beatmap discussion
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Hype
Sign in and hype this beatmap to make it more visible for nomination and ranking!
PraiseSuggestionProblem
Discussions
Sort by
Sources (for what I could find...not many available)
- Wikipedia - yes, I know, but in this case it was useful.
- TLT's Official Website
- Spotify
- SoundCloud
- YouTube
Last edited by Spkz .
Combo2 and Combo3 (the grey colors) are a little bit too similar to eachother. Makes for a "difficult-to-differentiate" contrast between the two, especially since they are one after the other - as mostly being present in the first song. If you could adjust one of the colors to make for a better contrast, that would be awesome.
Meta mod
===================
yes, this post did take me as much time as it probably seems like it took.
Explanations
- ❗ - Issue, needs to be fixed.
- 🟡 - Suggestion, recommended to be fixed.
Beatmap description
- It would be useful, informative and very handy, if you listed all the songs that's included in this songs compilation. 🟡
- You could even link the YouTube links with them, that would be very nice as well. 🟡
- You have Nattu in the "Big thanks" box, having the background associated to their name. Does this mean they found the background for use, or they drew it for the set? I'd presume it's the former, in which case please credit the author of the background separately. 🟡
- Similar deal with defreeyay with the background video, as the video even though could be considered custom-made for this map - it's ultimately a compilation of the official content put together into one video. Therefore I think it would be a good idea to make this distinction, while also linking the original YouTube videos, as mentioned prior. 🟡
Source
- Even though the songs are clearly for FNAF, they actually aren't the source, because the songs are not part of the original games. All songs as far as I can tell are inspired only. For this reason, the source should be removed. Do add the source in the tags though, because of the first song's title (read more in replies) ❗
Tags
TL;DR: replace your current tags with this below, explanations will be in the replies of this post. ❗
10 years anniversary marathon english electronic pop drum and bass dnb d&b d'n'b glitch hop dubstep dance edm karta nattu female male vocal vocals fnaf 1 2 3 4 5 sister location fnaf1 fnaf2 fnaf3 fnaf4 fnaf5 fnafsl tlt thelivingtombstone five nights at freddy's freddys it's its been so long die in a fire feat. feat featuring eilemonty & orko eileen montgomery i got no time can't cant fix you crusher-p crusherp
General
- For the artist, add the following tags for relevancy:
tlt,thelivingtombstone. 🟡 - I'm not sure why you have the
10yearsin tag. Assuming you made this for the 10 years anniversary of FNAF, it would be okay, but I personally don't think this is necessary? Anyways, I'd either remove it, or addanniversaryto make it clearer. 🟡 - Add
freddyswithout the apostrophe for easier searchability. 🟡 - Remove
defreeyayfrom tags. Audio (unless exclusively composed for this mapset) and video (unless exclusively made for this mapset) don't count as active contribution towards the set. Cutting together existing media with making sure transitions are nice cannot really be considered as exlcusive content imo. ❗ - Remove
zeraorafrom tags. Mapset banner put in beatmap description does not count as active contribution towards the set. ❗ - Several of the included songs can be considered as pop music, therefore I think adding
popas extra genre for good measure wouldn't hurt. 🟡 - You put dnb with many different spellings which I appreciate, but maybe you could also add
d'n'btoo, for good measure. 🟡 - Some other accessibility tags:
vocals,fnaf1,fnaf2,fnaf3,fnaf4,fnaf5,fnafsl,feat,featuring🟡
Last edited by Spkz .
I Can't Fix You feat. Crusher-P (5th and final song)
iis already present in tags because of the prior song, so it can be omitted. 🟡- Add
can'tin tags too, as per original title. ❗ - On Soundcloud, the genre is tagged as
danceandedm(?). Probably won't hurt to add them too, even though the song is clearly dnb. 🟡 - Add
crusherpfor accessibility. 🟡 - Add
feat.per title. ❗(already added with die in a fire)
Last edited by Spkz .
having me in tags is fine since i mixed audio for them +it was ranked two times before for other songs compilations
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/1831210
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/2229169
this is like whatever. i still would like to ask keep me in tags since i lost my hard effort on it (even edited video for this mapset)
Last edited by defreeyay .
Marked as resolved by Kaoruishi
Timing offset adjustments that imo would make the timing sound better (checked with osu!lazer)
- 1st red line (Five Nights at Freddy's): I actually think this is fine as is ✅
- 2nd red line (It's been so long): +6 ms
- 3rd red line (Die In A Fire): +6 ms
- 4th red line (I Got No Time): +6 ms
- 5th red line (I Can't Fix You): +6 ms
You could check this to see if these improve the timing, and also wait for aiyoko's input for confirmation before applying.