) -
01:20:200 (80200|3,80293|2,80385|0,80478|1,80570|2) -
this thing violates RC: Avoid using more than 5 consecutive 1/4 notes. given the default BPM is 180
but there some cases that this this is allowed in some rank maps if theyre below 180bpm. postin it here for debete if its aight to keep this or make an altenate pattern

permalink

hyep

permalink

update: change mp3 file to ogg and add volume by using audacity and this is the result:

dunno if this is gud enough but postin here

permalink

meta link: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O9S2bWkaiMI

tags:
tokidoki bosotto russia-go de dereru tonari no alya-san Аля иногда кокетничает со мной по-русски alya sometimes hides her feelings in russian roshidere ロシデレ alisa mikhailovna kujou アリサ・ミハイロヴナ・九条 Алиса Михайловна Куджо Кудзё 久世政近 anime アニメ sunsunsun Sun Sansan 燦々 im i'm i am sorry for being too cute haniwa ハニワ episode 2 ed2 shito ed ending ep2 japanese pop jpop j-pop mikhaylovna honeyworks capi cover joof12

permalink

permalink

posted feedback and mod thru o!m mapping & modding hub dm

permalink

Marking for mod as I promise thru o!m mamping and monding dm

permalink

Mod post thru pm in DM coz I dont want more kudosu

 

 

00:02:804

00:02:804 - to 00:06:157 - check out also for the bells in IN diff

feedback and suggestions in mania owner pm

permalink

by hyping this... I will get firefly for sure ( coz im guarantee :sob: )

permalink
/