forum

mimimemeMIMI - CANDY MAGIC [Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
75
Topic Starter
newyams99
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on December 15, 2015 at 10:22:25 PM

Artist: mimimemeMIMI
Title: CANDY MAGIC
Source: 山田くんと7人の魔女
Tags: yamada kun and the seven witches yamajo ending ed Yamada-kun to 7-nin no Majo yuka takao yuki
BPM: 160
Filesize: 2253kb
Play Time: 01:25
Difficulties Available:
  1. Futsuu (2.08 stars, 165 notes)
  2. Kantan (1.16 stars, 94 notes)
  3. Muzukashii (2.6 stars, 253 notes)
  4. Oni (3.49 stars, 361 notes)
Download: mimimemeMIMI - CANDY MAGIC
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
My 3rd submitted beatmap. First ranked :D

The ending theme to Yamada-kun and the Seven Witches, CANDY MAGIC by mimimemeMIMI

Good song :D

Nardoxyribonucleic
JUDYDANNY
Raiden
MMzz

Surono
M4M

k=Blue
d=Red

<(``)

[General]
Check ur AiMod
Disable Letterbox
Disable Countdown

[Kantan]
HP:3
Change Slider Velocity to 1.20
00:10:388 (9) - slider in here please
01:13:388 (84) - slider here too~

[Futsuu]
00:10:388 (9) -
01:13:388 (84) -
about slider, same like in kantan

[Muzukashii]
00:18:075 - add k

Nice mapset. well just it, no have motivation to mod Oni & Inner, just short mod, Hope Helpful :lol:
Topic Starter
newyams99

Surono wrote:

M4M

k=Blue
d=Red

<(``)

[General]
Check ur AiMod
Disable Letterbox
Disable Countdown

[Kantan]
HP:3
Change Slider Velocity to 1.20
00:10:388 (9) - slider in here please
01:13:388 (84) - slider here too~

[Futsuu]
00:10:388 (9) -
01:13:388 (84) -
about slider, same like in kantan

[Muzukashii]
00:18:075 - add k

Nice mapset. well just it, no have motivation to mod Oni & Inner, just short mod, Hope Helpful :lol:
All fixed. Check the sliders cuz I wasn't exactly sure what you wanted me to do.thx :D
Aerous
Your metadata is wrong it's suppose to be mimimemeMIMI CANDY MAGIC remove capital m and tv size
Also previously helped with 1/3 snapped notes and BPM changes at the end
Topic Starter
newyams99

Aerous wrote:

Your metadata is wrong it's suppose to be mimimemeMIMI CANDY MAGIC remove capital m and tv size
Also previously helped with 1/3 snapped notes and BPM changes at the end
Ugh osu ranking system so picky D:
Well, all fixed
-Sh1n1-


[About]

  1. d is don note
  2. k is kat note
  3. D is finish don note
  4. K is finish kat note
[General]

  1. You don't have breaks on your diffs, you should remove some notes.
  2. 01:22:200 (1) - Spin should finish at 01:25:031 - following the song, no voice
  3. Uncheck "widescreen support"
  4. 00:01:388 - 00:22:388 - increase volume to 40% and 00:07:388 - 00:33:638 - 00:52:388 - 01:21:075 - decrease volume to 70%
[Kantan]

  1. 00:10:200 (9) - reduce this slider, slider should finish at 00:11:888 -
  2. 00:17:888 (15,16) - avoid 1/4 pattern, Kantan should be mapped on 1/1, delete 00:18:075 (16) -
  3. 00:20:138 (19) - delete to add a break
  4. 00:47:138 (48) - and 00:48:638 (50) - delete to add more emphasis on 00:46:388 (47) - 00:47:888 (49) - 00:49:388 (51,52,53) -
  5. 01:06:638 (73) - delete to add a break.
  6. 00:54:638 (57) - 00:59:138 (63) - delete
  7. 01:09:638 (77) - 01:11:138 (79) - 01:12:638 (81) - remove to add more breaks
  8. 01:16:013 (86) - delete, 01:15:263 (84,85,86,87) - 4 notes too close for kantan is hard imo and you have an slider before these notes.
  9. 01:20:138 (92) - delete to add a break
  10. 01:22:200 (1) - you are following voice, right? but try to follow the song and spin should finish at 01:25:031 - I's up to you

[Futsuu]

  1. 00:07:013 (8) - remove, to add more emphasis on 00:07:388 (9) - that it marks the finish of calm part
  2. 00:09:638 (16) - delete because before this note you have D D D, on futsuu and kantan after finish you should add a break or will be confusing for newbies.
  3. you need breaks at 00:12:263 - 00:14:513 - 00:15:263 -
  4. same as above add more breaks at 00:19:013 - 00:21:263 -
  5. 00:24:638 (48,49) - change to d d feels better with piano
  6. 00:27:638 (51) - change to d same reason as above
  7. 00:42:263 - 00:40:763 - delete to add more breaks
  8. Where is break on Kiai?

