mapped by [LS]Gavin
submitted
ranked
This beatmap was ranked on 1 July 2024!
nominated by Protastic101 and Monoseul
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:13:244 (13244|3,13391|6) - the contrast here gets a little muddled by 00:12:508 (12508|3,12655|6,12802|3,12949|6), might be better if you moved these two notes outwards by a column

permalink

<3

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

00:16:479 (16479|1,16626|2,16773|3) - not too much of a fan of this transition as it's the only one here that's fully one-handed. would like if you arranged in a broader fashion instead

permalink

<3

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

00:23:097 - would be nice if you flipped from here to 00:26:185 for gameplay variety, 00:22:655 (22655|7,22655|2) transitions into a flip pretty well

permalink

if you do this please make it exactly the same as 00:19:567 because 00:23:832 (23832|4,23832|0,23979|3,23979|2) and 00:25:155 (25155|6,25155|7,25302|5,25302|9) play pretty differently and imo they should not be used to symmetrize with each other

permalink

<3

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

addon after update: 00:26:185 (26185|0,26185|4) could be [29] to be consistent with 00:22:655 (22655|2,22655|7) while also being different

permalink
Reopened by SilentWuffer

TACO BELL

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

this diff is closely related to the dinosaurs

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

00:27:949 (27949|8,27949|9) - you could add a note on col2 to continue the downwards stair here, as the melody here is still loud enough to be represented as a triple imo

permalink

<3

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

00:32:067 (32067|3,32214|6) - since you use gaps of 3 here you could move these two notes outwards to differentiate from 00:31:626 (31626|6,31773|3) as well as represent the way the kick is faded out here

permalink

<3

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

00:34:567 (34567|6) - woulld like if this was moved to col8 to show the jumps in pitch between it and 00:35:302 (35302|5)

permalink

similarly 00:38:832 (38832|7) could be moved to col7 to emphasize 00:38:979 (38979|9) more

permalink

<3

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

00:46:038 - imo would make the longjacks singles to reflect the low pass filter here

permalink
permalink

<3

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

00:47:802 - shouldn't these be LNs like Hyper

permalink

variation never hurt anyone

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

00:51:332 (51332|6,51332|5) - this is the only double here without a 4 width double, you could argue it's to show how the melody here isn't as loud but then it would be inconsistent with 00:54:861 (54861|2,54861|6)

For the record i'm fine with this i just want to make sure it's intentional

permalink

yeah it's intentional

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

01:17:214 - imo could have better pr, what about something like 6 10 7 8 9 7 6 10 8 9 6? (see image below)

can understand if the issue is it's a bit too finger controlly but at the very least i think that 01:17:361 (77361|6) should be on col10 instead

permalink

implemented, I like this, if anyone else has a problem I'll change accordingly

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

in line with the previous mod, 01:18:244 (78244|9) is the only time you map a softer piano note here as you omit it in places like 01:19:126 and 01:20:597. Consider removing this one or adding notes to all piano?

permalink

added a note to 01:19:126 and 01:20:597

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

01:24:567 (84567|4,84861|4) - this pattern sticks out a little but I don't hear any support from the song for a mini-anchor like this, maybe move the first note to the left? closest thing i can tell this might be representing is that 01:24:420 (84420|0,84861|4) is the same pitch but then they should be the anchor instead

permalink

<3

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

01:30:155 - pretty confident this should be an identical copy of 01:16:038

permalink

clarify please. there is a sound here 01:30:008 (90008|2) - I'm pretty unsure on what you mean by "should be identical", the timestamps you provided are very different in sound.

permalink

i made a mistake pasting timestamps this is the same mod as #4351912

permalink

can I mark this as resolved then?

permalink

uhhh not unless you applied/rejected it? as in this mod covers the same thing as the linked mod but that was on beginner

permalink

im sorry for making this so tough it's hard for me to understand I am so incredibly confuzzled so you want this change applied to the beginner?

permalink

nvm figured it out LOL

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

ok wait hold on a minute what is up with these timestamps

permalink

figured it out dw about it

permalink

01:52:655 (112655|8,113096|8,113537|8) - not too much of a fan of this, would move 01:52:655 (112655|8,112655|7) to the left

permalink

I agree

permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin

02:05:449 - this 808 is different from at 02:04:567 so the jacks should change column to show that

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by [LS]Gavin
/