forum

CtB Nomination Group [BN Request Queue] [Closed]

posted
Total Posts
30
Topic Starter
Ascendance
To moderators: This queue is in the CTB subforum since it's a specialized type of queue directed at this community. Please do not move it to the Modding Queues forum. Thanks!

Queue Status: Closed


Introduction



Hello! It's with great pleasure that I've decided to announce the first formal queue of the CtB Beatmap Nomination Group (BNG). We hope that this queue will solve the problems we've been having in CtB recently, and help towards a more unified team of nominators to properly distribute and quicken work around here. The purpose of the queue is simple. The centralization of work among the BNG members will not only increase the quality of mapsets across the board, but also create new means for discussion between us, which in turn, will improve our own outlook on maps. Members of the Beatmap Nomination Group will take BN check requests from ONLY this queue (NM/M4M will be done on their own) so that way we have a centralized way to deal with the workload on our shoulders. If you're a member of the Quality Assurance Team (QAT) and are interested in joining this group as well, please contact me directly.

How the Queue works



General

  1. This queue will run on a round-style basis. This is to prevent people from submitting 6 maps at once, as well as make the load more manageable for us in the BNG.
  2. You can submit maps of your own or maps of other people to be considered by the queue.
  3. This is NOT a NM or M4M queue. Anything that doesn't meet our quality standards for a BN check will be declined, possibly with no further modding.
For members of the Beatmap Nomination Group

Joining this queue is NOT mandatory, though it is HIGHLY recommended. Your job in this queue is to maintain a solid standard of activity, as well as provide input on as many maps as you can, whether it be a small opinion or a larger discussion. The process is simple:

  1. A map is submitted to the queue
  2. The map either receives 3 "yes" votes, or 2 "no" votes. The map will then either be moved to the Nomination pool, or out of the Submission pool, respectively.
  3. Once in the Nomination pool, a discussion of ~4-7 days will open up about the map for all nominators to give their input on the map's quality before it's pushed forward (Not just the ones who've claimed to icon it). At this time, members will be able to air any concerns they might have with the map, and discuss it more thoroughly.
  4. After this, you'll claim slot 1, 2, or 3 if it's an approval map. This is the order of icons that will be given out to the map. This system is to set a clear idea of who wants to check the map, and also prevent overlapping mods. Of course, if you feel like adding an extra slot simply to improve the quality of the map before it's pushed to qualified, then you'll be allowed to do so.
  5. Following that, the map will be modded and pushed into ranking by us.
For people looking to submit to the queue

For both members of the queue and mappers alike, submitting to the queue is fairly easy. There's no prerequisite of modding or mapping, but only simply to be putting forward maps that you feel meet the quality standard of the BNG.

  1. You are allowed to submit 1 map per round. This means either your map OR someone else's, but not both.
  2. You cannot post a map of someone who has already has a map of their own submitted this round. (If someone else submits one of your maps, but you want to submit something else of yours, the map that you submit will take priority.)
  3. The mapset owner must be the one to submit the map, meaning GD'ers must inform the mapset owner in order to submit here. (This applies to GD's only.)
  4. Your map should meet basic criteria such as +12 SP, a few mods, etc.
  5. Your map must be rankable. Submitting maps with incomplete spreads, unrankable elements, or any other blatantly low quality usages of the editor will be declined.

Members


Please post in this thread if you have an interest in joining.


Ascendance - Beatmap Nomination Group
- Magic Bomb - - Beatmap Nomination Group
alienflybot - Beatmap Nomination Group
ZiRoX - Beatmap Nomination Group
Xinely - Beatmap Nomination Group
[Sc4v4ng3r] - Beatmap Nomination Group
Yuii- - Beatmap Nomination Group

Map List



Submission Pool:
The submission pool serves to be an indicator of maps that have been submitted to this queue, and a way for mappers to check the status of their maps as we discuss them.

  1. Oskar Schuster - Fjarlaegur (Cypix Remix) - By Jusenkyo (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  2. saradisk - 176 - ikazuchi - By Riari (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  3. LeaF - Evanescent - By Anxient (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  4. nomico / DOWNFORCE - BRAVE OUT - By SYAHME (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  5. Chino(CV.Minase Inori) - Mahou Shoujo Chino (nenpulse bootleg remix) - By Asahina Momoko (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  6. Satoshi (CV:Rica Matsumoto) - XY&Z - By rew0825 (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  7. Painty the Pirate & Kids - Spongebob SquarePants Theme - By Dyl-Byl (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  8. sakuzyo - Refel - By Nelly (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  9. DJ Totoriott - Chronoxia - By Kyuare (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  10. goreshit - burn this moment into the retina of my eye - By Razor Sharp (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  11. Pierce The Veil - Texas Is Forever - By puxtu (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
  12. Alestorm - You Are A Pirate - By BoberOfDarkness (Status: Awaiting Discussion)
Nomination Pool:
The nomination pool serves as an indicator of maps that have passed our prerequisites of quality and are ready to be nominated by our members!

