forum

Akhuta - Virga Gigantum [Taiko]

posted
Total Posts
32
Topic Starter
Nyan
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2017년 7월 9일 일요일 at 오후 4:51:43

Artist: Akhuta
Title: Virga Gigantum
Source: GITADORA
BPM: 178
Filesize: 2854kb
Play Time: 01:45
Difficulties Available:
  1. Futsuu (2.18 stars, 237 notes)
  2. Inner Oni (6.03 stars, 950 notes)
  3. Kantan (1.46 stars, 145 notes)
  4. Lite Oni (3.6 stars, 620 notes)
  5. Muzukashii (2.84 stars, 381 notes)
  6. Oni (4.51 stars, 787 notes)
Download: Akhuta - Virga Gigantum
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
7/18 MP3 CHANGED. PLEASE REDOWNLOAD THIS MAP
7/23 MP3 CHANGED. PLEASE REDOWNLOAD THIS MAP(I hope this is last mp3 change)
4/02 BG RESIZED.
7/27/2016 added [Inner Muzukashii] -> [Lite Oni]

[Thanks for modding!]
xtrem3x, TwilightForest, Raiden, Backstep, [_Chichinya_], - Love1yV1ruS -, BrainBurst, shionelove, NlHIL, Volta, Kasha, Ayyri, Invective, Grimbow, Ulqui
xtrem3x
Mod request via Simple Taiko Modding Queue

________________________________________________________________________

General:

Hitsound Volume in 80%, is better imo (?)

Reduce mp3 to 192kbps or Take This

Diffs Kantan, Futsuu and Muzukashii can change name to Kantan+, Futsuu+ and Muzukashii+ ? ... for notify diffs more harder than usual .-.
Kantan is Easier comparing Futsuu and spreads in other diffs...

Don: d
Kat: k
Big don: D
Big kat: K

________________________________________________________________________

Kantan:

GOOD

________________________________________________________________________

Futsuu:

00:27:146 - kk dd -> dd kk

00:31:864 - Change to k (monotone sequence)
00:37:257 - same

01:30:740 - Change to d (is high but notes 101-102 are highter)
01:30:965 - Same

________________________________________________________________________

Muzukashii:

00:03:550 - Change to k (or is intentional this broken sequence?)

00:22:876 - Change to d (your sequence have few variations and this point no change)
00:23:550 - Same
00:23:663 - Same

00:22:988 - ctrl+g with next note

01:23:324 - Change to k (high sound)

01:25:852 - ctrl+g with next note
01:28:549 - same

________________________________________________________________________

Oni:

Change to Nyan's Taiko or a custom name ...(?)

HP=6 is better

00:23:438 - ddkdd -> ddkkd (is more possible this)
01:45:234 - same (?)

________________________________________________________________________

TwilightForest
Muzukashii
00:01:359 (11,15) - they can be k, IMO sounds better
00:25:629 (187,188,189) - maybe k?

Other:
I'm really NOT sure that doublets like 00:45:459 (105,106,107,108,109,110) and more can be
in Muzukashii at 1/4 . It's so fast for Muzu players... and so dynamic!

Oni:
00:09:618 (94) - should be k
00:32:650 (27) - ^
00:55:515 (239) - you can make this k
01:44:560 (655,656) - you really should swap them (check 'em then press ctrl + g), IMO sounds much better.

Anyway, I like this background!

Good luck, I hope my mod was useful for you!
Topic Starter
Nyan

xtrem3x wrote:

Reduce mp3 to 192kbps or Take This Thanks! My foobar2000 doesn't give me 192kbps mp3

Futsuu:

00:27:146 - kk dd -> d acceped!
________________________________________________________________________

Muzukashii:

01:23:324 - Change to k (high sound) accepted!

TwilightForest wrote:

Muzukashii
00:01:359 (11,15) - they can be k, IMO sounds better accepted!

