1. Insane (4.98 stars, 489 notes)
2. Nana's Normal (3.21 stars, 226 notes)
3. yuca's Hard (4.67 stars, 361 notes)

loveFantasy wrote:

[yuca's Hard]
- many green lines :3 otsukaresama
<00:37:220> (9) end at 00:37:382, add note at 00:38:199?
- same to all 2.5-beats slider + circle afterward if you want to avoid ugly slider tick point
<00:40:807> (7) move 1 grid right (Grid level 4)fixed
<00:43:579> (14) don't stack (14)?
<00:51:242> (8) move 1 grid right too (lv4) :3fixed
<00:54:014> (14) don't stack (14)?
<00:57:112> decrease spacing (4,1)fixed
<01:00:046> ^fixed
<01:01:351> (4) is very very hard to readfixed
<01:46:839> KIAI end here?fixed
<02:02:165> (6,8) stack directly or add spacing?changed stack
<02:07:708> insert break time after this?fixed
<02:51:078> KIAI end here?fixed
<03:17:817> (2) 1 grid up (Grid level 4)fixed
<03:32:654> (2) 1 grid downfixed

Mafiamaster wrote:

[yuca]
Your stack leniency is unrankable. Increase it by 1 tick or more.
01:01:351 (4) - The spacing of this note compared to the rest of the combo is a bit weird　fixed.

Mafiamaster wrote:

[Normal]
01:02:166 (5) - New combo? k

[Insane]
Stack leniency is unrankable.@_@0.2 is actually rankable(said xier), ive been using 0.2 in the past
01:07:709 - There's no uninherited timing section here like the other difficulties. oops my bad

How about changing the background to .jpg instead of .png? done

xierbaliti wrote:

-Insane-
00:50:753 (2,3) - 换成我的话会把(2)移到后面红线上 也就是这样: http://osu.ppy.sh/ss/76570 不知道你怎么看:D 改了:D，感觉100%的时候听起来不是很明显，25%就感觉不错。
00:55:644 (5) - 不太喜欢这跳啊:<这个感觉会被骂，扔掉了。

音量太小了:< 打着没手感 ~_~ 节奏总是被音乐拐走 D:加了5%，这歌很柔于是whistle超响DDD:

-Normal-
03:36:730 (5) - 把grid snap去掉重新调整下位置._.不太清楚具体哪里不好，改了一下你看看？

Gens wrote:

I just need to know why is stacking semi-disabled in the last two difficulties, because, as far as I knew, that's unrankable, and I don't really see why you'd have it like that in any case. Is it only because you hate it?

And, by the way, while I'm at it, I should probably point out that you shouldn't do stuff like [Normal] 03:29:719 (6), because it pisses players off when losing the combo. It is of no vital importance (although it'd be nice if you changed it), just take it in account for future maps.

Quick pop in the meantime.

Gens wrote:

Eh, for the record, I think it's looks uglier without stacking than with stacking...

Just to give some examples: (yuca's difficulty)

--

I haven't tested the whole map with stacking enabled, but I don't recall any pattern that could mess up thanks to stacking.

Being an standard and all I really think you should change it. The general consensus is that stacking is unrankable when stacking no longer occurs, and in this case, stacking does not occur in most of the map. The stacking options are there in case they mess up important patterns or look terribly ugly, but stacking should be enabled for the whole map.

I asked a few other BATs and they seem to agree with me (and I seem to recall peppy warning that if this goes on he'll disable the stacking options from editor). I realize you've gotten ranked maps with this setting, and I guess I can't justify it; maybe other people don't care as much as I do.

Sorry for being this stubborn, by the way. Making you rage or anything like that isn't really my purpose, and also sorry if I'm being offensive.

Also, thanks for fixing the slider at normal. There's another slider like it in yuca's difficulty (I was just generalizing in the first post), right at 02:38:687 (7), but don't worry, this is the only other one I remember; in the other cases the slider is isolated and it's sightreadable, but this one is really prone to combo-breaking.