Welcome to VA-11 HALL-A

Metadata sources:
http://waifubartending.com/
https://garoad.bandcamp.com/album/va-11-hall-a-second-round
https://www.garoadmusic.com/music/va11-hall-a

she approves

👀

we're so back

some of your hs choice of the drum hitnormal is still a bit inconsistent when it comes to patterns with repetitive patterns like 00:24:775 - 00:34:672 - 00:44:569 - 01:14:259 - 02:01:270 - 02:21:063 -, prob not intentional and might wanna check

The hitsound usage arrangement makes your hitsound pretty random.

1. I find that u seem to use normal-hitclap and soft-hitclap to represent kick and snare respectively, which is ok with custom sampleset. But actually mostly normal-hitclap and soft-hitclap (in default / many skins) are pretty similar, and they can't reach the expectation as u want imo.

I tend to use more different hitsounds for the different instrument, like normal(or drum)-hitnormal for kick, soft-hitclap for snare.

2. u use normal-hitclap for the prominent kicks in music, but sometimes u just ignore the kicks and follow the melody with soft-hitwhistle.
   It's pretty sad that u can't add normal-hitclap and soft-hitwhistle on a object, and the current logic of normal-hitclap and soft-hitwhistle usage is somewhat random.
   If u keep the current hitsound arrangement, u couldn't solve the problem well imo.

That's why I brought up the suggestion in the Issue1, u can add xxx-hitnormal and soft-hitwhisle/clap at the same time and avoid the apparent confliction well.

+1

awesome map!

+1

don't think it is a good idea to put a whistle sample on hitfinish2, 01:41:476 - is now kinda spammy with finishes on lower diffs

don't think some of the hs volume changes are necessary like 00:41:785 - 00:41:940 - 00:42:094 - , which ended up lower diffs lacking hs feedback like on normal diff 00:41:785 (1) - that hs on tail is stronger than on head

either make hs volume consistent or only do like a 50% -> 55% -> 60% change will be enough

i think u should use a cymbal for hitfinish so that stronger downbeats can be emphasized like 02:01:270 - etc, right now theres no hitfinish at all

hs

i think you are missing normal-hitclaps on most of the downbeats 00:02:507 - 00:07:455 - 00:12:404 - 02:01:270 - 02:03:744 - etc.

01:21:373 - 01:21:527 - should be claps not whistles

01:11:167 - 02:06:837 - clap

01:40:239 - should also add whistle for the main melody? could copy a new whistle file for the drum set

00:48:280 - 00:53:228 - could remove whistle, no main melody

00:47:971 - 00:50:754 - 00:52:919 - 01:18:898 - 02:31:888 - these normal hitclap should be 1/4 beat late on blue tick? the bases are on blue tick not white

01:11:476 - missing normal hitclap

01:40:857 - missing drum hitclap

01:29:414 - dont think u need a clap here

01:29:414 - perhaps add normal hitclap like 01:39:620 -

хайп тренд

С кайфом. Достойная карта. Я так понимаю почти все правки уже внесены, поэтому мне добавить нечего (Enjoyed it. Decent map. I assume all corrections have been made so I have nothing to propose.)

Fun map :)

wait to rank !

👀

nice

I see Va11Halla, I hype

this is completely up to you, but i see more potential in hitsounding this map:) right now i feel like it's a bit underwhelming and a constant spam of soft-hitnormal which is a shame given the song has cool bass and synth sounds (00:23:380 (4,5,1,2,3) - 00:30:338 (3,5,6,7) - can be heard here)
maybe im just a hs enthusiast but see for yourself how you feel about this!

finished modding! gl with ranked!

tags!

Remove:

• Valhalla (this isnt the actual name of the game, it has 4 L's)
• Va11ha11a (doubt anyone will search this when the real name is va11halla)

Add:

• anime (OMG!!!!!!! there is anime in the game sooooo)
• vaporwave (its tagged in the official source)
• cyberpunk (its tagged in the official source)
• synthpop (its tagged in the official source)
• vgm (video game music :))
• indie (its tagged in the official source)

enable widescreen support cuz why not :)

00:02:503 - could lower vol to ~45% given how suddle the song is here

offset sounds a tad off, 43 sounds better to me :)

02:40:853 - could have consistent vol with top diff on the end of these sliders :))

hype!

i don't have much to say really, the patterns and flows are clear and there isn't much that i could suggest you to change that wouldn't be mega subjective. it's a cute map and song! gg iwej keep slaying

00:42:090 - You need a new inherited point to do volume up at 60% here because the background sound and mood are gonna scale up. You can compare to 01:21:678 - here and there is also volume at 60%.

super nice map!

Compare to the start line of inherited timing point(00:21:059 - around here and their volume is 60% mainly), around 00:00:029 - Volume of this uninherited timing point sounds a little bit loudly(their volume is 70%), despite the sound and mood are more intense compare to the beginning of the music.

How about adding an inherited timing point volume as 60% around the uninherited timing point?

Hi! Will mod later! 🦆

!!!

ee-wedge

Amazing mapping

Great map!