mapped by - Mel -
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 17 December 2024 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

Would suggest buffing the spacing between 00:25:333 (5,1) - to distinnguish the 3/4 and the 1/2 gaps in this section more.

permalink

understood

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

00:29:833 (2,3) - They shouldn't overlap. To fix this, move the slider 00:30:666 (5) a bit away from 00:29:833 (2) (you may have to move the next sliders to keep the patterns of your map).

Also note in the ranking criteria that 1/2 notes shouldn't overlap (which is even true as the ranking criteria suppose that the BPM is 180).

permalink

Alright, thanks! I moved 00:30:666 (5) away a bit and adjusted patterns after.

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

00:37:833 (2) - would move this a bit up to avoid overlap with 00:36:916 (2) - to improve visuals a bit

permalink
permalink

Resolved!

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

00:38:333 (3) - Should perfectly overlap the head of 00:37:333 (1)?

permalink

woops, yeah, thanks!

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

00:47:333 (3,1) - You shouldn't overlap these 2 notes, this may look like a 1/4 gap.

permalink

Fixed!

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

00:50:333 (5,1,2,1,2,3,1,2,1,2,3,1,2,1,2) - imo this entire section feels way too dense, i would deffenitely remove some 3/4th forexample here 00:50:666 (1) - you can perfectly fine not have this as 3/4th since there isnt specific sounds

permalink

00:51:999 (1,2) - here too

permalink

I disagree, this part is a build up and this section is supposed to prepare the player for a dense section

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

00:59:749 (3) - would delete this circle because imo it is a little too dense for hard

permalink

The map is full with bursts, I don't think one circle will make a difference in density.

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

01:01:999 (1,2,3,4,1) - Consider nerfing this because they seems really complicated for a hard difficulty.

permalink

Nerfed it a little, hopefully it's better?

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

01:10:999 (2,3,4,5,6) - this is wayyyy to much for a hard, consider removing 01:11:083 (3) - this and making it into a burst

permalink
permalink

Resolved!

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

01:16:499 - I think you should add a circle here.

permalink

I thought a slider would be more fitting.

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

01:19:333 (3) - Shouldn't overlap with 01:18:666 (5), this may be confusing.

permalink

Fixed!

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -
  • 01:51:999 this section should include 1/3 rhythms when applicable
    the other difficulties utilize 1/3 and 1/6 rhythms in this sections and this difficulty only having 1/4 feels inappropriate and out of place, and with the piano being the most prominent part of the section it feels like a misrepresentation of the song
permalink

I agree with you but then again, I don't want to include too much 1/3 and 1/6 rhythms in a 3* difficulty. I feel like the piano is too quick and it would be difficult to include the piano that would be easy enough for a 3*.

edit: I wish I could implement the piano in this section but it would be too hard for a 3* difficulty due to speed and quick rhythm changes.

permalink

.

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

i feel like you can include 1/3, and exclude 1/6 by simplifying them to 1/3, i get that you dont want to inflate the difficulty of the map, thats why you stuck with 1/4 rhythms through the section, i still feel like my mod stands

permalink

I get where you're coming from. I just don't agree with including much of the piano in this diff. Thank you for your mod!

permalink

01:58:333 (3,1) - Should swap length of these and have the NC be the 3/4 instead, big kick on first sliderend is way more impactful of a note and should have that as the active click here

permalink

Okay! I didn't put an NC cause felt like they represented the same portion of the song.

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

02:07:166 feel like the piano here should be mapped

permalink

okay, gave piano a little more emphasis, let me know if it needs more

permalink

resolve.

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

02:21:333 (1,2) - I don't think they should overlap.

Same with 02:29:333 (1,2).

permalink

Fixed this and similar.

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

03:01:333 (1,2,3,4) - Those are 1/6, not 1/4. Maybe consider mapping this part differently if you think 1/6 sliders are too complicated.

permalink

Recheck this if you can, I tried a different change instead of using 4 1/6 buzz sliders. 2 1/6 and 2 1/2 sliders. I feel like 4 1/6 can be a bit jarring, let me know what you think.

permalink

Marking as resolved.

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

Forgot to recheck sorry but this is fine rn

permalink

All good! Thanks!

permalink

03:03:333 (1,2) - Should make this a repeat too and keep the rhythm across this burst consistent, more recognizable to follow for these lower diffs that way

permalink

Done!

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

03:03:666 (2,3,4,5,1) - is too difficult for a hard diff, 5 note bursts are already rare in hard diffs, but spacing them is even more rare. I would either suggest overlapping the burst, or just simply going for 1/4 kicksliders instead.

permalink

alright, 1/4 kick sliders it is.

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

03:16:749 (5,6) - This could just be simplified as a circle on the red tick so that there is a 1/2 gap to break the chain.

permalink

I agree!

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -

03:21:666 (2,3,4) - This could be changed to something like https://imgur.com/a/hbezoVl, so that the instrumental on the red tick is mapped.

permalink

Thanks for the suggestion!!!

permalink
Marked as resolved by - Mel -
/