[Muzukashii]

  1. 00:46:200 (129) - delete, it's not necessary because the song is decreasing
  2. 00:53:700 - delete
  3. 00:54:075 - same as above
  4. 00:56:888 (167,168) - Ctrl+G
  5. 00:59:700 (179) - delete
  6. 01:02:700 (191) - same as above
  7. 01:06:075 (206) - remove this note too
  8. 01:10:200 (222) - delete
  9. 01:20:888 (268) - and 01:19:200 (259) - because 01:19:013 (258,259,260,261,262,263,264,265,266,267,268,269,270) - is too long and many maps got DQ for this reason
  10. 01:22:200 (1) - as I said in General

[Oni]

  1. 00:36:263 (131) - move to 00:36:075 -
  2. 01:02:325 (262) - 01:02:700 (264) - delete both to follow piano sound
  3. 01:20:888 (365,366,367) - decide if you want to use K K K or you will use D D D as 00:08:888 (25,26,27) -, because you have the same sound here.
  4. 00:40:200 (151) - delete to add a break
  5. 00:50:700 (196) - remove this note to add more emphasis to the next notes ( 00:50:888 (197,198) - )
    I like this Oni because you added nice breaks :3
That's all from me, GL
Topic Starter
newyams99

-Sh1n1- wrote:



[About]

  1. d is don note
  2. k is kat note
  3. D is finish don note
  4. K is finish kat note
[General]

  1. You don't have breaks on your diffs, you should remove some notes. Done
  2. 01:22:200 (1) - Spin should finish at 01:25:031 - following the song, no voice Done
  3. Uncheck "widescreen support" Done
  4. 00:01:388 - 00:22:388 - increase volume to 40% and 00:07:388 - 00:33:638 - 00:52:388 - 01:21:075 - decrease volume to 70%
Done

[Kantan]

  1. 00:10:200 (9) - reduce this slider, slider should finish at 00:11:888 - Done
  2. 00:17:888 (15,16) - avoid 1/4 pattern, Kantan should be mapped on 1/1, delete 00:18:075 (16) - Done
  3. 00:20:138 (19) - delete to add a break Done
  4. 00:47:138 (48) - and 00:48:638 (50) - delete to add more emphasis on 00:46:388 (47) - 00:47:888 (49) - 00:49:388 (51,52,53) - Done
  5. 01:06:638 (73) - delete to add a break. Done
  6. 00:54:638 (57) - 00:59:138 (63) - delete Done for hit 57, instead of hit 63, I remove a hit at 00:57:638.
  7. 01:09:638 (77) - 01:11:138 (79) - 01:12:638 (81) - remove to add more breaks Removed hit at 01:09:638 instead for hit 79, hit 81 is removed.
  8. 01:16:013 (86) - delete, 01:15:263 (84,85,86,87) - 4 notes too close for kantan is hard imo and you have an slider before these notes. Fair enough, removed hits 84, 86 and 87.
  9. 01:20:138 (92) - delete to add a break I think there's already enough of a break before and after this hit, so no change.
  10. 01:22:200 (1) - you are following voice, right? but try to follow the song and spin should finish at 01:25:031 - I's up to you
I'll change it for now, see what other modders say.


[Futsuu]

  1. 00:07:013 (8) - remove, to add more emphasis on 00:07:388 (9) - that it marks the finish of calm part Done
  2. 00:09:638 (16) - delete because before this note you have D D D, on futsuu and kantan after finish you should add a break or will be confusing for newbies. Done
  3. you need breaks at 00:12:263 - 00:14:513 - 00:15:263 - Rather than this, I removed hits at 00:13:013, and at 00:15:263
  4. same as above add more breaks at 00:19:013 - 00:21:263 - Removed a hit at 00:19:763 instead. For the hit at 00:21:263, I kept since it's a relatively easy pattern.
  5. 00:24:638 (48,49) - change to d d feels better with piano I thought it would be better to keep this part the way it is, since you never mentioned it in the rest of the difficulties.
  6. 00:27:638 (51) - change to d same reason as above Done
  7. 00:42:263 - 00:40:763 - delete to add more breaks Done for the first hit, the second I didn't delete. Instead, I deleted a hit at 00:45:263.
  8. Where is break on Kiai?
Deleted hits at 00:53:513, 00:55:763, 00:56:513, 00:58:763, 01:01:763, 01:04:763, 01:07:763, 01:08:513, 01:10:763, 01:15:263, 01:16:763. The last stretch might still be a bit hard but couldn't think of something really good to remove.


