mancusojuanmattos wrote:

General:
- The Offsets are inconsistent in all difficulties. Let's see I suggest to use that timing points in all diff:
1st Timeline: BPM: 123,00 Offset: 895
2nd Timeline: BPM: 123,00 Offset: 47256
3rd Timeline: BPM: 123,00 Offset: 91518
I think that is the better option.
- Tags: In ezek's Hard Party you have to add in tags: ezek,wmfchris and k_o_g_u_r_e.
Maybe in tags you have to add Mario Bros.
- The Taiko BG 2 is 640 x 480 (too smalll). Resize to 800 x 600 or 1024 x 768
- To be consistent in all difficulties, you must have the same letterbox during breaks and countdown in all diff. I suggest to remove in all difficulties.
- The combo colours in ezek's Hard Party are differents comparing with another difficulties. So, you have to change the combo colours here.
- Audio Lead-In: 1996, you can change manually in .osu notepad to 2000 (all diff)
- When you use soft hitsounds, I think that you have to decrease the volume around 5%

Easy:
HP Drain Rate: -1
Overall Difficulty: -1
00:01:870 (2,3): Don't stack notes in Easy. It's quite difficult to read to new players
00:03:821 (2,3): Same as above
00:06:748 (3): Hmmm... This slider sounds weird, I suggest to remove the reverse arrow and after that try to find another shape
00:10:163 (x): Add a Note
WOW!! This diff need more flow, you have to add more sliders to sounds better the map, because I can see that you make a pattern with circles, but in some parts you don't have anything. For example the space to 00:09:309-00:10:529, here you don't have any note.
You add a lot of circles in random places that looks weird.
This diff need more work.

Normal Party:
00:13:090 (2): This slider must ends 1/8 back, to follow better the rythm (00:13:516)
00:18:455 (4): This slider looks really weird, try to make another shape
01:03:324 (T): Unsnapped kiai

mancusojuanmattos wrote:

- The Taiko BG 2 is 640 x 480 (too smalll). Resize to 800 x 600 or 1024 x 768

stickmeister wrote:

Wmf's Taiko
I don't mod Taiko, but I'm going to make an exception for the storyboard. I can't do much for it because it's not my storyboard, and I'd like to keep it the way it is. However, you did make me realize that a Paper Mario storyboard would be a beautiful thing and very much possible within osu!'s storyboarding capabilities given Paper Mario's art style. When I saw the background for this, I half expected there to be a fight going on beneath the Taiko screen. There isn't. I wish there was! And now I've been inspired to create one for my own beatmap. BYE.

I'm kidding. (I'm not kidding about creating a storyboard though, however) There are a few problems with your storyboard, though.
1.) This one's fairly obvious, but fix question.png. The top of it is cropped off.

~ The font used here is actually the font from the game itself (or so it says) and I did notice that all the letters are actually cropped a bit on top (try looking at the words on the Taiko BG pics). Guess I'll change it to another font then.

2.) blush.png looks really bad and should be a brighter pink, as well as smaller.

~ Sure, changed it, I think.

3.) Convert the original background into a storyboard element so you can remove it when the new background is swapped, thus reducing SB load. You can do this by checking out the first tip in this thread, which then converts your background into a storyboard element while still keeping it's thumbnail aspect and blah blah blah. I know the SB Load is only 2x, but given the chance to ever shave off SB Load of any kind, you should do it.

~ Hmm, never knew this, and it's a nifty trick! Thanks for sharing this ^w^
[EDIT: Ok, I'm confused. Does this mean I have to have two Taiko BG 1.jpg files, one for thumbnail and one for SB? That's kinda redundant... Ah well.

4.) Not sure why you're using Super Paper Mario elements in a song from the first Paper Mario game, but alright...

~ Ok, I'll be frank, I never even heard of this game until kokoroanime sent this request, and what I know is mostly based on Youtube video, so yeah ...

stickmeister wrote:

Normal Party

This diff is also inconsistent with timing sections, please use Kogome's Insane Party's timing sections.

