clp012345 wrote:

testplay

good luck

Rizia wrote:

pro

Rizia wrote:

pro

sahuang wrote:

Rank it someone has just ranked the same song so just do it

Settia wrote:

sahuang wrote:

Rank it someone has just ranked the same song so just do it

OK

SnowNiNo_ wrote:

wat seriously ><?
i want a GD \:D/

Rizia wrote:

really for rank??

FaiVillager wrote:

Would like a mod? ;w;
It was your map that made me did my job on this nice song lol

• [Metadata spread]

1. CS : easy>2.5 normal>3 insane>4, so the spread will be 2.5>3>3.5>4>4>4>4
2. AR(i dont prefer AR10 on Melia diff) : normal>6 insane>9 expert>9.2 extra>9.5 Melia>9.8, so the spread will be 4>6>8>9>9.2>9.5>9.8
3. OD : normal>5 hard>7, so the psread will be 3>5>7>8>>8.5>9>9.5
4. HP : original spread is fine, but i suggest 2>3>4>5>6>6.5>7

• [Melia]

1. 00:39:812 - mute
2. 00:41:067 (2,3) - awkward sapcing, make the flow/spacing more consistent with 00:41:332 (3,1,2,3) -
3. 00:41:728 (3,1) - make this more spaced, is easier for player to read
4. 00:43:314 (2,3,4,5) - make the spacing 2>3 more larger then 4>5, since thw pitch at 2>3 is much higher
5. 00:44:239 (2,3,4) - larger spacing
6. 00:45:957 (6,7) - inconsistent with the other part, other part all got sliders but 2 stacked notes here, but i think this is fine XD
7. 00:47:543 (2,3,4,5) - same as 00:43:314 (2,3,4,5) -
8. 00:51:508 (1) - make the slider nicer
9. 00:58:578 - mute
10. 01:09:217 (2) - oh god dont do this on the hardest diff lol, you are missing sound here like 01:09:482 - 01:09:878 - , consult the other part youve mapped 02:06:574 - and 03:07:896 -
11. 01:10:671 - dont ignore the drum sound here, you should map here since is the hardest diff
12. 01:13:975 (2) - same as 01:09:217 (2) -, missing sound 01:14:107 -
13. 01:14:768 (1) - ^, missing sound 01:14:900 -
14. 01:24:482 - mute
15. 01:24:283 - "suggestion", from the start of the kiai part to 01:32:741 - , since the vocal was getting higher and higher, so if you map the spacing bigger and bigger will pretty fit the music, and will be better to play either(?
16. 01:50:715 (1,2,3) - dont stack all together, make a little spacing
17. 01:59:173 (1,2) - inconsistent spacing, way to small
18. 02:16:750 (1) - unnecessary NC
19. 02:22:631 - mute
20. 02:37:499 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - dont you think the spacing here was smaller then other part? make it bigger~
21. 02:56:794 (1) - NC off
22. 02:58:380 (1,1,1) - same as 01:50:715 (1,2,3) -
23. 03:17:609 - mute
24. 03:32:213 (1,2) - since the flow after was jumpy, this feels really weird..
25. 03:34:063 (1) - NC off
26. 03:34:327 (1,2) - make the spacing bigger ?
27. 03:40:935 (1) - unnecessary NC
28. 03:46:750 (1) - ^
29. 03:49:393 (1) - ^

• [Extra]

1. 00:41:464 (1) - NC off
2. 00:48:865 (1) - ^
3. 00:50:451 (1,2) - consist the spacing with other part
4. 01:10:142 (3) - delete, no sound here
5. 01:10:671 - missing a note
6. 01:12:257 (3) - move 3 to 01:12:125 - to match the vocal, and 01:12:257 - there was no sound here
7. 01:13:314 (3) - same as 01:10:142 (3) -
8. 01:14:371 (3) - ^
9. 01:17:279 (3,4) - same as 00:50:451 (1,2) -
10. 01:22:433 (1,1) - unnecessary NC
11. 01:24:482 - mute
12. 01:27:852 (3) - hmm this sound pretty weird to me lol, i usually do a kickslider as a note in order to emphasized the second note, that is 01:27:984 (4) - , but 01:27:984 (4) - doesnt need to be emphasized imo
13. 01:29:504 (7) - same above
14. 01:41:067 (1,1) - unnecessary NC
15. 01:50:715 (2) - NC
16. 01:56:794 (4,1) - i think 01:56:926 (1) - should be more emphasized, make the spacing 4>1 larger?
17. 02:04:988 (1) - NC off
18. 01:22:169 (1,1,1,2,3) - if you make this part similar with 02:21:376 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - will be interesting and consistent
19. 02:23:689 - mute
20. 02:48:601 (1) - NC off
21. 03:22:433 (4,5) - spacing is to small for kiai part
22. 03:23:094 (2,3) - ^
23. 03:26:794 (1) - make the slider more symmetrical
24. 03:34:063 (1) - unnecessary NC
25. 03:39:085 (4,5) - make the spacing more consist with other part
26. 03:47:543 (3,1) - not good blanket, 03:47:940 (1) - should be at 56 331