[Muzukashii]

  1. 00:46:200 (129) - delete, it's not necessary because the song is decreasing Done
  2. 00:53:700 - delete Done
  3. 00:54:075 - same as above Done
  4. 00:56:888 (167,168) - Ctrl+G Done
  5. 00:59:700 (179) - delete Done
  6. 01:02:700 (191) - same as above Done
  7. 01:06:075 (206) - remove this note too Done
  8. 01:10:200 (222) - delete
  9. 01:20:888 (268) - and 01:19:200 (259) - because 01:19:013 (258,259,260,261,262,263,264,265,266,267,268,269,270) - is too long and many maps got DQ for this reason Done
  10. 01:22:200 (1) - as I said in General

[Oni]

  1. 00:36:263 (131) - move to 00:36:075 - Done
  2. 01:02:325 (262) - 01:02:700 (264) - delete both to follow piano sound Done
  3. 01:20:888 (365,366,367) - decide if you want to use K K K or you will use D D D as 00:08:888 (25,26,27) -, because you have the same sound here. k changed the K's to D's in all diffs.
  4. 00:40:200 (151) - delete to add a break Done
  5. 00:50:700 (196) - remove this note to add more emphasis to the next notes ( 00:50:888 (197,198) - ) Done
    I like this Oni because you added nice breaks :3
That's all from me, GL
Thanks for your mod :D
Topic Starter
newyams99
To anyone who mods this mapset.
This mapset needs some mods for the Inner Oni, so if you're going to mod this mapset, please map in order from Inner Oni to Kantan.

Thanks~
infr4
From Queue

[Timing]
kiai time end fix to 01:20:888

[General]
Don't overlap Slider with notes

[Kantan]
00:01:388 (1)-(4) : avoid boring 1/1, better k d k d
00:15:638 (15),(16) : k d - follow previous pattern and it's better
00:23:888 : add k
00:26:888 (25),(26) : d
00:32:888 (31) : ^
00:34:388 (33)-(38) : Like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3260997
00:47:888 (47) : k
01:22:200 (1) : spin fix to 01:22:388

[Futsuu]
00:08:888 (11)-(13) : not accept Big note stream on Futsuu. change to d
00:16:013 (25)-(27) : not accept this on futsuu. delete 26
00:22:388 (39)-(49) : what a k here. did u tried to add d?
00:34:013 (51) : delete
00:34:388 (52)-(55) : Like kantan, ttps://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3260997 follow this
00:54:263 (92) : delete, same as 00:16:013 (26)
00:58:013 (101) : ^ delete
01:01:013 (109) : ^ delete
01:04:200 (117) : ^ delete
01:06:263 (122) : delete
01:09:263 (129) : delete, same as 00:16:013 (26)
01:12:450 (137) : ^ delete
01:17:700 - d k, not kdk
01:20:888 (156)-(158) : same as 00:08:888 (11)-(13). change to d
01:22:200 (1) : spin fix to 01:22:388 same as kantan

i stopped modding this.

refer to other ranked maps at once.

non-sense big notes and streams make stop mod to modders -_-

edited : no kds, cuz not helpful for you and for rank

that old rule, can't 1/4 streams on futsuu
Topic Starter
newyams99

infr4 wrote:

From Queue

[Timing]
kiai time end fix to 01:20:888 The other three difficulties have a finisher at the point where I have the end of the kiai time, and I think it makes sense. It may feel like that I should move it to this point because it's on a beat, and it's where a hit is placed, but you can hear the emphasis on the instrumentals until the point that I have it set at right now. No change.

[General]
Don't overlap Slider with notes k I don't even remember placing a note in a slider :/ Fixed.

[Kantan]
00:01:388 (1)-(4) : avoid boring 1/1, better k d k d I see what you're getting at here, but this is the quietest part of the song, and for a Kantan, that kind of rhythm would be almost as hard as it gets. Also, the difficulty curves into the Futsuu if I keep it with this rhythm.
00:15:638 (15),(16) : k d - follow previous pattern and it's better As mentioned in a previous mod, it's important to have short, little breaks between hits. I wasn't really aware of this since I have experience with Taiko, but new players may find these simple rhythm hard and need a short period of time to catch up with the coming notes. No Change.
00:23:888 : add k Added
00:26:888 (25),(26) : d That rhythm would be wayyyyy too hard for a Kantan, especially in the quiet section of the song. No change.
00:32:888 (31) : ^ This suggestion makes sense, but I'd prefer to keep it to a k, just to keep the whole section consistent and unique to only the k.
00:34:388 (33)-(38) : Like this https://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3260997 Again, this rhythm is too hard for a Kantan. Putting hits that are not on the beat are relatively hard to new players.
00:47:888 (47) : k This is the same thing about the short break times.
01:22:200 (1) : spin fix to 01:22:388 The singer says the word sekaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaai, here and starts the long kaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa at where I have it already, so no change.