00:13:090 (2)- End this on a blue tick. (00:13:455) Fixed
00:56:280 (2)- Remove this note. Fixed
^ 00:55:548 (1)- Extend this slider to a red tick. Fixed
00:58:719 (1)- Possibly repeat only once? Fixed
01:05:060 (4)- Remove note. Fixed
01:05:792 (6)- Remove note. Fixed
^ 01:05:304 (4)- Repeat once. Fixed
00:59:695 (2)- Repeat only once. Fixed
01:28:719 (Timing Sections)- Why are these timing sections here? Fixed

Easy Party
00:08:699 (1, 2)- Not sure what you're mapping on here, but this should be mapped like the first part... Fixed
00:24:309 (1, 2, 3, 4)- Also not sure why these aren't mapped similar to the other combos...It's inconsistent and weird.Fixed
00:47:743 ~ 01:03:353- Remap this entire section so it's not just 1/1 notes, it's really boring.Fixed

Okay, that's abwoahshit that's an extensive mod...huh. Okay. That's all.

wmfchris wrote:

1) About difficulty name: whatever change it if you like
2) 00:43:577 (117) help me to change to d please (remove whistle)
3) SB: well my old ver doesn't hv SB, but I DO agree there shouldn't be solo SB on it. Inherit SB in the solo diffs will be fine.

Hika wrote:

I think you need some new combos in your life.

SPOILER

I AM COMBO MASTER MODDER PERSON
Easy Party -
00:41:870 (2) - New combo.
00:59:451 (3) - ^
01:30:060 (1) - Add finish at the end of the spinner.

Normal Party -
00:43:821 (5,1,2,3) - Remove claps. OVERUSING ISN'T COOL OKAY.
01:28:756 - Timing sections nooo...so bad. Should I delete these sections?
01:30:060 (1) - Add finish at the end of the spinner.

1. You have a red timing section at 00:47:256, BPM of 123,000, I think it should be at 00:47:743 on all difficulties. It's the correct offset to your kiai timing.
2. The countdown in all standard difficulties must be the same as the rules says, sir. The ezek's diff has countdown while other diffs don't. O suggest you to remove from the countdown from it.
3. The two standard guest diffs have letterbox during breaks, while your diffs not. Is that on purpose? I think you should make them all consistent disabling them from the guest diffs.
4. The tags of ezek's diff are 'Nintendo 64 Mario' while at all other diffs you have 'Nintendo 64 Mario ezek wmfchris k_o_g_u_r_e'. You need to make them consistent because if you search 'k_o_g_u_r_e' in game, you will not find ezek's diff.
5. You have different timing only on ezek's diff, make it consistent is highly recommended at all because you need perfect timed diffs to get the map ranked, and if you assume ezek's timing is right, it means each other diff has wrong timing and vice-versa.
6. ezek's diff is the only diff without custom combo colours, is that on purpose? If not, make them all consistent adding it the same combo colours as the other diffs.
7. The non-guest diffs' kiai times finish at 01:02:865, while the guest ones finish at 01:03:353. Consider making them all the same, if that's not on purpose.

1. 00:10:651 (3,1) - There is a long empty time between these two notes, it may cause the player to get bored. Consider mapping this empty time with something like this.
2. 01:26:768 (1) - I think the recover time between the spinner end and the next note is very short, consider making something like that.
3. New Combos:
   
   1. 00:36:016 (5,1) - You are using new combos on each two Big White ticks on the whole map, then I think you shouljd permute the new combos, because (5) is the third big white tick of the combo.
   2. 00:43:821 (4,1) - I think that's the same case as before here, permute the new combo.
4. Hitsounds:
   
   • 
     I slice this in two parts:
   1. Following the Drums suggestions:
      