• [Expert]

1. 01:07:367 - you should swap this part with Melia diff
2. 01:28:777 (2) - this feel inconsistent with the kiai since you are mapping 1/2 and notes, but a 1/1 slider here..
3. 01:53:887 (1,2,3) - consist the spacing here
4. 01:56:794 (4,1) - same as what ive mentioned in Extra diff
5. 01:58:380 (2,3) - consist the spacing with other part
6. 02:22:896 - mute
7. 02:22:169 (3) - seems like you are NC at white tick here so you should NC here either
8. compare 02:21:376 (1,1,1,2,3,4,1,1) - and 01:22:169 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - , same part but different combo usage, you should make it consistently
9. 02:27:984 (2) - same as 01:28:777 (2) -
10. 02:43:975 (3) - oh dude this slider is ugly ;w;
11. 03:12:125 (1) - same as what ive mention at Melia's 01:09:217 (2) -, missing beat at 03:12:389 -
12. 03:44:107 (2,3) - consist the spacing with other part
13. 03:45:297 (4) - no good slider :p

• [Insane]

1. 00:41:993 (2) - NC
2. 00:42:257 (3,4,5) - make this part same as 00:43:314 (2,3,4) - , fit the music more imo
3. 00:58:116 (1) - NC off
4. 01:20:583 (1) - ^
5. 02:01:684 (2,3) - awkward spacing
6. 02:36:178 (1) - no good slider
7. 03:25:605 (2,1) - bad overlap
8. 03:39:614 (1,2,3) - consist the spacing
9. 03:40:671 (1,2,3) - ^

• [Overall]

1. inconsistent NCs, take a look at Melia diff, 01:22:169 (1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - and 02:21:376 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1) - , same part but different combo usage, you need to fix these stuff so the map would look nicer, same as 01:39:349 (2) - 02:38:556 (2) - 03:32:477 (1) - , and 01:40:935 (1) - 02:40:142 (5) - 03:34:063 (1) - , check the other diff for the same part to see if the NC is consistent

SnowNiNo_ wrote:

lets have your first mod
well if you dont want to change the metadata spread, BNs will told you to change it anyway (maybe?

• [Metadata spread]

1. CS : easy>2.5 normal>3 insane>4, so the spread will be 2.5>3>3.5>4>4>4>4
2. AR(i dont prefer AR10 on Melia diff) : normal>6 insane>9 expert>9.2 extra>9.5 Melia>9.8, so the spread will be 4>6>8>9>9.2>9.5>9.8
3. OD : normal>5 hard>7, so the psread will be 3>5>7>8>>8.5>9>9.5
4. HP : original spread is fine, but i suggest 2>3>4>5>6>6.5>7 hold

• [Melia]