SV multiplier on 267 BPM part reduced to 0.9x (on Muzukashii)
Thanks for modding!
Raiden
Hai, from my queue \:D/


[General]
  1. Audio bitrate. You can use this webpage for the video and select 192 kbps or lower when converting the file
  2. Difficulty spread doesn't seem quite right at all. Oni isn't supposed to be that difficult. Consider making a proper Oni and rename the actual one to Inner/Ura
  3. No tags?
  4. Consider SV 1.2 in Kantan and Futsuu
[ Kantan]
  1. HP2 is not a good idea for a such low note density, consider making it higher
  2. OD4 in kantan seems a bit too high
  3. Sounds better if you remove 00:00:854 (2) - and move 00:01:528 (2) - to 00:01:022 - I think
  4. 00:46:246 (22,23,24,25) - Consider monocouloring them as they can be confusing for newer players

    Other than that, pretty good diff.
[ Futsuu]
  1. HP should be higher
  2. OD3 would be better for a futsuu i think
  3. 00:22:427 (62,63,64,65,66,67,68) - Some of this notes could be removed without altering the rhythm
  4. 01:23:830 (77) - can be turned into a k since to simplify the pattern
  5. 01:29:223 (94) - Same
  6. 01:43:550 (135,136,137,138,139,140,141,142,143,144) - same reason I stated above, some notes can be removed without altering the rhythm
[ Muzu]

Uhhh.. this is not easy for me to say, but I think you overdid this difficulty a lot... you kinda screw up the spread starting from here. I'd say a remap or even just a reduced note density overall.


[ Oni]

Spread is seriously screwed up at this point, I'd say reduce the note density of this to make a proper spread-wise Oni or rename it to Inner and make an Oni to act as a bridge between Muzu and Inner.


Sorry about the 2 later difficulties but I don't think they fit the ranking criteria. Might come back for another check (for no kd) if you do make the difficulty spread appropiate.

Might wanna check this post for more information regarding spreading
Backstep
From your queue that why I am here o3o

General

- What the 267 bpm? I suggest you remove this timing section and use green timing section to increase speed instead! (since it's all 178 bpm in this song)
- Overall... Futsuu, Muzukashii and Oni difficulties gap too high I think... and can break ranking criteria.
I suggest like this...
Kantan = 1.46
? for Futsuu = around 2.00 - 2.25
Change Futsuu to Muzukashii and make it a bit hard? = around 2.80 - 3.20
Change Muzukashii to Oni and make a bit hard = around 3.75 - 4.15
? for Inner Oni = around 4.50 - 5.10
And change your Oni to Ura would be okay!
- So you need to make new Futsuu and Inner Oni to make difficulty spread more balance~ DON'T GIVE UP!!! \:D/

Kantan
HP+1 OD-1 and use 1.2 SV (since it's fast song.)
00:03:588 (5,6) - ctrl+G here? I think swap k it's fit high pitch of think song imo.
00:05:274 (7) - Change to d to look be better and fit more?
00:22:465 (24,25) - Change to d
00:23:813 (26,27) - If you fix above change these notes to k to fit guitar freak sound :3

Futsuu (prepare to Muzukashii.)
* for your new Futsuu diff make sure you don't put any 1/6 notes + try not use 1/4 often, use 1.2 SV and setting HP 4 OD 3 it's look be okay.
00:07:184 (22) - Add note with d in this time (1/6)
00:07:409 (23) - Same above.
00:07:633 (24) - Change to K to fitting guitar freak.
00:10:498 (30) - Add note with d
00:13:364 (40) - ^
00:14:038 (42) - Change to k for high pitch sound.
00:15:217 (46) - Change to d here
00:15:555 (48) - If you fixed above add k here.
00:16:060 (50) - Add note with d.
00:19:431 (60) - Change to k for high pitch sound.
00:20:611 (64) - Change to d like my previous pattern
00:20:948 (66) - Add this with k like above reason.
00:30:048 (2) - Add note with d here to make a bit hard?
00:31:396 (7) - ^
00:32:745 (12) - ^
00:34:093 (17) - ^
00:35:441 (22) - ^
00:36:790 (27) - ^
00:38:138 (32) - ^
00:39:486 (37) - ^
01:00:441 (4) - You can add slider here and end at 01:00:946 to fit guitar sound c: (since 01:04:486 (13) - you use this pattern)
01:01:789 (8) - Same above reason.
01:03:137 (12) - ^
01:05:834 (17) - ^
01:07:182 (21) - ^
01:08:531 (25) - ^
01:12:239 (38) - Change to d
01:12:407 (39) - Add note with k
01:12:576 (40) - change to k
01:12:744 (41) - Add note with d
01:13:081 (43) - Change to k
01:13:587 (41) - Change to d
01:13:755 (42) - Add note with k
01:13:924 (43) - Change to k
01:14:093 (44) - Add note with d
01:15:104 (49) - ^
01:15:441 (51) - Add note with k
... after that you can repeat your pattern c:
01:22:520 (78) - Add note?
01:23:194 (81) - ^
01:24:205 (86) - ^
01:24:542 (88) - ^
01:25:216 (91) - ^
01:25:890 (94) - ^
... after that you can repeat your pattern.

