1. osu! forums
  2. Beatmaps
  3. Ranked/Approved Beatmaps
posted
This beatmap was submitted using in-game submission on 2017年10月4日 at 15:15:22

Artist: A-Lin
Title: Gei Wo Yi Ge Li You Wang Ji
Tags: 黄丽玲 邬裕康 游政豪 给我一个理由忘记 寂寞不痛 avex 爱贝克斯 愛貝克思 Chinese Geiwo Yige Liyou Wangji
BPM: 67
Filesize: 3199kb
Play Time: 01:59
Difficulties Available:
  1. Easy (0.76 stars, 47 notes)
  2. Normal (0.94 stars, 68 notes)


Download: A-Lin - Gei Wo Yi Ge Li You Wang Ji
Information: Scores/Beatmap Listing
---------------
33rd.
All diffs are done by me.
Metadata:
http://www.avex.com.tw/artist/artist_di ... D90135%2FA
Background from: https://arsenixc.deviantart.com/
Awesome artist!
posted
Hi there o/
I'm a new mapper from your queue, I hope my mod helps

Beginner:
00:27:893 (1) - I think this should be a 1 beat slider with a reverse

00:40:430 (2) - Maybe something here to represent the different sound (NC or different slider shape)

00:45:803 - I think this should be a 1 beat slider with a reverse too, but you could ignore it since the music is calm

01:39:534 - I think you should do something like this, as I think that this sound 01:40:430 - is stronger than this 01:40:878 - sound, so you should ignore the second one rather than the first one. I noticed that you didn't want to use time gaps less than 1 beat (aside from the beginning), but I'd say this is the most intense part of the song (Vocals and drums), so you could do that and use a new combo and different slider shape to indicate the change, or you could just do something similar to this and ignore this 01:41:773 - sound

01:59:596 - Lower the volume for the spinner end
Easy:
00:27:445 - You can add a circle here

00:35:057 - 1/2 slider with a reverse(?)
00:36:848 - ^

01:20:504 (6) - I think placing something on a blue tick is hard to read for new players(?)
01:44:683 (2) - ^ you can start this on the red tick before it

01:59:596 - Lower the volume for the spinner end


That's all I could find, if I said something wrong, I'd appreciate it if you explain to me why you did it like that, as I'm a new mapper, so this would help me improve

Good luck with the map ^-^
posted
posted
hey, really cute song you mapped!

[General]

  1. Make widescreen support consistent across diffs
  2. The (unmapped) outro is a bit more than 20% of the entire map, to fix this you could remove the silence starting 02:21:854 - from the mp3.
  3. The song has more rhythm to offer than just 1/2, wouldn't it be cool to make a third diff, maybe around 2 stars to map to the full rhythm? A lot of piano melodies are covered under sliders in your current diffs so i think another difficulty would definitely be a valuable addition to the set



[Beginner]

  1. 00:31:475 (3) - The slidershape felt a bit unfitting for the sounds this covers.. perhaps if you make the slider's direction change on the slidertick, it'll feel better
  2. 00:39:534 - hmm this note (start of the piano melody) goes ignored while a much less stronger sound is clickable here 00:40:430 - , perhaps extend that slider or add a note in between?
  3. 00:49:385 (2) - perhaps end this on the red tick so you can make this 00:51:176 - clickable. The note seems much stronger here. You can even make 00:45:803 (1) - just a note for a nice little break that'll go well with the calm section here.
  4. 01:11:773 - could you add a note here too? You did it for the vocal here too 01:06:400 - , and this one is considerably stronger



[Easy]

  1. 00:27:445 - in this diff, since it is the highest difficulty of your set, you could easily follow these kind of notes to be more rhythmically accurate with what the song offers
  2. 01:40:877 (5,6) - wat XD