[Futsuu]
00:08:888 (11)-(13) : not accept Big note stream on Futsuu. change to d There is no stream here (I'm pretty sure).
00:16:013 (25)-(27) : not accept this on futsuu. delete 26 1/2 patterns are very common in Futsuus, especially if the song is slow. Take a look at most futsuus under 200 bpm, and you're bound to find something like this.
00:22:388 (39)-(49) : what a k here. did u tried to add d? I considered putting some d's in here before, but I thought keeping it simple throughout all the difficulties was fine too. Taiko no Tatsujin does this very frequently, where they only put k's in a quiet section.
00:34:013 (51) : delete Removed
00:34:388 (52)-(55) : Like kantan, ttps://osu.ppy.sh/ss/3260997 follow this This rhythm is reasonable, but I'd like to keep it like this.
00:54:263 (92) : delete, same as 00:16:013 (26) Again, there are no streams in this difficulty. So no changes for any of these.
00:58:013 (101) : ^ delete
01:01:013 (109) : ^ delete
01:04:200 (117) : ^ delete
01:06:263 (122) : delete
01:09:263 (129) : delete, same as 00:16:013 (26)
01:12:450 (137) : ^ delete
01:17:700 - d k, not kdk I think my rhythm works too, so no change.
01:20:888 (156)-(158) : same as 00:08:888 (11)-(13). change to d Changed
01:22:200 (1) : spin fix to 01:22:388 same as kantan Same reason as Kantan.

i stopped modding this.

refer to other ranked maps at once.

non-sense big notes and streams make stop mod to modders -_- hehe sorry about that -.- '

edited : no kds, cuz not helpful for you and for rank

that old rule, can't 1/4 streams on futsuu
Sorry to deny so many of your suggestions. I think you misread the beat snap divisor, because I'm sure there are no streams in the first two difficulties. Also, I'll give you the kudosu. I give kudosu by seeing if you're trying to help this map get better, not by how good your mod is, or how many suggestions I took into account for, or any other reasons. If I can see that you took the time to do your best mod and it's easy enough for me to understand and try reasoning with you, I'll give you kudosu. Even if I did give kudosu based on how helpful this was for rank, this was helpful for rank to an extent.
Nishizumi
Hi o/ request from my queue

[General]

  1. Kiai time should be end at 01:04:388 - i guess
[Kantan]

  1. 00:10:200 - i think it's kinda hard to beginner, move to 00:10:388 ~ 01:11:888 ? also for little space
  2. 00:25:388 - change to d ? there have low pitch on vocal sound, also for not boring to play i guess
  3. 00:32:888 - same as above
  4. 00:47:888 - change to k ? i feel the pitch of vocal is high
  5. 01:13:200 - move to 01:13:388 ~ 01:14:888 - reason same as 00:10:200
[Futsuu]

  1. 00:09:075 - delete ? i think it's hard for futsuu player
  2. 00:10:200 - same as kantan
  3. 00:12:638 - change to d ? i think it more fit, like a kantan
  4. 00:20:138 - change to k ? i feel the sound is similar as (32)
  5. 00:20:513 - delete ? for little break
  6. 00:25:388 - change to d ? same as kantan
  7. 00:32:888 - same as above
  8. 00:38:513 - delete ? for little break
  9. 00:46:200 - delete ? or add d at muzu ?
  10. 00:47:888 - change to k ? reason same as kantan
  11. 01:13:200 - move to 01:13:388 ~ 01:14:888
[Muzukashii]

i think you must re-mapping this diff, since gap between muzu and futsuu is too big and muzu is overmapping i guess. so i won't full mod on this diff

  1. 00:24:263 - change to d ? there have low pitch on vocal sound, also for not boring to play i guess
  2. 00:25:388 - same as above
  3. 00:27:263 - ^
  4. 00:29:138 - ^
  5. 00:31:013 - same as above
  6. 00:32:888 - ^
[Oni]

  1. 00:01:388 - change volume audio to 40%
  2. 00:07:388 - too loud, change volume audio to 70%
  3. 00:10:575 - delete ? for little break
  4. 00:12:075 (39,41) - delete ? there have no sound
  5. 00:15:075 - delete, same as above
  6. 00:17:138 - ^
  7. 00:18:825 - ^
  8. 00:20:888 - change to k ? i think the pitch is higher than around
  9. 00:24:263 - change to d, same as muzu
  10. 00:25:388 - ^
  11. 00:27:263 - ^
  12. 00:29:138 - same as above
  13. 00:31:013 - ^
  14. 00:32:888 - ^
i think you must make this oni a bit easier