      1. 00:04:797 (1) - Add whistle on the last repeat would be better to fit the drums.
      2. 00:05:773 (2) - Same as before.
      3. 00:43:334 (3) - I think whistle here is better.
      4. 00:43:821 (1) - If you add the in before, remove the clap and a finish here and the same at 00:45:773 (4) - .
      5. 00:48:719 (2) - Add a clap would be totally better than nothing here.
      6. 00:52:621 (2) - Same as before.
      7. 00:55:548 (1) - Clap on the last beat.
      8. 00:59:451 (3) - Same as before.
      9. 01:03:841 (2,3) - Now I will show you my way to follow the drums in soft hitsounds. You can do this by adding a whistle at (2) and a clap at (3). You can hear the cymbal pre-clap, aand it's an awesome way to follow drums in soft hitsounds.
      10. 01:05:304 (4) - Add whistle at the end of the slider and add clap on the start of 01:06:280 (5) -, with whistle on the end of (5).
      11. 01:09:695 (3,5) - Add whistles.
      12. 01:10:182 (4) - Add clap.
   2. Following the melody suggestions:
      
      1. 00:02:358 (3) - Add whistle.
      2. 00:03:090 (1,2) - Add whistle in (1), remove whitle from (2) and add finish on (2) would be a better melodic hitsounds.
      3. 00:06:748 (3) - Add whistle on the start and finish on the end.

1. New Combos:
   1. 00:36:016 (5,1) - You are following the same new combo frequency as easy: One in two big white ticks. Permute the new combo for better consistency since (5) is the third big white tick of the combo.
   2. 00:43:821 (5) - Same as before.

1. 00:07:968 (4,5,6) - Sir, I don't think you should break the flow this way. The flow is based on making the mouse move in circles, and it's good for a more intuitive map. I think you should do something like that for a better flowed pattern.
2. 00:09:004 (1,2,3) - Bleh! This is spacing is too much confusing ezek x_x. Consider making the space between (2) and (3) a litter smaller for better consistency.
3. 00:22:358 (6) - I think you tried to do something like that!
4. Same as before :3
5. 00:32:114 (1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5,1,2,3,4,5) - Are you sure you want to do something like that? It looks much boring! Try making the star just once and remap the other two ^v^;

1. I think you should lower the AR to 8 since the BP< of the song is just 123, and AR9 works better for 170+. I think the HP Drain rate and the overall difficulty works both better at 7 since the map is not too hard as you imagine it is.
2. 00:02:724 (7,1) - I think the spacing between these two notes is quite confusing for an 1/4 snap distance. Consider removing 00:02:724 (7) - for better consistency of spacing.
3. 00:07:968 (1,2,3,4,5) - It's a quite confusing spacing for an 1/4 stream since you used and shorther spacing in before. Consider making the spacing in this stream consistent with other 1/4 stream spacing.
4. 00:09:675 (2) - Such a weird bad stacked section! Try making it spaced like that, it will work out much better for playing and much more visual appealing.
5. 00:10:285 (1,2,3,4) - Make the stream space consistent, it's weeeeird for play and is quite unesthetical.
6. 00:11:626 (2) - Same as 00:09:675 (2) -. Try spacing it correctly.
7. 00:23:821 (1,2,3,4,1) - This jumpy stream doesn't fit with the music and with the difficulty at all, consider please spacing it correctly.
8. 00:27:480 (3,4,5) - I have no problems with triplets spaced this way, but it looks a lot like 1/2 and may confuse the played a lot(at least confuses me a lot )
9. 00:46:260 (2) - This sudden slowdown made me ragequit your diff! Please consider removing the slow down and add a repeat, it would work a lot better than this sudden slow down.
   

Blue Dragon wrote:

You didn't seem to fix Katsuri's mod at all.

wmfchris wrote:

something that you need to concern:

- inconsistancy in tag, inherited time section
- [Easy] - end kiai at the same time with other diffs

I don't hv problem with my taiko diff, no kd here.

narakucrimson wrote:

You should read katsuri's mod again.

Weezy wrote:

To me just a single offset of 956 works just fine
may not be super perfect though

Noticed in the insane, there are 4 sv changes, thats a no no and not needed really...