Call me back when you're done with mods/sp and all that shizzle \o/
posted
hi m4m
拯救华语乐坛
[general]
beginner's widescreen support is on
[beginner]
00:35:057 (1) - there are sliders with angles before and after, a striaght slider without any radian is a little abrupt( just advice
01:35:952 (1) - blanket
[easy]
01:40:877 (5,6) - ???
01:18:041 (4) - blanket
第二次m4m的图bpm更慢了,我摸得好像也更水了 :? 射一发
posted
returning m4m

the timing is a beat off for the whole song; 00:17:146 (2) - is a downbeat
(if you care piano intro has 00:01:027 - as a downbeat which is 2 beats off from ^)
also people said this but there's widescreen support on beginner

Beginner:
00:20:729 (1) - ctrl+j this can help avoid overlap since rest of map doesn’t have them
01:18:042 (3) - hm i would make the end a circle for sudden intensity there
01:21:624 (1,2) - maybe two 1/1 sliders for different vocal phrasing

Easy:
00:39:534 - it would be nice if this were clickable since piano line starts here
01:26:549 (5) - move this 1/2 beat later since that’s where the important sound is
01:40:877 (5,6) - ye gotta hit both keys for special emphasis

good luck!
posted
我的马这个ar sv肾疼
beginner
01:39:534 (3) - 这个 我觉得折返的那个时间点上没有音 1/1吧
easy
00:15:355 - 如果可以的话从这里到第一次break结束的slidertick给消掉 感觉跟弦乐有这玩意很别扭
01:40:877 (5,6) - ??????

摸不出什么啊sad
posted
WA! M4M~

[beginner]
00:31:923 - 稍微重拉下滑条,使光球经过时正好在红色转点那
01:35:952 (1,2) - 目测blanket不太到位
01:55:967 (1) - 觉得转盘结束的位置还有待 可以接受

[easy]
01:19:832 (5,6) - 我觉得完全可以做成这样 空1/2在图里也多得很啊
01:44:683 (2,3,4) - 摆的有点迷惑性

扑通!我是真的摸不出来啊,可以随时来找我要摸
posted
拯救华语乐坛系列

就很尴尬,什么都摸不出来,就很尴尬,很尴尬,尴尬......
大部分都是nazi(不要问我为什么怎么做的那种)啊选点改就好....
我不知道近几年来有没有改,不过以前来讲有要求说一首曲子不能空20%上下不map,然后这张图前后加起来空了近30%没map....所以要不要考虑把最后的尾巴给咔嚓一下?如果需要的话我可以帮忙
Widescreen Support关掉
[Beginner]
00:39:534 (x) - 我觉得这里可以加个spinner就很酷
01:55:967 (1) - 拉到下一个红线结尾感觉比较好

[Easy]
01:41:549 (x) - 这个音很重哦不考虑加上么
01:44:460 (x) - ^
01:46:699 (5) - NC一发
01:55:967 (1) - 拉到下一个红线结尾感觉比较好

没了...感觉摸这么少很对不起你,给几个星星聊表歉意
posted

Moh_Magdy wrote:

Hi there o/
I'm a new mapper from your queue, I hope my mod helps Yeah! Thank you!

Beginner:
00:27:893 (1) - I think this should be a 1 beat slider with a reverse Consider this is a Beginner diff, it might not be a good idea to map all the beats out.

00:40:430 (2) - Maybe something here to represent the different sound (NC or different slider shape)

00:45:803 - I think this should be a 1 beat slider with a reverse too, but you could ignore it since the music is calm yeah calm music, so keep this

01:39:534 - I think you should do something like this, as I think that this sound 01:40:430 - is stronger than this 01:40:878 - sound, so you should ignore the second one rather than the first one. I noticed that you didn't want to use time gaps less than 1 beat (aside from the beginning), but I'd say this is the most intense part of the song (Vocals and drums), so you could do that and use a new combo and different slider shape to indicate the change, or you could just do something similar to this and ignore this 01:41:773 - sound

01:59:596 - Lower the volume for the spinner end
Easy:
00:27:445 - You can add a circle here

00:35:057 - 1/2 slider with a reverse(?) Don't want to add too many 1/2s
00:36:848 - ^

