My last post about it was deleted...
Then im spend 5 hour to write this, i belive that doesn't be deleted this time..
Its so Long text and represent my vision of a future better ranking system. In some parts I gave a suggestion well overall, and not specific, leaving open to other complementary suggestions, So if you do not understand some point, or have a good suggestion to increase my text, talk to me and I'll try to update with it.
If you liked and wants it be real, help me with this post. IS SO MUCH THIGS THAT I MENTIONED IN THIS. Then i make steps of how this could be increased step by step
WARNING = MY ENGLISH IS BAD!
Why a recontruction of the ranking system?
Objectives of this Request
Suggestions of Things to be Changed in Ranking System
Step 1-Teach beginners to make beatmaps with excellence, How?
The suggested changes up to this point would be able to improve the time it takes to learn how to map with excellence and reduces the bullshit maps.
Step 2-Change where the Beatmaps are Submitted and Icons
The suggested changes up to this point would be able to improve the search and division of beatmaps status and decreased with bubble maps that are forgotten.
Step 3-Change When a Beatmap can be modded and kudosu
The suggested changes up to this point would be able to improve the kudosu gain by modding quality
Step 4-Change BN's, QAT's, working method and making Star Priority really effective by rules
*HERE A POSSIBLE THING THAT ALL BN AND QAT CAN DISAGREE, BUT WHEN YOU ARE A MAPPER AND WANT YOUR MAP RANKED, BN'S AND QAT'S CANNO'T REFUSE CHECK YOUR WORK AND TIME SPEND ON A BEATMAP* how?
BN's and QAT's could cry for being forced to work on a map that they dont like the song or any personal problem, but this change would be make the system FAIR for the mappers!
The suggested changes up to this point would be able to make the system more fluid, fair, fast, reliable, right, and make the mappers give more help to others at modding for getting KUDOSU to shot at their own or others maps. Focuses the attention of the BN's and QAT's in the Queue's, and takes of them the people asking all the time for mods.
My opinion:
If BN or QAT desagree CHECK ANY KINDA OF MAP, because of their own tastes, it is preferable to have a voting system for players ranks a map than a system unbalanced where some maps are ranked and some are ignored.
Updates of the post:
Comments:
Yes it is a privilege for few peoples, but exactly for who? Don't is for the best mappers. Actualy have SOME EXCELLENT MAPSETS on graveyard because of silly things, not issues. Then it need to be changed for stop being a privilege of a few to be a reachable objective for all. If the BN's do not want to check and mod any kind of mapset, ONLY WHEN ARE FREE TO DO THIS, then it is certainly necessary to change the system to one that does not require volunteers.
Then im spend 5 hour to write this, i belive that doesn't be deleted this time..
Its so Long text and represent my vision of a future better ranking system. In some parts I gave a suggestion well overall, and not specific, leaving open to other complementary suggestions, So if you do not understand some point, or have a good suggestion to increase my text, talk to me and I'll try to update with it.
If you liked and wants it be real, help me with this post. IS SO MUCH THIGS THAT I MENTIONED IN THIS. Then i make steps of how this could be increased step by step
WARNING = MY ENGLISH IS BAD!
Why a recontruction of the ranking system?
- Actualy is very slow rank a map, it normaly takes months to get.
- Most of the maps end at graveyard because of many bad sectors in the current system.
- Mappers, speacialy beginners get crazy by trying rank a map
- Actualy kudosu and star priority is useless
Objectives of this Request
- Suggest points to be change on ranking system by Staff
- Increase the quantity, quality and reduce the time needed to get to rank a map
- Encourage beginner mappers to rank their maps and doesn't leaves them in the graveyard
- Make the system easy to understand, and right to those who want to rank a map
- Remove the *LUCK* element when you try rank a map
Suggestions of Things to be Changed in Ranking System
Step 1-Teach beginners to make beatmaps with excellence, How?
- Improve basic tutorials of beatmap editor tools
- Teach how to make correct timming, structuring, types, difficulties, standards, techniques, flow, spacing, forms, etc of a beatmap by another ways, like videos, ingame tutorials, etc, and facilitate access to it ingame through for the Osu! wiki (This need more assistance to be make by the experienced Mappers, BN's, QAT's, etc). Teach how to make glorious maps, not only teach the basics and let the beginner free to make anything...
- To define specifc rules of what can and what canno't be do in a Beatmap (eliminate the fallacy that there is no specific way of how to make a beatmap) defining what are the acceptable pattern and which are not. This could be done by a system part with a list of the figures of all the patterns found in the maps, and that would be administered by BN's and QAT's where the community would send their patterns and they would judge each one whether it is acceptable or not. Which is available for consultation with mappers. This does not take away the possibility of infinite different maps and mapper each have their own style. This would help to facilitate the following processes of bubble and qualification and also helps beginners to constantly improve on their maps by consulting this list (when I say this pattern does not mean equal spacing and repeated maps with the same patterns)
- Make a Spectating System at mapping in Editor. It will help so much when another want give mods to you or just watch how you are making a map
The suggested changes up to this point would be able to improve the time it takes to learn how to map with excellence and reduces the bullshit maps.
