1. 52's Taiko (4,83 stars, 1154 notes)
2. hackSL's Insane (4,99 stars, 561 notes)
3. Hard (4,83 stars, 490 notes)
4. Normal (2,98 stars, 258 notes)

Hellzero wrote:

General
BG конешно няшный :3 но размер не подходящий нужно либо 800*600 либо 1024*768 — ресайзнул до 1024х768.
http://puu.sh/3pwr < твой мп3. В осу разрешен максимум 192кб. Нужно будет исправить, но не обязательно сейчас (ибо оффсет собьется) — исправил (странно, и правда сбился. Вроде +30 мс).
http://puu.sh/3pww < Удалить ненужный осб файл — удалил.
Tags на обеих дифах должен совпадать — совпали.

Yarrr!
03:21:200 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7) - увидев этот момент не сразу понял что это антиджампы, ибо нет никаких подсказок даже музыка не меняется. Лучше поменять — поменял.
03:22:800 - KIAI закончить тут ( на всех дифах) — закончил.
Ну и к хитсаундам думаю стоит добавит побольше свистков например:
00:22:200 (8,10) - свисток на слайдеры
00:25:600 (5) - ^
00:28:800 (1,3,5) - свисток на начало слайдеров
00:31:200 (7) - свисток
и т.д. будет веселее играться — подбавил, плюс ещё на своё усмотрение пару прилепил.
и добавь несколько финишей, а то не увидел ни одного О_о
01:00:800 (1) - тут
01:00:800 (1) - тут
и т.д — добавил.

Elly-chan wrote:

(General)
For the difficulty 'Yarrr!', Please do not use 1/8 snap divisor. it screws up the note placement. ;~; Put the notes on the ticks after you change it back to 1/4 — done.
Do not start the preview point at the beginning of the map. I suggest you start it at 00:14:430 or at the beginning of one of the kiais. Sooner or later someone else is gonna rage about it if you keep it as it is atm. — done.
Make audio lead-in the same as Easy and Yarrr! :3 — what for? There is «built-in» lead-in in my diffs.
Each map should have the same Kiai time and almost all the same breaks. Fix this. — fixed kiai, breaks are fine.
I also know this is WIP, but don't forget to add a normal mode. — maybe.. later. I think Easy is enough.

(Easy)
00:08:030 (Break) - Make it start here. — done.
00:23:630 (x) - Add note here. — done
01:13:630 (Break) - Make it start here. — done.

(Yarrr!)
For the first break, move the break start point to 00:08:030. It'd make it look cooler. — done.
00:26:430 (Break) - Map Over This. Too short of a break. — mapped.
00:34:630 (x) - Add Note Here? — no.
00:27:230 (Break) - Make it start here. — done.
01:14:430 - Change this slider shape. — changed.
Too lazy for the rest, hope this helped though.

G.J, You, sir, deserve a star. — Thanks, where is my star T_T (joke, hah).

TicClick wrote:

Elly-chan wrote:

G.J, You, sir, deserve a star. — Thanks, where is my star T_T (joke, hah).

1. Why is "He is a Pirate" on the tags? The song is already named that way - you have to remove that from the tags.
2. Everything else looks nice and tidy~

1. 00:02:830 (2) - Why is this soo close to (1)? You see, it isn't easy for a new player to "understand" that they have to wait two beats there to hit. They will most likely rush on it. So it won't help them understand the way in which spacing works if you start the song like this xD
   Here, try this:
   
   SPOILER

   
   And here is the code, in case you want to add it directly by editing the .osu file:
   

   120,184,1230,2,0,B|148:244|216:252|216:252|216:176,1,200
   392,184,2830,2,0,B|364:244|296:252|296:252|296:176,1,200

2. 00:51:630 (2) - Nice slider art! I would have liked to see a complete pirate hat, instead of just half of it
3. 01:13:630 - 01:28:030 - This break is too long in my opinion... And also, you have quiet a lot of breaks in this map, so I'd recommend you to map this part. At least, it won't be so blank
4. 02:20:830 - This kiai doesn't create a good effect, imo. I mean... There is nothing that indicates to use a kiai there. I wasn't even expecting it when suddenly, boom! Kiai Please remove it~
5. 02:29:430 (7) - And this here, well, seems random at this point xD. Perhaps it's better to remove this and keep the 1/1 pattern.
6. 02:30:430 (1) - As in the very best point of the mod (of this diff), this is too close to the previous object. Please, place it somewhere further.
7. 02:46:430 (1,1,1) - No, please. Don't use hold sliders like this in the easiest difficulty. Please. At least make this 1/2 long, the effect won't change much.
   But I still think that this isn't a good idea. If you can map this in any other way that you like, not using those hold sliders... It will be much better, trust me.
8. 03:21:830 (2) - Perhaps you could remove this. This is because that kind of mini-stream can give some newbies problems, and since they had two 3-circles-long streams before, it will be a little easier to play this one!

1. Having this difficulty as the only one with a real custom name is pretty random xD Could you please just call it [Hard]?
2. The jump in difficulty from the Easy to this here is... Way too big. Please, consider mapping an intermediate difficulty (aka, a Normal).
3. 00:53:830 (5,6,7) - Can you move these so that they aren't overlapped by (3)'s hitburst?
4. 01:19:130 (9,10) - Remove the finish from (9), and the clap from (10). It doesn't sound good as you have it :C
5. Ok, a couple of things I want to mention in general:
   
   1. Many of your combos go up to like 13, 14, or even 15. Try to avoid that. Always try to make your combos not exageratedly long, being 9 or 10 objects long as a maximum.
   2. Try not to make so much overlapping. Your objects (sliders, circles) should be easily visible. It's best for the player and looks much better most of the time

1. 01:13:230 - About the break that starts here, I should say: guys! please decide! xD I mean, it's used in Easy and here, but not in that "Yarrr!" difficulty! Please, be consistent about this :T
2. Can't really say much, but it looks WAY too overmapped. And I'm not a big fan of overmapping, but oh well...