For other difficulty I can't mod sorry ;w;

Good luck with your map!
Topic Starter
Nyan

Raiden wrote:

[*]Consider SV 1.2 in Kantan and Futsuu Changed on Kantan

[ Kantan]
HP2 is not a good idea for a such low note density, consider making it higher Changed
OD4 in kantan seems a bit too high Changed

Backstep wrote:

- What the 267 bpm? I suggest you remove this timing section and use green timing section to increase speed instead! (since it's all 178 bpm in this song)
I follow official GITADORA bpm. You can see bpm changes here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PvNE5I8-fds


Kantan
HP+1 OD-1 and use 1.2 SV (since it's fast song.) Changed

Futsuu (prepare to Muzukashii.)
* for your new Futsuu diff make sure you don't put any 1/6 notes + try not use 1/4 often, use 1.2 SV and setting HP 4 OD 3 it's look be okay.
00:07:184 (22) - Add note with d in this time (1/6)
00:07:409 (23) - Same above.
00:07:633 (24) - Change to K to fitting guitar freak.
00:10:498 (30) - Add note with d
00:13:364 (40) - ^
00:14:038 (42) - Change to k for high pitch sound.
00:15:217 (46) - Change to d here
00:15:555 (48) - If you fixed above add k here.
00:16:060 (50) - Add note with d.
00:19:431 (60) - Change to k for high pitch sound.
00:20:611 (64) - Change to d like my previous pattern
00:20:948 (66) - Add this with k like above reason.
00:30:048 (2) - Add note with d here to make a bit hard?
00:31:396 (7) - ^
00:32:745 (12) - ^
00:34:093 (17) - ^
00:35:441 (22) - ^
00:36:790 (27) - ^
00:38:138 (32) - ^
00:39:486 (37) - ^
01:00:441 (4) - You can add slider here and end at 01:00:946 to fit guitar sound c: (since 01:04:486 (13) - you use this pattern)
01:01:789 (8) - Same above reason.
01:03:137 (12) - ^
01:05:834 (17) - ^
01:07:182 (21) - ^
01:08:531 (25) - ^
01:12:239 (38) - Change to d
01:12:407 (39) - Add note with k
01:12:576 (40) - change to k
01:12:744 (41) - Add note with d
01:13:081 (43) - Change to k
01:13:587 (41) - Change to d
01:13:755 (42) - Add note with k
01:13:924 (43) - Change to k
01:14:093 (44) - Add note with d
01:15:104 (49) - ^
01:15:441 (51) - Add note with k
... after that you can repeat your pattern c:
01:22:520 (78) - Add note?
01:23:194 (81) - ^
01:24:205 (86) - ^
01:24:542 (88) - ^
01:25:216 (91) - ^
01:25:890 (94) - ^
... after that you can repeat your pattern.

I will try this to reduce difficulty of present Muzukashii. Thanks.
Shinsekai-
\o HI M4M req by me

let's beging

[General]
Well that oni is very difficult to be an one ... that cna be Inner Oni and you can create one diff more Ez to be Oni i guess (is most recomendable)



[Kantan]

-change this to k 00:33:250 (6) -
- ^ 00:39:318 (15) -
- change to d 01:00:441 (2,4) -
- ^ 01:05:834 (10,12) -
- change the beat divisor and this pls put this slider in the line 01:04:486 (8) - , 01:26:733 (47) -

[Futsuu]

- ctrl + g 00:06:116 (18,20) -
- for add this 2 notes ( 00:07:184 (22,23) - ) put the beat divisor to 1/3 sound better i guess ( 00:07:409 (23) - k)
- change to d 00:12:521 (36) -
- change to k 00:37:295 (23,24) -
- to k 00:49:318 (64) -
- to d 00:51:845 (72) -
- to d 00:55:215 (84) -
- to k 01:09:711 (25) -
- to d 01:10:722 (29) -