  1. None
MBomb
I have 100% no interest in joining this queue, now add me to the members.
autofanboy
hehe xd
Topic Starter
Ascendance
bn circlejerk
Sonnyc
Good to see this!
Topic Starter
Ascendance

Sonnyc wrote:

Good to see this!
:D Your post really inspired it, so thanks!
Sonnyc
Good to hear that! /runs

Btw I'd like to ask when things get moved to the nomination pool. I assume mb wasn't joining the queue when you made the post, so.. Does that 3 votes for yes means it needs agreement from more than half of the bn? I feel a little confused atm x,x
Topic Starter
Ascendance

Sonnyc wrote:

Good to hear that! /runs

Btw I'd like to ask when things get moved to the nomination pool. I assume mb wasn't joining the queue when you made the post, so.. Does that 3 votes for yes means it needs agreement from more than half of the bn? I feel a little confused atm x,x
The members here agreed before the queue was made, so I had this in mind before I made the queue. 3 "Yes" votes is approximately half of our current members (3/6). The numbers will be tweaked as more members join, but basically the point is to incorporate discussion before and after voting, to ensure that we're making the right choices when moving maps forward.
Kagari
hi
Topic Starter
Ascendance

Kagari wrote:

hi
hi
Xinely

Ascendance wrote:

bn circlejerk
Cowboy
Wait Wait Wait Wait
Topic Starter
Ascendance

Round 1



We'll be taking requests until August 14th. If you think you have a map ready for nomination, throw it to us here!

A reminder to members of the BNG on this queue, you are NOT allowed to accept BN check/icon requests for CTB from outside of this queue anymore. All requests must be redirected to here!
Cowboy
t/474367

I'll try my luck!

Thanks in advance <3
Riari
Anxient
Kagari

Ascendance wrote:

A reminder to members of the BNG on this queue, you are NOT allowed to accept BN check/icon requests for CTB from outside of this queue anymore. All requests must be redirected to here!
oh...

k
SYAHME
If I lucky,
Maps link: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/469487
Thanks.
Asahina Momoko
oh apparently i should request validly here

https://osu.ppy.sh/s/458983

thanks!
rew0825
Qiyana
If I lucky,
Maps link: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/399704
Thanks.
Kimitakari
Kyuare
Hi, Chronoxia: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/429184
Thanks.
puxtu
BoberOfDarkness
Topic Starter
Ascendance

Closed!



Be sure to check back in regularly to check the status of your map! A reminder to PLEASE not rush us!
ZiRoX
I think I should give a small update on the status of this queue, since a few weeks have passed without word. So, here's some facts:

1) Since Ascendance is no longer a BN, I'm taking leadership of this queue. However, Ascendance was willing to keep helping us as the CtB BNG is a bit undermanned, so we will be keeping him as a voting member.
2) Some of us were a little bit too harsh when casting votes, basically expecting maps to be already perfect instead of a "near rankable state", which resulted in a lot of the submitted maps failing to pass. We discussed this, reaching the conclusion that we should be a bit more lenient when casting votes, giving a "Yes" to maps that would meet our quality criteria after we mod them, rather than expect them to be perfect beforehand. For this reason, we're re-casting our votes, hoping that some maps will be able to pass to the Nomination Pool.
3) We received a lot of submissions for this first round, so for the next rounds we're probably limiting the number of submissions we will accept each round. We're also discussing adding some additional requirements, though they won't be that hard to fulfill. This is still under discussion.

I am sorry that we've taken this long (and we aren't even ready, considering the changes we've discussed as of today), but we're trying to learn from the mistakes we've made this round to get this queue working in a more steady manner.
Kimitakari
Hope it will be active once again. Good luck!

Also would be nice to make a 3 slots in each round? 3 completed requests, 3 new requests in each round
ZiRoX
I'm sorry to announce that this queue isn't a thing anymore. Some members didn't have the commitment such a project needed, and the queue is incapable of working that way since it requires a team effort.
Deif
Talked to ZiRoX about the status of the queue and it seems to be totally inactive. Gotta close it at the moment so people don't wait for the results of it anymore, moreover to make clear that the participating BNs should be modding on their own accord from now on (I suppose).
Please sign in to reply.

New reply