this isn't game-breaking or anything but i don't think these sliders are supposed to have a sliderbody sound playing on them
06:02:134 (4) - (hitwhistle on sliderbody)
06:19:793 (1) - (drum sampleset on sliderbody)
D:
was looking through the entire mapset out of curiosity after the veto (just as many others do ig lol) when i noticed this :
why the perfect stacks? ngl i feel like they are *really* being out of place here as
it's as if the perfect stacks simply exist for... the sake of having perfect stacks in the map :(
hey there, i was curious of the map as it was being discussed elsewhere and just like many others i found out that the "lack of meaningful contrast" point in the veto is over-exaggerated and the map altogether to be fine. however, i do have to agree with Mirash here (345782#4680723/12439398) that the part around 02:53:382 - could really use a nerf in order to not over-exert the players during this down period.
not by much tho, in fact i'd just apply these three without changing the sv or remapping too much :
02:52:932 (3) - delete this circle
02:56:982 (5) - delete this circle
02:57:582 (3) - turn this slider into a circle
this would provide the much-discussed "contrast" to the section (through changes in rhythm density) without the need of anything radical as the veto implied as once again, i think the map is fine as is.
of course this is just a suggestion and feel free to close this if you don't feel like changing this („• ֊ •„)
yeah i don't think this is a problem (if at all)
if it indeed is a problem then it shouldn't be something that the mapper/the bns need to worry about i suppose, as it's *waaaay* outside of their scope
it's all down to peppy/the team if they choose to block this but i doubt that they will even remotely touch this lol
@takaneko your concern is fair, but that's... not really the map's fault lol. nor it is within the mapper's responsibility to fix the system.
if you feel like the warning isn't verbose enough, feel free to tell the people who are actually responsible for it (the developers) in places such as the Feature Requests forum! otherwise, please do not derail the conversation with complaints that are out of scope of the map.
as already said above, let's just wait for what the mapper has to say for now before moving forward.
(or if you want to contribute to the discussion, please make sure that it stays on-topic, ty! 🧙♂️)
yo guys this should be obvious but please don't clutter the thread with spam replies ty 🏂
---
that being said however, having played the map myself...
i don't think that the map feels "disconnected" from the song at all, nor is there anything overarching in it by any means. this is especially true when you went out from this sort of microscopic examination and actually give the map a go from start to finish.
(i do think independently of your mod that these two calmer sections 00:01:327 - and 02:58:169 - could be made more rhythmically active though, in a sense that they could use a little bit more circles and less sliders.)
---
i guess Arsalan has pointed out what i wanted to say quite well — looking at your mod, it seems that you have trapped yourself into thinking that "everything at any given time has to be 1:1 with whatever sound is playing".
this is very dangerous because a)) not only that this couldn't be further away from the truth, as you can see from the other replies here already b)) this way of thinking often leads to a personal discourse where you're starting to see completely harmless things that are considered fine by the rest of the community, be it players or other mappers alike, as a problem.
(in reality though, they're only a problem if you *really* want to see them as a problem.)
to quote Deca, "map the song, not the sounds in the song".
---
for now, let's just wait for the mapper to reply.
uhh there has been a mistake here i guess, i hitsounded this diff myself (http://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/2158109) but it looks like wrn81056398 forgot to upload the one file that i gave him in discord back then and went on to copy the top diff's hs instead D:
i'll just talk to him and give the file again i suppose... 😔