[Muzukashii]

- change to d 00:03:588 (29) -
- to K 00:07:633 (57) -

[Oni]

- this to k 00:12:184 (121) -
- chaneg this to d 00:12:352 (123,126,127) -


[Coments]

Well this is a cool map and cool song very nice :D but the only problem is the oni XD change the name to Inner is better because Oni is more EZ than Inner XD, The oni can be 5stars max no 6 :c inner can be 6,7,8, etc ;D! well for finish this Good luck with your wonderful map :D!
Topic Starter
Nyan

[_Chichinya_] wrote:

[Kantan]

-change this to k 00:33:250 (6) - Done
- ^ 00:39:318 (15) - Done
- change to d 01:00:441 (2,4) - Changed first one
- ^ 01:05:834 (10,12) - Changed first one
- change the beat divisor and this pls put this slider in the line 01:04:486 (8) - , 01:26:733 (47) - Done

[Futsuu]

- change to k 00:37:295 (23,24) - Done
- to k 00:49:318 (64) - Done

[Muzukashii]

no changes.

[Oni]

no changes.
I will try to make Oni
- Love1yV1ruS -
Hi from virus's modding queue.

Inner oni is suuuuuuuper hard.. XD. By the way i see some authentic taiko style(2000 series) in this inner oni. i wont mod this inner oni cuz my current skill doesnt allow me to handle such diff XD.

Oni
00:00:555 (4) - k? sound here is higher than 00:00:892 (7) -
00:10:161 (80) - delete this k? there might need a seperate.
00:53:783 (176) - k. the music rise up here, use a k to show the different from the former stream.

Muzukashii
00:22:465 (152,153,154,155,156,157,158,159,160,161,162,163,164) - eh, just my suggestion, since this is a speedchange part and this diff is muzu, set all the notes to d to make it more friendly?
00:23:588 (162,163) - delete this two note. make a space for newbies to breath.
00:43:138 (90) - change this k to d and move it to 00:43:250? two continuous even number notes is very unfriendly imo...
01:43:588 (464,465,466,467,468,469,470,471,472,473,474,475,476,477,478,479,480,481,482,483,484,485) - same as before.

Futsuu
01:30:441 (98) - move this d to 01:30:357 and add d at 01:30:525. i don think it is overhard for a futsuu diff.
and... that's it. well done

Very interesting and challenging map! Good luck! :)
Topic Starter
Nyan

- Love1yV1ruS - wrote:

[Muzukashii]
00:22:465 (152,153,154,155,156,157,158,159,160,161,162,163,164) - eh, just my suggestion, since this is a speedchange part and this diff is muzu, set all the notes to d to make it more friendly?
00:23:588 (162,163) - delete this two note. make a space for newbies to breath. partially changed. like below

01:43:588 (464,465,466,467,468,469,470,471,472,473,474,475,476,477,478,479,480,481,482,483,484,485) - same as before. changed like below
Thanks for modding :)
Canner_old
Hi, from my queue.

don=d
kat=k
DON=D
KAT=K
[Futsuu]
00:15:049 (41) - delete
00:20:442 (55) - ^
00:22:465 (62,63,64,65,66,67,68) - please delete some note advisable. they are too hard for Fustuu.
01:36:172 (113) - delete
01:41:565 (129) - ^
01:43:588 (135,136,137,138,139,140,141,142,143,144) - please delete some note advisable.

[Muzukashii]
Please recheck this is really a Muzukashii!? There are too many 1/4 even like Oni. Please delete some notes in 1/4.

[Oni]
00:26:594 (221) - k

[Inner Oni]
Nothing.

Good luck! :D
shionelove
from queue

[General]
change Signature 1/3 in 267BPM
[Futsuu]
for overall,depend on https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/152263,you should make more breaks
for example from 00:00:218 (1) - to 00:28:195 (83) - there's no breaks which are made by intention
but it seems you can't make breaks so much because of song,so i recommend reduce some 1/2
for example 00:10:667 (28,31) -
00:22:465 (62,63,64,65,66,67,68) - this is quite hard for Futsuu because they are same as 1/2 inBPM130,and 6 or more 1/2 streams are not allowed in Futsuu
maybe you will get same things when you ask BN to bubble rip
from 00:40:666 (33,34,35,36) - same,1/1 in 267=1/2 in 133.5 you know
01:43:588 (135,136,137,138,139,140,141,142,143,144) - 10 rip
[Muzu]
this also too much hard depend on https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/152263
"Stick to simple 1/4 patterns like ddd/kkk, ddk/kkd and do not overuse them."
00:12:352 (79,80,81,82,83) - from it "Same applies for 1/4 ddddd/kkkkk, but these should stand rather alone."
00:15:049 (98,99,100,101,102) - too... and etc
good luck
[Oni]
on the other hand nothing to say good
[Inner Oni]
00:08:897 (87) - delete?