[Inner Oni]

  1. 00:12:731 - delete ? i think this is weird
  2. 00:24:263 - change to d ? there have low pitch on vocal sound, also for not boring to play i guess
  3. 00:25:388 - same as above
  4. 00:27:263 - ^
  5. 00:29:138 - same as above
  6. 00:31:013 - same as above
  7. 00:32:888 - ^
  8. 00:40:294 - add d ? there have sound
  9. 00:51:450 - i think bignote in end stream isn't good, delete 00:52:294 - or remove finish at 00:52:388
change SV multiplier to 1.0X in the end part, it's overlap

sorry for poor mod, hopefully it would help you. good luck for the rank :)
Topic Starter
newyams99

Nishizumi wrote:

Hi o/ request from my queue

[General]

  1. Kiai time should be end at 01:04:388 - i guess
Not too sure about this one. If two more people say so, I'll change it.

[Kantan]

  1. 00:10:200 - i think it's kinda hard to beginner, move to 00:10:388 ~ 01:11:888 ? also for little space Done
  2. 00:25:388 - change to d ? there have low pitch on vocal sound, also for not boring to play i guess :/ ok I'll just do it
  3. 00:32:888 - same as above I think I should keep this one the way it is.
  4. 00:47:888 - change to k ? i feel the pitch of vocal is high Done
  5. 01:13:200 - move to 01:13:388 ~ 01:14:888 - reason same as 00:10:200
Done

[Futsuu]

  1. 00:09:075 - delete ? i think it's hard for futsuu player I think this is reasonable for a Futsuu, since there's no change in colour. No change.
  2. 00:10:200 - same as kantan Done
  3. 00:12:638 - change to d ? i think it more fit, like a kantan Done
  4. 00:20:138 - change to k ? i feel the sound is similar as (32) Done
  5. 00:20:513 - delete ? for little break Done
  6. 00:25:388 - change to d ? same as kantan Done
  7. 00:32:888 - same as above Same as Kantan, I'd like to keep this mostly k.
  8. 00:38:513 - delete ? for little break Deleted hit at 00:37:763 instead.
  9. 00:46:200 - delete ? or add d at muzu ? Deleted, and added a d in the muzu.
  10. 00:47:888 - change to k ? reason same as kantan Done
  11. 01:13:200 - move to 01:13:388 ~ 01:14:888
Done

[Muzukashii]

i think you must re-mapping this diff, since gap between muzu and futsuu is too big and muzu is overmapping i guess. so i won't full mod on this diff Deleted some hits, changed triplets to unicolour or removed them entirely, created more short breaks.

  1. 00:24:263 - change to d ? there have low pitch on vocal sound, also for not boring to play i guess Done
  2. 00:25:388 - same as above Done
  3. 00:27:263 - ^ Done
  4. 00:29:138 - ^ Done
  5. 00:31:013 - same as above Done
  6. 00:32:888 - ^
Same reason as before, no change.

[Oni]

  1. 00:01:388 - change volume audio to 40% Oops forgot to do that :P Done
  2. 00:07:388 - too loud, change volume audio to 70% Done
  3. 00:10:575 - delete ? for little break Done
  4. 00:12:075 (39,41) - delete ? there have no sound Fair enough. Done.
  5. 00:15:075 - delete, same as above Done.
  6. 00:17:138 - ^ I think this would keep the pattern more uniform. No change.
  7. 00:18:825 - ^ Done
  8. 00:20:888 - change to k ? i think the pitch is higher than around
  9. 00:24:263 - change to d, same as muzu Done
  10. 00:25:388 - ^ Done
  11. 00:27:263 - ^ Done
  12. 00:29:138 - same as above Done
  13. 00:31:013 - ^ Done
  14. 00:32:888 - ^
No change. Instead, changed a hit at 00:33:075 to d.

i think you must make this oni a bit easier :o Sorry I'll try to make it easier, but then the Inner Oni will be way to hard compared to the Oni.

[Inner Oni]

  1. 00:12:731 - delete ? i think this is weird Done
  2. 00:24:263 - change to d ? there have low pitch on vocal sound, also for not boring to play i guess Done
  3. 00:25:388 - same as above Done
  4. 00:27:263 - ^ Done
  5. 00:29:138 - same as above Done
  6. 00:31:013 - same as above Done
  7. 00:32:888 - ^ No Change. Instead, changed a hit at 00:33:075 to d.
  8. 00:40:294 - add d ? there have sound Done
  9. 00:51:450 - i think bignote in end stream isn't good, delete 00:52:294 - or remove finish at 00:52:388
Removed finisher

change SV multiplier to 1.0X in the end part, it's overlap Will do for this diff and previous two diffs

sorry for poor mod, hopefully it would help you. good luck for the rank :)
This mod wasn't poor at all -_- This really helped make the map easier :D thanks for the mod. Helps a lot 8-)
Raiden
Hi, from M4M request.

