1. Reminiscence (5.7 stars, 1750 notes)

359,250,3,2,10,100,1,0
3359,500,3,2,10,100,1,0
40408,346.820809248555,3,2,10,100,1,0
40754,348.837209302326,4,2,20,100,1,0
102149,348.837209302326,3,2,10,100,1,0
127254,247.933884297521,3,2,10,100,1,0
170399,244.897959183673,3,2,10,100,1,0
173337,241.935483870968,3,2,10,100,1,0
174788,238.095238095238,3,2,10,100,1,0
176216,230.769230769231,3,2,10,100,1,0
177600,234.375,3,2,10,100,1,0
179006,220.588235294118,3,2,10,100,1,0
180329,206.896551724138,3,2,10,100,1,0
181570,202.702702702703,3,2,10,100,1,0
184002,193.548387096774,3,2,10,100,1,0
185163,375,3,2,10,100,1,0
214903,517.241379310345,4,2,10,100,1,0
216971,494.641384995878,4,2,10,100,1,0
217960,535.714285714286,4,2,10,100,1,0
219051,217.391304347826,4,2,10,100,1,0
246995,344.827586206897,4,2,10,100,1,0
247512,344.827586206897,4,2,10,100,1,0
268738,344.827586206897,4,2,10,100,1,0
274427,344.827586206897,4,2,10,100,1,0
279771,344.827586206897,4,2,10,100,1,0
335115,344.827586206897,4,2,10,100,1,0
339252,217.391304347826,4,2,10,100,1,0
367088,434.782608695652,4,2,10,100,1,0
368827,461.538461538462,4,2,10,100,1,0
372519,476.190476190476,4,2,10,100,1,0
374423,483.870967741935,4,2,10,100,1,0
376358,500,4,2,10,100,1,0
378358,517.241379310345,4,2,10,100,1,0
380426,555.555555555556,4,2,10,100,1,0

Dashyy- wrote:

bg not even from the correct album -______

1. 00:13:859 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This spot seemed a bit too off in all layers so I adjusted it a bit
2. 02:07:265 - This section seemed way too early to me, just made it connect with the previous one and added a section at 02:31:066 that makes it connect to the next one bc somewhere between those they get slightly earlier so ye lol
3. 02:56:205 - Somewhere around here I changed stuff bc most notes except the downbeats sounded late, so I did compromises
4. Other than that I just smoothed stuff out

Bonsai wrote:

Täming Chäck!

1. 00:13:859 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - This spot seemed a bit too off in all layers so I adjusted it a bit
2. 02:07:265 - This section seemed way too early to me, just made it connect with the previous one and added a section at 02:31:066 that makes it connect to the next one bc somewhere between those they get slightly earlier so ye lol
3. 02:56:205 - Somewhere around here I changed stuff bc most notes except the downbeats sounded late, so I did compromises
4. Other than that I just smoothed stuff out

redline-diff to copypaste from

Very cool map so far, though I really don't see how those songs are supposed to be together more than any other two consecutive songs from any album, I mean they don't even have any sort of transition to each other, just silence, so ngh, maybe reconsider bc people already lost their shits about stuff like this which I didn't get at all, but here I'm that kinda person too I guess xd

Hectique wrote:

hi bad modder

nice hitsounding! :>
00:40:754 (2,3) - personally, i like making rhythmic transitions like these a bit more passive so the player can adjust, so i'd probably swap these circles for a kickslider
It's already stacked, so this should help players read the bpm change quite easily.
00:56:277 (2,3,4) - most of your patterns similar to this this flow pretty well but this one seems particularly janky, i think you could lead the triples into the curve of the slider more or change the slider to be less sharp against the angle of the triple
I disagree, 00:56:277 (2,3,4) - is ~kinda~ parallel to 00:55:928 (1) - and the counter-clockwise flow fits fine.
01:16:335 (1,2,3,4,5) - this is hard misread material. the slider here points away from the stream, and is of similar length to sliders like 01:15:986 (1), but plays immediately into the next stream. i think just having it direct the player into the stream would save a lot of trouble
For an Extra, I think its fine. Hard to misread stuff is common in extras, it is done consistently, and additionally, 01:16:684 (5) - sliders lick these play like singletaps. Furthermore, slow sliders are NC'd to indicate a velocity change 01:15:986 (1) - and the kick sliders 01:16:684 (5) - are not.
01:55:230 (3,4,5,6,7,8,1) - just a thought, maybe slightly increase the spacing between the three copypasted streams to give a sense of progression?
No, they are relatively the exact same volume. Furthermore, the idea of progression is played out in the fact that the spacing slightly increases after each measure.
02:07:388 (2) - when i played this i didn't expect the sudden bpm increase and totally misplayed here because of the sheer speed of these reverse sliders. i'd either reduce the spacing significantly or, alternatively, have a pattern like this: http://i.imgur.com/mViXxsS.png
I disagree, I think that the reverse sliders actually do justice as they play like single taps. You'll notice that the first measure of each of these sections are the least note dense.
03:23:163 (1) - omg nice
Yuh:3
03:39:051 (1,2) - idk, i think this'd work better as a 1/2 slider followed by a stacked circle slider
Both should play fine
04:06:669 (1,2) - i'd put a reverse slider but that's just preference, it's fine as is, just a bit sudden
Well, as the song is sudden, it is mapped accordingly. Additionally, I've asked for a lot of testplayed and people don't mess up here (at various ranks)
05:06:323 (1,2,3,4,5,6) - during this section you have jumps that feel excessive for this part of the song. i really like the patterns you made like 05:29:944 (2,3,4,5,6,7) where the jumps become definitely larger on the harder drum hits, but not in any stressing amount to fit the calmed nature of the song. dunno
I think there is stress to fit the "calming" prat of the song. Stuff such as 05:02:703 (4,5,6) - is spaced really low. As you can see, the jumps get progressively larger after every 4 measures and "Reset" on the 5th, 9th, 14th, etc. Additionally, this is meant to represent the vocalists change in pitch when he says "Oh oh..."
05:34:254 (3,4) - seriously though, this is too much qq
06:07:088 (1) - i sliderbroke, maybe make the slowdown more gradual for this and the following sliders
Yeah, changed.

this map is super cool and even though i can't play it well because speed i think it could end up being spectacular, hope this helps <3

Shadw wrote:

i've played the map over several times and truthfully i'm not able to point out too much wrong. might be cuz i haven't modded in a while and i have no clue what i'm doin anymore or your map is too good :3 regardless my mod might not be a long one and i apologize in advance

[Reminiscence]
- 00:19:859 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - when playing this part i don't feel like there is anymore emphasis than parts around it. perhaps making the spacing larger (for more emphasis) and flow more angular, rather than linear. i understand this might not be very clear so we can talk about it next time you catch me online or just message me on discord x3 the point i'm trying to make is that it doesn't feel very different to play emphasis-wise compared to the parts around it, despite the song feeling a little more emphasized at that part
Already discussed in irc, I think the equivalent of 240bpm jumps (120 1/4 jumps) are too hard for this section.
- 00:25:859 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - ^ (as well as other similar parts in the beginning)
- 00:46:335 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8) - timestamping just the beginning part of the stream, but for all the streams around this part of the song i find the nc's seem inconsistent to me
Fixed
- 01:02:992 (4,1) - i find that the very close overlap here might be hard to read and contrasts the momentum that you had from 01:02:730 (1,2,3,4) - . i figured that if you were trying to kill the momentum, you would already be doing that with the kick slider and that the hyperclose spacing between 4 and 1 might be unnecessary
Fixed
- 01:05:521 (4,5,6,7,1) - it's playable, but visually might be too much change in spacing, so the drums you are emphasizing i feel could be overemphasized by this
I think it plays fine and it is a good representation of the percussion
- 01:11:102 (4,5,6,7,1) - ^
- 03:54:703 (1,2) - stacking these notes to me feels like you have a lot of momentum, and then you stop it very suddenly, only to resume it again. so maybe some spacing these two notes could work
I disagree, I think that the dynamic shifts in momentum make it play better, not worse
- 04:16:668 (2,3) - what do you think of ctrl+g
I think both ways play fine
- 04:54:254 (3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,1) - i feel there might be unnecessary contrast since this is the only stream out of many in this section that has a sharp angle
I disagree, I think that the sharp angle doesn't feel like its forced.


overall i do think you're map is very nice, the bpm changes were handled very well ^^
Thanks!