[CSGA]Ar3sgice wrote:

[ezek's Hard Party]
00:12:541 (1) - change combo colour, blue color blends in mario OK
00:16:443 (1) - clap remove, add whistle OK

1. The TAG are Inconsistency only Easy "Nintendo 64 Mario Bros. ezek wmfchris k_o_g_u_r_e" is different another diff's "Nintendo 64 Mario ezek wmfchris k_o_g_u_r_e" pleasse make same all diff then full submitt

1. You map BPM is different all diff should be same all diff because the bpm different just complety unrank pleasse make same bpm all diff

1. you all diff open on osu.notepad you will see this "AudioLeadIn: 1996" make 2000 for all diff then SAVE and full submit

1. 00:16:565 (1,2) - I wanna clean Boderslider i mean this http://puu.sh/fPNr then is cool like you did at 00:20:468 (1,2)
2. 00:32:175 (1,2) - Grid 1 UP to make symentricl with 00:34:126 (3,4)

1. the OD is bigger than AR this is hard for this normal IMO
   Od need -3
   and HP need -2

1. 00:18:516 (4) - this slider just ugly
2. 00:22:419 (4) - again slider ugly
3. 00:43:395 (4,1) - I worry about this because this is hard read stack because bpm and normal are just slow then is hard read hitburst then get nervous will better if you unstack this like this http://puu.sh/fPVH if you fix this you need fix spacing at 00:44:858 (2,3,4)
4. 00:58:718 (1,2) - don't try overlaps try clean overlaps i mean this http://puu.sh/fPWH can be easy read
5. 01:28:718 (1,2,3) - Inconsistency spacing

1. http://puu.sh/fPZz you kiai only end is different another diff pleasse make same all diff

1. 00:08:882 (1,2,3) - I not sure this is fine because iis insane... you should reduce spacing IMO
2. 00:42:297 (2,3) - is not nice blanket try nice blanket you did at 00:10:590 (1,2) - http://puu.sh/fQ41

Pereira006 wrote:

hello~~

IMO -> my opinion

General

1. The TAG are Inconsistency only Easy "Nintendo 64 Mario Bros. ezek wmfchris k_o_g_u_r_e" is different another diff's "Nintendo 64 Mario ezek wmfchris k_o_g_u_r_e" pleasse make same all diff then full submitt

I see it, fixed.

1. You map BPM is different all diff should be same all diff because the bpm different just complety unrank pleasse make same bpm all diff

Well, I thought everything's okay when them, but I told everyone to please explain everything what's different and I'll fix them.

1. you all diff open on osu.notepad you will see this "AudioLeadIn: 1996" make 2000 for all diff then SAVE and full submit

Done.

kokoroanime wrote:

Pereira006 wrote:

hello~~

1. You map BPM is different all diff should be same all diff because the bpm different just complety unrank pleasse make same bpm all diff

Well, I thought everything's okay when them, but I told everyone to please explain everything what's different and I'll fix them.

Pereira006 wrote:

hello~~

ezek's Hard Party

1. 00:08:882 (1,2,3) - I not sure this is fine because iis insane... you should reduce spacing IMO Do not exaggerate, is not too hard...
2. 00:42:297 (2,3) - is not nice blanket try nice blanket you did at 00:10:590 (1,2) - http://puu.sh/fQ41

OK, now is nice (for me)

00:00:956 at 00:47:785 why they are blue tick ? http://puu.sh/fQ6m
example this 00:08:882 (1,2,3) - is blue tick and i put 25% slow song this are just overmapped orz
stuff cool

theliveanddead wrote:

Theliveanddead M4M Request
General:
Well first of all excuse my bad spelling, English is not my mother language so you maybe you’ll find some spelling mistakes well then here you have my mod… OH btw… I’m noob at moding so please if you don’t like my mods don’t have to use it…
• I don’t like this kind of instrumental music without voice and multi bmp is a head ache maping this… well I recommend you to change the offset to 1178 in all your diffs sounds a lot better than the one you have now, remember re-snap the hit notes and re-snap slider lenghs

REMEMBER, check your distance snap when you apply this mods
~Easy

SPOILER

00:01:199 (1) – replace this for a slider and make finish at 00:01:443
00:03:151 (1) – ^finish at 00:03:395
00:04:370 (3) – put a hit note here
00:06:809 (3) – finish at 00:07:297
00:08:760 (1) – move this slider to here 00:07:541
00:09:004 (2) – put a slider here finish at 00:09:736
00:10:712 (4) – move this to here 00:10:955 and finish at 00:11:687
00:15:834 (x) – put a slider here finish at 00:16:077
00:25:346 (2,3,4) – replace for a slider, could be a reversal slider
00:28:273 (1) – I think this spin is too long.. short it a bit I think fits better here 00:30:224
00:31:199 (X) – put a note here
00:38:029 (3,4,5) – replace for a reversal slider
00:41:687 (x) – put a note here
00:47:743 (1) – why this timing point here? You’re using the same BPM if you’re using it to change the hit sounds why don’t you use a inherit point? Well it doesn’t matter
00:47:743 (1,2,3,4,1,2,3,4) – I think you could use some sliders here

