mapped by SamStarfish2013
submitted
last updated
This beatmap wasn't updated since 22 October 2020 so it was graveyarded...
New Discussion
Please sign in to post or reply
Discussions
Sort by

The Hard and Insane difficulties feel weirdly disjointed with each other, on one hand the Insane diff is where 1/4 rhythm starts being used in a major way, yet in the Insane the ending is a slow slider, while on the Hard difficulty which is primarily 1/2 rhythms, it ends on a 5 note burst coming out of a jump section. If anything these two endings should definitely be switched, if not the difficulties should be reevaluated considering which mechanics are going to become prevalent at which difficulties.

permalink

you make a great point. The ending on the hard diff is definitely harder than that on the insane diff. I will switch when I get back to my PC.

permalink
Marked as resolved by SamStarfish2013

accidentally resolved.

permalink

I need to reopen this

permalink
Reopened by SamStarfish2013

This set seems very unfinished... If I may give my personal input, this is not near ready for ranked, and I would highly suggest remapping not only your difficulties, but have the GD's also remap. Rhythm consistency throughout is astoundingly inconsistent, and there are times where it feels like you're things just for the meme. Ex: 00:12:960 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - on hard diff.

Please revise everything you've done throughout each diff, and make sure not to use uncomfortable angles as much. The biggest issue I see with the set, is that it seems like it was made in less than 30 minutes. I feel like you could do better, and while I am being a bit harsh with this, I do think it is necessary for you to understand where the map stands as a whole.

Overall, this set is not near ready for ranked, and you should focus more on making sure that the set is clean, rankable, and not a jumbled mess, instead of going straight to ranking it. Again, don't take this mod as an insult, but constructive criticism to try and fix the set and improve your mapping as a whole.

permalink

it's a WIP, and rest-assured i'm working on it. I didn't ask my friends to hype because I thought it was ready for rank, rather I want to make sure I actually put effort into it before I give up like my other mapping attempts. I also fixed the timestamp linked, because I've been getting a ton of complaints on that.

permalink

set the combo colors all diff!

permalink

ahh thanks!

permalink
Marked as resolved by SamStarfish2013

"oneroom harumachi clover" do not need to be in the tags

permalink

thanks for the info

permalink
Marked as resolved by SamStarfish2013

Missing GDers in tags.
"xtxa's Insane" is possessive but "xtxa" isn't in the tags, ignore if not a user.
"Devil's Insane" is possessive but "Devil" isn't in the tags, ignore if not a user.

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by SamStarfish2013

Incorrect marker spacing.
Missing whitespace before "(CV:" or full-width bracket "(" in artist; "Hanasaka Yui(CV: M.A.O)".

permalink

there are examples of both of this in previous HaruClover maps.

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by SamStarfish2013

Inconsistent metadata.
Inconsistent tags between xtxa's Insane and Easy, difference being "anime japanese"

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by SamStarfish2013

Missing genre/language in tags.
Missing genre tag ("rock", "pop", "electronic", etc), ignore if none fit.
Missing language tag ("english", "japanese", "instrumental", etc), ignore if none fit.

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by SamStarfish2013

should put genre and language in tags (anime, japanese)

permalink

done

permalink
Marked as resolved by SamStarfish2013

pog

permalink

We need more harumachi

permalink

I want new top play

permalink

Hype

permalink

you're a god

permalink

Yes

permalink

Hey thanks for the hype oh my goodness!

permalink

I saw your mod req on Hakku's. I'm gonna mod if you don't mind.

permalink

go right ahead! Thank you so much!

permalink
/