[Kantan]

  1. 00:37:013 (36,38) - probably a good idea to turn it into d's here to simplify the patterns
  2. 00:39:638 (40) - consider removing this for a small break
  3. 00:46:388 (46) - I'd go for a k here to fit the pitch a bit, but I guess it's personal opinion :p
  4. 01:02:888 (63) - I suggest turning it into a d to simplify the pattern
  5. 01:17:888 (79) - I see you only put d here in Kantan. It can be turned to k for consistency.

    That's all for this difficulty
[Futsuu]

  1. 00:17:888 (30) - Hmmm.. I think it would fit just fine in 00:18:075 -
  2. 00:46:388 (46) - Same than in Kantan
  3. 01:19:013 (149,150) - Consider removing those 2 for a small break

    Nothing else, pretty good diff overall
[Muzukashii]

  1. 00:12:825 - Consider adding a d here, to keep the flow
  2. 00:14:138 (36) - I'd move it to 00:14:325 - and change it to k
  3. 00:19:575 (53,54,55) - These 3 fit the pitch of a k rather than a d in my opinion, but again,
    personal preference I guess. Also, consider removing one or two notes on that pattern for a break.
  4. 00:37:388 (92,93,94) - My suggestion on how to handle these 3 is the following:

  5. 00:58:950 (159) - I suggest removing the note for a small break
  6. 01:12:075 (206,207,208,209,210,211,212) - you can extend this pattern to k d d k k d k and remove
    the final nonte since I don't hear anything there. Like this:
[Oni]

  • At the kiai sometimes you end some patterns with "d k" and others with "k d", even if they sound
    basically the same. Is this intentional?

    Apart from that, not much to say about this difficulty. Good fitting patterns. Very well done.
[Inner Oni]

  1. 00:21:638 (106,107,108,109,110,111,112,113,114) - I'd rather go for a stream like

  2. 00:38:138 (163,164,165,166,167) - kkddk instead of kkddd? It sounds nice as well
  3. 00:53:325 (251,252,253,254,255) - dkddk instead of dkddd?
  4. 01:03:263 (315) - Consider starting the 1/3 stream with k instead, so it ends up being
    kddkddkddkddk, which (in my opinion) fits better the part.
  5. 01:20:231 (429) - My suggestion: remove this note. I know it's an Inner oni, but I think it's a
    better idea to split this stream in 2 different patterns.
  6. 01:20:325 (429,430,431,432,433) - Consider kkddk instead of kkddd (in case you accepted the
    suggestion above ^).


That's pretty much it, there isn't any crazy thing I've seen, however some patterns can be
improved in to fit a bit more the rhyhtm.

Other than that, very well done. You'll have no problem ranking this.

regarding M4M
Considering the song is only 1 minute and 5 difficulties, feel free to only mod 1 difficulty from my song

GOOD LUCK WITH THE RANK!
Topic Starter
newyams99

Raiden wrote:

Hi, from M4M request.

[Kantan]

  1. 00:37:013 (36,38) - probably a good idea to turn it into d's here to simplify the patterns Done
  2. 00:39:638 (40) - consider removing this for a small break Done
  3. 00:46:388 (46) - I'd go for a k here to fit the pitch a bit, but I guess it's personal opinion :p Done
  4. 01:02:888 (63) - I suggest turning it into a d to simplify the pattern Done
  5. 01:17:888 (79) - I see you only put d here in Kantan. It can be turned to k for consistency. Done

    That's all for this difficulty
[Futsuu]

  1. 00:17:888 (30) - Hmmm.. I think it would fit just fine in 00:18:075 - I see what you're getting at, but when I tried it, it sounded a bit weird if I didn't put another hit where the moved hit used to be, and that would probably be too hard.
  2. 00:46:388 (46) - Same than in Kantan Oops :P done
  3. 01:19:013 (149,150) - Consider removing those 2 for a small break Done

    Nothing else, pretty good diff overall
[Muzukashii]

  1. 00:12:825 - Consider adding a d here, to keep the flow Done
  2. 00:14:138 (36) - I'd move it to 00:14:325 - and change it to k hmmm I'll see what other people have to say about that. I think it's too difficult.
  3. 00:19:575 (53,54,55) - These 3 fit the pitch of a k rather than a d in my opinion, but again,
    personal preference I guess. Also, consider removing one or two notes on that pattern for a break. No change with hit, but removed hit at 00:19:575.
  4. 00:37:388 (92,93,94) - My suggestion on how to handle these 3 is the following:
    Makes sense, but I don't want to make it too hard, especially at places where it's not the kiai time.
  5. 00:58:950 (159) - I suggest removing the note for a small break Done
  6. 01:12:075 (206,207,208,209,210,211,212) - you can extend this pattern to k d d k k d k and remove
    the final nonte since I don't hear anything there. Like this:
Again, I think this is too hard x.x sorry. And the hit at 01:13:388 matches the instrumentals so I think I should keep it.