Step 2-Change where the Beatmaps are Submitted and Icons
- Separate the beatmaps by characteristics, how?
Like following a folder in levels:
Qualified and Waiting Qualify dont need to have subfolders because it would have few maps in - REMOVING THE GRAVEYARD: All maps that you have submitted would be free to edit and improve.(submission limit could still existing)
- Change administration of maps: When you submitt a beatmap, you should select the genre and if its Incomplete Mapset or Complete Mapset. Then if its Complete, this go to Needing Mods folder. When you judge its ready for Qualify, you move it for Waiting Qualify folder. The map Can't be modded or updated if in Waiting Qualify folder. You could back it to Needing mods if u judge necessary. Then when a BN check your map, he select can move your map to Needing Mods, or still on Waiting Qualify folder, or move to incomplete mapset if its missing. Then the BN point all mods necesarry in the beatmap thread. If beatmap is good to qualify, the BN bubble ur map. If the beatmap have issues, it back to needing mods and the creator can't move to Waiting Qualify, at least for 3 days (for dont spam the system and realy make the changes). If the map get bubble, then another BN will check it, If all is OK, then the second BN can Qualify the map and write on the thread. If have issues that the first BN didn't see or the second BN judges wrong, then he give a icon to signal that something has wrong, then a third BN will check it. If all is ok, then the thrid BN qualify it. If realy have issues, then it back to needing mods and the BN point the issues in the thread. When it is qualified QAT's will check it, if all is ok, a QAT rank it. If have issues it will be get a icon of something wrong, then the second QAT will check it, so the system repeat like the Waiting Qualify phase.
^^^So much logic DUDE^^^
The suggested changes up to this point would be able to improve the search and division of beatmaps status and decreased with bubble maps that are forgotten.
Step 3-Change When a Beatmap can be modded and kudosu
- For make a mod for a map it need to be in Needing Mods folder, then it would be select "MOD POST" at thread for other peoples, and only if its a mod, the creator can give 1,2 or 3 kudosu depending on the quality of your mod, differentiating comments of mods
- Anyone can give mods for your map, like actualy, if your map is on Needing mods folder.
The suggested changes up to this point would be able to improve the kudosu gain by modding quality
Step 4-Change BN's, QAT's, working method and making Star Priority really effective by rules
*HERE A POSSIBLE THING THAT ALL BN AND QAT CAN DISAGREE, BUT WHEN YOU ARE A MAPPER AND WANT YOUR MAP RANKED, BN'S AND QAT'S CANNO'T REFUSE CHECK YOUR WORK AND TIME SPEND ON A BEATMAP* how?
- When you send a map to Waiting Qualify, this folder is supposed to be a QUEUE. Your map takes the position of the queue according to their STAR PRIORITY and date of moving to the Waiting Qualify. Then the BN's ONLY can give icons or move back to other folder FOR THE FIRST 'X' MAPS ON THE QUEUE.("X" is number that can be changed by the number of BN's available at the moment to check maps)
- Same above for Qualified folder, its supossed to be a QUEUE too where the QAT's only can works at the first map of it
- Removing the need to find and request BN, When you move the map to Waiting Qualify you can have the certain it will be checked by a BN, and removing the 1 week of qualify state, making needed a QAT check all MAPs, independent of time, but following the queue
- BN's give mods for the maps on the Waiting Qualify Queue, when the map reaches the top of the list
- Rules changes for Star Priority and Moving to Waiting Qualify:
1-Only With 5 Star Priority you can move your map to Waiting to Qualify
2-If your map was in Waiting to Qualify and a BN move it back to Needing Mods/Incomplete Mapset, the Star Priority of the Beatmap Resets(to prevent spaming incomplete maps in Waiting to qualify)
3-When the map is on Waiting to Qualify or Qualified status, you can shot more STAR PRIORITY to it to reduce your waiting time at Queue's.
4-If Your map was DQ, the Starpriority dont reset, cause DQ is supposed to be a SMALL issue.
BN's and QAT's could cry for being forced to work on a map that they dont like the song or any personal problem, but this change would be make the system FAIR for the mappers!
The suggested changes up to this point would be able to make the system more fluid, fair, fast, reliable, right, and make the mappers give more help to others at modding for getting KUDOSU to shot at their own or others maps. Focuses the attention of the BN's and QAT's in the Queue's, and takes of them the people asking all the time for mods.
My opinion:
If BN or QAT desagree CHECK ANY KINDA OF MAP, because of their own tastes, it is preferable to have a voting system for players ranks a map than a system unbalanced where some maps are ranked and some are ignored.
Updates of the post:
Comments:
Yes it is a privilege for few peoples, but exactly for who? Don't is for the best mappers. Actualy have SOME EXCELLENT MAPSETS on graveyard because of silly things, not issues. Then it need to be changed for stop being a privilege of a few to be a reachable objective for all. If the BN's do not want to check and mod any kind of mapset, ONLY WHEN ARE FREE TO DO THIS, then it is certainly necessary to change the system to one that does not require volunteers.