mapped by nyawaa
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 18 August 2023 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

00:03:185 (3185) - to 00:28:785 (28785) - just a suggestion, maybe change the doubles in a way so that it represents the piano pitch more? For example 00:07:585 (7585) - can be changed so that it goes to the left rather than to the right etc.

permalink

tried, kinda (i hear it like the same sound but the second one with just a note more lol)

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

00:05:985 (5985) - missing double for the piano

permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

00:31:570 (31570) - consider adding a note here for the piano

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

00:34:544 (34544|1,34544|3,34674|2,34805|0,34805|1) - the doubles don't represent anything here, it should be 1-2-1 in terms of chord size

permalink

00:34:544 represents the bell-like sound that is vanishing, tho i guess its better to change now that you mention it, as 00:34:805 which is also used for the bell is pretty hard to hear

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

00:37:218 Apparently there's a sound here

permalink

Not focusing that sound

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

Why does 00:37:283 have only one note and 00:37:413 has two? it sounds the same sound in both, I think it would be better to have 2 notes at 00:37:283 as well

permalink

removed it before while fixing other things by mistake, added again ty

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

00:37:544 - This jumpstream is a bit weird from a patterning standpoint but we can fix that. I see that you wanted it to be even on both hands, but it ends up being more awkward to play than anything, so I rearranged it so it's more comfortable to play. In addition, I made 00:37:805 a triple to add a bit more emphasis to the sound here since a double is a bit weak for a stronger sound. I provided an image of how I would arrange this jumpstream.

permalink

At least for me this pattern is pretty simple to hit, but if it makes some players struggle when this is not what i want on this then i guess it's better to change it. Hand added also

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

00:37:935 -> 00:38:196 You got the right idea by making to notes follow the melody, but we can move the notes a bit to follow the melody a bit closer. We can shift back 00:37:935 & 00:38:000 by one column since these are higher of a frequency, especially compared to 00:38:131 & 00:38:163 which I would move so the first not is in the same col as 00:37:935 but have 00:38:163 be on the second column instead of the 3rd like we did with 00:38:000. Then we would place 00:38:261 on the first column. In case you are confused, I provided an image for reference about what I'm talking about.

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

00:38:783 -> 00:39:435 The excess notes here kind of take away the emphasis you have with 00:38:718 so as a solution, I would recommend removing the notes in the section except for the following: 00:38:979, 00:39:109, 00:39:239, 00:39:305, and 00:39:370. This would also server as some diversity in-between all the handstreams for a beginning section at that.

permalink

This would also apply to 00:47:131 -> 00:47:783 Which would help break up all the handstreams by removing all the notes in this section except for 00:47:326, 00:47:457, 00:47:587, 00:47:652, 00:47:718, 00:47:783

permalink

The main sound i follow here is the persistent one that you can hear in all the section, which i used to make a stream pattern to make less empty overall. If I only mapped the notes you said it would feel pretty empty and an awkward feeling to play 00:38:326 -> 00:38:718 and after that having almost no notes. Tho you still made me realize that 00:39:305 -> 00:39:435 burst are only 3 notes instead of 4

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

oops

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

00:56:457-01:03:239 What were you mapping out here in that part? I couldn't quite figure out whether it was the piano or the background sounds, or something else

permalink

the sound of the bells (like in 00:29:347 (29347|1,29347|3,29535|0,29535|2))

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:00:109 - I believe you are missing a note here for the bells in the song since at least in this section, you seem to prioritize them.

permalink

also missing a note at 01:01:022

permalink

ty, tho 01:01:022 doesn't seem like there's any sound that i was following. Only the 1/2 constant sound

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:03:109 - I think a note here would help into the buildup for 01:03:370 since you would be emphasizing the riser here.

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

I'd say leave this empty since this breaks the consistency of the previous section, and I don't think representing this sound is necessary

permalink
Reopened by DraterTD

k again

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:03:370 -> 01:04:152 - This section would benefit from just being chordjacks instead of jumpstreams. It would differ from all the handstreams and jumpstreams from not that long ago and it would at least help 01:04:152 -> 01:04:413 stand out more. I've provided an example image of what you can do if you apply my suggestion.

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:10:674 (70674) - you should use burst pattern here instead of 01:11:718 (71718) - since the rhythm is in 1/8 rather than just 1/4, you can use 1/6 for playability. As for 01:11:979 (71979) - it is very clear that it is in 1/4.