1. 00:39:812 - mute fix
2. 00:41:067 (2,3) - awkward sapcing, make the flow/spacing more consistent with 00:41:332 (3,1,2,3) - adjust a little
3. 00:41:728 (3,1) - make this more spaced, is easier for player to read fix
4. 00:43:314 (2,3,4,5) - make the spacing 2>3 more larger then 4>5, since thw pitch at 2>3 is much higher fix a little
5. 00:44:239 (2,3,4) - larger spacing same as avove
6. 00:45:957 (6,7) - inconsistent with the other part, other part all got sliders but 2 stacked notes here, but i think this is fine XD no change
7. 00:47:543 (2,3,4,5) - same as 00:43:314 (2,3,4,5) - fix a little
8. 00:51:508 (1) - make the slider nicer fix
9. 00:58:578 - mute fix
10. 01:09:217 (2) - oh god dont do this on the hardest diff lol, you are missing sound here like 01:09:482 - 01:09:878 - , consult the other part youve mapped 02:06:574 - and 03:07:896 - fix
11. 01:10:671 - dont ignore the drum sound here, you should map here since is the hardest diff fix
12. 01:13:975 (2) - same as 01:09:217 (2) -, missing sound 01:14:107 - fix
13. 01:14:768 (1) - ^, missing sound 01:14:900 - fix
14. 01:24:482 - mute fix
15. 01:24:283 - "suggestion", from the start of the kiai part to 01:32:741 - , since the vocal was getting higher and higher, so if you map the spacing bigger and bigger will pretty fit the music, and will be better to play either(? hold
16. 01:50:715 (1,2,3) - dont stack all together, make a little spacing fix
17. 01:59:173 (1,2) - inconsistent spacing, way to small fix
18. 02:16:750 (1) - unnecessary NC fix
19. 02:22:631 - mute fix
20. 02:37:499 (2,3,4,5,6,7) - dont you think the spacing here was smaller then other part? make it bigger~adjust a little
21. 02:56:794 (1) - NC off fix
22. 02:58:380 (1,1,1) - same as 01:50:715 (1,2,3) - fix
23. 03:17:609 - mute fix
24. 03:32:213 (1,2) - since the flow after was jumpy, this feels really weird.. no change. because there are no snare sounds
25. 03:34:063 (1) - NC off fix
26. 03:34:327 (1,2) - make the spacing bigger ? adjust a little
27. 03:40:935 (1) - unnecessary NC fix
28. 03:46:750 (1) - ^ fix
29. 03:49:393 (1) - ^ fix

• [Extra]

1. 00:41:464 (1) - NC off fix
2. 00:48:865 (1) - ^ fix
3. 00:50:451 (1,2) - consist the spacing with other part hold
4. 01:10:142 (3) - delete, no sound here fix
5. 01:10:671 - missing a note fix
6. 01:12:257 (3) - move 3 to 01:12:125 - to match the vocal, and 01:12:257 - there was no sound here fix
7. 01:13:314 (3) - same as 01:10:142 (3) - fix
8. 01:14:371 (3) - ^ fix
9. 01:17:279 (3,4) - same as 00:50:451 (1,2) - hold
10. 01:22:433 (1,1) - unnecessary NC fix
11. 01:24:482 - mute fix
12. 01:27:852 (3) - hmm this sound pretty weird to me lol, i usually do a kickslider as a note in order to emphasized the second note, that is 01:27:984 (4) - , but 01:27:984 (4) - doesnt need to be emphasized imo no change
13. 01:29:504 (7) - same above no change
14. 01:41:067 (1,1) - unnecessary NC fix
15. 01:50:715 (2) - NC fix
16. 01:56:794 (4,1) - i think 01:56:926 (1) - should be more emphasized, make the spacing 4>1 larger? adjust a little
17. 02:04:988 (1) - NC off fix
18. 01:22:169 (1,1,1,2,3) - if you make this part similar with 02:21:376 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2) - will be interesting and consistent no change because these sounds are different a little
19. 02:23:689 - mute fix
20. 02:48:601 (1) - NC off no change. i like this nc lol
21. 03:22:433 (4,5) - spacing is to small for kiai part fix
22. 03:23:094 (2,3) - ^ adjust a little
23. 03:26:794 (1) - make the slider more symmetrical fix
24. 03:34:063 (1) - unnecessary NC fix
25. 03:39:085 (4,5) - make the spacing more consist with other part fix
26. 03:47:543 (3,1) - not good blanket, 03:47:940 (1) - should be at 56 331 fix

• [Expert]

