beatmap discussion
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
PraiseSuggestionProblem
Discussions
Sort by
there was some discussion about the artist field in BN server in case u weren't aware
HOYO-MiX feat. Robin (VO: Chevy)
Marked as resolved by SuzumeAyase
shouldn't the artist field use CV instead of VO? based on https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/en/Ranking_criteria#fn-character-voice-actor as Chevy is the voice actress behind Robin
Reopened by Reihynn
as the person who did proposal for adding the VO clause, its made for case like this where the singer is different from the person who did the normal voice in the game
the issue with using CV is it cause confusion to people thinking that Chevy did the voice in game (outside the song)
Last edited by Drum-Hitnormal .
Marked as resolved by Drum-Hitnormal
This beatmap set was updated by the mapper after a nomination. Please ensure to re-check the beatmaps for new issues. If you are the mapper, please comment in this thread on what you changed.
Marked as resolved by SuzumeAyase
Is vgm video game music necessary? I usually only save those tags for if the song was from a rhythm game or has strong elements of your typical vsrg songs (e.g. https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/743090#mania/4402594 which wasn't included in any rhythm game but sounds like it's from sound voltex). I'd delete it as it's otherwise misleading. Sure, this song is from a video game, but it's part of the OST rather than being made to smash keys to lol.
Might also consider adding swing, extended play (abbreviation of EP) to tags as that's the rhythmic style. You can also add the names of composers, arrangers, etc.
Eli.WXinbo ZhaoGonLuis Pachecogolden hour(part ofPenacony Golden Hour)
I feel it's unnecessary to add the recording studios though, especially if you don't add the other studios (there's multiple). Remove
阿烈@soundhub
Final tags:
ferdixia- hsr inside chevy robin ep extended play penacony golden hour hoyoverse hoyomix mihoyo english pop original soundtrack ost 王可鑫 vocal 黑金雨 ruby qu 宫奇 Eli.W Xinbo Zhao Gon Luis Pacheco swing
Last edited by Protastic101 .
Marked as resolved by SuzumeAyase
i dont think the video game genre is specifically made for VSRG only... that is not intuitive, u cant assume all osu player even knows whats VSRG
theres nothing wrong with having that tag
Last edited by Drum-Hitnormal .
Video Game
Made for or made popular by a video game. This is also used for arrangements and remixes of those songs.
https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/en/Beatmap/Genre_and_language
pls dont spread bad information
The normal diff name is so clunky, does it really need a custom name or can you not just use a simple Ferdi's Normal? It's really hard to use any of the song lyrics to try and fit a diff name in there cause Normal makes everything sound lame lmao
Marked as resolved by SuzumeAyase
What about doing custom diff names for both but just adding the difficulty after with a separator? E.g.
Ferdi's Renewed Definition | NormalWelcome to My World | Hard
I think that way it doesn't sound awkward but still accurately displays the intended difficulty.
Reopened by Protastic101
This suggestion by itself, I agree, I wouldn't reopen, but with all my other suggestions, I figured it's worth reopening to discuss some more ideas about the diff names so they don't sound so awkward to say.
I also think it's good for a simple map like this to be clear about the intended difficulty of each diff rather than make the player guess.
Marked as resolved by SuzumeAyase
Pretty minor but I do think offset could benefit from +4ms to all timing points (476 -> 480) to closer align with the peak of the percussion.
Marked as resolved by SuzumeAyase
Double check your vocal snappings. It seems that most of the vocal actually lands on the 1/4 ticks while percussion primarily lands on the 1/6 to create a swing beat. I've pointed out a handful in Ferdi's diff already, but it's worth reviewing again in both diffs to ensure accuracy. Also, suggestions in one kiai will translate over 1:1 in the other kiais if it's concerning snapping.
Marked as resolved by SuzumeAyase
just a suggestion but you could add "vgm video game music" to tags. You have "video games" plural for some reason. Could also add "hoyomix" for accessibility without the dash
ferdixia- hsr inside chevy robin ep penacony hoyoverse hoyomix mihoyo english pop original soundtrack ost 王可鑫 vocal 黑金雨 ruby qu 宫奇 阿烈@soundhub studios vgm video game music
Marked as resolved by SuzumeAyase