[Oni]

  • At the kiai sometimes you end some patterns with "d k" and others with "k d", even if they sound
    basically the same. Is this intentional? Yes, some of these are matched more towards the instrumentals, while the others to the vocals.

    Apart from that, not much to say about this difficulty. Good fitting patterns. Very well done.
thx. It's all thanks to modders.

[Inner Oni]

  1. 00:21:638 (106,107,108,109,110,111,112,113,114) - I'd rather go for a stream like
    Fair enough. Done.
  2. 00:38:138 (163,164,165,166,167) - kkddk instead of kkddd? It sounds nice as well Done
  3. 00:53:325 (251,252,253,254,255) - dkddk instead of dkddd? I wanted the hit at 00:53:700 to contrast more with the next hit where it matches the instrumentals. No Change.
  4. 01:03:263 (315) - Consider starting the 1/3 stream with k instead, so it ends up being
    kddkddkddkddk, which (in my opinion) fits better the part. That pattern is possible, but keeping it a d will help match the vocals imo. No change.
  5. 01:20:231 (429) - My suggestion: remove this note. I know it's an Inner oni, but I think it's a
    better idea to split this stream in 2 different patterns. Yea that sounds better. Done.
  6. 01:20:325 (429,430,431,432,433) - Consider kkddk instead of kkddd (in case you accepted the
    suggestion above ^).
Done

That's pretty much it, there isn't any crazy thing I've seen, however some patterns can be
improved in to fit a bit more the rhyhtm.

Other than that, very well done. You'll have no problem ranking this.

regarding M4M
Considering the song is only 1 minute and 5 difficulties, feel free to only mod 1 difficulty from my song

GOOD LUCK WITH THE RANK!
I will still mod all the difficulties, since this M4M was initiated by me.

Thanks for the mod :D
Nitrousdragon
I dunno, Kantan and Futsuu look fine to me. Great map! :)
Topic Starter
newyams99

Nitrousdragon wrote:

I dunno, Kantan and Futsuu look fine to me. Great map! :)
Sounds good to me xD
Volta
Hi, a random pick mod :)

Muzukashii
00:01:763 (2) - move to 00:02:513
00:13:013 (32,33,34) - change to dkd
00:14:513 (38) - k
00:18:075 add k here
00:18:638 (51) - k
00:19:013 (52,53,54) - change to kdk
00:21:075 (60) - move to 00:21:825
00:28:388 (75) - swap with 00:29:138 (76)
00:33:638 (83) - k because it sounds like clap
00:35:513 (88) - ^
00:39:263 (98,99,100) - kkd
00:42:450 add k
00:43:950 ^
00:43:763 - 00:46:388 it doesn't sounds right. i suggest you change it like this https://www.imageupload.co.uk/images/2015/06/20/e.png
00:53:513 add k and change 00:53:888 (143) - into d
00:56:513 add k and change 00:56:888 (154) - into d
00:55:763 (151,152,153) - kkd
00:57:263 (155) - k
00:58:763 (162) - ^
01:01:575 (170,171) - swap
00:59:700 - add d?
01:05:138 (185) - k

Oni
00:18:638 (71) - k
00:37:763 (133,134,135,136,137,138) - ctrl +G
00:42:263 (150) - you can change it to k and move it here 00:42:450
01:02:513 (249,250) - swap
01:05:138 (261,262) - ^
01:05:700 (264,265,266) - kkd

inner oni
00:08:325 (24,25,26,27,28) - change to ddkkk, i think it flows better
00:10:013 (34,35,36,37,38) - ddkkd for this
00:10:763 (40) - k
00:18:638 (87,88,89) - should be kdk
00:33:638 (136,137) - add finish?
00:36:825 - 00:38:888 i think you're a little overmapped at this area. i suggest you to remap this part
00:39:263 (171,172) - swap
00:39:825 (174,175,176) - ddk
00:40:575 (180) - change to d and swap this --> 00:40:950 (182,183)
00:51:919 (242) - change to d and change 00:52:106 (244) - to k
00:55:763 to 00:56:888 - change into like this https://www.imageupload.co.uk/images/2015/06/20/f.png
01:03:263 (315) - k

i think that's all. hope its helpful. Good luck.
Topic Starter
newyams99

Flying Pan wrote:

Hi, a random pick mod :)

Muzukashii
00:01:763 (2) - move to 00:02:513 Done
00:13:013 (32,33,34) - change to dkd Done
00:14:513 (38) - k Done
00:18:075 add k here Done, removed hit at 00:18:263 to make it sound better.
00:18:638 (51) - k I think it's fine as a d
00:19:013 (52,53,54) - change to kdk No change
00:21:075 (60) - move to 00:21:825 Done
00:28:388 (75) - swap with 00:29:138 (76) No change
00:33:638 (83) - k because it sounds like clap No change
00:35:513 (88) - ^ Done
00:39:263 (98,99,100) - kkd Done
00:42:450 add k I think I'll just keep it to the vocals here
00:43:950 ^ Done
00:43:763 - 00:46:388 it doesn't sounds right. i suggest you change it like this https://www.imageupload.co.uk/images/2015/06/20/e.png hmmm this one's very matched to the instrumentals. Change it a bit.
00:53:513 add k and change 00:53:888 (143) - into d Makes sense, but I'd like to have a fairly large break there.
00:56:513 add k and change 00:56:888 (154) - into d Added a d instead. I personally like that better.
00:55:763 (151,152,153) - kkd Done
00:57:263 (155) - k No change, I matched this hit with the instrumentals here rather than the vocals.
00:58:763 (162) - ^ No change, hits 162 and 163 need emphasis with the k.
01:01:575 (170,171) - swap I think it can go either way. No change.
00:59:700 - add d? Following the vocals precisely here.
01:05:138 (185) - k Done


Oni
00:18:638 (71) - k I think it's fine as a d.
00:37:763 (133,134,135,136,137,138) - ctrl +G Done
00:42:263 (150) - you can change it to k and move it here 00:42:450 Done
01:02:513 (249,250) - swap Pitch goes up in these two hits. no change.
01:05:138 (261,262) - ^ I think it's fine the way it is. No change.
01:05:700 (264,265,266) - kkd Done

inner oni
00:08:325 (24,25,26,27,28) - change to ddkkk, i think it flows better Done
00:10:013 (34,35,36,37,38) - ddkkd for this No change.
00:10:763 (40) - k Matching with instrumentals, no change to put more emphasis on pitch change on hit 41.
00:18:638 (87,88,89) - should be kdk Done
00:33:638 (136,137) - add finish? Maybe a bit too loud for a relatively quiet section. idk.
00:36:825 - 00:38:888 i think you're a little overmapped at this area. i suggest you to remap this part Yeah, Removed hits 164 and 166.
00:39:263 (171,172) - swap Done
00:39:825 (174,175,176) - ddk Done
00:40:575 (180) - change to d and swap this --> 00:40:950 (182,183) Done
00:51:919 (242) - change to d and change 00:52:106 (244) - to k I guess that works, but it's boring :P Will change if someone says so again.
00:55:763 to 00:56:888 - change into like this https://www.imageupload.co.uk/images/2015/06/20/f.png Done
01:03:263 (315) - k Done

i think that's all. hope its helpful. Good luck.
Thanks for the mod :D
Kankri
from modding queue


[General]


General things on this map looks rankable. ;)



[Kantan]


00:37:388 (37) - k

01:16:388 (76) - D


[Futsuu]


00:32:888 (49) - d

01:10:388 (130) - D



[Muzukashii]


00:44:513 (113) - k

01:11:325 (204) - ^

01:20:138 (235) - ^



[Oni]


00:16:200 (59) - k

Rest of this diff looks fine. :D



[Inner Oni]


01:11:513 (374) - k




This map really looks good, GL on this map! :)
Topic Starter
newyams99

Kasha wrote:

from modding queue


[General]


General things on this map looks rankable. ;)



[Kantan]


00:37:388 (37) - k Done

01:16:388 (76) - D I like it without a finisher.


[Futsuu]


00:32:888 (49) - d No change, I'd have to change it for every difficulty too.

01:10:388 (130) - D Inconsistent with other hits. No change.



[Muzukashii]


00:44:513 (113) - k Done

01:11:325 (204) - ^ Changed hit 203 to k instead.

01:20:138 (235) - ^ Done



[Oni]


00:16:200 (59) - k I like it as a d. no change

Rest of this diff looks fine. :D



[Inner Oni]


01:11:513 (374) - k I want to put more contrast between the vocals here. No change.




This map really looks good, GL on this map! :)
Thanks for your mod :D
show more
Please sign in to reply.

New reply