1. Разобраться с перерывами

EEeee wrote:

Normal
01:32:430 (6) - add new combo seems right to me — added.
01:38:430 (5) - ^ — ^
01:43:630 (6) - ^ — ^

Hard
Looks good :O

hackSL's Insane
00:02:430 (1) - remove new combo? — removed.
00:23:030 (8) - add new combo — added.
00:50:830 (4) - add new combo — added.
01:01:230 (6) - ^ — ^
01:52:030 (6) - ^ — ^
hmmm, that's about it

MoodyRPG wrote:

Easy
00:20:030 (7) - Delete whistle — no, I think it sounds better.
00:23:630 (5) - More symetric with (4) — don't know what you're talking about, but moved that.
00:24:030 (1) - End this spin in 00:27:230 and delete whistle — fixed.
00:34:430 (4) - Delete whistle — no, I think it sounds better.
01:29:630 (4) - Maybe new combo? — later, after waves.
01:31:230 (3) - ^ — ^

sherrie__fay wrote:

General :

Offset should be equal in every difficulty — we haven't decided yet what to do with insane diff. Workin' on that.
Add Pirates of the Caribbean on the source (as it's the soundtrack) and add "Hans Zimmer" and "Klaus Badelt" to the tags (they are the original creators of the song) — this is techno remix of the song so there is no source


Normal :
+1 Drain Rate HP ? — Don't know if this is really needed.
00:08:030 (1) - 00:13:630 - I think a spinner will be nice here — no.
00:22:029 (7) - You can improve the art of the slider, maybe like this — Thanks. Not this, but I fixed it anyway.
00:28:829 (1) - Hitsound Finish at the start of the slider — no, thanks.
00:27:230 - Remove this break, the arrows are above the spin — I added slider to fill it.
03:01:230 (4,5,6) - this is confusing, snap the (5) in 1/4 ( http://puu.sh/3Pca ) — what the hell?! I bet I didn't use 1/3 here. Fixed, thank you.
03:10:830 (3,4,5) - same ^ — fixed.
03:21:830 (2,3,4,5,6) - same ^ ( http://puu.sh/3Pcd ) — fixed.

Hard :
Why did you mapped it all in 1/3, only this part should be in 1/3 " 00:01:276 - / 00:07:276 " , from here 00:14:430 (1) - the Beat Snap Divisor should be setted to 1/4, let's fix and snap them in 1/4, (02:07:629 (1) - here 1/3 starts again and it finish here 02:14:429) so it's okay there the 1/3, until the finish it should be mapped to 1/4 again — holy shit. Looks like I accidently selected RESNAP ALL NOTES. Thank you again; fixed that.

+star, nice map and moe background >//<

TicClick wrote:

this is techno remix of the song so there is no source

HeatKai wrote:

Can I make a taiko diff?

CracK wrote:

[Hard]
00:04:476 (1,2) - лучше бы были короткие слайдеры+круги — Исправил. И правда лучше.
01:34:030 (1) - не звучит. я бы сократил и добавил круг — Исправил.

в звуках мне не нравятся только слайдеры со свистком.. если ты хочешь их оставить, то мб поставь на начало этих слайдеров ещё свистки — Я убрал свисток с большинства тел, поставил на начало.

02:14:430 (5) - — Пофиксил брейк, как ты и посоветовал.

Lizzehb wrote:

[Normal]

00:23:230 (4) - Add whistle? — Not bad.
03:01:230 (4,5,6) - strange triple since it's not in the rest of the map. — No. But I found another mistakes, thank you.
03:09:630 (2) - This slider needs to decide if it's straight or curved. — Okay. It decided to be curved.
03:19:630 (2) - Center this beetween the sliders better, it's a bit off. — Remapped.
03:21:830 (2,3,4,5) - What I said before...not in the rest of the map except twice? Kinda strange. — I like this moment so I think I leave it as it is.

[Hard]

00:22:230 (8) - This slider shape could be better. — No; that's exactly what I want.
00:23:030 (10) - ^ — The same.
00:28:830 (1) - ^ — Okay, fixed.
00:32:630 (2) - Move this note to it's in the center of those sliders. — Done.
00:40:030 (7) - Ahhh I dislike this slider shape too. — Me too; I deleted it and used notes here.
01:26:430 (x) - I'd end the spinner here. — No, I think it sounds better when it ends at 01:25:630.
01:55:630 (2) - I don't hear any music at this part, kinda strange for a note to be there. — I made slider instead of two notes

CracK wrote:

[hackSL's Insane]
00:00:076 (1) - лучше бы поставил что-нибудь начиная с 00:01:276
00:02:342 (X) - круг
00:03:076 (1,2,3) - не подходит. потому что здесь не 1/4 и нет такого в самой музыке
переделай под 1/3. и следующий слайдер тоже
00:06:342 (X) - круг
я бы и здесь ещё добавил правда 00:06:209 (X)
01:03:730 (X) - круг
01:10:130 (4) - перенеси на 01:10:330
01:29:630 (1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9) - что-то неладное со спейсингом здесь. если хочешь - можешь не менять, но хотя бы отодвинь всё подальше от следующего слайдера
02:00:696 (8) - плохо. потому как должна быть кнопочка на 02:00:830, иначе странно звучит
02:07:630 (1,2,3,4,5) - переделай в 1/3. такие слайдеры с возвратами очень не ок
02:14:230 (9) - тоже
02:16:230 (2) - ^
02:18:530 (6,7) - ^