no reply=fixedHootOwlStar wrote:
generalnormal
- would suggest to shift the circle sizes a little. normal to 3.5 and hard to 3.8 would be better since it produces a progression throughout the difficulties and smaller circle size in normal would make the whole map neater in my opinion imo current CS choose is good
- personally think the background image is rather bland and a concert image would be more fitting since it shows a livelier atmosphere and could represent the whole song a little bit better. also it would be cool if you include the official video in the set I decided to use dark BG because one of the members of the group had died, about the video, it ends very suddenly and idk if it will fit the map but if anyone will help me with it I'll add it
- consider to add alternative and electronic in the tags to indicate the genres
hard
- 00:22:062 (5) - seems out of place in terms of rhythm and it doesn't really represent the music as good as before, so consider to remove the note
- 00:23:271 - it would be better if you could implement a click here to indicate the introduction of the first verse since covering the note up with a reverse didn't really bring out a sense of emphasis to the shifting of the intensity
- 00:59:078 (3,4) - distance snap problem
- 01:19:400 (1) - didn't really get the purpose of the spinner as well as in hard and insane diff, like you should either start the spinner at 01:17:465 - or 01:21:336 - imo + putting the spinner here causes the two drum notes before the first kiai to be forcibly missed and it really isn't a great idea to be honest i'll think
good luck in everything for everyone
- relatively this difficulty is blander than the other difficulties since the aesthetic didn't stand out and the rhythm choice is not representative especially the circle spamming in the kiai parts but it's just my point of view so idk
- aesthetic nitpicks: 00:18:916 (4,1) - seem to be clumped and untidy so consider to add a little more distance in between i cant because i didnt change ds in this part anywhere + 00:49:400 (3,1) - consider to add in better blankets or such irdk i don't want to use so many blankets
- 02:40:207 (4) - rhythm wise it would be more interesting if you implement two circles instead of a slider to make the moment denser and stand out from the previous three crotchets
- 03:04:884 (2) - applying a different rhythm for this note, like putting two similar 1/2 sliders instead of 1/2 reverses as before, would differentiate the change in instrument in a much more interesting way im not sure
thx