I'm actually checking maps regularly and already have over 200 mapsets I'd like to place a fav on.
forum
[added] More than 50 map favorites
posted
Total Posts
53
Topic Starter
You shouldn't play that much then
nrii_old
I think the idea of limiting the online favourites is to maintain their value. With the supply limited, seeing a mapset with hundreds of people favouriting means something. When the number of new mapsets gets sufficiently large and peppy notices, it will probably go up again.
there shouldn't be that much awesome maps thennrii wrote:
nah thats not the issue, the issue is that this would diminish what the word "favourite" means by having so many "favourites"eldnl wrote:
You shouldn't play that much then
Topic Starter
I dig a lot and check a ton of maps all the time. My favs are hardpicked from many and really deserve it. I want to support mapper with +1 fav on their map when it deserves it but there's too many awesome maps today and it feels wrong to have to pick only a few.
To be honest, there is a very low number of unranked Maps which makes attention over their Favorite number. And mostly, Maps gets after the rank the attention, aka Fav, etc.Aqo wrote:
I want to support mapper with +1 fav on their map when it deserves it but there's too many awesome maps today and it feels wrong to have to pick only a few.
peppy has all ready stated that he wants a limit on this number to make you really think about which maps are your favorites. 50 should be enough for now
EDIT:
EDIT:
peppy wrote:
I like having a limit because it makes you think about which you consider the best of the best. Sure the overall number of maps is increasing, but you could just replace the maps you consider better into your favourites list.
Pretty much this, what peppy said.
Topic Starter
The overall amount of maps is increasing A LOT lately, and there's a ton of new maps I'd like to add to my favs as an easier reference for people looking for great fun maps. You definitely need more than 50 today. More like 200-300. And this is after a ton of consideration and filtering over 4000 different playtested maps.peppy wrote:
I like having a limit because it makes you think about which you consider the best of the best. Sure the overall number of maps is increasing, but you could just replace the maps you consider better into your favourites list.
Experienced mappers are also able to produce more new extremely good maps faster, and there's quite some active experienced mappers right now.
I can't just replace one map I like for new maps I like anymore. No possible. Need a higher limit.
how many people even need 200-300 favorites. that's way more than what is needed. hell how many people have even filled up all 50 slots?
20 was already too much for me to fill to begin with. maybe my standards are too high.
and my favorites also aren't filled with hard things either. Sometimes i honestly feel like since the song is hard then it's automatically awesome, aqo. I know it's not really completely true, but yes (for example) saten's maps are good, but i would not favorite them, because they are not epically mapped and are not super epic songs.
my favorites are kinda outdated tho. and i don't really agree with what i have there lol
and my favorites also aren't filled with hard things either. Sometimes i honestly feel like since the song is hard then it's automatically awesome, aqo. I know it's not really completely true, but yes (for example) saten's maps are good, but i would not favorite them, because they are not epically mapped and are not super epic songs.
my favorites are kinda outdated tho. and i don't really agree with what i have there lol
Topic Starter
take a look at my favorites, a lot of my favs are not hard at all; I don't fav based on what is hard, I fav based on what map is beautiful and fun and I'd recommend to others. imo there's really a lot of really-good maps now and the list limit has to be extended.winber1 wrote:
and my favorites also aren't filled with hard things either. Sometimes i honestly feel like since the song is hard then it's automatically awesome, aqo. I know it's not really completely true, but yes (for example) saten's maps are good, but i would not favorite them, because they are not epically mapped and are not super epic songs.
don't know how you can say stuff like Assailant or Creator or Chinden is not epic, anyway. has amazing flow, fits the song great, looks professional and slick, everything about it is great and I can't hope for better possible maps in this game
what an annoying limit.
the songs aren't most amazing thing ever. I have taste in music i guess, but for song to be on my favorite, it has to be at a song where if I randomly find it/hear it/f2 it, i just HAVE TO PLAY IT CUZ IT'S THAT SONG... well for the most part.Aqo wrote:
don't know how you can say stuff like Assailant or Creator or Chinden is not epic, anyway. has amazing flow, fits the song great, looks professional and slick, everything about it is great and I can't hope for better possible maps in this game
Topic Starter
I guess I must be one of the very few people in this game that don't like most of the music and don't give a damn about it and only play for the maps :'s
Who cares about who favorites what map?
It makes them easier to find to play again.
What purpose does a maximum amount even remotely serve other than irritating people by not allowing them to remember fun maps outside of making a notepad document? (which is what i do, lol) Think logically people.
It makes them easier to find to play again.
What purpose does a maximum amount even remotely serve other than irritating people by not allowing them to remember fun maps outside of making a notepad document? (which is what i do, lol) Think logically people.
Just use Favourites A/B instead of Online Favs?Unkind wrote:
Who cares about who favorites what map?
It makes them easier to find to play again.
What purpose does a maximum amount even remotely serve other than irritating people by not allowing them to remember fun maps outside of making a notepad document? (which is what i do, lol) Think logically people.
If I would fav Beatmaps because of the Music, my List would go around +500.Aqo wrote:
I guess I must be one of the very few people in this game that don't like most of the music and don't give a damn about it and only play for the maps :'s
Topic Starter
Well I'm already using notepad documentation like Unkind said for my own listing. I just don't understand why the site limit is restricted. Sharing fun maps through fav'ing them is important in helping those maps get approved, too, by making other people notice them and spread the attention to them.Luna wrote:
Just use Favourites A/B instead of Online Favs?
Feels like 50 songs is a bit to much would be hard to find with all those beatmaps in there.
I just save the beatmaps that i enjoy at the moment and clear them out after i'm done with them.
I just save the beatmaps that i enjoy at the moment and clear them out after i'm done with them.
lol I only have one.
I don't understand why you would need so many. Do you really adore more than 50 beatmaps so much?
There's always favourites A and B.
I don't understand why you would need so many. Do you really adore more than 50 beatmaps so much?
There's always favourites A and B.
Works fine for ranked maps, but when editing the map (Pending/WIP), it'll disappear :Vtheowest wrote:
lol I only have one.
I don't understand why you would need so many. Do you really adore more than 50 beatmaps so much?
There's always favourites A and B.
I stopped adding favorites after 20 because the old limit (then accidentally removed favorites while mis-tapping on my smart-phone lol)
I didn't even know the limit was set to 50 (yes, shame on me)
One weird thing is that you can add your own submitted maps to favorites
the list is fine for now imo.50 maps is a lot, I think you should be happy with that.
peppy wrote:
I like having a limit because it makes you think about which you consider the best of the best. Sure the overall number of maps is increasing, but you could just replace the maps you consider better into your favourites list.
I guess more to the point is what do we use online favourites for? If it is as I intended (to let other players know what you like) then it should be limited; noone is going to sit and read a list of 1,000 maps.
Topic Starter
bump
50 maps isn't a lot anymore
it used to be a lot a year ago maybe. but the amount of experienced and active mappers has exponentially grown as of late and not only that a lot more maps are being submitted but also a lot more of them are great quality maps that stand far on top of the majority/rest.
Please increase the limit to at least 200 to be more relevant for today's amount of beatmap sets. This doesn't hurt anybody and it's as easy to implement as changing one constant number somewhere, so why not
deadbeat edit: I'm not going to deny this. this will mostly likely be added at a later date. but not yet.
50 maps isn't a lot anymore
it used to be a lot a year ago maybe. but the amount of experienced and active mappers has exponentially grown as of late and not only that a lot more maps are being submitted but also a lot more of them are great quality maps that stand far on top of the majority/rest.
Please increase the limit to at least 200 to be more relevant for today's amount of beatmap sets. This doesn't hurt anybody and it's as easy to implement as changing one constant number somewhere, so why not
deadbeat edit: I'm not going to deny this. this will mostly likely be added at a later date. but not yet.
Topic Starter
bump
you don't lose anything by letting people pick more favorites
I'm sick and tired of having to remove a map from favs to add a new one; there's way more than 50 truly amazing maps today that are hard to decide which is 0.001% subjectively better and it would only benefit users to be able to fav them all.
I also like looking at the favorites lists of other users who favorited the same maps as me (to find new maps that are likely to be relevant to my interests) and noticed others who've hit the 50 limit as well. please increase the limit. to at least 200. this is not 2009 anymore, where you barely had 10k maps and barely 2 of them were good; there's a lot of active experienced mappers today who spawn stunningly amazing maps at a steady rate and even picking between those is hard in itself, the limit of 50 is waaaay too restrictive for today
you don't lose anything by letting people pick more favorites
I'm sick and tired of having to remove a map from favs to add a new one; there's way more than 50 truly amazing maps today that are hard to decide which is 0.001% subjectively better and it would only benefit users to be able to fav them all.
I also like looking at the favorites lists of other users who favorited the same maps as me (to find new maps that are likely to be relevant to my interests) and noticed others who've hit the 50 limit as well. please increase the limit. to at least 200. this is not 2009 anymore, where you barely had 10k maps and barely 2 of them were good; there's a lot of active experienced mappers today who spawn stunningly amazing maps at a steady rate and even picking between those is hard in itself, the limit of 50 is waaaay too restrictive for today
Aqo, I have the feeling you don't really understand the term "favourite". You just cannot have 50 "favourite" maps. Favourite maps have to be something special, they can only be a very few, they have to be far superior compared to the average map. Just being good doesn't make a map one of your favourite ones.
If the category would be renamed from "favourite maps" to let's say "recommended maps" then I'd agree with you, then there shoudn't be a limit. But as long as they are called "favourite" maps the limit shouldn't be increased.
Maybe one should replace favourite maps with recommended maps?
If the category would be renamed from "favourite maps" to let's say "recommended maps" then I'd agree with you, then there shoudn't be a limit. But as long as they are called "favourite" maps the limit shouldn't be increased.
Maybe one should replace favourite maps with recommended maps?
i like how aqo says that there are tons of great new maps around, yet i don't really download that many anymore since i feel that maps are getting worse. hooray for opinions.
anyway. the number of favorites will most likely be increased at some point when time when peppy agrees to this :p
also didn't notice this earlier
anyway. the number of favorites will most likely be increased at some point when time when peppy agrees to this :p
also didn't notice this earlier
to make you really think about which you consider the best of the bestAqo wrote:
I just don't understand why the site limit is restricted.
if your really using your favorite maps list for this then your doing it wrong. you have a userpage for stuff like that. plus it would be more effective sharing it with friends in-game or playing them in multiplayer so other people play themAqo wrote:
Sharing fun maps through fav'ing them is important in helping those maps get approved, too, by making other people notice them and spread the attention to them.
Topic Starter
I think, the misconception here is that...Tshemmp wrote:
Aqo, I have the feeling you don't really understand the term "favourite". You just cannot have 50 "favourite" maps. Favourite maps have to be something special, they can only be a very few, they have to be far superior compared to the average map.
lets say somebody has only 100 maps.
He can have maybe 5 favorites out of those. 50 will really not make sense.
But with 1000 maps, 50 can be favorites. They're still hard-picked from a very large amount.
I download pending maps all the time and check out a ton of maps nonstop. I'm aware most people don't do this; but there's still A LOT of maps today, and a lot of maps worthy of a special spot.
Well, I think there is a maximum of maps a person can have as favourites. The more maps someone plays the stricter his criterias will become for a map to become a favourite map. Every now and then I check my favourite maps and decide to remove some since they cannot hold my criterias anymore. Ofcourse if you have only 100 maps you will also only have like 5 favourites. But at some point the number of favourites just can't go up anymore. 50 maps just _can_not_ be favourites. This is would be against the meaning of the word favourite.
Recommended maps - yes. Favourite maps - no.
Recommended maps - yes. Favourite maps - no.
Why would you need to have more than 50 anyway?
If you have too many you can't really call them favorites anymore.
And just having more than 1000 beatmaps doesn't mean that you'll have more favorites.
That's like saying I've got more than 1000 people so I'll need more kings. Implying that 50 kings wasn't already enough.
Personally, I don't even have online favorites, that's what i use favorites A for.
And favorites B are just extremely hard taiko maps.
If you have too many you can't really call them favorites anymore.
And just having more than 1000 beatmaps doesn't mean that you'll have more favorites.
That's like saying I've got more than 1000 people so I'll need more kings. Implying that 50 kings wasn't already enough.
Personally, I don't even have online favorites, that's what i use favorites A for.
And favorites B are just extremely hard taiko maps.
There's a difference between maps that you like, and maps that are your favourite, really imo favourite should be like only a single map, the best of them all in the player's opinion, but well we get 50 so...
fwiw when i started playing the max favourites was 20, and i barely needed it, then after long fighting peppy decided to increase it to 50, i highly doubt this number will be going up anytime soon.
fwiw when i started playing the max favourites was 20, and i barely needed it, then after long fighting peppy decided to increase it to 50, i highly doubt this number will be going up anytime soon.
Thank you Lanturn for finding this, come on people! Let's make this happen 
dat necro, this thread is just asking to be locked
the main purpose of faving a beatmap now is to get the BAT's attention to rank a map
We can pretty much use collection to organize the beatmaps now
the main purpose of faving a beatmap now is to get the BAT's attention to rank a map
We can pretty much use collection to organize the beatmaps now
Thanks for the bump
that's not how things work here[MY] yummy90 XP wrote:
dat necro, this thread is just asking to be locked
please stop using the online favorites if this is what you're using it for. infact, if this is what people use it for now, then i'll just deny this[MY] yummy90 XP wrote:
the main purpose of faving a beatmap now is to get the BAT's attention to rank a map
how does it actually get their attention?
Seeing your comment gives me hope :3
Bump
I'd really like to see it (stupid duplicates >.<)
I'd really like to see it (stupid duplicates >.<)
Looks like this request was completed some time ago
Really?
Nice!
Nice!
This is already added.
Does anyone know the current amount of favs then?
The current limit is 100 favourites
Then remove some...D FN R wrote:
I have reached the limit of 100 favourites((( rip
But that defeats the purpose of favoriting in the first place (unless you favorited by request)Bara- wrote:
Then remove some...D FN R wrote:
I have reached the limit of 100 favourites
If you're asking me: "Who is your favourite artist", I wouldn't come up with a list of 100 names. Most people don't have that either. Favouriting nowadays only seems to be there to 'save' maps in case you lose all maps, or to appreciate the map. There is nothing to be sad about
^ ThisBara- wrote:
If you're asking me: "Who is your favourite artist", I wouldn't come up with a list of 100 names. Most people don't have that either. Favouriting nowadays only seems to be there to 'save' maps in case you lose all maps, or to appreciate the map. There is nothing to be sad about
I have added many song to Fav list cuz when I wipe my Hard Drive or I play Osu! in a friend's house I have a backup but I would like to "save" more than 100 maps,anyway , I know there are more options to save/backup maps but I still preferring Osu!'s fav map list