forum

"This score doesn't look right" Thread

posted
Total Posts
2,149
show more
Derekku
I know this has probably been asked before, but is there any way to convert the old algorithm scores into the new algorithm? :/
mattyu007
Probably not, the scores will most likely be simply removed.
rust45
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
blade3285
#1 score for http://osu.ppy.sh/b/18170
The replay seems bad
What he said ↓
Starrodkirby86
Hm...A bugged replay, perhaps?

HarZens is a very good player, so I wouldn't think of him as a cheater.
Inozuma
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/3206

Benda_11's replay.
Yoshi348
A Complicated Song [Easy] has quite a few plays with a max combo of 257 instead of 255, and replaying the replays does indeed confirm they should get 255. Fruits mode is illuminating; while the max combo numbers are instead 255 and 253, you can see that the 255 have two large fruit drops (or slider ticks) that don't exist in the other ones. These only exist in the score readout, not in the actual replays. Perhaps this song got updated with a change when it wasn't supposed to or something?
Gilgamesh
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/2664

Easy mode 1st place person.
I watched the replay, the person broke his/her combo once and also at the end it said 97000- something. No way it would show up as 190636
RogueHiyru

sword414 wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/2664

Easy mode 1st place person.
I watched the replay, the person broke his/her combo once and also at the end it said 97000- something. No way it would show up as 190636
Following this, this person also has #1 place on "you are an idiot" [easy]
Lucidity

sword414 wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/2664

Easy mode 1st place person.
I watched the replay, the person broke his/her combo once and also at the end it said 97000- something. No way it would show up as 190636
That score was set more than a year ago. When was the old spinner algorithm replaced? The spins could have counted more than it does on the replay. Also the combo was broke on a slider...I have a few replays where it shows that I break a combo on a slider, but when I played it originally the combo was never broke. Might be the same.

Speaking of Dodgy though...Look at the #2 on that difficulty. FML if that's a natural spin. Definitely using some program or macro or something to spin :/

Shame on you Hiroshi248.

Same thing here '-' http://osu.ppy.sh/b/32022
Yoshi348
Tsugaru Japan [Beginner] has a top score that beats any other by a ludicrous 52,000 points, and doesn't replay correctly, with the final spinner being failed. Was achieved 9/17/2008; is this that spinner algorithm thing I heard of?
mikhe
http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=15228&m=2

In this map in CtB, the level "insane" have a error; the first have 685 combo SS and the second have 633 combo SS.... it's impossible; look please :D

Bye
talic
Player [rurusiyu] clears stage with cheater under difficulty IOSYS-Miracle-Hinacle[Vieroz Curse].
You can see through spinner section as attached screen shot shows. Please consult and dispose it with staidness.

The attchment below is 22% brightness increase screen shot.


Xgor
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
Dean
A lot of earlier Catch the Beat replays have bugged replays with misses that don't show up in the scores. And the map mikhe linked, as well as Oblivion by darrihuka have top scores with combos exceeding the maximum obtainable.
Ryohan
Can you look at this one? I know that this is FCable but I feel something strange in movement of this guy D:

arkiandruski
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/3516

Second place on Easy has no mods and a score that even the autobot can't acheive.
Mystearica
Ok, this might be a witch hunt but after talking with a lot of people, I'd really like to request someone to check up on this guy:

http://osu.ppy.sh/u/119022

Note his accuracy and rank.

Now look at this: (just a couple of his scores)

http://osu.ppy.sh/s/8004
http://osu.ppy.sh/s/5574
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/25212

Ok seriously, top players would have trouble getting those scores if you watch the replays. I smell another one_love macro user >_> I think the playcounts in his profile are just there for show or that's how many times it took him to get a perfect run >_>

I really don't buy this guy.
Takuma
The "Over The Future" replay is ridiculous. Most of the notes he hits can't even be seen anymore due to the flashlight's range.. *sigh* Yeah, check him out.
MegaManEXE
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
minyeob
OK, OK
I'll talk to him as a same Korean.

At first, he played like this
638 plays - Yoko Hikasa - Don't Say "Lazy" [Alazy]
578 plays - t+pazolite feat. - Okkusenman (Hardcore Mix) [Hard]

But it sucks play counts so now he plays a map with Spun-out mod until he FC it. (About 200~500 retrys)
That's why his playcount is low.