Normal

SPOILER

00:01:178 (1,2) – over slap notes
00:01:178 (1,2,3) – what you think of this?
00:03:860 (2) – over slap
00:05:568 (x) – put a note here
00:06:787 (4) –finish at 00:07:519
00:06:787 (4) – what you think of this
00:08:007 (x) – put a slider here finish here 00:08:251
00:08:982 (2) – maybe like this?
00:47:743 (1) – here again why a timing point? If you’re not changing the bpm.. .

ask for re-check if you want more modding i don't mod any other diff because i don't know if you like or not my mods so to prevent the waste of my time i'll mod only this if you liked my mods ask for further moding

waiting for your kudosu hehehehe

1. I feel the timing works incorrectly, especially end of music. But I can't give you my opinion due to my poor PC. :p
2. 00:47:732 - That audio volume of normal sampleset is too loud. 60% works well to me.

Nymph wrote:

ezek's Hard Party:
Issue
HP drain 7 seems a little high cuz you didn't have much objects in this diff.. No change

Beatmap design/suggestion
00:08:951 (1,2,3) - this spacing maybe very confusing, because they have the same spacing, but the time between these notes are different.
My objetive is to confuse
00:13:463 (3) - you are using 0.8 spacing, but here you got 0.7, any particular reason or a error? I don't know..
00:17:732 (2,3,4) - the spacing between these notes and the sliders are not quite neatly, not a big issue though. No change
00:28:220 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - same^ There's no problem with the space in here...

Hitsound
00:18:463 (5) - a whistle would fit perfectly at the head of this slider. OK
00:22:366 (6) - ^same OK
00:26:268 (6) - ^ OK
00:42:366 (2,3) - finishes are pretty loud here. No change
00:44:805 (1,2,3) - ^ No change

Mafiamaster wrote:

[Easy]
00:08:707 (1) - This slider is too early and sounds bad at its' current location. Move it forward by a 1/2 tick.
00:10:659 (1) - ^ Don't forget to shorten, etc.
00:13:098 (2) - Shorten this slider by a 1/4 tick?
01:29:341 (2) - Using 1/8, move this back a tick so it's at 01:29:280. Afterwards, space accordingly.

[Normal]
00:13:098 (2) - Extend this slider by a 1/4 tick.
01:29:341 (2) - Same thing as [Easy].

1. 00:12:122 (3) - 1 grid up? It will look better with 00:10:171 (3)
2. 00:39:439 (1) - ^

1. 00:48:463 (5) - Slider 1 grid down
2. 01:28:243 (1) - Remove new combo
3. 01:28:853 (2) - New combo

Alduric wrote:

[ezek's Hard Party]
[list][*]00:12:122 (3) - 1 grid up? It will look better with 00:10:171 (3) No change
[*]00:39:439 (1) - ^ OK

• Hi hi~ request from my queue~ ( M4M )
  　
  General :
  　

1. Some slider you that you make is very ugly... Read This!! I think it will help you so much ^_^
   　
   Easy Party :
   　
2. 01:26:780 (1,1) - It's too close >_<
   　
   Normal Party :
   　
3. 01:29:951 (1) - add finish
   　
   ezek's Hard Party :
   　
4. 00:17:976 (3) - different spacing here...
5. 01:24:829 (1) - ^
6. 01:30:073 (1) - add finish
   　
   Kogure's Insane Party :
   　
7. 00:09:683 (2,1,2,3,4) - strange spacing!
8. 01:30:073 (1) - add finish
   　
   
   You must to read~!

   red: I think you must to fix. bule: need to discuss. Black: just suggest.