actually BN always check easy diffs carefully,you should make them good especially
Oni and Inner Oni are seems fine already,good luck
Topic Starter
Nyan

shionelove wrote:

from queue

[General]
change Signature 1/3 in 267BPM accepted
[Futsuu]
for overall,depend on https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/152263,you should make more breaks
for example from 00:00:218 (1) - to 00:28:195 (83) - there's no breaks which are made by intention
but it seems you can't make breaks so much because of song,so i recommend reduce some 1/2
for example 00:10:667 (28,31) -
00:22:465 (62,63,64,65,66,67,68) - this is quite hard for Futsuu because they are same as 1/2 inBPM130,and 6 or more 1/2 streams are not allowed in Futsuu
maybe you will get same things when you ask BN to bubble rip accepted
from 00:40:666 (33,34,35,36) - same,1/1 in 267=1/2 in 133.5 you know
deleted 00:40:891 (34) , 00:43:363 (43)
01:43:588 (135,136,137,138,139,140,141,142,143,144) - 10 rip changed 01:44:261 (138,139,140) to 1/1
[Muzu]
this also too much hard depend on https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/t/152263
"Stick to simple 1/4 patterns like ddd/kkk, ddk/kkd and do not overuse them."
00:12:352 (79,80,81,82,83) - from it "Same applies for 1/4 ddddd/kkkkk, but these should stand rather alone."
00:15:049 (98,99,100,101,102) - too... and etc
good luck
no changes here

[Oni]
on the other hand nothing to say good
[Inner Oni]
00:08:897 (87) - delete?

actually BN always check easy diffs carefully,you should make them good especially
Oni and Inner Oni are seems fine already,good luck
NlHIL
[Kantan]
00:01:566 (3) - move to 00:01:397 -
00:25:161 (28) - move to 00:24:993 -
00:53:362 - 00:56:733 - add?
[Futsuu]
00:41:340 (35) - move to 00:41:453 -
00:43:138 (42) - move to 00:43:026 - as 00:41:902 (37) -
00:43:138 - I think this sound is weak enough to ignore (you often ignore this sound on this diff)
00:43:812 (44) - move to 00:43:924 -
00:45:610 (51) - absolutely move to 00:45:497 - and k
01:30:441 (98) - remove and add to 01:30:357 - and 01:30:609 -
[Muzukashii]
00:22:802 - 00:23:476 - add? It seems difficult rhythm ;w;
sorry, many rhythms seemed too difficult for me ;w;
NlHIL quit
Topic Starter
Nyan

NlHIL wrote:

[Futsuu]
00:41:340 (35) - move to 00:41:453 -
00:43:812 (44) - move to 00:43:924 -
Those are changed. Other parts are modded before so I will keep those.
Volta
[Oni]
00:48:531 ~ 00:49:992 - add inherited timing points (green line) at notes to make it gradually slow down. it's a bit overlapped with 00:50:329 -

00:30:329 (5,6) - swap
00:32:464 - add k?
00:34:149 (1,2) - swap
00:37:857 - add k?

01:16:536 (122,123) - swap. i find it strange because it is the only kdkd pattern. and kddk is fits better imo
01:43:418 ~ 01:45:946 - maybe the last stream is like this

cool oni.


[Inner Oni]
00:47:520 ~ 00:49:992 - add green lines to avoid overlap

00:30:329 (5,6) - swap
00:34:599 (45,46) - ^
00:40:104 (98) - d

01:05:076 (311,312) - swap? the guitar high

so pro.


notes: the spread between muzukashii and Oni is close because muzu has many 1/4. i think you should make an easier muzu and rename current muzu to oni, oni to inner oni, and inner to ura oni/something oni/giga oni.
Topic Starter
Nyan

Flying Pan wrote:

[Oni]
00:30:329 (5,6) - swap
This point is changed and over 70 notes are removed on Muzukashii diff.
Kankri
whats with the picture wot


[Futsuu]


01:16:621 (51) - kat


[Muzukashii]

00:34:374 (31) - kat

00:34:936 (36) - ^



[Oni]


00:30:554 (7) - kat



[Inner Oni]


Everything looks good.


GL!
Topic Starter
Nyan

Kasha wrote:

[Futsuu]


01:16:621 (51) - kat Changed.


[Muzukashii]

00:34:374 (31) - kat

00:34:936 (36) - ^



[Oni]


00:30:554 (7) - kat Changed.
Thanks for modding!
nyanmi-1828
Hi~ :) From my Queue

umm...it look good.

instead of star~><ノ ミ★
guro
As requested, I took a look at the Oni and Inner Oni, but by all means, I can't see anything that might need a change. Although there is a steep jump in star rating between Oni and Inner Oni, I would say it's because of the Inner Oni being overrated by the system. However, you can try lowering it nonetheless by going less hard on those 1/6s.
In general I agree with this down below

nyanmi-1828 wrote:

umm...it look good.

instead of star~><ノ ミ★

If you have need another map modded at some point, just PM me, I will NM it as some kind of compensation.

Good luck for rank!
Topic Starter
Nyan
Okay I am free from modding now
Topic Starter
Nyan
Update log

Kantan HP 3 -> 7
Futsuu HP 4 -> 6
Oni HP 6 -> 5
Inner Oni HP 7 -> 5
Topic Starter
Nyan

JUDYDANNY wrote:

The difficulty spread is too far gap between to Kantan~ Muzukashii.
You need add more notes on Kantan, and nerf Muzukashii.
Added new [Muzukashii] for even spread, nerfed Futsuu.
Ayyri
Hello~

NM from Bow Queue

Keep in mind, these are my suggestions, don't change something I mentioned unless it seems good to you! :)

[Futsuu]
  1. 00:24:824 - Change to k. This note has the same pitch as 00:24:150 -
  2. 00:41:115 - Move this to 00:41:453 - . It seems weird to just map something in the middle of a guitar solo, if you can't map the rest of it. Whereas moving it would make it fall at the end of that rhythm.
  3. 00:43:138 - Move to 00:43:026 - I think it makes more sense to follow the same pattern that you're following with 00:41:677 - / 00:41:902 - and 00:44:149 - / 00:44:374 -
  4. 00:43:587 - Move to 00:43:924 - Same reason as for 00:41:115 -
  5. 00:53:362 - Add a k. Why map this sound at 00:52:014 - but not at 00:53:362 - ? It sounds rather empty without it.
  6. 00:56:733 - Add a d. Same reason as above.
  7. 00:57:744 - Change to K. You already have 00:57:070 - as D, and 00:57:744 - has about the same amount of power as that note.
[Muzukashii]
  1. 00:14:712 - Remove. This note doesn't feel like it's following anything other than the drums. Yet you've mainly been following the guitar.
  2. 00:15:386 - Change to k. This note has the same sound as 00:14:880 -
  3. 00:20:105 - Same as 00:14:712 -
  4. 00:20:779 - Same as 00:15:386 -
  5. 00:25:835 - Change to k. Has the same pitch as 00:26:173 -
  6. 01:35:834 - Same as 00:14:712 -
  7. 01:36:508 - Same as 00:15:386 -
  8. 01:41:227 - Same as 00:14:712 -
  9. 01:41:902 - Same as 00:15:386 -
  10. 01:45:946 - Change to k. Has the same pitch as 01:44:935 -
Nice background, I like that artist's other works.
Fuel
M4M, sorry for delay :?

mod
There wasn't much to comment on in the higher difficulties tbh, nice set :D

Muzukashii
00:06:116 (22) - Change to d or make the pattern kd? I think that fits with pitch of the instrumental part better.
00:25:835 (94) - Change to k? Fits with the stronger drum sound compared to the following d (also lands on the instrumental sound).

Oni
01:24:626 (183) - Move to 01:24:289 to match the drum sound?

Inner Oni
01:12:154 (380) - Delete? No drum sound and in every other occurrence of this pattern in the kiai you leave this beat unmapped.
01:24:373 (485,486) - Ctrl+g? The k sounds weird on a blue tick since the drum sound doesn't occur on that tick (and the k's for the most part have been landing on the stronger drum sounds).

Hope it helps :D
Topic Starter
Nyan
applied
Grimbow
M4M time \o\ \o/ /o/

My mods are heavily based on the relation of the notes to the music, feel free to deny everything if your mapping style doesn't follow my style of modding!

d - Small don (red note)
D - Big don (red note with a finish)
k - Small kat (blue note)
K - Big kat (blue note with a finish)

Black means something that I think needs changed
Orange is just a suggestion
Blue is a comment

[General]

The Oni and Inner Oni have different preview points than the rest of the difficulties, might want to put them all on the same place

[Kantan]

00:28:532 (1) - I think this would be better suited as a slider as it is only a short held note and a short spinner might be a bit disorientating for a beginner player
00:32:576 (5) - Add finish to this note, you have one on every other cymbal crash
00:37:969 (13) - Same here, add a finish
00:46:284 (22) - This note is off center!!! please fix!!! (not unrankable but everything else is centered!)
00:58:418 (1) - Same as the first suggestion, I think this might fit better as a slider
01:04:486 (8) - I'm not sure why this slider is here however? It doesn't map anything that I can think of that would warrant a slider, so maybe putting a d at 01:04:486 - would be a better option?
01:30:104 (53) - You had a finish at 01:24:711 (44) - so you could add one here to make them consistent
01:26:059 (46) - More off-center notes!!! There are a few after these too! :(

[Futsuu]

00:22:128 (49) - Add a finish to this note, all the other cymbal crashes in this section have them
00:26:173 (58) - Change this to k, the guitar note played here is a much higher pitch than the note previous to it and this would reflect the pitch change
01:04:486 (9) - Same as in the Kantan, I'm not quite sure what this slider is for? You could add a d at 01:04:486 - and a K at 01:04:823 - to map the bends on the guitar if that is what you are following?
01:13:587 (27,28) - Ctrl+g these two notes, the guitar goes from low to high here and you have it going from k to d which is higher pitch to lower
01:17:632 (37,38) - Same here, Ctrl+g these two notes
01:18:980 (41,42) - These also, Ctrl+g them

[Muzukashii]

00:12:605 (45) - Since you already have another harder Muzukashii I think you should delete this note and make it a kkk k, that way it's not too much of a step up from the Futsuu and you can still have it in your harder version
01:12:407 (44,45) - Ctrl+g these two, the pitch of the guitar suggests you should map this as kddk as it goes from high to low then back up, it would also add some pattern variation from 01:14:767 (54,55,56,57) - which is mapped the same, but sounds different in the music
01:17:800 (69,70) - Same applies here, Ctrl+g these two notes


[Inner Muzukashii]

Maybe rename it to Ura Muzukashii?
00:46:846 (112,113) - Ctrl+g these notes, the pitch of the guitar goes from low to high and then back from high to low and this would reflect it better
00:47:857 (117,118) - Same here, except it goes from high to low and then low to high, Ctrl+g will fix it
00:50:329 (130) - The density of this part is a massive jump from the Muzukashii, you might want to remove a few of the notes in this part to make the spread a bit more even (00:50:918 (135) - Even just deleting notes like this and removing some triplets makes it a bit better)

That's all from me for now! If you want to call me back to mod the Oni and Inner Oni I can in about two weeks time maybe, sorry if this mod is a bit too short :(! All the best in getting it ranked! It's a fun set and song. :oops:
Topic Starter
Nyan

Grimbow wrote:

[General]

The Oni and Inner Oni have different preview points than the rest of the difficulties, might want to put them all on the same place

[Kantan]

00:28:532 (1) - I think this would be better suited as a slider as it is only a short held note and a short spinner might be a bit disorientating for a beginner player Changed
00:32:576 (5) - Add finish to this note, you have one on every other cymbal crash Removed Other Finishes.
00:37:969 (13) - Same here, add a finish Removed Other Finishes.
00:46:284 (22) - This note is off center!!! please fix!!! (not unrankable but everything else is centered!)
00:58:418 (1) - Same as the first suggestion, I think this might fit better as a slider Fixed.
01:04:486 (8) - I'm not sure why this slider is here however? It doesn't map anything that I can think of that would warrant a slider, so maybe putting a d at 01:04:486 - would be a better option? Deleted.
01:30:104 (53) - You had a finish at 01:24:711 (44) - so you could add one here to make them consistent Added
01:26:059 (46) - More off-center notes!!! There are a few after these too! :(