14:20 <kkhpeople>: Macro? Is there something like macro on osu?
Yes, this words has no authenticity
but
He said he might take a video like Cyc's justice to Believe SS
He got really angry D:
edit: His live video is not very effective :p

His damn #1 records are here
viewtopic.php?f=58&t=17263
Let's check his records.

By the way, this reminds me about my past.
Some osu-ers said "I'm convinced that minyeob uses tablet" "minyeob uses tablet wtf"
I uploaded "LIVE VIDEO" orz


Fuck Flaslight :o


Believe or not,
It's very hard to doubt kkhpeople for me.
I saw his success&failure for so many many times......
edit: This is an old story he's a pro actor. He released his true character lol

btw
He respects ShaggoN lol
---------------------------------
Mystearica

minyeob wrote:

OK, OK
I'll talk to him as a same Korean.

He said he plays a map with Spun-out mod until he FC it. (About 200~500 retrys)
I don't think you understand what macros do.

He just needs one good run, record it as a macro, then add Hidden and Flashlight then run the macro since clicking does not change with these mods.

Me and Takuma and Megaman were just speccing him play that map he took #1 from Cyclone on, he used Hard Rock ONLY. Not even half an hour later he gets that #1 score with 3 mods. Spun-out, really? I bet if we randomly popped in to spec then we'd find his skill to be quite different ~_~

It's just like one_love where he used Hard Rock to get #1 on Candy man, it's not humanly possible really and he was dumb enough to do it, this is just less obvious.

I can't even see top players like Jerry getting those scores as fast as he did.

Also with spun out, he can do the same thing with the macro, just spin normally where there are spinners, record a good run then add mods and run the recording, no difference at all.

Those videos aren't live, they're based on replays and shows nothing because unlike Cyclone he's an unproven player with a very low rank and accuracy to show. As well, even if he did record his hands and osu in game screen on a replay how would we know he didn't use a macro? Just look at his profile:

3h - Chihara Minori (Nagato Yuki) - Yuki, Muon, Madobe Nite [Hard] 6,952,104 (SH)
4h - Chihara Minori (Nagato Yuki) - Yuki, Muon, Madobe Nite [Hard] 5,908,521 (S)
4h - Chihara Minori (Nagato Yuki) - Yuki, Muon, Madobe Nite [Hard] 5,870,646 (S)

First 4h ago HR S, he didn't like the acc.
Second 4h ago HR S, he liked it and was recorded
3h ago #1 SH he puts on Flashlight and Hidden and runs his recording. Note this map isn't even on his most played list and that Spun-out thing is hard to believe.

How he seems to be oblivious of macros totally made me laugh. Even if he did make a "live" video it's still easily editable, I will not believe he's legit until I see him play in person because the speed at which he gets Flashlight/Hidden #1s on hard maps is quite impossible. Not 100% impossible, but for a very unknown player, yeah I'll take my chances that his scores are macro'd.

Why don't you try getting any player to Hidden + Flashlight SS/S on Under the Sky Another and Over the Future Hard in 200 or whatever number of plays? I'd like to see that very much if you want to show me that it's doable.
arien666
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/29035
Taiko Insane #1's play looks impossible.
Cuz... he doesn't use left side. But he used only right side and mouse...
I think it's hack :3
Shulin
http://osu.ppy.sh/b/1560

Taiko - Easy 2nd place.
Taiko - Normal - 1st and 3rd place.
Taiko - Hard - 1st and 2nd place.
Taiko - Insane - 1st and 2nd place.

All these scores get a full combo but in the replay it clearly shows they miss several, I've seen this before but not on this scale. Is it a problem with the replays?
MegaManEXE
ROFL

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/18682

#1 score, I think that's enough said, especially if you look at his profile
RemmyX25
http://osu.ppy.sh/p/beatmap?b=31401&m=2

#3 (CtB, Normal) Mods: Hard Rock, Hidden

I watched his replay, and it seems hacked to me. His jumps are similar to |Auto|'s and he avoids droplets? Hmmm...