01:20:504 (6) - I think placing something on a blue tick is hard to read for new players(?) I think 1/3 is okay, considering this BPM
01:44:683 (2) - ^ you can start this on the red tick before it

01:59:596 - Lower the volume for the spinner end


That's all I could find, if I said something wrong, I'd appreciate it if you explain to me why you did it like that, as I'm a new mapper, so this would help me improve

Good luck with the map ^-^
@Amamiya Kanade: :cry:
00:15:355 - 如果可以的话从这里到第一次break结束的slidertick给消掉 感觉跟弦乐有这玩意很别扭 不好,因为已经消音了sliderslide

@rs_fadeaway
01:19:832 (5,6) - 我觉得完全可以做成这样 还是不了 其他地方的被我删了

@tutuhaha:
Beginner:
00:39:534 (x) - 我觉得这里可以加个spinner就很酷 鉴于难度限制 还是不了
01:55:967 (1) - 拉到下一个红线结尾感觉比较好 后面的位置比较模糊 这里刚好有乐器 感觉还是这里比较好

Easy:
01:41:549 (x) - 这个音很重哦不考虑加上么 这里的节奏重新改了,下同。现在更符合Easy的难度要求
01:44:460 (x) - ^
01:46:699 (5) - NC一发 不了,会破坏整体的NC结构

Thanks for modding!
Other all fixed!

I cut the mp3 to meet the RC.
I am not planning to add higher diffs since I think they do not match with the style of the song and will sound quite overmapped.
posted
looking good
posted
Thanks a lot! :D
posted
placeholder
posted
BG by Everlasting Summer lol
posted
general

  1. 00:49:384 (2) - some slider ticks like this one sounds too loud compared to the music, specially when there is no piano sound, would be cool if you reduce the volume of those a bit


normal

  1. 00:51:624 - don't you think that the pianos at the red tick are too loud to being ignored a 1/2 repeat slider would fit the music a lot better
  2. 00:59:235 (3) - same


easy

  1. 00:40:430 (3) - you better remove that tiny break, tbh it will take everyone offguard and miss the next note xd
  2. 01:54:758 (4,5) - a slider would work better for an easy diff
posted

Natsu wrote:

general

  1. 00:49:384 (2) - some slider ticks like this one sounds too loud compared to the music, specially when there is no piano sound, would be cool if you reduce the volume of those a bit
Lowered to 10% for volume of this part

normal

  1. 00:51:624 - don't you think that the pianos at the red tick are too loud to being ignored a 1/2 repeat slider would fit the music a lot better
  2. 00:59:235 (3) - same


easy

  1. 00:40:430 (3) - you better remove that tiny break, tbh it will take everyone offguard and miss the next note xd
  2. 01:54:758 (4,5) - a slider would work better for an easy diff
all fixed!
thank you!
posted
cool
posted
Congratz!!
posted
I disagree with the diff spread.

0.76* makes sense for an Easy diff, but 0.94* for a Normal? That's barely a difference from the Easy diff. Sure, people may say that "SR is messed up for low bpm songs" but songs with similar bpms have Normal diffs >1.3*. Since 0.94* is significantly lower than every other map of similar bpm, and the Normal diff is like 0.18* (~25%) more difficult than the Easy diff, the spread issues revolving around SR shouldn't be ignored.

Also the map is 2 minutes long... Surely more diffs can be made other than just an Easy and Normal..? This map could definitely be better...

My thoughts.
posted

ignorance wrote:

I disagree with the diff spread.

0.76* makes sense for an Easy diff, but 0.94* for a Normal? That's barely a difference from the Easy diff. Sure, people may say that "SR is messed up for low bpm songs" but songs with similar bpms have Normal diffs >1.3*. Since 0.94* is significantly lower than every other map of similar bpm, and the Normal diff is like 0.18* (~25%) more difficult than the Easy diff, the spread issues revolving around SR shouldn't be ignored.

Also the map is 2 minutes long... Surely more diffs can be made other than just an Easy and Normal..? This map could definitely be better...

My thoughts.
lol, personally I think the normal diff is enough for this kind of song
Please sign in to reply.