The plot thickens, dun dun dun.Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
Rantai: It turned out "mafia", not "guilty".
IDK about insanity, but the very fact I was given a Miller in my role has to mean something.Rantai wrote:
The only thing stopping me from being completely convinced is the possibility of insanity : \
That would be a huge ass move by Swift. Huge.Chris wrote:
it is possible they are both mafia and are just liars
IDK if it is part of my role or it was just a chance thing , but I can say the contents of the PM I did get, and Swift can verify it.0_o wrote:
Calling BS on NoHItter's roleclaim. A miller whose "results" are completely unverifiable? Does this not seem wayyy too convenient to anyone?
vote NoHItter
Mafia Role Cop?NoHItter wrote:
IDK if it is part of my role or it was just a chance thing , but I can say the contents of the PM I did get, and Swift can verify it.
I said we can't verify your claimed results, not the thing about Swift. I didn't doubt that you got Swift's role, but it doesn't really matter with regards to whether you're scum or not.NoHItter wrote:
You vote me because you say that we can't verify any of what I say.
Then when I do give a way on how to verify something, you brush it off and say it's a scum aux power.
This is important, and was overlooked. NoHitter never questioned swift's alignment, and the possibility that he could be making up his night results.Chris wrote:
You don't really seem to be denying the fact you came back as Mafia though, NoHitter.
A miller is a pro-town player who turns up guilty under investigation.NoHItter wrote:
I'm not Mafia. I'm a Miller Graverobber.
A mafia would stay neutral to hinder town progress. Yes, a skilled mafia could actually throw it off, but that's an easier and more convenient shortcut, especially on D1.Rantai wrote:
I think you misunderstood this one. I meant, knowing it's a scum tell or whatever, what mafia would stay neutral? Town progress could easily be taken off track by a well played mafia.
Bandwagoning, overreactions something along those lines would be more solid than a preset criteria of playstyles.I really disagree with this very much...though I guess this is a difference in what we consider to be scumtells.
I've noticed that it also exists with any other alignment >.>IMO, that's the idea here. By D1, it is reasonable to assume that the more aggressive players or town. It's like when you're playing poker, you can classify players into various profiles (e.g. rocks, maniacs) and then change your playing based on that (ex. if a maniac raises a lot, it would be more worthwhile to call).
Which part were you referring to?This:
Hmm how does saying not wanting to vote on gut make it wifom?I guess this whole argument is a difference in our playstyles, but go ahead and accuse me if you wish = =||
I doubt there would be 5 mafia in a 15 person gamepieguy1372 wrote:
Oh I made a mistake, with 5 mafia we would be at LYLO with a myslynch. With 4 we could have another mislynch.
Not really, NoHItter claimed miller, remember? Swift is quite likely to be a cop regardless of how NoHItter flips.pieguy wrote:
if he's town, Swiftwolf is definitely mafia
oops0_o wrote:
Not really, NoHItter claimed miller, remember? Swift is quite likely to be a cop regardless of how NoHItter flips.pieguy wrote:
if he's town, Swiftwolf is definitely mafia
I'm not sure how I forgot about that. I blame the fact that I just woke up and can't think straight... >.>This makes me pretty sure that NoHItter is mafia, but Hammering right now would be a horrible idea for multiple reasons.Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
There is a 50-50 chance as to whether or not the mafia gets to know about my role.
Awesome, thanks. Now I don't have to worry as much anymore.Rantai wrote:
Hi, I am posting in this thread with the intention of fulfilling a request.
it's a problem now cause they haven't posted in 2 days~Two wrote:
I don't have a prodding rule. If inactivity becomes a problem, I'll just replace/modkill case by case.
they are the only 3 which is why I called them out0_o wrote:
Seeing as yesterday only lasted about 12 hours, and nobody posted for the last 24 hours, I'd say not posting for the last 48 hours is somewhat reasonable?
or maybe bus driver exists?Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
That's what I'm wondering, too. I roleclaimed cop, and even NoHitter confirmed it. There's a possibility that I was getting protected that night, and if that's the case, they want to take out the doctor, first.
Bus Drivers just switch what happens to two people during night actions.Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
..wait. If it IS a bus driver, wouldn't it have come up as such? I mean, if there IS one, wouldn't Rolled come up as such, and not townsperson?
Swiftwolf Yellowtail wrote:
..ninja'd.
That's what I was getting at, Chris. But there's one thing that still doesn't register as right. Wouldn't it show that he's a bus driver?
.definitely lybydose, only thing he posts are votes nowLadySuburu wrote:
HoS: Lyby, animask.
Traditionally, a doctor can't protect the same player consecutive nights. Though sometimes they ARE allowed if their protection is successful, thus making it even riskier for the mafia.Rantai wrote:
What stops someone protecting him twice in a row?
But I do see your point.
Wojjan wrote:
yeah that's true, you don't ever.
unvote
feeling pretty good about LS
These two stand out to me quite a bit right now. Now, aside from being quite cryptic (yep, I'm dumb), LS refused to vote on either bandwagon (granted the reasons were sound, but that's just convenient too). I'll think on this a bit more.LadySuburu wrote:
Feel free to lynch me if you'd like, just take the fact that I believe Wojjan and Lyby are almost guarenteed town into consideration once I flip.
To clear up it's only a slight read on foulcoon.Chris wrote:
I still think LS is the Jester who ended up losing their role cause Lybydose called them out, losing post restrictions right after that happens is too convenient.
Rantai - Assuming town, nothing to confirm it yet though. Saying you believed foulcoon was town surprised me though, possible you + foulcoon are the last mafia alive.
Rantai wrote:
To clear up it's only a slight read on foulcoon.
Alright, time to give you something then and also to show why I don't think LS is a jester.
Roleclaim: Setup Watcher
Basically, every day I am given a list of how many of 4 types of roles are left (Vanillas, power roles, mafia and independents). I will say right now there is 1 mafia left and no independents. Meaning it's a 8v1 set up at this moment.
However I noticed someone was jumping between power role and mafia on day 1 and 2. I believe there is someone who swaps roles based on a trigger. My guess is if that person is voted, they swap alignment then swap back the next day. Now, before I give you numbers, I want to make sure that actually giving out aux role numbers won't hurt the town.
Opinion?
1. I am unsure how it works, I'll copy paste my notes on mafia numbers for you though.Chris wrote:
1.I don't see how it's possible for someone to switch back and forth? .. wouldn't they like, know who the other Mafia are and be able to win it for town?
2.You wouldn't of been able to see LS as an independent though just for the fact they were called out D1 and possibly lost their alignment right there, unless your ability is used during the day. (and before that happened)
3.It's hard to believe there is only 1 mafia member left though, I'm assuming it's more along the lines of someone who comes up as town when they use their night ability. (possibly 1 shot?) <-- and oh I just realized this might be what you meant.
4.I don't think it would be beneficial to state how many of what are left in this game, though. Just keep us informed if the Mafia count hits 2, cause I doubt this was a 3v12 game.
Mafia - 3 - 4 - 2 - 12. There have been 0 independents the whole game, believe it or not. It has been 0 the whole way through.