Download: yuliu1202 - Haru - Shanghai Tea House (Instrumental) [Normal] (2009-07-06) CatchTheBeat.osr
Derekku

MegaManEXE wrote:

ROFL

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/18682

#1 score, I think that's enough said, especially if you look at his profile
I thought one_love was banned orz
MegaManEXE

Derekku Chan wrote:

MegaManEXE wrote:

ROFL

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/18682

#1 score, I think that's enough said, especially if you look at his profile
I thought one_love was banned orz
Yeah me too

I guess he just got his scores wiped and had to start over?

x_x
DeathxShinigami
This map has been deleted on the request of its creator. It is no longer available.
MegaManEXE
Uh...yeah. Hard rock S and then the very next run flashlight + hard rock + hidden S?

Bullfuckingshit.



So is that enough for a ban yet or still no
Mystearica
Like I said he can add Flashlight and Hidden once he gets a good enough (in his definition) full combo run because it's recorded and Hidden/Flashlight doesn't change how he has to move/click. So many of his scores support this and when he overtook Cyclone's #1 on Moun, that certainly was the case.

Best way would be to just compare his Hard Rock replay (the play he used to macro Hidden and Flashlight on, so his most recent S before SH) against his HardRock Flashlight Hidden replay, bet you they have the same accuracy and everything, lulz. Pay attention to this and you will easily catch him. It's not he's trying to hide his macros so just pay attention. If you spec him though he probably won't be stupid enough to do this, I know when we spec'd him with Takuma he waited til no one was speccing to add Flashlight and Hidden and instantly overtook Cyclone's #1, that was epic lulz.
MegaManEXE
E-detectivework ftw

(Large picture warning)

SPOILER
Today I noticed that kkhpeople was online, so I checked his profile to see what latest shenanigans he's been up to, since he's very suspicious, and saw that he achieved rank #36 in Nightmare (Normal):


I happened to load up this browser window while I was speccing the tail end of his run for the #1 rank, for the record, and when I saw the final score I immediately screenshotted this.

Okay, anyways, so then he goes afk for a while (sorry, don't have pics of this), comes back, loads up Nightmare (Normal) and gets rank #1 in one run using hidden/flashlight. WITH THE SAME EXACT ACCURACY AND NUMBER OF 50s AS IN HIS #36 RUN:



And I've taken the liberty of screenshotting his recent #1 rank as well so you don't have to go look at the beatmap listing:



Immediately after I specced the last 15~ seconds of that #1 run, what does this guy do?

Why, he goes off to spec someone else of course, so that I'll stop speccing him.



y u scared bro, u hidin sumthin?

Can we please ban this blatant cheater now? These kinds of people are the worst, I have zero respect for them.

And while you're at it please that cheater ban one_love too, this time for good.
Mystearica
lol ^

I also like how his profile is always normal gold S then right away a silver S #1 score.

Does this guy even know that it takes time to memorize maps for Hidden and Flashlight?

Yeah.
-SiN-
maybe he planted a microchip in his brain
Real1
Just ban his ass. -_-
He has been active for so much time... it.. makes me mad.
MegaManEXE
Well

I'm not going to say anything more on the matter, I've found the evidence I wanted and I've directed peppy to this thread so the rest is up to his judgment I guess.
march9th

arken1015 wrote:

http://osu.ppy.sh/b/29035
Taiko Insane #1's play looks impossible.
Cuz... he doesn't use left side. But he used only right side and mouse...
I think it's hack :3
You made a mistake
I didn`t used mouse
:oops:
Zekira
arken, you don't need to use the left side to strum quickly. >_>
MMzz
Ok I had 10x 100s and I didnt hit many big notes (When you use 2 fingers) But the player in front of me had 58x 100s? and got 40k+ more score than me, even if he hit all the you use 2 finger notes I dont think he would be ahead of me with my acc of 98.96%. Oh and Zekira's score raped mine cause obviously he hit all the you use 2 finger notes and only had 10x 100s, looked like he missed the last 2 notes. But even if my math proves me wrong I still declare BS, and This player does not hack im sure I have played him in Multiplayer.

arien666

march9th wrote:

You made a mistake
I didn`t used mouse
:oops:
Umm... That's right. I didn't see anything(=X2 score on Big note)
Ok. It's my mistake. Sorry :(
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply