thanks for moding merchat !merchat7 wrote:
Haven't mod in a while and a little sick of mapping atm so here's a random mod :D
[General]
Don't really see a problem, would prefer circle size 3 for normal through since it's the easiest diff here, but I recommend mapping an Easy more. :d
[Normal]
Personally ar 4 fits much better, current setting is like an Easy, but the note density is like a Normal. It doesn't increase the star rating and make it play much better so I highly recommend you change it to 4. 4
00:29:899 (2) - Really feel like a finish should be here to emphasize that bell sound and to differentiate from the sound at 00:29:441. o.o
00:33:106 (4,5,6) - Hm, I guess you should use a repeating slider here too, read 00:43:182 for reason. Doesn't annoy me too much through so you can keep it if you want.
00:43:182 (1,1) - I disagree with the circle usage here. This part has lot of parts on the red tick so why not following it with a repeating slider? 6 circles can be tiring for beginner to play so this should give a little break. Place (2,3) like this http://puu.sh/a7dW (3 is stack with 3 in the next combo), then the repeating slider (new combo on it) like this http://puu.sh/a7e4.
00:52:342 (1) - I don't really like how you place this repeating slider, it look like a kick slider to me (I thought there was going to be another repeat). I would prefer if you ctrl+J and put back in the same spot.
00:54:174 (1) - ^
01:02:190 (4) - Spacing? Fix to 0.9x, if this was on purpose, I don't think it play well so keep spacing equal here if that was the case.
01:18:907 (1,2) - Repeating slider again for the same reason as 00:43:182 (this is also to emphasize the drum more for 3,4,5). It seems you want to do something symmetrical here, I suggest like this http://puu.sh/a7fc.
01:32:190 (1,2) - It's will look nicer if you move the middle anchor point more up so that's it symmetrical and copy and paste to the other slider. Right now, it doesn't look good at all. http://puu.sh/a7fZ (adjust a bit, this is something I did really quickly).
01:34:022 (3) - Points it to 5? Give a nice effect I think. http://puu.sh/a7gn
01:37:686 (3,4) - The way the singer sings this note, slider fit really nicely with the flow. So slider here and place like this http://puu.sh/a7h1?
01:49:594 (4,5) - Doing a short slider like (3) is better. Like this, it feel like there's something missing since you didn't add a hit circle to 01:50:052. I would prefer through if you do this instead [01:49:594 - 01:50:510] http://puu.sh/a7hM. http://puu.sh/a7hQ. Much simpler rhythm, follow the song nicer and you get -0.05 star rating.
Pretty good, everything above is just suggestion (I usually disagree with using 4+ hit circle in Easy/Normal unless the music really feel like it and here, repeating slider/slider fit better for almost all the parts that you used more than 4 hit circles in a arow imo). Consider making an Easy, this feel a little too hard for the easiest diff. The only reason why star rating is this low is because of the BPM. Mats will probably suggest this so consider it.
[Hard]
I got distracted on this difficulty since I was hitting notes 20 ms late for some reason (so I was starring at it the whole way through). Nothing really caught my attention here
[Insane]
00:01:045 (T) - I feel you should reduce the volume, the finish sound too loud and drown out the music a bit. I didn't suggestion for other diffs since you didn't use many finish at this part.
I don't see a problem, everything plays well enough for me Was slightly worried about some jump, I felt some were random, but I check through the editor and the jumps that I checked made enough sense to me
Good map, I really recommend you make an Easy so you don't have a problem when a mat/bat check this. Sorry if a mat/bat come and say Insane has too many random jump, I can't seem to find them for some reason .
Star!
Hm I decide to look through Insane again.SPOILER[Insane (Continue)]
For some reason, when I play this in game, I notice lot of random jumps (when I play editor, everything play nicely for me :S) so here's everything I found weird. Use it how you wish.
00:03:793 (1,2,3,4,5) - This part is quite calm but the spacing here make it feel like a guitar solo in a metal song.
00:06:083 (3,4,5) - This part really doesn't feel like at 2.25x jump. Also why jump for (4), there isn't really an accent on it.
00:08:602 (1) - There shouldn't be a jump for this since this note isn't accented, the end of the last slider is.
00:10:205 (1,2,3,4,5) - Similar to 00:03:793, way too intense compare to the music.
Imo, the intro for this song should be quite calm, a little bit of jump here and there. This part should be where you start to get the feel of the song.
00:20:281 (5) - Perhaps end this slider at 00:20:510, add a hit circle to 00:20:739. And do a jump for the stream. Really feel like there should be a jump at this part.
00:22:571 (3) - Why jump on this note? The accent is on (4) so do a jump on it instead.
00:23:945 (3) - A little weird that you didn't do a jump on this note since this is accented.
00:25:090 (2,3,4) - I disagree with the jumps here. This notes are following the drum and imo, jumps make more sense on the electronic piano. The drums here are more like background instrument that keeps the rhythm, while the electronic piano is the rhythm so I feel jump make more sense there.
00:26:006 (6) - This note isn't accented, the jump should really be on (5).
00:26:464 (1) - Depending on if you change the previous part or not, there shouldn't be a jump here.
00:32:190 (1,2,3,4,5) - I'm not so sure about this jump and unequal spacing.
00:36:541 (4) - Feel like a jump should be here.
00:45:014 (1) - Unnecessary big jump, should be lower imo.
00:45:930 (1,2,1,2,1,2) - ^ it make this play weird, 2.25x spacing then > 1.0x. do some mini jump on the (1)s.
00:49:823 (4,5,6) - Lower spacing for this since it's calmer.
00:54:174 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - I find it a odd that you keep spacing equal here when the singer isn't singing the same way through out this part.
00:56:464 (4,5) - Better for jump to be on (4) then (5).
00:57:151 (1) - This note isn't accented, doesn't make sense for such a big jump here.
01:11:579 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - This part is quite calm, I don't a reason for such a big jump.
01:35:854 (1,2,3,4,5) - Singer isn't singing the same way thorough and all the notes are jump here. Doesn't flow too nice.
01:39:518 (4,5,6,7,1) - Slowly increasing spacing here make more sense.
01:51:884 (2,3,4) - Symmetrical pattern doesn't really make sense since (4) isn't accented, only (3).
01:57:609 (2) - Nothing accented here, jump doesn't really make sense.
Use it however you want , if a mat/bat say that Insane has too many random jumps, take a look at this. I probably miss some stuff so sorry about that.
Good luck!
many stuff changed :3
thanks for checking :dfrost-b-spec wrote:
thx reqs~
[Insane]
1.43.411(6,7,8) - symmetry(3,4,5) I like this randomnes :p
[Hard]
0.51.426(5) - delete and (4)slider end time. ?v?
[Normal]
1.02.190(4) - spacing merchat has indicated this before
nice~