mapped by Mao
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 13 February 2019!
nominated by Myxo and Sotarks
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

fun map, just this sounds too early imo 00:47:822 (1) - , 00:47:883 - this offset sounds way more accurate

permalink

it's a weird vocal, i tried later offset before and it didn't worked well enough, using the offset on the peak makes it sound very delayed.

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

01:21:838 (5) - The slider shape is almost the same (or completely idk xD) so I highly recommend to add a NC here for reminder.

permalink

that slider is sooo slow that you wouldnt break on it anyway and "nc spam" doesnt quite fit the section since we didnt do that otherwise

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

01:26:106 (4) - Yoo this the only thing that really bothers me when playing this map. (It's great a great map otherwise). can you slow that down a bit. It feels a bit too fast considering how you move with the circles before. Feels awkward. 1.50x would be nice.

permalink

I made it 1.6 to have give the "ooo" just a slight bit of contrast

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

02:15:025 - wouldn't ignore this vocal note as there is nothing else going on

permalink

ok

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

how about mapping this one too 02:16:712 -

permalink
Reopened by pimp

ok

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

02:16:100 (2) - slidertail seems late or early depending on if you wanna follow vocals or piano. i suppose since 02:15:237 (1) - follows vocalss this one should too, so the tail is currently late

permalink

oki

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

02:22:329 (2) - pretty sure the note is supposed to begin on a grey tick there instead of a pink one (so it would begin on 02:22:311 instead).

permalink

the intended snapping for the vocal is clearly 1/6. the singer just missed by a few ms. no big deal imo

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

02:44:090 (1,2,3,4) - Follow guitar still seems a bit late, probably only for me, better recheck it again. :3c

permalink

the guitar could be mapped accurately by just using different ticks, they chose to use a more consistent/playable snapping, i prefer it that way honestly.

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

02:46:073 (3) - sounds too late and doesn't seems easier to play like that, so move this to 02:46:020 -

permalink

ok

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

02:54:351 (3) - this slider looks way too generic compared to what you use to do in this part, i exepted some fancy slider shapes like you usually do..

permalink

ok

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

03:08:926 (1,2) - 03:09:729 (1,2) - 03:10:531 (4,5) - this section is really low volume, it sounds weird to have this slider ends not muted, can you maybe mute them ?

permalink

we agreed on not silencing because then the map gets more feedback, tho changed volume

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

03:22:052 (3) - are you sure about the snap of this slider end (like the other one are snapped to 1/8 and this one 1/12 better be consistent) ? idk also 03:21:326 (1,2,3,4) - would be better to silence those slider ends as that you don't need to hear any slider ends since you're following vocals.

permalink

I decided to end the slider that way because 1/8 would be too close and play awkward and because slider ends are not that relevant here. Already disccussed this with pimp too btw

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

03:41:533 (1,2) - wouldnt make more sense to ctrl g those NCs since new vocals start at 03:41:736 (2) - ? u apply it already here 03:44:705 (3,1) - .

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

03:48:270 (4) - you forgot nc here xd to be consistent with previous pattern

permalink

ay

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

04:02:351 (2) - i wonder what this is following, have no clue

permalink

I mapped this intuitively as a transition from 1/4 to 1/3 and it works pretty well for that imo

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

04:07:357 - Sounds better if u add Normal-sampleset here! :D

permalink

Could also make it 1/16 return here for those clear 3 drum beats with a normal sample set since its passive rhythm anyway. Just sounded kinda off while playing

permalink

Added the sample, snapping sounds better as is though imo

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

04:07:635 (3,4) - this would play waaaaaaaaaay better if it was a 1/6 slider tbh, 04:07:704 (4) - clicking this is aweful x)

permalink

making it a 1/6 slider would not have enough impact imo and I don't have an issue playing this at all

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

04:24:326 (1,3) - can you make these generic L sliders a bit more fancy to fit your slider concept in the whole map? basicly what i did before.. idk for me these sliders looks way too generic compared with what u are going for.

permalink

ok

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

05:09:210 (3) - This one should snap to 05:09:213 - instead even it is 3ms difference only lol

permalink

05:08:781 - add a red line here 69,350bpm

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

05:12:651 (2) - looks like a little mistake i think? should be snapped to red tick as well not 1/8, like slider before

permalink

it sounds more accurate than the red tick so it's probably not a mistake

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao

05:16:414 (4) - sounds way better at 05:16:307 - to me and is less awkward imo

on the blue tick it starts on the most pronounced sound on the vocal, on the yellow it sounds like it doesn't really start on anything so it makes it awkward to play esp as someone who knows the song

permalink

u think current one is ok since "c" isnt really that audible and u really start hearing the vocal at the "a" imo

permalink

^

permalink
Marked as resolved by Mao
/