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:13:022 - Would recommend removing notes like this since the main thing the song is focusing on is the melody which is 01:12:761 & 01:12:892 so by removing 01:13:022, you would help emphasize it more.

permalink

do this with 01:13:413, 01:13:805 & 01:14:196 as well

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:15:500 -> 01:15:892 is weirdly snapped. You should just have it be a 1/8 single note stream instead (this means getting rid of the double at 01:15:500)

permalink

wanted to represent that weird sound as a 1/8 stream burst, using jumps where it starts and ends, and like while it is dissapearing follow it with 1/4 notes. Thought playability could be affected idk

permalink

01:15:631 (75631) - remove this double, this isn't representing anything important, you can keep the double on 01:15:500 (75500) - instead of representing the percussions on these two bars, consider it as representing the "wub" sound with chords (Same goes for 01:17:718 (77718) - 01:19:805 (79805) - etc.)

permalink

K

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:17:587 - A double into a 1/8 stream at this bpm I imagine would be frustrating to play so instead I would improvise and have had it be without doubles and would keep the 1/8s going until 01:17:979

permalink

keeping a 1/8 230bpm stream for that long would be pretty unbalanced so no

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:18:370 (78370) - there's a slight hihat burst thingy here, maybe double into 1/6 can do if 1/8 is too much

permalink

done, on 01:18:370 (78370|1) sounds more clearly tho

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:18:718 -> 01:18:892 - I don't exactly get what you are doing with the 1/6 here since it seems snapped to nothing, and you miss out on being able to make a 1/4 stream from 01:18:761 -> 01:18:957 with a double at 01:18:761.

permalink

Changed to 1/4 as im dumb and also added the jump

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:18:761 (78761) - doesn't need a jump, move the note on col 4 and make it into a stream with the triple before it

permalink
Reopened by DraterTD

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:19:805 - This double makes this part frustrating more than anything so it's best to just remove it from how negative it affects gameplay. Also remove the double at 01:19:674 since it makes your streams flow weirder and would give you more freedom by removing it.

permalink
permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:20:066 -> 01:20:326 - This would be much better as regular trills instead of jumptrills since it plays badly after going through the 1/8 stream, especially with the way it's currently patterned to be with jumptrills.

permalink

keeping the jumptrills but changing it from splittrills to normal jumptrills starting from the opposite site of 01:20:000, the sound is pretty important to just map it as a single

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:24:239 (84239) - this should be the same with 01:15:892 (75892) - either use doubles or triples to represent this sound

permalink

brain cant handle 1 week without mapping

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:25:022 (85022) - the 1/8 burst here doesn't seem to be representing anything noticeable, consider making it into a splittrill

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:26:392 (86392|1) - consider removing this note to differentiate both chords before and after it

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:26:718 (86718) - maybe make this a 1/6 or 1/8 burst into the double for the "hihats" burst

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

jumps there are following the vocals

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:32:848 (92848) - to 01:38:848 (98848) - not sure what these doubles are representing here, consider removing them

permalink

this was only singles before but when playing it thought that it was too empty and pretty boring, tried searching for something to add and could hear something there (would say what that sound is but im pretty ignorant on instrument and things) Tho could consider removing it if it's pretty hard to hear

permalink

01:38:848 (98848) - change this to triple for the crash sound

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:47:326 (107326|3,107457|1) - consider removing these two doubles since the only sound here are the pianos

permalink

keeping the jump on 01:47:326, as there is a sound that can be represented using a jump

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

01:47:457 (107457|1,107587|1,107718|1,107848|1,107979|1,108109|1) - idk if you consider this a bad thing, but here's an anchor that could be avoided if you messed with a few notes

in 01:48:761 it was inevitable, since it had handstream, but in 01:47:457 da to avoid the anchors if you want, since it is Split trills just distribute the notes in some different way that already decreases the anchor

1:48:761 v

permalink

I dont think 6 notes is really that much problem on anchors. If i did for example, a maximum of 4 notes for every anchor it would feel like hitting the same part again and again. Thought this type of anchor should not be common but just to make the pattern a bit different than the other ones

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

Alright, that's your choice, is that I usually try not to leave large anchors on most of my map, but I don't think that's a problem

permalink

01:48:239 (108239) - missing triple

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

02:02:979 (122979) - maybe make this a double so it's more "consistent"?

permalink

when did I removed that jump

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

02:02:979 (122979) - maybe make this a double so it's more "consistent"?

permalink

duped, anyways free kudosu

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

02:04:152 (124152) - this should be a double and 02:04:544 (124544) - should be a triple, there are some percussions on 02:04:283 (124283) - 02:04:413 (124413) - as well, maybe use doubles here instead of streams

permalink

changed, also added jump on 02:04:413 (124413|2) to keep the jumps to the part where the 1/4 stream actually starts

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa
permalink

fixed

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

02:21:804 (141804|1) - not sure what this note is trying to represent, I'd suggest removing it

permalink

represents some of the 1/8 that also happens on other instances, just forgot to map them :skull:

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

02:23:327 (143327) - I'd say make this trill into minijack from col 4 to 1 so that it fits the song and it's funnier (i.e. single note as 44332211 in columns) do make adjustments to the pattern after this if you accept it

permalink

funny minijacks, would be more funny if this was only in one lane

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

02:24:077 (144077) - two issues:

  1. 02:24:077 (144077|0,144077|3,144077|1,144170|2,144170|1,144264|2) - this block of notes isn't consistent with the layering with others, where the chords 3-2 has minijack and the single note doesn't, here it has minijack for 2-1, consider changing it
  2. 02:25:108 (145108) - there's not much of a reason for this to be a double, make it single
permalink

connected the singles to minijacks and also removed that jump, tho it was used for vocals

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

02:25:577 (145577) - there's quite a bit of layering issues within this section, I'll list a few below

I also highly recommend making use of minijacks as a part of layering, since it looks pretty random right now

permalink
  1. 02:25:670 (145670|2) - move this to col 4 to remove the minijack on this first note
  2. 02:26:139 (146139) - this note shouldn't create a minijack with the double after it
  3. 02:26:514 (146514) - this should be a single rather than a double
  4. 02:26:983 (146983) - compared to 02:28:483 (148483) - the "kick" is less audible, consider making this a double
  5. 02:28:014 (148014) - should be single
  6. 02:28:764 (148764) - should be single
  7. 02:29:983 (149983) - same issue as point 4.
  8. 02:31:014 (151014) - should be single
    etc. this should also apply to the second half
permalink

single notes are not connected to minijacks, 02:26:983 feels as loud as 02:28:483, so I prefer keeping it like a hand. Fixed some notes that should be singles tho in 02:28:764 i can hear the sound so i will keep it as a jump

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

02:37:108 (157108) - should be double as there are no audible percussion here

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

02:49:764 (169764) - 02:52:764 (172764) - etc. should be single, there are no audible sounds here to be represented by a double

permalink

i can hear something so gonna keep those

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

03:07:858 (187858) - I'd suggest changing the anchor placement to better represent the song, pattern should look like [134][34][34][124][12][12][134][34][123][2] in columns as 1/4 (this includes the last note, making it a minijack), the same applies to others after this

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

03:08:702 (188702) - please change this goofy ah trill to something like a ladder (213243), adjust it to fit the next chord

permalink

320 two hand trill not that bad

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

03:10:108 (190108) - missing note for the "vocal"

permalink

its already a note there?

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

03:19:577 (199577) - maybe make this triple to represent the "thump" sound

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

03:29:427 (209427) - suggest removing these doubles and the jumptrill after this, for emphasizing the doubles are representing the "vocals" here

permalink

keep the jumptrill as just a trill and changed the jump to a single

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

03:29:538 (209538) - this "burst" doesn't really fit with the intensity of the song, consider nerfing this into a simpler jump stream with doubles on 1/2, if not then check for anchors, especially on columns 2 and 4

permalink

nerfed

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

04:48:576 (288576) - the triples should be on 04:48:696 (288696) - 04:48:816 (288816) - not 04:48:576 (288576) - since the melody is not here, the same applies to 04:50:496 (290496) - 04:52:416 (292416) - etc. If these triples are representing both the bells and the melody, keep the triples and still change the others

permalink

hands are only following the bells, so keeping it the same on this part

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

05:03:396 (303396) - missing double

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

05:07:236 (307236) - missing double

permalink

k

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

05:08:256 (308256) - just a suggestion, maybe make this into a 1/6 burst to represent the "brrrrrrrrrrr" and also differentiate this from the previous parts

permalink

already in 1/6

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

05:13:536 (313536) - consider making this a 1/4 stream to represent the melody

permalink

done, removed the jumps between so it doesn't get the same as 05:14:016

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

05:19:716 (319716) - this should be a double as there's a melody here

permalink

cant hear anything here

permalink

05:27:636 (327636) - make this a double to represent the melody, ie make it as a jumptrill, same for 05:28:116 (328116) -

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

05:40:896 (340896) - the triples here feels pretty off since it's not on 1/1 and it is not representing the melody as well, I suggest changing this pattern

permalink

keep some of it the same way until 05:42:816 where i changed to a 1/6 stream as it feels like the part with the least representation with the patterning that was before

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

06:01:536 (361536|3) - heavy anchor on column 4
06:06:936 (366936|1) - column 2

permalink

23 notes anchor incident

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

06:07:776 (367776) - highly suggest using triples on 1/1 beat, and if there are sounds on 1/4 beat, make it double and make the 1/1 after or before it (if any) as double

permalink

as this is not in the hard part changed this to a more light pattern, so i can keep the 1/1 hands and also map the sound which also used for hands before but now with jumps instead, also added sounds on 1/4 according to the song

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

06:26:382 (386382) - should theoretically be double

permalink

doesn't seem like now

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

06:36:329 (396329|3) - unintentional anchor on column 4?
same for 06:37:908 (397908|3) -

permalink

fixed, cant done that much on 06:37:908 (397908|3) - because the splittrill

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

06:43:698 (403698) - consider representing the burst here with 1/8 or 1/6

permalink

Didnt add it as it would be pretty hard to keep something at 427 bpm (and it's 1/6). Just added them on 06:45:487 as they are short enough and you can make simple patterns with it

permalink
Marked as resolved by nyawaa

actually just gonna do half of it

permalink
/