Using spoiler boxes to prevent long walls of textRed = Major issue, you should fix thisPurple = Issue, It's better if you fix this, and can sometimes pass if justifiedBlue = Minor issue, you can ignore if you dont want to changeGreen = Feedback / CommentsBlack = Suggestion
[General]
SPOILERIf i make suggestions that are different from what i made last time about combos, it's because i've become better now at judging good new combo spots
Delete .osb file and full submit, there's a osb but i dont see any storyboard
Insane is still considerably longer than the other 2 diffs, remember your diffs should have some certain consistence between them, im not asking for perfection but if possible try to make them all end at the exact same spot in timeline or close to it (i mean off by a second or 2), i cant ask for you to have breaks on the exact samse spots since you are just starting and i dont think you planned those breaks ahead, but at least kiai times should be consistent as well throughout all the diffs.
It isn't particularly breaking any rules as the guidelines currently are about difficulty spreads, however i do agree with peppy's comments on something: "Where's the Normal?" We should be trying to provide beatmaps for beginners and experts alike, however that doesnt mean that people that cant do Hards should stick to an Easy and get a really low score or destroy their accuracy by playing a Hard just to get a better score, im not going to ask you to provide a Normal if you dont want to map it, as it currently stands you arent breaking the difficulty spread rules, however it would be good if you could provide a Normal as well.
[Easy]
SPOILER00:54:352 (1,2,3) - Sorry but you should avoid the use of triplets on easy diffs, you can remake this into a repeat slider, then stack the last note at the end of it, though it MIGHT still be confusing for newbies because of the 1/2 distance to the next note, an alternative is to map an slider through this whole section or a spinner
00:59:556 (1,1) - [IMPORTANT] Sorry but this is unrankable, a slider cant cover another slider (specially completely like here) by the time you need to hit it you cant tell if it's a hit circle or a slider [IMPORTANT]
64,438 Remove this timeline, change the kiai one to Normal hitsounds instead and make sure you add another timeline section to normal hitsounds before it, aditionally i recommend you lower the volume of this one coz it's being considerably louder than the song, or just drop the normal hitsound idea, your call
01:00:781 (1) - No new combo
01:06:597 (4) - New combo
01:09:658 (6,1) - Move the new combo to (6)
01:11:495 (2,3) - Both of theese are new combos (considering you're using a combo per stanza on chorus)
01:26:189 (1,1) - 1 slider end is being covered by the other, i have been yelled at for this before, you should consider placing them apart a bit
01:27:413 (1) - No new combo
01:42:719 (2,3) - [IMPORTANT] Note covering slider, you cant tell it's slider until after you hit it, this is Unrankable sorry [IMPORTANT]
01:43:944 (1) - No new combo
01:50:033 - Random break?
01:55:577 (1) - No new combo
02:03:536 (1,1,1) - Remove new combos
02:09:046 - Empty part...
02:15:168 (1) - No New combo
02:17:617 (5) - New Combo
02:22:515 (4) - New Combo
02:24:964 (1,2) - 1/2 distance, i recommend you remove the last repeat and then start a slider where this would end that ends on where (2) is at
02:30:913 - Random Break?
02:37:209 (1,1) - Placing a note 1/2 beat after a spinner is too much for a newbie, 1/2 a beat is not enough for them to regain control after the spin
02:39:658 (1,2,3,1,2,3,1,2) - Try to avoid 1/2 spacing on easy, red ticks should be used RARELY on Easy difficulties
02:47:311 (3) - New Combo
02:54:352 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I cant agree with a 1/2 stream on an Easy (even on a Normal that's rare) plus it doesnt really add much to the aesthetic pattern here since you go zig zagging and all of a sudden straight notes
[Hard]
SPOILER00:33:536 (3) - I think if you reverse this slider (select it > Edit > Reverse selection) would look better
00:47:005 (5,1) - Make (5) the new combo instead
00:55:577 (1) - No new combo, it's still on the same stanza
01:03:842 (8,1) - Move the new combo to (8)
01:05:985 (7,8,1) - Move the new combo to (7)
01:09:352 (5) - New combo, it's in another Stanza
01:13:332 (1) - Remove new combo
01:32:923 (8,1,2) - Move the new combo to (2)
01:40:883 (6,1) - Move the new combo to (6)
01:50:679 (1,1,1,2,3) - Center theese?
01:54:352 (1) - No new combo
02:10:423 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) - 1 grid to the left [Nazi for symmetry]
02:12:719 (1,2,3,4) - Center theese?
02:15:168 (5) - New combo
02:20:066 (1,2,3,4,5,6,1) - Maybe instead of making this straigh to the center you would like to make them curve around so that (1) can be Dead Center on the grid
02:21:903 (1) - No new combo
02:22:515 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - Coincidentially you could make theese a mirror of the previous curve you just made in the previous suggestion (to do that copy/paste then flip horizontally then reverse selection)
02:24:658 (1) - I dont really think this part deserves a spinner, spinners are usually for building up energy till climax
02:32:005 (6,2,3,4,5) - You could make theese a mirror of (1,2,3) 2 combos behind for symmetry
02:47:311 (5) - New combo
02:53:740 (1) - No new combo
[Insane]
SPOILER00:01:699 (3) - Out of bounds
00:02:617 (5,1) - Move the new combo to (5)
00:04:760 (1) - No new combo
00:07:209 (1) - No new combo
00:10:270 (8) - New combo
00:27:413 (5,1) - Move new combo to (5)
00:34:760 (3) - New combo
00:35:985 (1) - No new combo
00:42:107 (3,1) - Move new combo to (3)
00:47:005 (5,1) - Move the new combo to (5)
00:51:903 (1) - No new combo
00:54:352 (1) - New combo
00:55:577 (1) - No new combo
01:09:658 (5) - New combo
01:11:495 (9,1) - Move the new combo to (9)
01:14:250 (7) - New combo
01:20:679 (1) - +1000 Slider is unrankable make it +2000 or more (this refers to the bonus score auto play gets on it)
01:35:679 (1,2,3) - Ehh dont think theese notes are following anything and they dont make sense to just add 3 notes at the end of an stanza after that break, why dont you map the whole stanza instead of just the 3 final notes?
01:35:985 (3) - New combo
01:38:434 (12) - New combo
01:39:199 (1) - No new combo
01:40:883 (6,1) - Move the new combo to (6)
01:52:974 (6,1) - Move the new combo to (6)
01:58:026 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12,13,14,15) - I think this is kind of overmapped
02:00:474 (15,1) - Move the new combo to (15)
02:03:536 (1) - No new combo
02:12:719 (4) - New combo
02:15:321 (1) - Awkward spinner
02:28:026 (8) - New combo
02:34:454 (1,3) - Move the new combo to (3)
02:41:801 (1) - No new combo
[color=#BF40FF]02:42:107 (1) - Awkward spinner[/color
02:47:617 (6) - New combo
02:54:046 (1,2) - Move new combo to (2)
02:59:250 (1,2) - Move new combo to (2)
03:00:781 (1) - No new combo
03:03:536 (1) - No new combo
03:10:883 (1,3) - Move new combo to (3)
03:13:332 (1) - No new combo
03:16:393 (6,1) - Move new combo to (6)
03:18:842 (9) - New combo
03:19:607 (1) - Silence this spinner?