BoatKrab wrote:

Hoi!
Bad mod is incomming

[dat diff name, im too lazy to write it]
00:03:734 (2) - I know you are trying to lead players to make them read it with 1/4 slider for the first time, but I don't think about this with 00:04:109 (3) - cus they have a lot of different spacing. Try to increase more spacing for 00:03:734 (2) - might be better
Done
04:30:030 (5) - Really disagree with this. Same reason as above. About da distance :v (If you fix this, don't forget to fix others)
Changed
04:55:806 (4) - Wait, what? Try to change it to 1/4 steaming slider or maybe reduce its distance instead of this? It's too sudden to see ;__;
Ah, the drum fill is 1/6 though.
06:20:426 - Increase a volume in red line timing to 80% could be the best one
Fixed!
[]
This map is fcking crazy. I love this !!!!
Thank you!

Plaudible wrote:

eggcellent map

hihi

Dance Gavin Dance - NASA / I'm Down With Brown Town
General

1. soft-hitfinish40.wav unused?
   Whoops
2. 00:15:359 - Timing point/greenlines NEED to match in volume/audio set sample.
   Changed
3. Also applies to 00:39:359, 01:42:149, 02:31:066. https://osu.ppy.sh/wiki/Ranking_Criteria#Timing

Poop Village

1. 00:04:109 (3) - Spacing feels a little large compared to other notes in this section when this rhythm repeats
   Changed
2. 00:10:109 (3) - same, try to keep them closer to 00:11:609 (3) - in spacing so they aren't too different
   Changed
3. 00:40:754 (2,3,4) - feels out of place to stack here :T you overlapped the other triples, you don't stack at 00:51:916 (1,2,3) -
   It actually was spaced out, but I changed it because its the first triple so that people can recognize the bpm change more easily.
4. 02:36:518 (5,6,7,1,2,3) - Lots of clickable circles here, little too dense. I think it'd be better to introduce this dense 3 circle rhythm at 02:35:527 (1,2) - and then make the second instance a slider + circle at 02:37:014 (1,2,3) -
   I think its fine, stuff like 02:13:215 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - is already really dense so really density shouldn't be too much of a problem
5. 03:16:225 (4) - Shouldn't this be small since u made non-kicks tiny
   ... There is a bass drum hit there, baka.
6. 03:48:616 (1,2,3) - This fits into the 1/2 streams too much imo. I think with these you should make them more clearly different from the 1/2 rhythms so they don't get mixed in with the streams here and towards the end. Maybe cute triangles or something :3
   I think the contrast in rhythm with the same spacing is what makes it fun.
7. 03:50:464 (2) - offscreen daddy no
   Changed
8. 04:34:427 (1) - 04:37:185 (1) - imo it'd be cool to emphasize these with some kind of jump or something for the boomboom.
   Oko
9. 04:54:599 (7) - Stream kink felt a bit out of place since this is the only time you don't use smooth flow in them.
   It plays smoothly www
10. 05:27:185 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - and 05:32:703 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - You made the jumps smaller in the lower "oh oh" sections like at 05:29:944 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - , feels overspaced here.
    Beginning in this section 05:12:875 - the lead guitar enters, that's why its mapped differently.
11. 06:20:426 (1) - Nitpicky as fuck but if you could maybe make the sliderend shape more interesting to match the fading guitar sounds that'd be cool.
    I already think it does

gud job call me bak
okay Senpai OwO

00:15:359 (custom set number)
00:39:359 (custom set number)
01:42:149 (custom set number)
02:31:066 (custom set number)

Hobbes2 wrote:

00:15:359 (custom set number)
00:39:359 (custom set number)
01:42:149 (custom set number)
02:31:066 (custom set number)

^Please check those for inconsistent custom hitsound set numbers (ive double checked them and there are inconsistencies there)
im dumb
00:03:359 - hmm...volume seems a bit too loud this section
Forget to change that, yeah. Set it to 40%
01:18:602 (4,1) - found it weird that you did this overlap thing with these two sounds just this one time
Changed as well.
02:09:124 (3,4,5,6,7,1,2,3,4,5,6) - having this much active 1/4 consecutively at this bpm is quite difficult. i suggest removing one of these active triplets, it would make this part a lot less stressful to land. i feel like its a bit much atm
Made it slightly less dense!

call me