forum
Report a Qualified beatmap here!
posted
Total Posts
2,851
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/6535920
Mappers willing to change things based off suggestions on their respective difficulties.
✓ by Mao
Mappers willing to change things based off suggestions on their respective difficulties.
✓ by Mao
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/699588/discussion/1481914/general/pending
stiff movement due to very low sv, wide angles and huge spacing on highest diff
stiff movement due to very low sv, wide angles and huge spacing on highest diff
MBomb
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/694107/discussion
Emphasis issues as well as some consistency issues that stand out quite a bit. Also, a few recommendations to get rid of silence in the mp3, to make breaks less tedious.
(Only 1/3rd of the map has been checked, rest can be checked later on, posting now due to how close to ranked the set is).
✓ by Deif
Emphasis issues as well as some consistency issues that stand out quite a bit. Also, a few recommendations to get rid of silence in the mp3, to make breaks less tedious.
(Only 1/3rd of the map has been checked, rest can be checked later on, posting now due to how close to ranked the set is).
✓ by Deif
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/732994/discussion/-/generalAll#/146547
various smaller things that add up (missing hitsounds in many of the diffs, low hitsound volume, weird 1/1-gaps in insane, out of place pattern in mir's)
✓ by Mao
various smaller things that add up (missing hitsounds in many of the diffs, low hitsound volume, weird 1/1-gaps in insane, out of place pattern in mir's)
✓ by Mao
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/736560/discussion/1554502/general#/146254
There are plenty of points made about this maps construction and obvious purpose. An active discussion is underway and I believe it would be appropriate to DQ so that the mapper may be more willing to cooperate rather than blindly refusing all points to avoid DQ. In general the map specifically avoids all "difficult" rhythms of 1/4 even though for a map of this difficulty that seems highly inappropriate. I understand it's subjective but flat out ignoring a large component of the game (streaming) where there are clear points in which the songs not only support it but are built for it seems highly inappropriate. There are a couple specific points I mentioned where the mapper simply uses 1/4th roll over for rhythms that are far more intricate than simple passive rhythm.
Lets make mapping great again!
As a side note I would also like to also share this image where Sotarks deliberately tells me that he will not change anything no matter what I say. This seems pretty counter productive considering the purpose of qualified is for maps to be given a chance for community feedback and goes against the code of conduct.
https://puu.sh/zGQQo/80bf9ea84b.jpg
Since I cant post a second time I'll just do it here:
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/725171/discussion/1541573/general#/146173
The usage of an 85 note combo cannot be left up to a community to discuss. I'm simply asking for clarification on this as I want to make sure that it's not something simply being overlooked and that osu! will allow such a rational in the future for all maps. Please consider at least addressing this formally QAT, thank you.
There are plenty of points made about this maps construction and obvious purpose. An active discussion is underway and I believe it would be appropriate to DQ so that the mapper may be more willing to cooperate rather than blindly refusing all points to avoid DQ. In general the map specifically avoids all "difficult" rhythms of 1/4 even though for a map of this difficulty that seems highly inappropriate. I understand it's subjective but flat out ignoring a large component of the game (streaming) where there are clear points in which the songs not only support it but are built for it seems highly inappropriate. There are a couple specific points I mentioned where the mapper simply uses 1/4th roll over for rhythms that are far more intricate than simple passive rhythm.
Lets make mapping great again!
As a side note I would also like to also share this image where Sotarks deliberately tells me that he will not change anything no matter what I say. This seems pretty counter productive considering the purpose of qualified is for maps to be given a chance for community feedback and goes against the code of conduct.
https://puu.sh/zGQQo/80bf9ea84b.jpg
Since I cant post a second time I'll just do it here:
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/725171/discussion/1541573/general#/146173
The usage of an 85 note combo cannot be left up to a community to discuss. I'm simply asking for clarification on this as I want to make sure that it's not something simply being overlooked and that osu! will allow such a rational in the future for all maps. Please consider at least addressing this formally QAT, thank you.
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/694402#osu/1469136
Unsnapped notes in light insane : https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/694402/discussion/1569768/timeline#/146554
✓ by Lasse
Unsnapped notes in light insane : https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/694402/discussion/1569768/timeline#/146554
✓ by Lasse
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/737714#osu/1556943
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/737714/discussion/1562274/timeline#/138950
Diffspike, making spread with Hard questionable, in addition with some wrong emphasis on last diff + difficult rhythm on lower diff.
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/737714/discussion/1562274/timeline#/138950
Diffspike, making spread with Hard questionable, in addition with some wrong emphasis on last diff + difficult rhythm on lower diff.
MBomb
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/694025/discussion/1468430/
Quite a few comments on how general emphasis can be improved consistency wise.
Quite a few comments on how general emphasis can be improved consistency wise.