[Futsuu]

00:22:128 (49) - Add a finish to this note, all the other cymbal crashes in this section have them
00:26:173 (58) - Change this to k, the guitar note played here is a much higher pitch than the note previous to it and this would reflect the pitch change Changed.
01:04:486 (9) - Same as in the Kantan, I'm not quite sure what this slider is for? You could add a d at 01:04:486 - and a K at 01:04:823 - to map the bends on the guitar if that is what you are following? Deleted.
01:13:587 (27,28) - Ctrl+g these two notes, the guitar goes from low to high here and you have it going from k to d which is higher pitch to lower
01:17:632 (37,38) - Same here, Ctrl+g these two notes
01:18:980 (41,42) - These also, Ctrl+g them

[Muzukashii]

00:12:605 (45) - Since you already have another harder Muzukashii I think you should delete this note and make it a kkk k, that way it's not too much of a step up from the Futsuu and you can still have it in your harder version Changed
01:12:407 (44,45) - Ctrl+g these two, the pitch of the guitar suggests you should map this as kddk as it goes from high to low then back up, it would also add some pattern variation from 01:14:767 (54,55,56,57) - which is mapped the same, but sounds different in the music Changed
01:17:800 (69,70) - Same applies here, Ctrl+g these two notes Changed


[Inner Muzukashii]

Maybe rename it to Ura Muzukashii?
00:46:846 (112,113) - Ctrl+g these notes, the pitch of the guitar goes from low to high and then back from high to low and this would reflect it better Changed
00:47:857 (117,118) - Same here, except it goes from high to low and then low to high, Ctrl+g will fix it Changed
00:50:329 (130) - The density of this part is a massive jump from the Muzukashii, you might want to remove a few of the notes in this part to make the spread a bit more even (00:50:918 (135) - Even just deleting notes like this and removing some triplets makes it a bit better) Changed

That's all from me for now! If you want to call me back to mod the Oni and Inner Oni I can in about two weeks time maybe, sorry if this mod is a bit too short :(! All the best in getting it ranked! It's a fun set and song. :oops:
Ulqui
Hi!!!
from noob chilean modding queue :DD

Inner Muzukashii
Lite Oni(?

00:09:487 (54,55) - delete and 00:09:656 (54) - D

00:22:577 (139) - move to 00:22:802 -
00:23:251 (143) - move to 00:23:476 -

00:32:127 - add k?
00:37:520 - add k?

00:32:464 - add k??? (Suggestion)
00:37:857 - add k??? ^

00:46:059 - i think it sounds good with a k

01:30:272 (179,181) - delete and 01:30:357 (179) - change to k?

Oni
00:17:493 (143,145) - change to d?

00:32:464 - add k?
00:37:857 - ^?

01:10:553 - add d, it feels better

01:30:441 (226) - move to 01:30:525 -
and 01:30:272 (224,225) - Ctrl + g

This diff is really good

Sorry for the noob mod, I hope i've been helpful :c
Topic Starter
Nyan

Ulqui wrote:

[Inner Muzukashii]
Lite Oni(? Changed

00:09:487 (54,55) - delete and 00:09:656 (54) - D Changed

00:22:577 (139) - move to 00:22:802 - Changed
00:23:251 (143) - move to 00:23:476 - Changed

00:32:127 - add k? Changed
00:37:520 - add k? Changed

00:32:464 - add k??? (Suggestion)
00:37:857 - add k??? ^

00:46:059 - i think it sounds good with a k Changed

01:30:272 (179,181) - delete and 01:30:357 (179) - change to k? Changed

[Oni]
00:17:493 (143,145) - change to d?

00:32:464 - add k? Changed
00:37:857 - ^? Changed

01:10:553 - add d, it feels better Changed

01:30:441 (226) - move to 01:30:525 -
and 01:30:272 (224,225) - Ctrl + g

This diff is really good
Thanks for modding :3
BanchoBot
This modding thread has been migrated to the new "modding discussions" system. Please make sure to re-post any existing (and unresolved) efforts to the new system as required.
Please sign in to reply.

New reply