1. 01:07:367 - you should swap this part with Melia diff hmm no change.
2. 01:28:777 (2) - this feel inconsistent with the kiai since you are mapping 1/2 and notes, but a 1/1 slider here.. changed pattern
3. 01:53:887 (1,2,3) - consist the spacing here no change
4. 01:56:794 (4,1) - same as what ive mentioned in Extra diff no change
5. 01:58:380 (2,3) - consist the spacing with other part no change
6. 02:22:896 - mute fix
7. 02:22:169 (3) - seems like you are NC at white tick here so you should NC here either
8. compare 02:21:376 (1,1,1,2,3,4,1,1) - and 01:22:169 (1,2,3,4,5,1) - , same part but different combo usage, you should make it consistently fix
9. 02:27:984 (2) - same as 01:28:777 (2) - fix
10. 02:43:975 (3) - oh dude this slider is ugly ;w; lol fix
11. 03:12:125 (1) - same as what ive mention at Melia's 01:09:217 (2) -, missing beat at 03:12:389 - fix
12. 03:44:107 (2,3) - consist the spacing with other part no change
13. 03:45:297 (4) - no good slider :p fix but i think still bad slider lol

• [Insane]

1. 00:41:993 (2) - NC fix
2. 00:42:257 (3,4,5) - make this part same as 00:43:314 (2,3,4) - , fit the music more imo no change
3. 00:58:116 (1) - NC off fix
4. 01:20:583 (1) - ^ fix
5. 02:01:684 (2,3) - awkward spacing hmm no change
6. 02:36:178 (1) - no good slider adjust a little
7. 03:25:605 (2,1) - bad overlap no change
8. 03:39:614 (1,2,3) - consist the spacing no change
9. 03:40:671 (1,2,3) - ^ no change

• [Overall]

1. inconsistent NCs, take a look at Melia diff, 01:22:169 (1,2,1,2,3,1,2,3,4) - and 02:21:376 (1,2,1,2,1,2,1,2,1) - , same part but different combo usage, you need to fix these stuff so the map would look nicer, same as 01:39:349 (2) - 02:38:556 (2) - 03:32:477 (1) - , and 01:40:935 (1) - 02:40:142 (5) - 03:34:063 (1) - , check the other diff for the same part to see if the NC is consistent

wont mod HS problem, took me so long ;w;
maybe you need a SB lol i can't make SB lol
GL ranking~

NeonLights wrote:

Fun map, love every bit of it. Going to try modding for once ;_; so please treat me nice

[Hard Diff]
01:33:667 - Possible nc? Fits with the other pattern of combos fix
02:22:433 (1,2) - This pattern was quite jarring compared to the ones around it, and when I listened to the track I didn't see any need for that syncopation here. no change
03:28:512 (3,4,1,2) - The 4 seems a little obtrusive and could be confusing to read (at least it was for me), and the overall flow of that section seems chopped by having the 4 in the middle. That's up to your decision though. fix

Hope this helps.

FaiVillager wrote:

so hard for me to make a piece of time modding ... sry about that
NO KUDOS UNTIL I FINISHED 2 MORE DIFFS
[Melia]
00:38:424 (4) - blanket better if u like. i may type B for blanket issues but only if you want fix those. one thing to mention is that sometimes blanket will make sliders look silly, and that happens to short sliders more.
00:40:142 (2) - little bit higher will make the notes more loose and comfortable
00:41:067 (2) - x74 y150 to make a better equilateral triangle
00:41:993 (1) - suggest less curve or just straight
00:42:521 (4) - B
00:42:918 (6) - i think place this more to the left make the flow better
00:43:843 (6,1) - ds is a lit bit small. suggest increase it
00:44:636 (5,6) - make a pattern to use same shape
00:45:693 (5) - B
00:45:957 (6,7) - ds^^^
00:47:279 (1) - B
00:49:261 (1) - B tips:using more white dots (or whatever u call it) to fix
00:51:508 (1) - B and i suggest a perfect symmetry slider
00:52:433 (1,2) - somehow weird. the clap of the lyric is on the white line so better start a slider there
00:54:680 (1) - B
00:55:605 (6,2) - make an exchange?
00:59:438 (4) - B
01:02:477 (3) - B or keep away to make it less curve.
01:04:592 (3) - B and i don't recommend the overlap
01:05:517 (3) - B
01:07:367 (1) - B
01:09:217 (2) - B
01:09:878 (3) - B
01:10:539 (1,2,3) - i suggest change to slider
01:11:596 (1) - B
01:12:257 (3,4) - like what i said before. this stop makes the gaming broken sometimes (my friend's feeling)
01:13:314 (3,4) - place one more note before or later. only two is ok but not suit that song perfectly
01:16:089 (3,4) - B
01:18:468 (4) - B
01:19:526 (4) - B
01:20:319 (3) - B
01:21:112 (1) - B
01:21:508 (3) - move left and B
01:22:433 (2) - B
01:23:094 (1) - B
01:24:283 (1) - B
01:29:570 (1) - B
01:33:270 (4) - B
01:40:935 (1,2,3,4,5) - increase ds (B by using a slider and ctrl+f)
01:50:715 (1,2,3) - straight
01:58:116 (1,2) - B
02:00:759 (5) - B
02:00:627 (4) - two grid left
02:01:684 (3,4,5) - (good shaped )
02:03:799 (3) - B
02:04:592 (2) - B
02:16:089 (1) - B
02:20:319 (1) - x266 y262
02:22:565 here is an accent and you missed it. you can change 02:22:433 (1) - to 1/2 slider with a note at 02:22:631
02:24:415 (1) - B
02:26:530 (1) - B or make it symmetry by 02:26:134 (4) - (some 1/2 slider can be changed like this)
02:27:455 (7) - suggest turn at the right mid
02:28:777 (1) - B
02:30:759 (1,4) - B
02:34:988 (1) - B
02:39:878 (1,2,3,4,1) - increase ds
02:40:803 (3) - B
02:41:464 (1,2) - the flow is a lit bit strange. maybe straight the slider will be better
02:42:918 (3) - B
02:43:314 (4) - move down a lot since it is easy
02:46:750 (1) - here don't blanket i suggest. simply make it less curve
02:55:605 (3,4) - humm..
>? PRO
03:11:332 (2) - here it is too difficult because it is slow down
03:12:786 (4) - ^
03:17:411 (1) - B
03:26:398 (4) - B
03:27:323 (4,5,6,7) - personally id like to place the tripple stream after 7..
03:29:438 (3,4,5,6) - ^ (if u have time u can have a look at my map about this part)
03:30:098 (1) - B
03:32:477 (1,1,1) - equidistant
03:48:072 (1) - B
03:50:054 (1) - B
03:50:847 (2,3,4,1) - possible version:

use ctrl_shift_d to check the triangle

First part down o.o
Give me some time & GL
Almost fix! thank you for modding!!!
and i'm waiting for the next mod

FaiVillager wrote:

continous modding

Extra

00:38:028 (2) - maybe ctrl g?
00:39:614 (5) - B
00:54:019 (3) - B
00:58:380 (4) - suggest turn at the right mid no change
01:04:592 (3) - B
01:06:178 (1) - a slider suits better
01:24:283 (1) - B
01:29:305 (6) - can make the slider towards 01:29:504 (7) - straightly.
01:32:675 (7) - consider remove this because the ds is way too big here
01:40:605 (2) - ^
01:50:715 (1,2,3) - B and make sliders less curve
01:52:697 (2,1) - NC?
02:08:424 (1) - B
02:29:173 (4) - keep away from 02:28:909 (2) - more will look better no change
02:48:204 (4,1,2) - suggest a 1/1 or 3/4 slider no change
02:50:451 (4) -like ur style?↓
hmm no change
03:10:010 (1) - ctrl j and replace
03:18:336 (1) - Ｂ
03:22:565 (5) - i dont prefer this overlap no change

for those sliders turn at about mid i suggest fix to right mid of them

Expert

these two diffs like in the same difficulty which is not that good
suggest make expert to about 5.6-5.8 or use only one of these two
00:40:539 (4) - B or less curve
00:52:565 (1,2) - when i play i feel a lit bit uncomfortable here o.o maybe change flow?
00:55:737 (1) - B
00:58:116 (3,4,5) - suggest 3 to 1/2 and 45 to 3/4 no change
00:59:702 (4) - stack at 3 feels better no change
01:07:367 (1,2,3) - B
01:34:195 (3) - better use this slider at 01:34:327 no change
02:20:715 (3) - B
02:50:186 (3,4,5) - B or better equilateral triangle
02:57:852 (1,1) - ds is way too big
03:16:882 (1,1,1) - ^^
03:40:407 (6,1) - using this kind of pattern with a big white line here is a lit strange no change

due to the samilar of these two diffs i suggest u have a GD on about 5.6
if u'd like me to do that i can finish it after next week's final exams (holy finals QAQ)
i don't want to add GDs on this mapset><
and i don't make it