Kuron-kun
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/6537046#p6537046
really overmapped rhythm in expert, some inconsistencies with spacing and emphasis issues
✓ by Myxomatosis
really overmapped rhythm in expert, some inconsistencies with spacing and emphasis issues
✓ by Myxomatosis
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/680812
00:32:250 - oddly inconsistent rhythm
01:00:107 (2) - 01:16:920 (8) - really poorly done overmapping
00:32:250 - oddly inconsistent rhythm
01:00:107 (2) - 01:16:920 (8) - really poorly done overmapping
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/728885#osu/1554749
taiko
lack of variation, full of copypasta well saw some small variation tho still feels dull, im okay with this
barlines issues
and 1 inconsistent note on muzu
taiko
barlines issues
and 1 inconsistent note on muzu
Kuron-kun
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/740043/discussion/1561320/timeline#/147507
wrongly snapped slider (1/16) and some spacing suggestions
wrongly snapped slider (1/16) and some spacing suggestions
https://osu.ppy.sh/forum/p/6537854
SB went wrong, missing hitsounds and few quality issues for the top diff
SB went wrong, missing hitsounds and few quality issues for the top diff
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/724844/discussion/-/generalAll/pending
Too low hitsound volume, and some more or less minor suggestions
Too low hitsound volume, and some more or less minor suggestions
https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1377245
normal diff uses tick rate 2 which is inconsistent from other diffs and renders ticks invisible for the entirety of the map.
normal diff uses tick rate 2 which is inconsistent from other diffs and renders ticks invisible for the entirety of the map.
Kuron-kun
Mir wrote:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/728276
od 10 seems unjustified since notelocking at this bpm is kind of unavoidable and a lot of the streams are overlapping aside from certain emphasized spaced streams
also "axarious said it would be unique" doesnt seem like solid reasoning to keep it either - suggested od to not exceed 9.4
Kuron-kun wrote:
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/724883/discussion/-/generalAll#/144809
needless timing point that could be fixed by adjusting offset
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/691546
normal diff needs some work on NCs and Hard diff is missing some important hitsounds on some sections.
normal diff needs some work on NCs and Hard diff is missing some important hitsounds on some sections.
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/694402/discussion
this map has a bunch of burai sliders indicated by my "mod"
this map has a bunch of burai sliders indicated by my "mod"
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/734616
Insufficient rest moments in Muzukashii, and over the top 1/6 usage in the top diff, plus some minor suggestions to improve structure and flow.
(done by Raiden)
Insufficient rest moments in Muzukashii, and over the top 1/6 usage in the top diff, plus some minor suggestions to improve structure and flow.
(done by Raiden)
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/673138/discussion/1463669/
Some major issues regarding musicality. For context, there are a few problems with streams while the song has no instruments playing other than the melody and a pattern that seems to be incorrectly mapped.
Moreover there seems to be one issue that makes a pattern extremely wacky to play for the reason below
Some major issues regarding musicality. For context, there are a few problems with streams while the song has no instruments playing other than the melody and a pattern that seems to be incorrectly mapped.
Moreover there seems to be one issue that makes a pattern extremely wacky to play for the reason below
04:05:042 (8,1,2) - This sounds really wrong. 8 is mapped on the first beat of the scratchy sample (the 1/8 sample) and the first slider starts after the sample kicked off already. If anything 8 should be replaced one of the back and forth.
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/642004
Beginner diff has zero hitsounds at all.
Basic diff is missing hitsound on 00:33:140 - pretty emphasized section on the song.
Beginner diff has zero hitsounds at all.
Basic diff is missing hitsound on 00:33:140 - pretty emphasized section on the song.
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/713086/discussion/-/generalAll#/150924
Map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/713086
Despite the same suggestion of Surono, I found out unnecessary timing points and needless timing settings for fine-tuning offset.
Map: https://osu.ppy.sh/s/713086
Despite the same suggestion of Surono, I found out unnecessary timing points and needless timing settings for fine-tuning offset.
Kuron-kun
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/741975/discussion/1565958/general#/153801
concerns about the lowest diff being too difficult. fast paced, dense rhythm and too dynamic rhythm for the lowest diff
concerns about the lowest diff being too difficult. fast paced, dense rhythm and too dynamic rhythm for the lowest diff
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/747066 need to be dqed cuz now are qualified other map https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1208673
ok nvm no sense to dq nao's map cuz axient's ror tommorow(maybe?) will be ranked i guessDjulus wrote:
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/747066 need to be dqed cuz now are qualified other map https://osu.ppy.sh/b/1208673
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/689313
Various issues in the Inner Oni, related to flow, structure, note placements, and others.
Various issues in the Inner Oni, related to flow, structure, note placements, and others.
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/719200/d ... al#/154923
Unrankable sliders in Frontier's Insane: 00:29:938 (1,1) - sliderheads directly overlapping slidertails
Unrankable sliders in Frontier's Insane: 00:29:938 (1,1) - sliderheads directly overlapping slidertails
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/692587
shouldn't this have (TV Size) in the title? the other ranked versions have it, sorry if i'm wrong here
shouldn't this have (TV Size) in the title? the other ranked versions have it, sorry if i'm wrong here
https://osu.ppy.sh/beatmapsets/680812/d ... generalAll
The MP3 in last reff is off, the creator doesn't cut it perfect
The MP3 in last reff is off, the creator doesn't cut it perfect
https://osu.ppy.sh/s/693750
Combo colors too similar
Top diff;
02:28:771 - Slow section feels REALLY forced here imo
03:00:419 - don't really like how the last kiai is done in general, too many unecessary kick sliders imo but this is more or less just my opinion here
Combo colors too similar
Top diff;
02:28:771 - Slow section feels REALLY forced here imo
03:00:419 - don't really like how the last kiai is done in general, too many unecessary kick sliders imo but this is more or less just my opinion here